Transcript

Use with ChatGPT / Claude Auto-scroll A

1. Introduction: Three Branches of Philosophy

Overview of epistemology, ethics, and metaphysics, explaining how metaphysics has been discarded in modern philosophy and why the course will focus on recovering it through the ecumenical councils and St. John of Damascus.

0:00 - 0:53
We're going to start with, as we said, what are the three basic branches of philosophy?Well, we have epistemology, which is essentially just how we know what we know.The doctrine of knowledge.Where do we get our knowledge?How do we justify our beliefs?Can they be justified?Is all knowledge relative or are there some truths that are absolutely certain such that they cannot be doubted?Is there a middle category for these things?Are some things partially certain?Are some things unknowable?Uh can we doubt everything?So for these are the kind of questions that apply to epistemology from the Greek the basic of epistemma which is are again knowledge.Now ethics of course this should be pretty obvious.This is the basic ideas of how do we know what's right wrong what's good what's bad value judgments moral judgments these fall under the category of ethics.
But today for our purposes what we're going to be looking at is metaphysics.And this is so important because this is in the course of the modern world, modern philosophy, this doesn't exist anymore.This has been crossed out.It's now been replaced by something like physics and more so physical materialism.Um the ideas of consciousness now are classed under metaphysics and things that must be tossed aside, right?free will, the spirit and man, angels, devils, all these things are classified as metaphysics and have been essentially tossed away as no longer relevant.Why?Well, because of, as we're going to see here in a minute, the rise and prevalence of certain philosophies and uh ideologies that were promoted for the purpose, I think ultimately of social engineering in the long run.Um, but I think they began as bad philosophy and bad ideas that weren't curbed or refuted adequately.
And so down the road, you just have the outworking, the logical self-consistency of these errors playing themselves out over several centuries.And that's what we're going to see especially in the west when we get to the time of uh the reformation the rise of nominalism Luther Gabriel Bile uh Calvin these different reformers as well as in Roman Catholicism similarpatterns and trends that will lead to um things like tomisism and then the counterreformation and so forth.But all of these these developments in the west uh are going to be kind of over constantly overturning and and revolutionizing right whereas in the east it's more so situation of stasis in terms of the theology because thetheology still has a central role in determining the outlook the metaphysic right and we're going to see that obviously continued into places like Russia now we're not going to get deep into that we're going to focus on these
more formative of basic periods of how the church and how the the seven ecumenical eight ecumenical councils essentially hammered out these doctrines of anthropology through christologology.So what we're going to see is that Christologology is going to directly affect and and give us a basis for our doctrine of man.And we believe that that would be revealed, right?So it's not just something that you can go out there and study like under a microscope.It's actually something that's revealed.And this again comes to us from the 78 ecumenical councils.And these are the councils under and convened by the emperors that are part of the omen which is where we get ecumenical, the universal church, the universal empire, right?And so these seven to eight councils, these take place in the first thousand years of the church.And as the doctrine of of Christian theology and Christianity spreads throughout the empire, east and west, you have a more or less united church for the first thousand years that's going to through these giant councils hammer out a
consistent pattern.And they don't contradict.There's a consistent pattern of theology based on the person of Christ.This logos, right, which is the Greek for reason, meaning, logic, explication, right?This this revealed anthropology around this is how we're going to understand the proper anthropology of man and then thus man's ills and man's healing.And so all of this is crucial and you can't do proper theology without this.And so we would say as eastern uh eastern theology that what's missing in Protestantism is precisely this Protestant theology doesn't really do this or have this because Protestant theology and by extension all of its schisms and evangelical theology.It really begins after the period when this begins to be crossed out.So with the rise of scientific revolution, scientism and so forth, Protestant Reformation, humanism, this begins to be seen as useless.And of course, by the time of Darwinism and so forth, this is completely gone.
Right?So more recent evangelical movements don't even know what this is.But what as we're going to see the Bible and the petristic philosophy of the first several centuries of the church all the way at least for the first thousand is impregnated with this.It's full of these ideas and especially the Greek New Testament usages of a lot of these terms that we're going to look at show us again a wide ranging scope of anthropology and not just anthrop anthropology but alsoChristologology uh cosmology uh and ultimately the relationship of God to the world as a whole.So that's why this is going to be so important.And really all you get in Protestantism is maybe some kind of attempt to work out epistemology, how we know what we know.Calvinists do this quite often.They try to figure out, you know, having certainty on XYZ proposition or whatever or how can we distinguish natural knowledge from revealed knowledge or whatever.
Um, and they might try to do ethics, but they cannot and will not be able to do metaphysics because they are birthed from a period in which metaphysics begins to be denied under what we call nominalism.And we're going to see what that is and look at that more in depth here in a moment.But that's going to serve as our intro here as you see.And as I said, we will be working from a rough outline of the book of the fountain of knowledge by St.John of Damascus.So, if you want to take notes, that would be good.Of course, the first hour is always free and then the second hour will be uh for paid subscribers and you can subscribe at jaysanalysis.com for $4.95 a month or for $60 a year.And you can also get my book esoteric Hollywood sex cults and symbols and film where I where I apply all of this philosophy and worldview analysis and to film to the biggest films that have ever been like uh
Spielberg films right Bond films and so forth and so you can Kubric films you can get a good in-depth philosophical analysis of Hollywood and its messages there but here we're going to we're going to continue into looking atthe subjects of the person of Christ and how it gives us a revealed anthropology and how this is much more I think stable and consistent than anything that the modern world has to offer which really has nothing tooffer.It can only offer no metaphysics and anti- metaphysics a metaphysics.Uh it then by extension it ultimately has no epistemology and can really only offer us physicalism.That's the only option that that the modern world ends up having and that's a dead end nihilistic turn.So to get real philosophy, to get good philosophy, you have to go back to these things.And that's what we're going to do today.

2. St. John of Damascus: Philosophy as Love of God

Introduction to the Fountain of Knowledge, where St. John defines philosophy as metaphysics, discusses the relationship of revelation to Greek philosophy, and presents classical pedagogy in harmony with theology.

Now, we're going to begin by some of the introductory statements that St.John makes.And and again, this is fountain of knowledge, the philosophical chapters.And he begins by saying uh an interesting quote that's reminiscent of Pltonism in so far as he says,"I who am defiled and stained with every sort of sin and bear within myself the tumultuous seas of my conjectures whohave neither purified my mind nor my understanding but rather that they may serve as a mirror of God and his divine reflections."This is the idea that what Plato talked about when he mentioned the forms, John is appropriating that and saying that we in our minds, our human minds do in a sense have a mirror reflection of the ideas ofGod.And there's nothing wrong with that.That's actually uh correct theological approach.And that's how we can in a way see that Plato has some usage.
Although we again reject of course the overarching teachings of Plato as a whole because they end up being problematic and in a very fundamental sense.But John says the relationship of revelation to philosophy is such that I will set forth the best contributions of the Greek philosophers because wherever the wherever there is good and truth it is been given to men from aboveby God.It comes down from the father of lights quoting James 1:17.If there is anything contrary to the truth then it is of course the invention of Satan and we will reject those things.So a fair and balanced approach to philosophy in the Greeks uh there by John and he says that what we're going to do in philosophy is seek trunosis right notnosticism of the heretical teachers of the first few centuriesbut trunosis and trunosis is the light of the rational soul that banishes ignorance he says and so it is it is proper for rational beings humans with rationality for rational beings to seek knowledge and to banish ignorance.
Right?So, education is good, philosophy is good.These are all proper and uh John cites of course Colossians 2:3 that all things adhere in Christ who is the logos.And so, that's why logic and logos relate directly to philosophy, right?logic, truth and explication uh are all in some way related to the logos.So he does say that philosophy is in a way a handmaiden to theology something that Aquinus will say later.Uh nothing wrong with that.It's a true statement.If then we are lovers of learning, then we shall learn much.And it is of the nature of all things that they may be apprehended through industry and toil.And all these of course come to God through grace.Come to us from God's grace.So uh human toil and so forth.These are operations that we engage in to obtain the truth.Truth truth doesn't come automatically or simply without some study and toil.
And uh that's why I think for example you can't rely on hallucinogens or something like this as some sort of shortcut to truth.It has to be through a lot of years of research through a lot of time and toil.And you know many of the eastern fathers say that.So so what is philosophy?Well according to St.John uh chapter 3 philosophy is the knowledge of the things which are in so far as they are.Now that sounds a little obtuse but what he's saying is that we want to move beyond appearances and actually see things as they are in truth in ray in reality.And so it is a knowledge of the nature of things which have being.So for St.John the beginning of philosophy contrary to so many moderns is not ethics.It's not epistemology.It is metaphysics.philosophy is metaphysics essentially.
Now other questions like how do we know things and so forth these certainly come into play and they will be uh related to metaphysics because all three of the branches ethics, metaphysics and epistemology hanger fall together.They all they all stand together.They're all connected.You can't do one without the other because anytime for example you were to make a a claim about truth a truth claim uh you would be thereby also assuming that it's ethically appropriate or necessary to maintain the truth.Right?It assumes some value to truthfulness.uh any anytime you say that something is is true, you're also making a metaphysical statement that it exists or subsists in some way or some mode or some some means.Uh and so therefore, you're also making a metaphysical statement.There's all sorts of other assumptions that are presupposed in an epistemic claim or proposition that apply to metaphysics.
For example, if you say I exist, that's not just a knowledge claim.It's also a claim of metaphysics because it includes a notion of I or the subject, right?Which is a metaphysical question.So you can't slice these up and divide them up like modern philosophy tries to do.It's all part of the modern modernist project which is all again a disastrous doomed failure.Uh philosophy is the art of arts and the science of sciences.He says it is the principle of every art is and since it is through every art that science since through it every art and science has been invented.So it's through philosophy that we get all the arts and sciences.True philosophy is the love of wisdom and because God is true wisdom.True philosophy is the love of God according to St.John.So that's our starting point.And for St.
John classical pedagogy includes math, music, right?All these things and these have to be in harmony with the virtues.And so in a way that we could we could say here that all the way back in the 8th century when St.John is writing this in the 750s, there was already a kind of a developed notion of classical pedagogy, classical education.So the ideas of triv and quadrum are not invented by 20th century guys.These are ancient ideas that have always been combined with theology especially in the church fathers all the way back to St.Basil here in St.John and then later in St.Fosius of Constantinople who will also be an advocate for this kind of classical pedagogy.

3. Transcendental Arguments and the Nature of Being

St. John's transcendental argument against those who deny philosophy, followed by discussion of being, taxonomy, and how modern philosophy reduces classifications to mere social constructs.

Now we're not going to talk about math and all that really.We're going to mainly focus on kind of the more basic terms of philosophy which are I think most relevant for us.But I always love this fact that that uh if you've listened to or read much of my stuff, you know that I advocate transcendental argumentation or transcendental arguments.I think they're more in line with the philosophy that we hold to in orthodox theology.Uh and this is a kind of apologetic approach that's I think better than the standard evangelical or evidential approaches because it can include evidential approaches but it's not entirely reliant upon them.as means or methods alone because th that's faulty.All right?You can't just show somebody evidences because their worldview is already going to determine how they interpret the evidences.So, what you have to do is begin to question the foundations of their worldview to begin with, their presuppositions.
And that's really what we do in in transcendental argumentation.And on pages 12 and 13 of this copy, St.John actually offers a transcendental argument.He says, "Well, what would we say to someone who says there is no philosophy?you can't do philosophy, it's impossible.Uh there are people who have endeavored to do away entirely with philosophy.He says people who by asserting uh that philosophy does not exist or that there's no knowledge whatsoever or perception at all, we shall endeavor to ask them how is it that you say that there's neither philosophy nor knowledgenor perception.Do you know and perceive this?How did you come to know and perceive this?Right?So this is that basic transcendental argument that I hammer home so often.Uh you know we've seen people like Dr.Greg Bonson point this out for many years.Uh and it's and it's good.
It's a true argument and here it is in St.John of Damascus in the 8th century.So we know there's some validity.We know there's validity to that.It's a the appropriate starting point of how to approach these questions.Now the beginning of division is philosophy concerns what he says concerning concerning reason and dialectic.So we're going to talk about reasoning and dialectic.How we get from point A to point B.Um and what does he start with?Being.What is being?Being is what is real, what exists.The nature of the things that are out there in the world.Be they men, be they angels.etc.Uh, and what they are and how we might classify them.Taxonomy.And what's interesting is that the taxonomy of Aristotle all the way back to ancient Greek days is still in use, right?We still use genera species, right?
So forth for classification and taxonomy in the animal kingdom.But the irony is that of course the modern world claims to no longer believe in metaphysics.So these classifications aren't real.They're just useful tokens.They're called token symbols.They're just useful classifications.They're not they don't describe anything really out there in the world.I know that sounds ludicrous, but that is the actual status of philosophy in the modern world.I mean, it's it's a it's a night nightmare dreamscape in which we live.But that is the height of man's wisdom in our day and knowledge.is nonsense and absurdity.They will sit there and say that yeah, we can talk about classifying things and animals and humans, but in reality, these things aren't real objective differences out in the world.They're just mental distinctions that we've invented through social constructs to help us to make sense of things.
But don't ever ever think that you're actually understanding something that's out there in the external world.That's actually impossible.Modern philosophy says, "Well, why why would they believe such bizarre things?"Well, that's because, as the Bible even says all the way back to Solomon, man's wisdom is made foolishness, right?Because he attempts to reason autonomously on his own.Uh, and he ends up in all these stupid, inane positions.And it's been going on for millennia.

4. Weaponized Absurdity and the One and the Many

How philosophical absurdity can be weaponized for destruction, followed by Plato's problem of the one and the many, the noose as the eye of the soul, and the logoi as principles unified in the Logos.

So, we needn't be surprised that the great academics so-called of our day believe utterly ludicrous ideas.Um, that's exactly what we were told would happen.Especially the further a society moves away from God and from truth and from metaphysics, they're only going to be caught in more and more ridiculous and absurd positions that are ultimately self-destructive.And of course, as we've been pointing out in Jay's analysis more recently in the last several years, that absurdity is not just absurdity.It can actually be weaponized.So, you can actually weaponize the inanity and the absurdity and the nonsense.Not just in all those other fields, but also in philosophy.Philosophy can be weaponized just like the arts because it it's kind of one of the arts, right?To destroy.So when so John's going to start talking about kind of basic ideas in metaphysics and one of those is that we go back to Plato and we talk about the one and the many.
Now what is this?Well, this is just a basic question that Plato asks, and I've talked about this in my Plato lectures if you've heard them, is that how do we make sense of something being on the one hand singular in itsqualities or properties that it shares with other things like for example dog, not dog the bounty hunter, just a dog.How do we understand that dog on the one hand is one but dog is also many and that there are many dogs in the world, right?And so how how is it that there can be a whole bunch of dogs?Uh and yet they share some something between them that that makes them part of a class or a group, a structure.Uh yet at the same time they're distinct in being many.What is it?Well, this is that kind of question that Plato was asking.
So the unity that they share would we would say or Plato would say this is constitutes an essence or a form or some universal, right?So there's some dogness dogness that's shared between all dogs that makes them dog and not horse or something else.Right?Now, the many refers to the particular, right?There's that dog over there, Pho.There's uh Goofy over there, specific dog, right?There's Spot over here.These are instances of a certain type or classification of thing.And so, this this very fundamental question that that Plato asked is a metaphysical question.And Plato proposed that we could have we can have groupings a unity a higher level of of unity that's shared amongst these beings that all of them participate in.And call it whatever you want.Call it dogness form of dog or the the essence or or what it is to be the nature of a dog.
And we're going to use essence here to be synonymous with nature.And this is not does not mean nature in the sense of the plants and the trees out there.We're speaking of a philosophical term of what it is for that thing to be that thing.So what is it for a dog to be a dog?Well, it might be kind of difficult to define the nature of a thing because I mean there could be many things that go into what it is to be a dog.But whatever dog nature or essence is, it's what is shared by all dogs.Now since we don't have a direct perception from our senses at least uh as it is what it is to be a dog or the essence of a dog is I should say how is it that we perceivenature's or forms or universals?
Hm.Well, Plato said there's a noose n o u us s and this is the Greek term for the what we're going to call for our purposes the eye of the soul.And the eye of the soul, the mind's eye perhaps uh is not just an intellectual faculty as we're going to use it and see it in theology.It's also the means by which we know God.And so it's an intuitive faculty that God gave man by which he can perceive truth.And so to know the forms of the universals is this is something that's known by the noose the eye of the soul and seeing these truths directly.And this is very revolutionary, very unique because this is ultimately going to be lost in the west especially after a th000 AD virtually non-existent.nowhere there.Gone.And you're going to get these kind of weird similar approaches.
You're going to get a kind of um
a kind of light or illumination theory in St.Augustine.Uh Augustine is going to propose a kind of a version of this, but not what the Eastern theologians teach because uh Augustine does not believe in this.He does not believe that there's a noose or or a specific aspect of the human faculty by which we can directly see God.Rather, I mean, Augustine would say we have a mind or an intellect, but it's this mind or intellect that perceives all of these through the light of of God's illumination.We kind of wander through the maze of reality through all of these forms back tothe one who is God.So we do not believe that.We do not believe that God is some super essence that we're wandering through the fantasms of life to get back to as if all of this is not real and we're just kind of wandering through this mental labyrinth
of of experiences or phenomena that present themselves to our senses or to our mind's eye.No, we believe that there's a world out there.There's a real world.There's nothing bad about it.There's nothing inherently evil about the created world or matter or whatever.uh and but rather that the noose is given to us by which we can see not just God and not just truth in its essence directly but that by grace we can see all things ultimately in God.And this is where we get to the doctrine of the logo logi.And what this means is that all of the principles or archetypes or essences of things that are out there in the world that we see by virtue of the eye of our soul or the noose that these areultimately understood to be this all of the logo the many principles and archetypes of things are one in the logos.
So the one and the many for eastern theology is summed up in the logos

5. Methexis, Dialectics, and the Trinity

Explanation of methexis as participation without loss of identity, critique of dialectical tensions between unity and multiplicity, and how the Trinity and logoi doctrine resolve the one-and-many problem.

and his encapsulation of all the logoy.So this philosophical problem is remedied in eastern theology through this.In western theology, there's an attempt at this through Augustine's light theory and so forth, but I don't believe that it works.And it doesn't work because of what we're going to see later on in lecture two when we get to the debate between Maximus and Purus because of what's called absolute divine simplicity.But set that aside for a moment because we're not there yet.We're going to do some more of these basic philosophical and theological terms that's that are going to give us a grounding by which we can then sort of leap into that next level of of discussion.So next we come to building on what we saw before.We're going to look at how the principles that we saw with the one and the many can be further and better explicated and understood through what we're talking about in terms of orthodox theology.
So we have this principle that we get from Plato.It's an idea that's interesting that I think works.It's called matexis.And this is the idea of participation without loss of identity.And so that question that we saw earlier of the one and the many.One of the problems that might arise from that is, well, if we have a whole bunch of dogs and they're all sharing this property of dogness, but they're all unique particular individuations or instances of dogs.What about other things that they might share?Like maybe all of these dogs say in our class are white.So they all share the property of whiteness or the quality of whiteness.But if we say that these dogs are white, we're not identifying whiteness with their essence, right?Because some dogs are brown.Not all dogs are white.So whiteness cannot be something that's essential to being a dog, right?
And that's what we would call an accidental property.Not accident in the sense of wrecking a car, but in Aristotle's categories, an accident as opposed to the essence or the substance.And we'll get into that a little bit later.But for our purposes here, we're going to say that we're going to look at this and say that Matexis is the the great philosophical insight that we have that something can participate in a real metaphysical onlogical sense.Dogs really do possess whiteness or brownness, right?they really have this quality and it's a real existing quality uh that at the same time does not destroy their dogness and it does not destroy the color brown or white or red or whatever that the dog mighthave.It's not totally swallowed up in the being of the dog, right?You can there's there's the ability for two different properties or qualities to subsist in the same entity without losing their particularity.
Right?So we can say that uh a book uh is square perhaps or rectangular.It's solid.Uh it's also numerically one perhaps.Um and all of those properties that we say about the book are true and yet none of those single characteristics sums up the totality of that book.Right?So we can have multiplicity existing within a unity without either the multiplicity or the unity being enveloped or dissolved or destroyed or overridden.And why is that?Well, that's because in Orthodox theology, we don't believe that there is some preeminence to the one or some preeminence to the many or some dialectical tension.And this is what unfortunately Greek philosophy and platonism and the history of Western philosophy would do was they would set up
dialectics.And this is the idea that there's a real tension between unity and multiplicity.And you either fall on one of these sides or the other.Right?Either unity is preeminent, primary, ontologically superior or perhaps multiplicity is preeminent and superior to unity.And we're talking about as abstract ultimate highlevel concepts here.Which one is it?Where do you fall?You say, well, what does this matter?Well, this affects everything.And this might affect your view of the government, of nations, of states.Maybe unity in the government, right, and some sort of tyrannical dictatorship is is what's preeminent and superior and should be the case.Many tyrants have thought so, right?Uh or perhaps the many is superior.This would be democratists, uh democracy proponents or anarchists.they would say no, the multiplicity and anarchy and chaos is superior to the tyrannical unity of the great dictator.
And so that would be a political example of the manifestation of dialectics.But dialectics is not just political.The political manifestation of dialectics is based on the metaphysical view of dialectics.And so in orthodox theology, we don't believe that there's some preeminence to the one over the many or some preeminence to the many over against the one.And this is because in our doctrine of the trinity and we believe that the father, the son, and the spirit all are co-equal in their essence, their divinity, their divine nature.But that unity that that the godhead shares which is summed up in the father as the cause of the godhead that unity is not superior in a metaphysical sense to the multiplicity in god and in the same wayin the logos and his logo his many principles by which he is the architect of creation and I'm not saying architect in a masonic sense I'm saying in an ex neilo creator and giving matter form sense.
Right?He is both the unity and the multiplicity in creation.And that's according to Ephesians 1, Colossians 1 and two.And that's our doctrine of the logoy.And so there's no there's no in Christ there's no preeminence to particularity in the many.There's no preeminence to the fact that oh well Jesus is more one than he is the many in the logoy.Right?So in both ways we would say that there's a balance there's a balance between the one and the many in God in the logos and the logo in the church the way the church is governed right there's notone super super bishop of pope right no god bishop there is rather an equality because of the one and the many and able to govern the church in this balance between the one one and the many just aswell as he's able to govern the universe verse in the mini logoy in the one logos.
So that leads us then to with this principle of matexis participation without loss of identity

6. Nature, Apophatic Theology, and Hypostasis

Discussion of nature (physis) as common essence, apophatic theology by negation, the distinction between nature and person (hypostasis), and how the Logos is the icon of the Father's hypostasis.

to nature.The question of nature what is nature or fouseis in the Greek this is the common essence that something shares right and this is again relates to the question of the one and the many.So we can talk about in nature or in the nature what it is to be man right humans have a body and a soul and a noose and that makes up human nature.God is different although there's some because we're made in God's image there's some analogy there.Uh God is different though.God is has a nature but we don't know what God's nature is.And we say that all the biblical references to the darkness that surrounds the the aloponic manifestations of God, the theophanes, you you know Moses says it was great darkness, right?That's because the oneness or the the nature the essence of God is unknown.
We don't know.We'll never know God's essence because it's even the saraphim have to cloak their eyes.You can never ever see into the divine essence.And this to say that you can see the divine essence is the heresy of Eomius.And it's one of the errors of Aquinas repeating the heresy of Unomius.We do not see God's essence.We will see God face to face in the person of Christ as Paul says in 2 Corinthians and we see God in his inner gaya or his operations energies.But before we get to that, let's understand again that the nature is what's common.The common essence that you know all humans, you and I, we share human nature.That's our common essence that we have.Uh father, son, and holy spirit, they share common divine nature.Whatever that is, we don't know what it is, but it's it's it is beyond us.
But is it is revealed that God has a nature.And when we say that we call that apohatic theology that is theology of negation or to not know doesn't mean that that we can't make any positive statement about God being wise or just or whatever but rather thatwe make a distinction between nature and person or hoopistasis.We make that distinction because it's a revealed distinction.It's very important and it's a crucial aspect of the theology of the first thousand years of the church in avoiding dialectics and in hammering out the proper christologology and human anthropology that we believe.So aphatic theology just simply means theology by negation or uh when we say for example God is infinite.Well humans don't have any direct conception of what infinity is.We know that it's not this it's not that it's not a created thing.It's not a fixed set of numbers, right?
So it's it's a non it's not that, not that, not that.And therefore, it's by negation.That's what apohatic theology means.Simply put, and even human nature, there's an aspect to man which is even aphatic.I mean, I for example, scripture says that only the spirit knows the spirit of an which is in a man, right?The spirit of God alone knows the deepness of our spirits.So how then can I as a human know the depths of even another human being?So even amongst men and mankind there's an apohatic aspect to human nature right and in nature in general.We saw before how would you define dog nature?Well I don't know but we know that there is some kind of something that uh archetype or principle logo that makes dogs dogs and not horses and not chickens and not humans.Right?So in the same way there's something man and what's revealed is that we have a body soul noose and we're made in the image of God and that's what makes man much like God being made in his image
and that Greek word for being made in the image is icon and this is why iconology and iconography and icons will play such an important role because we read in scripture in Hebrews that the logos is the iconof the father.He's the direct image of the father's hoopostasis.And that is the Greek word that is used in Hebrews there at the beginning Hebrews 1.The hoop he's the direct image of the hoopasis of the father.Now what is this?This is particular subject, right?Or person.And this is very important because we have a doctrine of the human person, a theology, an anthropology of the human person.Most philosophies do not.And they do not because they don't have this anthropology because they don't have revealed anthropology.In all other philosophies, person just gets snashed into intellect or human nature or soul or whatever.
And now in modern philosophy, that's been as we saw canceled out.That doesn't exist anymore.So particular human nature is always going to be instantiated in a particular person or hoopistasis in the Greek.And this is a sub this is the personal specific subject the locus of action.I am the person J the hoopostasis J.You are the person Bill Cosby or whoever you are.And so this is going to lead us to another important term that we have to understand and this is going to help us to understand the incarnation.This is what the fathers will use inhypostatize.
And while this may sound a little obtuse, don't worry.It's not a big deal.All it is is that anytime that nature, human nature exists in reality in ray actually all instances of human nature are going to be of a specific hoopist that's particular and that's all that means inhypositized.So you're never going to find human nature in the abstract.It's always instantiated, right?It's it's universal.Well, it's common amongst all humans and it is a real essence, a common essence that we all share.But it's always and only instantiated in a certain mode which we call inhypositiz that is in the human form.Now, so what is a hoopist?Well, it's just a particular subject Peter and Paul.And what did Peter and Paul share in common?Human nature.What do the father and the son and the spirit share in common?Divine nature.
But they are particular singular uh hoopostasis.

7. Energies, Operations, and Theosis

Explanation of enhypostatized nature, the distinction between essence and energy, how divine energies are proper to God's nature, and theosis as participation in divine energy without loss of human identity.

Right?Now the way that we know beings is through the communication of their person their hoopistasis through their actions, operations, speech, messages, letters, whatever.And this is what we mean by inner GA energies, right?So this is action operation that is proper to nature.And we say that because energies are proper to the nature that has that operation.So for example, God's energies or operations are not the same as man's.There might be some parallel or carryover or analogy, but the way that the divine nature operatesis not the same as the way you and I.So when we speak of humans having wisdom, this is not wisdom in a
univocical sense, right?So univocical meaning here the same sense, right?So I don't have go wisdom in the same sense that God has wisdom because God is infinitely infinitely beyond us.Right?Now we do as humans have the ability to participate in God's wisdom.But God's wisdom is not the same as God's nature.God's wisdom is an energy of the divine nature.And there is a difference between essence and energy.It is a real distinction.Right?Just as if I operate in the world to build a house, the actions that I use to build a house are not the same thing as my human nature.They're also not the same thing as the person Jay, right?They're building a house is an action proper to human nature as is living or thinking or communicating or speaking or anything.But they're not the same thing as me obviously.
Right?And so in the same way, God's creation, the created world or the act of creating the world, not the same thing as his nature.They're distinct.The father is not the same as the created world, right?And the act of creating was at a specific point.Now, God can continue to create, of course, and he can create in the future.But this is why we believe there's a distinction between the essence of a thing and the thing's operation or energy.Now those energies are proper to the nature.Right?So if I speak or if I exemplify wisdom or knowledge hopefully I am then that wisdom or knowledge is proper to me as a human person and human
exemplifying the energy of human nature.If God does something then it is proper to the divine nature.Right?So the energies of God are proper to his nature.The energies of man are proper to human nature.And what we believe in theology is that metexis that participation without loss of identity is how we participate in the energies of God.And that's what we will call
theosis.Theosis deification.It is the participation of human nature and human persons in the divine energy without the loss of human identity or human nature or submersion into the divine essence.We have nothing to do with the divine essence in the sense of knowing it or seeing it or perceiving it directly.Now the divine operations or energies they proceed from the divine nature and that they're proper to him as a divine being.But we never see this or know this.All we know is the direct active energy of God.And that is the crucial crucial crucial distinctions and um theological terms that I think have to be understood to understand our theology.Now for example, intera is used several times in the New Testament.It's used three times in Ephesians.It's used in Philippians, Colossians, 2 Thessalonians.Paul speaks of the operations of the spirit in Corinthians.
That's all the Greek word interactions of the spirit are distinct from the spirit.So that's why we would say these kinds of things, right?So Paul when he says in Ephesians 1:19 in the Greek that we know the mighty working of his power the effectual working of his power in Ephesians 3:7 Ephesians 4:16 that's inner gaya now his that refers to Godthe divine person the father his power in gaya hoopistasis his power.So we see that these are again Greek terms used in the New Testament.Many of them noose is used in the New Testament.Hoopasis is used in the New Testament.Fouseis is used in the New Testament.Mexis, I'm not aware of that being in the New Testament, but it's still just a useful concept.um in Gaya uh Peter says we participate in God.Jesus says that in John 17 that you'll share in the immortality and the life and light that he has and that's that participation in the divine energy.
When Jesus is on Mount Tabor and the light is coming out of him, we believe that's the divine energies.So that I think is a good discussion of some of these basic terms.

8. Abstract Objects, Plato's Forms, and Universals

Analysis of Plato's third realm of forms, its problems with participation and dualism, followed by Feser's arguments that universals, numbers, and laws of logic cannot be reduced to matter.

Hopefully you can see all those.I know it's getting kind of messy.Uh when we're looking at the notion of abstract objects, universals, numbers, concepts, propositions, laws of logic.We're looking at objects that uh are unlike the objects of our world.So we're gonna remember Pltonism here.We're going to use Platonism as kind of our uh exemplar to to branch off from.So if we remember Plato's ideas of the forms, Plato thought that the realm of the forms was uniquely simple.It was uniquely one.It it uh is summed up in the monad, right?That first primal unity.The forms are unchanging.The forms are impersonal in the sense that they're not like a human person.And I know that that Plato doesn't really have the conception of personhood as subject as personal subject the way that the Capidocians will um explain that.But regardless, it is important to mention that it's ideal and personal, immaterial, eternal, it's in stasis.
This is very important because it's not in becoming.Uh and then that's why Plato can point to things like well numbers are the best example of this kind of thing, right?So for Plato, they're in a third realm.They're not in our realm.They're in another higher realm.And they're not they're not in the mind per se.They're not in objects.So they must be in a third realm.Now the the the important part is that when we look at this realm, it's usually characterized by the opposite.The right the realm that we inhabit.The realm that we inhabit is characterized by many.It's characterized by change.is characterized by flux is characterized by being lesser in the chain of being according to how it relates to these things.So think about these things as higher on the the spectrum so to speak.Um the things that we experience are temporal.
They come and go and they participate thus in becoming.So the problem as you can see pretty quickly which actually Faser will mention is that it doesn't really see how there's any relationship between these two disperate realms.Now for Plato uh his solution, one solution he thinks kind of works is what he calls methexis which is participation.The idea that the faint reflections of this world participate quote unquote in the forms.But of course as you can begin to see this doesn't really solve much.which is still problematic because if if this realm is essentially one and the h the highest of this realm is pure unity then it would seem to exclude the possibility of distinctions in this realm.How are the things of this realm distinct?Well, it's just ad hoc.Well, they just are, right?And as many of you guys know, what's the uh solution that uh this is a great example of ad hoc rescue, which the idiot atheists the other night in the debate uh decided was not a fallacy.
You could use them in debates.So now you can use any inval informal fallacy in the debate because it's not a formal fallacy as if formal and informal has anything to do with whether it's a nonsequittor or not, right?Uh they're all non sequittors.it doesn't matter whether it's they don't follow right uh in the context of a debate.So when we think about uh that realm we have that basic outline there from Plato uh that's going to help us as we progress into this chapter from Faser where we look into the pros and the cons.So we start by uh Faser mentioning the uh the notion of universals.Okay, the notion of particulars and ofthe general.So if we think of something general like catnness, right?There the idea of a cat, then when we look at a cat that that we see on the mat, that is the particular that's the instantiation of the common, the universal.
For Plato, what's more real is not the physical instantiated cat in front of you.What's more real is the universal cat.Right?Now, why do we speak of a universal cat or a universal idea?Well, Plato reasoned just pretty simply that that obviously what makes a cat a cat is not that it has four legs, hair, two eyes, because a cat could lose any of those properties, right?And it still is a cat, right?You you know, tabby cat Garfield's out there running around.He gets drunk.He gets coked up and he falls underneath Tony Soprano's Range Rover.He gets his leg run over.He owes Tony Soprano money.He doesn't pay up.Garfield gets his eye poked up, right?He's still He's still a cat.He doesn't lose catnness because Tony Soprano took his eye in his leg because of his fendish habits.Thus, Plato argued the essence of cat, the idea of cat, the form of cat cannot be identified with any of the traits, nor merely just adding the traits up.
There's something else, some higher order there that is that thing.Now, remember, what's an essence?The essence is that which a thing must have to be that thing and no other thing.All right?Now with that in mind we can come to the notion of what universals are.So universals immediately relate to the problem of the one and the many.Plato has a whole dialogue.If you've listened to the the lectures as we did throughout uh Plato's
dialogues you will know that well one of many comes up often.Um,but I think it's in Fedo.Uh, FIDO seems to be occupied.Yes.And I will give you some sources for all you know-it-alls out there.So, you can go find the sources for the one and the many and the Universals.And I had it and then I just lost my page.Where'd it go?
Just read the fo first of all, but uh
here it is.
Universals and participation comes up in Fedo
8 uh 99 100 101 and then out throughout the FIA you'll get discussions about one and many particularity universality or the forms of things.Obviously, this is shouldn't be controversial, but there's always somebody who wants to harass.Um, so Faser goes on to say, uh, when we look at things like roundness, redness, triangularity, uh, etc.These are properties or features that cannot be identified with any, uh, single object, right?And obviously they have to have some reality because if we deny that they have some reality then we're going to run into a whole host of epistemic metaphysical problems.So abstract objects then cannot be identified or reducible to matter or the instantiations of matter.If you remember the debate with Stefon, I mean I was just making this simple argument when I was pointing out that seven coconuts is not the same thing as seven.
Obviously uh other uh arguments that philosophers invoke would be things like 2 plus 2 equals 4.Obviously the the proposition the truth value of 2 plus 2 equals 4 is not identifiable to two rocks and two rocks.I mean it's just pretty obvious that those two things are distinct.It doesn't take a whole lot of thinking power to realize that.But philosophers will also resort to things like possible worlds.Right?Right.So if you've been in the discord, if you've heard a lot of the argumentation that father deacon, Dr.Ananas has given on possible worlds and how philosophers utilize possible worlds to demonstrate which things are logically impossible.uh then you'll know that those are examples of things that refute materialism because materialism can't really explain how if everything is reducible to matter.There can be arguments that are sound and valid from logic that show the impossibility of the possible worlds being reducible to matter and there's actually a paragraph where phaser covers that.
But the uh the first one and many argument is that universals like triang triangularity redness are not reducible to any of the particulars because anytime we talk about these things it makes no sense to reduce the predicates thatwe're using to the instantiations.There must be some notion of triangularity that's not just identifiable with the secondary characteristics or features of the object in front of us.Um and he he goes on to point out that when we look at geometry, you've heard me make this argument from Roger Penrose, comes up in the uh mind of God book by uh Paul Davies, mathematical principles uhare not invented, they're discovered.Okay?Nobody invented or made up Mandelro sets.They were discovered.And the mathematicians who are honest that uh spend their lives on these topics will tell you that they often speak this way that they are discovering truths in the mental scape.
They're not making them up.Right?So this idiotic atheistic materialistic reductionist argument that we just make up numbers.We just make up Pythagorean theorem.They're just made up, right?As if it would work consistently over time and across cultures.if they were just made up, it's ludicrous.So, Faser Phaser covers that and shows that those are examples of principles that are universal.So, he lists things like numbers, universal concepts, universal propositions, laws of logic, possible worlds.These are all uh uh examples of things that are utilized that are not obviously not reducible to physical matter.Uh other concepts that are useful in mathematics like zero and infinity uh any of the the pi any of these things are obviously not identical to any specific thing under a microscope or any collection of molecules.He goes on to also point out the argument you've heard me make many times.
This is from the philosophy of science.Huserel makes this argument.Science assumes the laws of logic and universals.If you heard the debate with infidel pharaoh that I had about a year ago, that was the summation of that whole debate.The whole debate was whether science is uh utilizing principles and laws for its argumentation and and scientific process that are not immediately under the purview of empirical investigation.Duh.Obviously it does.So uh then he goes on to mention the argument from the nature of possible worlds.This is the argument that father deacon ananas makes similar to it that you can conceive of a possible world uh that is not reducible to matter laws of logic still hold.Therefore how could you conceive of these things if all of these argument all this argumentation is reducible to matter.Right?So it just it's just a simple way to disprove the reducibility of um of logic in the realm of possible worlds to matter.

9. Arguments Against Nominalism and Conceptualism

Detailed refutation of nominalism through the resemblance regress, linguistic arguments, and the objectivity of concepts, showing that language and knowledge presuppose universal metaphysical realities.

Uh then he goes on to talk about phaser does about indirect argumentation.So then he goes on to say that this is the types of argument that you hear us make often as presuppositionalists where we talk about the self-detonating nature.You could say to quote Stef on here the the impossibility of the contrary in the sense that when you deny universals you put yourself in a host of problems.One of those would be the uh immediate claim against what's called realism.So if we're affirming an ontological reality or status, metaphysical status to universals in some way, then we would be called a realist.Okay?There's not not everybody has the same notion of realism.If you listen to last night's lecture, we talked about John Wickliffe who was a ultra realist.He had a basically a platonic type of view.So not everybody has the same notion of realism, but just at the level of the debate here, we're just talking about whether we believe that universal concepts and universals have a a real existence or or whether they are
uh reducible to matter or whether they as he lists a different position are have only a conceptual reality.And we're going to see the problem with that as well as it falls into solypism becomes useless.So uh but he argues that um
uh if you can think of a possible world where it's uh at least possible for the uh universals to exist then it shows that universals are not dependent on a human mind for their existence.Uh and so the mere possibility of them shows that they are not reducible to matter.So those are a lot of different types of arguments he gives for realism.Then he moves on to point out that um if we think of general names like redness, red etc.Uh if you were to deny uh those and be a nominalist, nominalists are those who deny the the reality of universal predicates or universals.then it's kind of a difficult to explain what are we predicating that's in common and the the the most common response from the nomalist is that well um what we're predicating is that they just have a similarity between
them.Well that begs the question what is it that resembles the other thing?What is it that is the similarity?Right?We're that's the very question that we're asking.You can't just say well they're similar.Uh because that's assuming that there's a universal category that's not instantiated there.That's the point of what we're trying to argue here.And even uh Bersian Russell himself an atheist noted the difficulty of this regress that the resemblance argument that's the that the nomalist often appeals to is itself a universal resemblance is a universal concept and it would have tobe the case for this argument to work.But then it's self-refuting.If a stop sign resembles a firet truck, since they're two different objects, then the thing that we call red has to be something more than just the instantiate because the objects are obviously different.So to just to say that they share quote resemblance is to assume assume that resemblance is a real state of affairs that occurs across time and space, right?
Because there's countless numbers of red objects in the world.when you're saying that the resemblance itself uh is consistent and and hears over time.It's invariant, right?Because redness doesn't turn into the opposite of itself in terms of the resemblance itself.And the anomalist just has to say that well we just we just don't know.Well, then the nominalist can uh resort to another level of moving the argument to say that okay, well uh I can avoid this dilemma by saying that we only call all of these examples resemblances merely because they resembleeach other.They don't have an actual higher level existence.But this problem just moves the step to a higher level because he's uh phaser notes the various cases of resemblance resemble other various cases of resemblance.So now you just said what is the resemblance of resemblance you see.So this higher order moving up the problem uh is also itself relying on a universal concept.
And so this uh Bur and Russell notes would lead to an infinite regress.Umthe next argument you've heard me make many times which is the linguistic argument.Uh language uh predication assumes universal truth predicates.Right?The tree is uh the the tree is green.The um what else is green?The the social justice hair is green.The ice pop is green, right?So, all three of those things are green.They're different things.Uh and when we have a sentence that's meaningful, right, for communication, if we're actually communicating in a sentence, then greenness has to be something that is really meaningful and not reducible to the uh breath that's coming out ofmy mouth, not reducible to the gray matter in my head, not reducible to the molecules in the social justice greasy hair or in the uh corn syrup popsicle or in the tree leaves.
So what are we predicating here?If it's something that's not real, it doesn't exist.Greenness is not real.Yeah.You see, we begin to we begin to have these ridiculous problems that now we we utilize and communicate with all these things that are not real.But remember, most of the time these are atheists who don't believe in madeup things.But now all language itself is just made up and therefore meaningless.
When I utter the word red, Socrates utters the word red.They are obviously particular distinct instances and utterances of the same word.Yet this word exists over and over in our utterances and in the concepts in our mind.And yet they're different minds.So therefore, there's something beyond the instantiations that allows for the conveying of meaning.Thus, words and language assume metaphysical realities.If you've been in the Discord the last week, I've probably made this point, this argument at least 10 times with different people, different atheists bringing this up and they don't get it.Some do.In general, it is a notoriously very difficult position to defend.Nominalism leads ultimately to the impossibility of knowledge.That's not Faser saying that.That's me saying that.It's completely destructive to the possibility of language, meaning, knowledge, metaphysics, etc.And ultimately when you move to the position uh that uh it's all just dependent upon a human mind which we don't even have any con I mean to say that it depends on a human mind assumes the universal
concept of mind that all minds possess.You can't even know that on this stupid position.It's a total collapse.It's totally stupid.Um it's really low IQ low brain stuff.But every atheist pretty much believes this.I mean, unless you're some weird variant of a platonic atheist, uh, they believe this nonsense.They can't even make sentences.That's my chief argument against the atheist.If you listen, I always you can't make a sentence.You'll say, "But yeah, I just did."Right?So, that proves that your worldview is not true.That's tag right there.The argument from the objectivity of concepts and knowledge.uh any objective uh truth statement, any claim, any concept itself such as triangularity or redness.Um uh assume that the mind has the same idea, right?For us to meaningfully communicate about any object, anything, any proposition, any sentence, we can't reduce the meaning to the gray matter because I have different gray matter, right?
So how do we have if we reduce concepts to brain states?My brain states are not your brain states.Therefore, communication would be impossible if there was not something else higher than all of the physicalist instantiations.
Phaser goes on to make uh linguistic types of precondition arguments that you've heard me make a h 100 times.Consider also the many things that must be the case just for communication to be possible.This is the preconditions transcendental argument about the possibility of communication.There's communication and then there's a higher level of argument about what must be the case for communication to even be possible.Two different levels of argumentation.And he quotes uh um Fraga's essay uh thought, right?So Frager has an essay thought where he talks about the presuppositions of what must be the case uh for language to even be possible.Yes, exactly.Been here making that argument for years against atheism and materialism.Uh then he goes on to the argument the reductio of the impossibility of psychism.That's an easy one.You've heard me me argument many times.Uh one of which would be the naturalist fallacy that if all of our brain states are part of a determined chemical process, then they're not really you making choices.
Your brain states are illusorally.It's an illusion that you are making choices and that you are coming to truths.You are merely a determined chemical process.So there's no you that stands behind these uh discoveries and these argumentations.Um mind logic right these things cannot be reducible to matter.He says it is a necessary about our minds that we have concepts standards of logic etc.uh and they must be set forth as we are saying in order to have knowledge claims in all to have the objective knowledge of of or uh nature of the workings of things our minds must be situated inthis way.He says it goes on to say for to formulate and defend any claim there must be an appeal to certain universal things like mind.Right?If I'm going to make an argument about minds or about states of affairs from my mind, I'm assuming mind.
I'm assuming self.I'm assuming logic.It's that simple.It's not that hard of an argument.Now, I'm not empirically demonstrated all those things that I'm assuming.But remember what all most 95% of the 99% of these atheists all say.Don't believe in anything unless it's empirically demonstrated, bro.Otherwise, it's superstition.

10. Critiquing Feser: Maximus's Logoi Doctrine

Examination of Feser's scholastic realism and its deficiencies, contrasted with St. Maximus's teaching that logoi are uncreated thought-wills in the divine mind, distinct from created essences and from God's essence.

Now uh next phaser moves on to consider areas where we will have to begin to critique him.And if you want to ask questions, we got one there.Be be feel free to uh leave super chat questions.Next he calls the the solution to this the that neither the nominalist nor the mere conceptualist positions.And the conceptualist position was just that um abstract objects are not physical.They only exist as mental states.But that's just that doesn't really get you anywhere because if everything is mental states then you're stuck in psychism and soypism.The end result of thatism.So he says so there's other versions of realism that we could give.There's platonic realism, arisatilian realism and scholastic realism.Now Faser is not aware of the fact that St.Maximus's view is not the view of Thomas Aquinas.And we will show that we will demonstrate that here in a minute because Faser deals with the objections and he actually brings up the absolute divine simplicity objection that I'm going to bring up and he doesn't rebut it.
He just says they're not really good objections, but he brings it up, but he doesn't say why it's a bad objection.It's a perfect objection, and we'll get to that in a minute.Anyway, so he calls the position scholastic realism.We'll call it St.Maximus realism, okay?Because it it shares some similarities with both Plato and with Aristotle.And Faser will admit that the scholastic realism position he thinks does that.But it's very crucial.This is why Maximus does not locate The universals or the exemplars in the essence of God and the loi are not the same thing as the essences of creatures.It's very easy to prove that Maximus says that the that universals can perish.Well, I'm sorry, but loi cannot perish, right?Uh if the essences of of created things were in in the divine essence, they couldn't perish, right?But universals can perish, Maximus says.
So there's a distinction between universals.They're created and the loi which are uncreated.The universals are patterned on the uncreated loi and the loi are not the essence of god.So the first um he says let's uh let's look at the uh solutions to nominalism.The different schools that we could go with.One school he says we could go with is platonic realism.And you heard me outline that at the beginning.We talked about the forms, Plato's conception of the forms, and we talked about how these aren't really good uh uh they seem to give a little bit of an answer to the immediate problem of reducing uh the thethe universals to the instantiations or to matter.It shows the problem there.But when we just say that there's another realm of these ideal things, we still got all these problems, right?How do we relate the that unchanging realm to this realm?
In what sense do they participate?How do we avoid the third man argument, etc.There's a whole bunch of problems.The dualism problem of Pltonism, right?Plato's ad hoc rescue of just saying, well, we know the forms because like we were reincarnated, bro.That's literally his ad hoc rescue for his whole metaphysic.We were we were in the realm of the forms once and then we kind of fell into this one.And so we're remembering the forms from, you know, the time when we were all in the monad.That's not a good answer.That's a terrible answer actually, but that's the best thing Plato has.And uh Faser actually mentions some of my critiques of Planism, right?Not everybody knows of the third man critique.That's that's ancient.Even Plato brought it up.Uh but there's other ones too, like the the duality of the two realms.
How do they actually relate?Um Plato's one in the many argument actually doesn't work because if the many particular objects that we experience are different objects then how do they have forms that are not really different?Because remember that the forms of objects have to have a higher level perfection in terms of their simplicity.So ultimately they're all located in the monad.But the monad doesn't have real distinctions.anytime you enter into the equation real distinctions then you're moving into the lesser gradations of being the lower rungs of the chain of being because you're moving away from the one.So for Plato the more distinct things are the further down they are on the chain of being down towards non-being.That's why we're all striving to get back to unity with the one.So once you have that pre that metaphysical presupposition about the the onlogical supremacy of ultimate unity and simplicity you have all these problems in your system.
So manyiness is on a lower status of being.And as you can imagine, when the church fathers encounter this, it takes centuries of debating, especially throughout the Capidosians, to try to demonstrate the fact that the threeness of God is not somehow lesser than the unity of God.We'll come into that later when we look at Andrev and some of the quotes about love.But uh so basically Faser just runs through some of the critiques and the problems with the blatonic response on realism.And he one of the ones that he notes that's pretty good is umuh a better objection would be to consider a universal concept like animality.Every individual animal is either rational uh as human beings are or nonrational as other animals are.So what is animality itself?Right?Precisely because it is a universal, it has to apply both to rational and nonrational animals.
But it can't itself include both rationality and non-rationality for these are contradictory properties.And thus the problem for saying that animality is located in a higher level reality of perfectionism in the forms.So we have to say that it inherently entails either rationality or non-rationality.No individual thing can be neither rational nor non-rational and exist any existing thing has to be one or the other.Therefore the universal concept of animality cannot be said to exist as an individual thing in its own right as a self-subsisting form.And so it doesn't it seems to not work on that system.
Another problem that I just pointed out uh Faser goes on to say is that the things of our experience are not the forms themselves.So how do we even speak of a participation or a resemblance?Because remember the characteristics the properties of the form are completely different than the characteristics of the particulars in our experience.So in what sense is there any kind of real relation between these two?How are how do they resemble?Makes no sense.This is the same argument you hear me make about ads.Same argument I make to the Muslims.It's the same point because any any system that has the presuppositions of absolute simplicity in this sense will have a hell of a time an impossible task of trying to explain and locate the grounding of the particulars ofthis world in that thing doesn't work.And thus all ads systems will collapse.
That's also of course why Maximus does not say that the essences of creatures are identical to loi.The essences of creatures are in the creatures.He agrees with with uh or Aristotle on that.But the creatures and their instantiations, their particular, their the loi of their being, their time ex coming to be, their existence, their providence, every molecule of their body is patterned on the loi, but not identical to the loibecause the loi are in the divine mind.You're not identical to the divine mind, obviously.But many people make this mistake.They will identify the loi with the essences of created things.No, they're not.The essences of created things are in the objects.And he agrees with Max with Aristotle there.But Maximus is also giving a nod to Plutinus by saying that the loi really are uncreated because they exist in the divine mind.
Uh and they come to be when God wills it.Therefore, they are thought wills about creatures.And so they are a different type of energy.They are a type of energy distinct from the eternal what Palamos calls the natural energies.That doesn't mean that there's non-natural or unnatural energies.It's just a word that is used to signify the energies that would shine forth whether God created or not.And this comes from Athanasius's argument against the Aryans.And that's why we distinguish God's love, glory, right?If he had not created, that would still be shining forth and uh reciprocated amongst the persons of the trinity without a created order.This is why we're going to have to show we're going to point out in a minute that Loski Staneloy Andrev's argument and St.Nikolai Belarovich makes this argument too that uh you can actually show that the trinity is the only logical rational uh deity that avoids a necessary creation because if he's god if he's lord who is he lord and god
in relationship to unless there's an eternal is he eternal lord eternal god if he's a single hypostasis single god then he must be lord god over an eternal creation Unless he's triune and there's an eternal reciprocation of loveand attributes like glory shining forth amongst the triad uh regardless of a created order.Right?But then when he creates on the basis of will, not on the basis of any necessary pattern in his essence, but only on the basis of will and yes he did create on the basis of uh patterns youcould say in the divine mind that are called the loi but he didn't have to bring them to be.He willed to bring them to be.That's why this view is different.But that's precisely where we're going to critique Faser because Faser is not aware of Maximus.He doesn't appear to have any knowledge of Maximus at all.
He thinks that really there's just Augustine and Aquinus and that sums up the whole exemplar doctrine.No, it doesn't.Um,

11. Aristotelian Realism and Divine Conceptualism

Critique of Aristotle's view that universals exist only in objects, followed by Augustine's divine conceptualism argument and the problem that generic monotheism cannot avoid eternal matter or dualism.

next he moves to Aristoilian realism.And as you can imagine, Aristotle believes that animality, triangularity, redness, humanness are not in a third realm.They are located in the objects so to speak of uh experience.um the mind abstracts from these particular instances of the objects in terms of the fantasm it's able to in the mind so that the basically the exterior objects in Aristotle's view imprint upon our mind through the senses thesedifferent instances right and then the mind through that fantasm is able to abstract the universal so we get a concept of the universal right that is present so to speak in the objects the essence of the objects isin those objects.Of course, there's other problems with this view which I've outlined in other papers and essays which is that uh Aerosol seems to have this this notion that objects are reducible to the essence of that object.
And so therefore there's not really multiple uh universals or or or levels of participation in specific objects.But if that's the case, then they don't really possess different types of realities.And that becomes problematic when we start talking about Christology, when we talk about anthropology in the in the orthodox conception.And that's why um there's a nod given to both Plato, Aristotle, Plutinus in our tradition.Uh Maximus will make free use of these different systems when they're right and reject them when they're wrong.Let's look at now uh the divine conceptualism argument that Faser moves to that you hear me make often.And I'm going to tweak it because I don't think Faser he's on the right track here, but he doesn't really take it uh to the right place because he's still situating all this within quote natural theology
for Faser.This doesn't prove this proves any kind of god, right?Oh, it's going to prove a generic god that has omniscience.Oh, so uh Judaism, Islam, what good of an argument is that?But we will give some props because he will mention the fact that the divine conceptual argument that he locates first in St.Augustine, he says that Augustine made the argument that uh universals, propositions, mathematical and logical truths, necessary and possible worlds, etc.or excuse me, necessary and and possible states of affairs can only be logically grounded in an intellect or a divine mind that is infinite and eternal.Thus, uh some form of realism has to be true.But the Platonic realism and the arisatilian realism are severely deficient and thus all we're left with is some form of a realism in which there's divine conceptualism.And basically what that means that we're grounding the lo we're locating and grounding uh the the universals etc in the mind of God.
But now remember and he will mention this objection at the end of this chapter.What is the Roman Catholic doctrine of divine ideas in terms of Aquinas?Now maybe a Scottus could get around this.I don't really think so.But because I I mean John Duncotus in his treatis on uh unicity of God, he says all the same stuff about simplicity in terms of knowledge, will and and act that Aquinus says.He equates them all with the essence of God and a and a strict identity.Even though he also says that there's a formal distinction, whatever.I don't think that that position avoids the problem because I think Scotas is drawing quite a bit from Augustine when it comes to some of these ideas.And if that's the case, then you're still going to have the problem of locating the archetypes in the essence of God.
In other words, even if you say that the divine ideas are formerly distinct, which I'm not sure Scott says that, maybe he does, but it doesn't avoid the problem of saying that, but they're really ultimately identical to theessence of God.
Either way, it doesn't matter because it's not Maximus' position which is the correct position which is that they are thought wills.Uh soI did want to mention too even Augustine's argument is lacking because when Augustine makes this point again uh this this what is this kind of God?I mean we don't believe that God is just a singular divine mind.Okay, that's absolutely simple and contained all these universals.That's not our view.That's like a neoplatonic view.But that doesn't work because our god is the triune god who created the world, right?I mean, you could hold that view and hold to emanationism as neoplatanist.So, what distinguishes this view from neoplatanism?Well, then you have to start injecting things like, well, this god's personal.Ah, yes.Now, if this god's personal, how do we know that it's not still just a singular personal God?
That's why you have to bring in trinity.Not just because of the one and many argument and and grounding the one and the many in equal ultimacy in God in terms of the trinity and the low gate, but also uh in the sense of what wesaid earlier about uh uh necessary and and uh freely willed creation, right?the single god, right?If we have the the arisatilian or um any sort of monotheistic concept, the strict monotheism in the sense of just one hypotheasis, uh the problem with that position again is that and in pretty much maybe not every case,but a lot of the the philosophers and theologians who've held that position, whether Muslim, Jewish, or whatever, they they they oftenimes will accept the arisatilian argumentation about eternal matter and eternal creation.Well, that's not our view.We don't we believe in exilo, right?
So, that's not the same god as we believe, right?And you say, "Well, but so what?"Uh, well, Basil specifically says Aristotle is an idiot and a blasphemer for saying that.I'm going to show you that.So, you what we start to realize is that you can't divorce your argumentation of God from what's revealed about God and posit a God who is a great architect working with eternal matter.That's masonry.That's not our view.So, you have to have the whole Christian paradigm.That's what we're arguing for.We're not arguing for Aristotle's great architect of the universe God.An architect works with existing matter.He doesn't create exilo.Oh, well, we'll just tack that on later down the road.Uh, as Thomas or whatever, no, that doesn't work because those are no good arguments.So, we got we have to argue for the paradigm as a whole because guess what?
None of the concepts that we're using here, universals, mind of God, uh laws of logic, existence, divine intellect, uh all of these terms that we're using are situated and explained within the paradigm.None of those terms are neutral.The laws of logic are neutral.They only make sense and are coherent within the paradigm as a whole.That's of course what phaser does not get as a tonist.So, as we see, even if we prove a divine mind or whatever, it's still not a very good argument because any Muslim, any Jew could make that same argument and could argue that that that the created world iseternal.Now, Basil laughs at that and says that that is destructive to your whole argument for monotheism because now you've given the attribute of eternality and uncreated to matter.But your whole argument was that God alone is God.
But if God alone is God and he's got to be God and Lord over someone or something, then it seems to necessitate an eternally an eternal matter or creation that he's God over.Well, now you've made the created world prima materia, the first heavens, whatever matter eternal.Now, Basil says, he laughs and he says, "Now you're an idiot because you have made in your in your quest to be a strict monotheist, you've now had to admit that matter takes on a divine property and hasto be another hypothesis.So what?You've got eternal God and eternal matter.That's dualism.We all know that there's serious problems for dualism.And if you have that dualist system, then how can I mean dualism can easily fall into the opposite of itself because now you got two eternal principles that are that necessitate one another.And as you know from pretty much every dualist system that's ever existed.
This tends to to to lead to the conclusion that they're intention.Do we need to flee to the first cause or are we stuck in the realm of matter and flux?You see, so dualist systems are incoherent.They're stupid.They don't work.And the very pos the the strict monotheistic position which was intended to avoid uh polytheism and dualism ends up falling right into it.When you ask about the doctrine of creation, Aristotle himself makes this argument.He says the first mover to be pure act has to be eternally moving something or else it makes no sense.So he says it has to be the first heavens and eternal substance or matter that he's eternally moved.So there's no creation doctrine.So that's not our God.That's masonry.Did you know masonry teaches the great architect of the universe?Oh, but look.So imagine using a bunch of Masonic arguments like as a Christian let's borrow all the Masonic arguments to to argue for what thought thinking itself.
Come on

12. Leibniz's Eternality of Truth and Actus Purus

Leibniz's argument that truths like Caesar crossing the Rubicon are eternally true and cannot be reduced to matter, followed by critique of actus purus showing that pure actuality without potentiality undermines free creation.

now back to uh the good point that Faser was making about the universal concepts about the Austinian argument and then he moves to the good a good argument that livenets makes about the eternality of truth.He says that the basic thrust of this argument is that um livenets borrowing from Augustine made the argument that truth itself uh seems to suggest eternality right so if Caesar you know uh if was crossed the Rubicon youknow whatever year that was uh and even though it's in the past it's forever true right that Caesar across the Rubicon.So the truess of it, the event even if it was temporal, at least from this point on, is eternal.And it doesn't matter whether that was uh you know whether there's a possible world where Caesar didn't have to do that.It doesn't matter because that did happen.We believe that happened in some sense.
Therefore umtherefore the tress of it is in a sense eternal.It will never be the case that Caesar crossed the Rubicon and did not cross the Rubicon.Right?That that's impossible.So it will eternally be true that Caesar crossed the Rubicon.Now if that's the case, then the truthfulness of events or propositions or whatever cannot be identified in the material events themselves.Obviously, it's I mean these are pretty simple arguments if you think about them.They do not the the propositions and their truths arguments he says do not depend on the material world.Triangularity and redness etc however are universal and therefore nominalism and conceptualism are false and do not work.Um the platonic the platonic realist solution doesn't work.The arisetilian realist solution doesn't work.And so really the only option here is to not ground uh abstract objects only in the human mind.
The human mind is changing.It's in flux.It's not uh uh it comes and goes in time and space.And as we pointed out from Aristotle, you can't I mean from from livveness there, you can't reduce universals or the truess of universals to the instantiations of the human mind.So the only other option really is to have a divine mind.By the way, he also points out that this makes sense too.Um because even by the way, even if you collected all the human minds, that still doesn't give you the universal.You see, where's the universal?How do you locate it?There's also a universal for every particular.That's Livess's point.So um if that's the case then the ultimate ground has to lie beyond individual finite human minds.The only other possibility given the fact that the universals and the particulars are an interlocking system.
Did you hear that?That's the argument I make all the time.They relate to one another.They interlock.Given the fact that they interlock, no finite mind can hold these together.You can't ground them in any finite mind.He says even angels, if you were trying, oh well, maybe we can ground these in the minds of angels.It doesn't work because they're still finite.Right?
Now, these logical relationships, he says, would hold whether or not this natural world existed, whether or not there was even any finite mind.So there must be a necessarily existing divine intellect which grasps all the logical relationships, all the propositions, all the possibilities and thus even the infinite number of mathematical propositions and thus if this is infinite then you need anomnisient mind.There's no other options.The ultimate ground of existence of the abstract objects would thus have to be the divine mind.There's no there's no other options.Right?Well, why does this mind have to be omnisient?Now, he goes into pointing out that uh gives some arguments about actus purist as to why this mind has to be omnisient that that's somehow uh higher level perfection or something that if if if uh if God haspotentia then somehow he's less perfect.Well, then he could then he didn't create freely, right?
Because we all believe that God could or could not free uh create the world, right?And if he freely created or if we just make the simple argument that God had the potential to create the world in a different way or is it logically possible that God created a world where there was noGod where there was no pope or Aquinas?If those are logically possible and if I can reverse this argument and say on the basis of God is pure potentiality with no with uh God is pure actuality no potential then all the potential must also be actualizedright you can reverse this argument either way then if all the potentia are actualized and there are all of the worlds that are possible logically possible then there's a world where there's no Aquinas and no pope and sotherefore the papacy is not necessary By the way, show me how that's a false argument on these grounds.
You can't.All right?Because again, listen to what I'm saying.So, if God is pure act, right, with no potential, I can take that argument in two different routes.I can go with the typical ads critique and say, then creation was not freely done.God didn't have the potential to create or not create, right?There was no dunamis distinct from ina.Does God have the power to create a world?Of course he does.Did he have to create it?No.He freely created it.So then God is not excluded from all potential.He does not have to actualize all the potential.But if he's pure act with no potential, then any potential possibility has to be actualized, right?I can cut the argument either way.And if that's the case, is it logically possible that God can create a world where there's no Aquinas and no Pope?
Yes.Then Aquinas and the Pope are not logically necessary.And the Roman Catholic system doesn't work.Anyway, divine conceptualism.uh he he h he tries to bring in absolute divine simplicity and act as purists, but there's a there's a big problem with this.Uh that's going to be the last point here.We got to make sure that I'm not going too close.By the way, in a few in a few minutes here, uh yes, please put the Discord link because we're going to have Metropolitan Jonah giving catechism classes in about 20 minutes in the Discord.So, I'll be getting off here uh and then we can do the rest of this in the part two of the talk.Uh maybe I'll have to extend this into other talks because I didn't really even get I only got halfway into Phaser's chapter here.I didn't even get to Basil and Aristotle and Andrev and I want to get to the sections of Aristotle that are relevant for this.
But

13. Feser's Divine Conceptualism and Divine Simplicity

Walkthrough of Feser's formal argument for divine conceptualism, highlighting his failure to address the absolute divine simplicity objection and how discrete ideas in God's intellect conflict with ADS.

uh Faser makes one of my critiques against uh Pltonism that
no that we already covered that earlier.What does it mean to say that uh the this world represents the forms?He's already said that.Um but the I won't have time to do it.So, uh Father Deacon will be put Yeah, there's the Discord link if anybody wants to join the discord and uh you can hear the uh um MS and Jonas lectures.But let's see if we can get through this argument from from Faser on divine conceptualism and and we'll follow this through.So he gives a series of steps and he says there are three possible accounts of the abstract objects such as universals, propositions, numbers and other mathematical objects and possible worlds.Realism, nominalism, conceptualism.There are decisive arguments in favor of realism.They are uh there are inseparable arguments against nominalism and there are insufferable arguments against conceptualism.So some version of realism must be true.
Correct.I would agree with that.There are three possible versions of realism.Platonic realism, arisatilian realism and what he calls scholastic realism which we are going to modify to say the realism of St.Maximus.If platonic realism is true then abstract objects exist in a third realm distinct from either the material world or the or any individual human intellect.If Arisatilian realism is true then abstract objects exist only in the human or in other contingently existing intellects.If scholastic or squish that if St.Maximus' realism is true, then abstract objects exist not only in contingently existing intellects, but also in at least one necessarily existing intellect, namely the divine mind.There are inseparable objections against the claim that abstract object objects exist in a platonic third realm distinct from either the material world or the intellect.Therefore, Platonic realism is not true.Correct?Yeah, we just covered all that in the rest in the earlier part of the chapter.
There are inseparable objects against the claim that abstract objects exist only in the human mind or in other contingently existing intellects.We covered that earlier.Therefore, Arisatilian realism is not true.So the last option here is a form of what he calls scholastic St.Maximus's realism.So abstract objects exist not only in contingently existing intellects but also in at least one necessarily existing intellect.
Next, uh, abstract objects such as universals, propositions, numbers, and other mathematical objects and possible worlds are all logically related to one another in an interlocking way such that they form a system of ideas.Yes, interlocking.The reasons for concluding that at least some abstract objects exist necessary in a necessarily existing intellect also entail that this interlocking system of ideas must exist in a necessarily existing intellect, the divine mind.Yes, we've argued that earlier.So, this interlocking system of ideas exists in at least one necessarily existing intellect.This is where it becomes problem 19.A necessarily existing intellect has to be purely actual.No, it doesn't.I just gave you uh the argument as to why that's impossible.It doesn't work.And he will even mention this argument and not answer it.Uh so there can be more than so there cannot be more than one necessarily existing intellect.
We would agree with that.uh an intellect in which the interlocking system of of ideas in question existed would be conceptually omnisient.Correct?We do agree with that.And by the way, it has to be the triad.And that's what we're going to argue as we move on.Uh now he moves on to some some more points that kind of we would agree with in a sense.But he basically just concludes this by saying therefore God exists, right?The the omnisient.But the problem is that what God are we talking about?uh we have not distinguished this generic theism of of a sort from any other generic monotheism.But we do not argue for generic monotheism.We argue for the father of our lord Jesus Christ who eternally generates the son and eternally spirates the spirit.That's the only god there is.And if we say that he is a bare monotheism, guess what?
Aristotle is the more consistent monotheist.What does Aristotle say in book 12 of the metaphysics?Aristotle says in book 12 that uh he he gives his definition of actis purus and absolute simplicity in book 12 chapters 567.I'm trying to hurry so we can get to Metropolitan Jonah.But uh you'll notice that it's right here.It's very clear.Uh if you want to go read these you can.567.He will speak of eternal matter, eternal movement, eternal substance that the first cause, the unmoved mover moves the first heaven eternally as his first substance.He's eternal substance, eternal matter.Basil, as we said, makes fun of this.He says, "You're a If you think this, this is in Hexamaron homaly 2 at the very beginning."And he will make fun of the great architect deity.and he's referring to this section of aerosol.So, props to father deacon anonyas for finding because the actually the notes in the shaft set are wrong or uh some other numbering system.
So, it took forever to find this but it's in book 12 56 and 7.Aristotle is more consistent because if the eternal first mover is is an eternal first mover for that to mean anything coherent he has to eternally move something.
If God is the eternal creator then he eternally creates or has a creation that's eternal which he's gone over.These arguments are dumb.Therefore, you can't hold to a bare monotheism and have the words and predicates and names of him mean anything without an eternal creation for him to be God and lord over.So, it's a very simple argument.Uh, and when we get to part two, we'll look at how Andrea responds to this, how Losi and Stanoi respond to this by pointing out that this obviously shows that the trinity is the only god who really solvesthis.There's no other options, right?There's no the the the dualism argument doesn't work.St.Maximus will refute that.The dualism god.The only other the only one you're left with is the trinity.Okay.So, it's not it's not that difficult here.Um but I'll close the part with uh with Faser by pointing out listen to what Faser says here with his objection the objections to uh realism and the problem his in his to system.
William Waywright suggests uh based on Grim's objection there also seems to be an an assumption of a model of divine knowledge which would be rejected by those that hold to God as absolutely simple or a non-composite being.In particular, it seems that uh it seems to assume that the view that Faser is arguing for, it seems to assume that truths that God knows correspond to discrete ideas in the divine intellect.Well, yeah.If the things in the in the world are grounded in in the divine mind in the Roman Catholic divine ideas argument, then if the things in the world are really distinct, then they got to be based on ideasthat are really distinct.But then you turn around and you say that the divine ideas are absolutely identical to the essence of God and they're not really distinct.They're only virtually anomaly distinct.
Yeah, it's a great argument.In particular, it seems to uh he says that um in the divine intellect, we could say that these are a set.But given the divine simplicity, what we describe in terms of such discrete ideas is really one and the same thing in God.Thank you for admitting that Phaser.There is in God something analogous to what we call our own intellects.So analogia and thus we grasp a propos proposition for example all men are mortal.We grasp something analogous to what we call uh to what we call a grasp or the proposition that Socrates is a man and so forth.So these propositions they're analogous to something in the divine mind.But these are just different ways of describing what in God is really one and the same thing.Exactly.So, how does that work?Guess what?Faser doesn't address it.
He just goes on.So, the very thing that I would go to, the very argument, Faser doesn't even reply to it.He just says, "Uh, yeah, well, it's different in God."Okay, but that's not an answer.Uh, and so he says, "These objections are not powerful."Right?The next page, this is the final page, he doesn't address that argument.He just says that it's not You know, it's just different in the divine intellect.But that's the very thing that's in question.So, Faser, how do you avoid the critique that you gave of Plato?Because you critiqued Platonic realism by saying that the descriptors of what's in the form in the monad are totally different than the descriptors of the things in this realm that are supposed to be analogous to or resemble it.You got the same problem, dude, when it comes to Aquinus.And you just pass over that argument.
you don't even address it.Maybe he'll address it.I hope so.Right.Uh anyway, in part two, we'll get to um how the triad is necessitated and solves these dilemmas via the exchange of love in the trinity.And this comes from St.Nikolai Maravich, Father Stanlo, uh Vladimir Loski, and Andrev, the Russian apologist Andrev.

14. Higher Order Logic and Aristotle's Categories

Introduction to the distinction between lower-order and higher-order logic, transcendental preconditions, Aristotle's ten categories, and his reductio proof of logic in Metaphysics Book 4.

So, we're going to make a distinction between two types of uh arguments, two types of logical statements, you could say.
And we'll call these uh lower order logic uh versus higher order logic.Those that would probably be the easiest way to categorize it.You'll hear me at times refer to kind of common claims, normal claims, but I'm going to go ahead and say uh let's talk about uh higher order and lower order logic.So if we have normal propositions that are made like the tree is green, whatever we can those kinds of statements and we move them to uh propositional logic, right?That's a higher order.That's a step up.So for example, the tree is green is a lower order statement than X is Y because now we're moving into a more higher formal type of statement, right?Or all X or Y, right?What we're doing in a transcendental argument is just kicking the bar up a step, right?We're moving up a little bit higher and saying, well, what has to be the case for that?
So, it's an even higher order meta, you could say, level question.And that's where we get into the necessary condition
or necessary preconditions you could say.
So here and if you go to the um Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy when they give uh the example of transcendental arguments this is the one that they always use uh it's the one I use in the debate youcan go see that that we've constantly pointed this out father deacon Dr.anis paper that we often direct people to.Uh it just lays this out, right?Because it's the most easy way through disjunctive form to see what a transcendental argument is.And as you can see when you compare it to these lower order claims, it's just a higher level, more powerful type of statement, right?So it's it comes before in the order of logic you could say as a precondition for these kinds of statements.Now there are perhaps some people who might take issue with this but typically speaking this isn't objected to.
There's nothing about X is the necessary condition for Y therefore X that's invalid.Now, we know that the atheist is going to take a issue with our plugging God into this.We know all that.But we just want to point out that all we're trying to demonstrate here at the outset is that this type of a of a claim or statement is of a higher, deeper, more powerful, use whatever analogies you wantorder of statement than this.And in fact, these are more fundamental and powerful than these.Such that if you deny this, this isn't possible.See how that is?In other words, for me to make these kinds of statements, I have a whole bunch of these kinds of statements or beliefs already assumed.So, this is where we get into what we call preconditions or transcendental types of categories.Now, Aristotle does not flesh out the notions of necessarily preconditions, right?
He doesn't have this really abstract uh contean style of precondition transcendental arguments.But if you have basic works of Aristotle, you'll know that the very first work is the categories.All right?And the categories according to Aristotle, it's not that it's kind of common sensical when you when you think about it.Aristotle lists in his trans uh his not transcendental his 10 categories and he just kind of comes up with 10.He says there is uh substance, quantity of that substance, the quality of the substance, the relation, the place, the time, the situation, the condition, the action, and the passion.And so he has a four-part system that then overlaps those 10 categories.So there's another important section that I would call your attention to.You don't even have to understand all the ins and outs of Aristotle to understand just kind of the basic ideas of what we're dealing with here if you're new to this stuff.
And it's Aristotle's book four of the metaphysics chapter 4.In that section, Aristotle just posits a kind of reductio where he says that if you deny logic, you're using logic to deny it.And so he says that logic itself is proven by reduio.Right?If you were to be a sophist and you argued against logic, said Aerosol, how do you know logic's true?Uh you would be assuming logic in the denial and that would be a reductio.So therefore, normally speaking, we don't get sofas to question logic itself.But if we did get one of those guys, we could refute them thus in that section.Now, this is going to bring us to again just kind of understanding the course of the debate over the centuries, right?To help us understand what we're talking about when we talk about transcendental categories of presuppositions, we're going to get through the 10 objections here.

15. Kant, Hume, and Transcendental Arguments

Kant's response to Hume's demolition of metaphysics through the Prolegomena, his categories as an ice-cube tray schema, and why Kant's phenomenal-noumenal distinction causes his project to fail.

We're going to start those here in a minute.Um now when Kant we have to understand that Kant is situated within the context of reading Hume.So Kant reads Hume uh he writes this book.I'll show it to you.
It's called the proleinant to any future metaphysics.Okay.And he says, "You know what everybody?I've read David Hume and Hume has really smashed metaphysics as a possible science or as the undergurting of science.And therefore, we're going to have to respond to Hume in order to be able to do metaphysics or philosophy proper ever again."Right?So, Kant correctly understands the import of the dilemma that Hume has put everybody in.This is why K human Kant are so important for us as proponents of transcendental argumentation.It is not because we are human or contean.Let's make that very clear from the outset.We are not contean.We are not adopting the philosophical autonomous man project of Kant.We are not human in the sense that we are accepting his radical skepticism.We are pointing out that on the skeptics's grounds, on the empiricist school of thought grounds, we're not justified in any of the claims, leaps, science, induction, etc., etc.
that we do.That is what Kant is saying here.Kant is saying we're going to have to answer Hume.We're going to have to answer the synthetic opriori dilemma.if we're ever going to be able to do any future metaphysics.So Kant thinks Kant's Kant's right as to assess what the issue is.He's right to propose using transcendental arguments as a way to reply.But Kant has a fatal flaw in his response which is the assumption of the phenomenal numinal distinction that we can never get to the exterior world.We can never know that the sense data is presenting us with the thing in themselves.Okay?And so therefore, Kant's project fails not because of transcendental arguments, but because he makes the whole project situated in the mind.The individual human mind becomes the schematic organizer of the sense data.The mind in Kant's view is like imagine it like a 12 uh sectioned ice cube tray.
The sense data that comes in to the ice cube tray is like the water coming into and being given form and organization in this 12 schema ice cube tray.What is the schema for for Kant?It is the the the time space medium by which we bring in the sense data that the mind as the ice cube tray organizes.The 12 spots in the ice cube tray for Kant are his version of Aerosol's categories.Does that make sense?So even though what we're saying kind of sounds abstract, it's actually if you think about it, it's not that difficult.So for example, Aristotle I'm going to read just a brief uh intro level statement about this.Aristotle claimed that the following 10 predicates or categories could be asserted of any object in general.Substance, quantity, relation, right?The things that we read before.The categories of Aristotle and Kant are the general properties that belong to all things that don't necessarily express any particular object.
Okay.So, so far no problems, pretty clear.Any object, however, must have the categories as a precondition for the possibility of knowing those objects.Okay?So, in order to know about an object in your sense experience, it's going to have to have these relations or these qualities or these categories like uh what are the ones we listed?Aristotles were uh unity.No, wait, that's not that's cons.Aristotles were substance, quantity, quality, relation, place, time, situation, condition, action, passion.Now, Kant doesn't think that this is the the best list.He kind of uh tweaks this list and he gives what he calls a table of judgment, right?So he puts these into a different kind of ordering system, but it's the same basic idea.The the categories do not provide knowledge of individual particular objects.Any object must have these categories as a precondition, right?For the experience or for the knowledge of those objects.
It is presupposed or assumed that anything that is a specific object must possess the categories as its properties because categories are predicates of any object in general.Now Kant is correct in looking types of things and saying that we need this for metaphysics to be possible.Right?I mean Aristotle's metaphysics is all premised on these kinds of things.Yeah.But Hume is sayingnone of that can be proven from sense data.And Kant's like, "Okay, Hume, we can't respond to that if we start with sense data."So Kant's problem is rather than looking to reveal theology to answer these dilemmas to smush all of this into the human mind.In other words, in Kant's system, the problem is not transcendal argumentation, but rather the smooshing of what the divine mind does for us as theists into a finite human mind.Doing this undermines the entire project because you don't actually know that anything out there in the external world is the case.
You don't know if other minds operate like the mind that you think is operating in this way.Right?Kant might could study his own phenomenal mental states but he doesn't know if other minds work this way by the very fact that he can never get beyond uh the phenomenon.This leads to a school of philosophy called phenomenalism.And centuries after this you'll have people who who admit we can never know objects in themselves.And since we can't we'll just study the phenomena as they appear to us.phenomenology.
Anyway, the all of that was just to say that we're not interested in Kant's autonomous humanist project.We're not interested in transcendental idealism.We're not transcendental idealists.So, but transcendental arguments have a life outside of Kant.They're not restricted to they don't begin with Kant or Vanill,
right?The form of the argument can go back to Aristotle.
And so, as you can see, one of the objections that we'll deal with that this is all Calvinism or Contianism completely fails because the arguments have nothing to do with the people who make the arguments because the formis valid.
So that's the first thing that we wanted to understand is that what are we talking about when we're talking about transcendental categories or preconditions.So as you saw what we're saying is these categories Kant puts them like uh for quantity he has a universal and a particular right and that the mind makes judgments about these states for quality affirmative or negative forrelation categorical or hypothetical for modality problematical or asoretic right so it's similar to what Aristotle was after but Kant gets really kind of like specified about it he's like Aristotle's categories weren't good enough.We need better, more and I'm not saying Kant's right in all this.I'm just saying that the basic principle here is correct that what we're looking at and there's other types of things too like Kant talks about for example that in order to have perceptions there has to be a perceiver.
So there has to be some kind of transcendental unity of app perception he calls it which is just to say that there's a self there's some self that undergurs the incoming sense data that gives them meaning and perceivesthem that self is obviously not the subject of empirical sense data.So next what we want to do we want to see why this is such an important crucial debate and issue is we want to be familiar with what's called the parapotetic axiom.

16. Peripatetic Axiom and Hume's Critique

The peripatetic axiom that nothing is in the intellect not first in the senses, Hume's devastating consistency argument against empiricism, and Quine's abandonment of rational justification.

The parapotetic axiom is the basically the position of Aristotle that will be 100% adopted by Thomas Aquinus
and it really is the root of the whole problem.Right?When we did when we covered this in part two last night, we saw that phaser never grasps the actual critique is of the parapathetic axiom itself.In other words, if if you're going to be an empiricist, you need to be consistent.What is the parapathetic axiom?Nothing is in the intellect that is not first in the senses.Right?It is found in Deerat of Aquinus.Question two, answer three, response 19.Aquinus adopts this principle from the parapotetic school of Greek philosophy, namely Aristotle.A Quinus argued that God's existence could thus be proven by reasoning from sense data and he used this variation of the Arisatilian notion of the active intellect which interprets the which is interpreted as the ability to abstract universalsfrom the empirical sense data in front of you.Now what all Hume is doing if we want to understand the project of Hume very simply is just to point out that if you're an empiricist a strict empiricist and Hume is saying all you guys that want to
start with sense impressions all you guys that want to start with a parapathetic axiomif we are going to be consistentthen none of the things that we believe in that are that are these categories ories or principles or powers or energies or intelli or whatever tilos causation all these arisetan things act potency principles sufficient reason all these differentcategories that you could or principles that you could come up with they're not immediately under the purview of sense data hence argument billyard ball A hitting billyard ball you're not actually perceiving causation you're perceiving event A, event B,and you're calling that causation.Where in the sense data, where under a rock, where in a microscope do you see causation itself?You don't.Therefore, none of these things can be proven empirically.It's a very simple premise and a very simple presentation.It's not that complicated, not that difficult.
So after Hume, you have centuries of philosophers simply trying to respond to this all the way up until Quine.Go into the discord.Read Father Deacon's paper.What is Father Deacon's paper?Is epistemology naturalized?Really epistemology?This is his analysis of WVO Quin's two dogmas of empiricism and it just simply says that look Quin admits that we are and nowadays centuries after David Hume still stuck in the problems that Hume presented.If we are sufficiently skeptical then we can't justify the principles upon which science is based because they're non-empirical.It's a very simple argument.So they cannot be justified.Quin argues, let's just give up the project of rational justification.Just give it up.And now it will be merely the project of psychism.Right?Now philosophy will just be the study of mental states.We're just going to be pure rank psychologists.Hence the term psychologist.
Because what else are we left with?You can't justify these things obviously, right?None of these things themselves are empirical.And the whole system is collapsing because of the fact that it's built on the parapathetic axiom.Right?So all Hume is doing is saying that if nothing is in the intellect that isn't first in the senses then God is never in the intellect because God is never in the senses.Tilos is never in the intellect because tilos is not in your sense data.Causation is not in your sense data.Right?and subsequent philosophers for many centuries will just eviscerate all the assumptions of empiricist philosophers right for the next several centuries all the way up to modern day Wilfrid sellers and people saying that it's even worse than that there'sa myth of the given that objects are just given to us as if we could just pick out one sense data to start with as if that one picking out of sense data that we're going to start with
as an empiricist isn't part part of a lex lexicon or web of beliefs that we have obviously and so the whole project is laughable and ludicrous and then you've got to people living in the middle ages like thishasn't been critiqued for the last several hundred years they don't even understand what they're replying to anyway so let's get to the first mistake now that we've grasped what we're talking about when we're talking about preconditions Right?We're talking about things like the self.We're talking about categories, right?We're talking about things like universals, particulars.We're talking about abstract concepts.We're talking about relation.We're talking about time space placement, you could say.Okay.Um, we're talking about unity and quantity.We're talking about distinction itself.Okay?These are predicates of objects that are necessary as preconditions for the possibility of experiencing objects.
Um what else did we say?We said uh Aristotles were substance, quantity, quality, relation, action, affection, place, time, position, and state.Kant modifies those.Comes up with 12.Uh we're not going to spend too much time focusing on Kant.It's not that big of a deal.Because what we're getting at here is just that these things have to be the case.Okay.Now when we ask how do you prove those things?This is where transcendental argumentation comes into play because what do you mean by proof?Do you mean by proof give a physical proof of that?I mean a rank empiricist type of person literally means yes.give me physical proof of immaterial types of things like preconditions or universals or whatever.Well, that makes no sense.And that's what we call the crackers in the pantry fallacy because the type of thing that we're arguing for if it's immaterial is obviously not going to be proven in a material way.
And everybody already admits and believes this.Nobody believes that everything is demonstrated or proven in the same way.Right?You don't prove whether or not water boils at 100° in the same way that you prove a really abstract math problem.Right?So that's equivocating on the notion of proof and in what sense and how we prove different types of things.So you're not going to it's impossible to prove something abstract and immaterialby necessitating that it be proven in an empirical uh material way.right from the outset that uh moves the goalpost to where it's impossible to do the thing that you're trying to do.It's like the the atheist saying for example um prove to me immaterial objects in a material way and I will believe them.It's already limiting the types of proof that he will allow by metaphysically saying I don't accept anything immaterial unless it's material.
You see it's very simple.So uh what has come to be the case in terms of argumentation that I think refutes a lot of these mistakes is transcendental arguments.Right?The same way that we're going to prove these types of preconditions since they're immaterial is by the impossibility of the contrary.That is what Kant does, right?Kant makes this move.He doesn't think they're true of the external world which is self-defeating.But regardless, the idea that you got to have these preconditions to have knowledge is clearly true, right?I mean, if there isn't logic, meaning these kinds of things, then you can't have knowledge of these of anything, right?I mean, having knowledge of something in some way presupposes things like a knower.It presupposes the ability to have knowledge.It presupposes some concept or some notion of knowledge itself, right?I mean all of these things are prior to right knowing objects.
So we're not talking about any particular object yet.We're talking about what has to be the case for the possibility of knowing objects and that's what we're talking about when we talk about preconditions.So when we list those preconditions that as I've said and I think that there's more than I mean includes universals and particulars in that but I mean I think you can include other things too like the self umthese these things also kind of are assumed in any knowledge act you could say none of those things are under the purview of empirical data but they're assumed in the process of empirical sense data you Okay.

17. Objections: TAG Doesn't Prove and Circular Argument

Response to the objections that TAG is merely an assumption and that it is circular, explaining paradigm-level argumentation, the crackers-in-the-pantry fallacy, and unavoidable circularity at the transcendental level.

So, let's deal with then the first objection.Now that we've understood what we're what type of thing we're doing here, the way that we're doing it, and by the way, I'll remind you that my version of tag is we'll we'll have a three-step process to myversion, which is, as you know, one uh we have knowledge claims, right?Knowledge claims presuppose are based or are based on preconditions,the things that we're already talking about, the categories, etc.All these different uh things that are assumed for knowledge to be possible or to be the case.And then when you bundle all the preconditions together, you need a specific type of thing that grounds, justifies, and makes coherent and explains those preconditions.And that's God in our in our argument.Now, I'm going to flesh the argument out for you atheists have a meltdown.I know you're not going to immediately accept that.
I'm going to flesh this out.But I'm saying that this is the three three-step process that I'm going to do in my argument, right?All right, I'm going to say that all knowledge claims are predicated on preconditions.The types of things that we've talked about, aerosols, types of categories, the they're the preconditions for the possibility of experience.They're not experiences themselves, per se.They're the preconditions for the possibility of experience.Again, remember at the beginning we talked about lower order and higher order, right?This is lower order.We're moving it up to higher order the preconditions and I'm going to include things like universals abstract objects.Then when we look at all these as we saw if you watch the last lecture phaser has one good chapter in this book chapter 3 where he makes an argument that these things he doesn't talk about preconditions he
talks about universals but these things including universals interlock.If these interlock and necessitate one another, they do.Then we need something even higher, a third higher order of justification that justifies them.Now, an atheist could conceivably say, "Ah, well, what's going to justify this?"In this system, this is the final reference point of justification in this whole paradigm.Right?In the orthodox paradigm, there is no higher justification than God himself.God is the ultimate transcendental.He's the ultimate circularity, right?he is the there's no other reference point beyond him and you say well how do we know that because the system itself dictates that right so this circle here is not just an abstract conception it's not just uhan argument about God or an idea it's the entire paradigm so this is this is this is why I'm not going to argue the argument just on the basis of um a conceptual scheme because well that's one of
the objections we're going to deal with in a minute.My argument, my version of this argument is the entire orthodox paradigm which is part of the argument for God, right?Including everything that we believe is orthodox that is the the ground and the basis for the preconditions which are the ground and the basis for any possibility of knowledge any knowledge claim.Now, I know that right now that's not going to necessarily uh convince people, but as we go through the objections, hopefully it will be a little clearer what exactly we're saying.
So, the first objection is this argument doesn't prove anything.It's an assumption.Now, as we saw, this is a uh tripping up on the word proving.It's related to the crackers in the pantry fallacy as Bonson correctly called it which is just to uh mistakenly assume that everything is proven in the same way.If you saw the Matt Dillah Hunty debate, this is what Matt did.Matt said proving something is an empirical de demonstration, a scientific demonstration or a mathematical logical demonstration.Except that even Matt and Malpest and other people admit that not everything is proven in the same way.Right?So if we admit that, then the way that we're going to argue for and prove God is not going to be the same as the way that we argue for and prove material objects, right?Because God is not a material object.God is not a object of sense data.
God is not a thing.So the way that he's argued for or proven will not be like the way that we prove things that are not like him.The way that we go about proving him will be more like not identical to but more like the way that we argue for universals, abstract concepts, math in itself, mathematical entities, the laws of logic
uh or uh transcendental preconditions.That does not mean that God is identical to math or that he's identical to logic or that he's identical to universals.It's just saying that the way that we argue for that type of a thing is similar to the way that we're arguing for those types of things, the abstract entities.And by that, I don't mean that God is an abstract entity, right?We don't say that.So what we're looking for then in this kind of an argument at a at we're calling a higher order paradigm level.So when you hear me talking about paradigm level arguments I'm meaning the same thing as higher order logical argumentation meta level stuff.That's all we mean.And you can you can you can make the analogy higher order or more foundational.It doesn't matter either way.It's making the same point.So what we're looking for is I would I would argue uh a paradigm has to be coherent.
It has to have explanatory power and it has to have justificatory force.Right?So these three things are involved in reasoning for or convincing people of a paradigm.So you can't just say uh well I come up with a mental scheme that is a perfect uh math algorithm that explains everything.So therefore I don't have to believe in your god because I I could come up with a mentally coherent math world that's coherent.But you see therefore uh tag isn't true because you don't believe in the perfectly coherent algorithm, right?You believe in a god.Well, that might have some degree of coherence, but that's not all that we're asking for in terms of a worldview.Remember when we had the objection from some of the atheists that I can come up with a uh universe that is one molecule, there's nothing contradictory about that.
It's coherent and therefore you can't prove tag if there is that as a possible world.That fails not because of coherent.First of all, I don't think that's coherent.But even if it was, it doesn't have explanatory power for this world and the paradigm that we're arguing for in this reality.And it doesn't have any just victory force at all.So it completely fails in terms of what we're looking for in justifying uh explaining and making coherent a paradigm.the one molecule universe, the one atom universe or whatever, the the fictional world of JF where there's a computer on a planet spitting out algorithms that's not incoherent is not a justification of paradigm level questions.It's not an explanation and it's not coherent.So that's the first objection that we want to deal with is that your argument doesn't prove anything.It's merely an assumption.
It's not merely an assumption.It's an argument.It's an argument from the impossibility of the contrary that is about an entire paradigm.Right?If the argument was something like um God exists and therefore God exists, right?That would be circular.It wouldn't do anything.It wouldn't prove anything.It wouldn't be a very good argument.It would just be a restatement.it would be circular, right?It doesn't tell us anything.Rather, the argument is in the domain of ethics, metaphysics, and epistemology, what we're going to call the most basic level of paradigm, only the trinitarian orthodox conception of God, can give a coherent, justificatory, and explanatory power to thebasic assumptions of those three things.That's the argument.Okay.And because all those three things go together, they interlock, right?Not just the preconditions, but the preconditions in these three domains of philosophy or a paradigm or a worldview.
Because they interlock, they cannot explain themselves.They have to be grounded in something that's even higher order.That's our argument.Now, you may disagree with that as an atheist.I'm sure you will.But let's at least understand that that is the argument first because I think 90% of the time they don't even understand what the argument is and that that is the argument.So uh it the the objection that it doesn't prove anything.It's just an assumption is missing the point that it's an argument at the paradigm level.And so therefore it does prove things at a paradigm level.And we showed in the first 20 minutes on what basis we are arguing for something that's norm that's normal language or lower order language natural language versus something that's higher order.So objection one dispelled.Objection number two this is a circular argument bro and circular arguments are invalid.
Now if we were classical foundationalists we would agree.we would have to say, "Yeah, dude."Uh, circular arguments are valid, invalid, unless we're at the paradigm level where they are unavoidable.For example, arguments about words.How can you define or prove that words have meaning without using words?You can't.How can you describe or define or explain numbers without using other numbers?You can't.And so those are examples of things that at a certain level there's no lower or higher order things that you could appeal to, right?Because they become self-referencing.So this is why for example, remember what we said about Hume earlier.Hume says, "You guys who affirm the parapotetic axiom that nothing is in the intellect that's not first in the senses, you're inconsistent because I want you to show me in the sense data where any of these abstract thingsthat you appeal to are."
You can't do it.You have to assume the thing that you're appealing to, right?And if you assume the thing that you're appealing to in a foundationalist scheme as an empiricist, you're being circular.Now, as proponents of the transcendental argument, we're admitting yes, it's unavoidable.At a certain level, at a certain point, all arguments become circular.How can you argue at a meta level for anything without being circular?How can you argue for the status of logic itself, the logic of logic without being circular?You can't.What does Gordell's incompleteness theorems show?Circularity, right?It's impossible to avoid.
So this argument that it's circular, bro, is missing again the point that the argument is about uh truths, beliefs at the precondition, presuppositional paradigm level, not about normal language or lower order logic or claims or natural language.uh and by extension we can include the uh really uh low-level argumentation or or excuse me u mistake that this is uh all Kant and this is all vaniel why would that's like saying that all the church fathersare arisatilian because they use arguments that aerosol use right that's a genetic fallacy it doesn't matter whether uh vanill made a million transcendental arguments or never made any transcend it has absolutely nothing to do with whether transcendental argumentsthemselves are valid or invalid.Uh and as I said earlier, we are not adopting Kant's humanist project.So it has nothing to do with conteinism.Right?As if the person who says, you know, as if uh syllogisms uh are only valid because Aristotle said them or invalid because Aristotle said them.
I mean nobody believes this.This is ridiculous, right?And and especially when the toists come with this stupid objection where they say this is all Bonson and Vaniel.Oh, really?Uh you guys are obsessed with St.Aristotle.Give me a break.

18. Objection: TAG Doesn't Prove God

Response to the claim that transcendental arguments only prove preconditions but not God, showing how interlocking universals require an omniscient divine mind as their ground and comparing rival paradigms.

All right.And thank you for those super chats.We'll be getting to those here in a minute.But umI'm going to hold off for the main objections to the very end.Um, this one is related to the main objection at the very end, which will be how does it prove the Trinity or Jesus?We're going to save that for the last objection because that's one of the most difficult.But maybe a more general version of this objection is look, dude, the transent argument might show preconditions, right?But it doesn't prove God.Okay?It doesn't prove any kind of higher order thing beyond the preconditions.Now, I'm going to direct you.I know you don't have this book, but if you didn't hear the talk that I did the other day from chapter 3 that's public, go listen to the talk that I did on universals.
All right?Because Faser's one good chapter in this book is the chapter on universals.And what he talks about in that chapter is look when we try to consider universals you could also look at father deacon's um argument that he gave uh on the immaterial immateriality of abstract objects right that you couldprove this even from strict boolean argumentation all right even with no existential import you can show that um speaking of an entire set of objects cannot be identified with material physical objects All right, which if you go readhis paper, watch his or go watch his video on that, he argues that just strictly in terms of set theory, you can show that it's not the case, that you can't reduce any universal to any particular physical.But more specifically on the ontological issue, what phaser does is show in in in many many arguments that abstract objects, universals, numbers, laws of logic, concepts, possible worlds, propositions, truth values, all have to have some type of existence.
And maybe we're not even going to say what kind yet.We don't know yet.that cannot be identified or reduced to states of matter.Okay?None of those things are uh uh coherently isomorphically reduced to or identified with or um encapsulated by pure matter or physicalism.And in fact, we run into all kinds of basic self-refuting nonsense when we reduce universals, possible worlds, words and predicates, um, preconditions, even science as a methodology, the principles of science or concepts to physical matter.It's really stupid and self-refuting.And so we get to the fact that words and language there's an essay by Fraga thought where Fraga makes the argument that even language and communication has a whole host of transcendental types of preconditions that are necessary thathave to be the case for even to have the possibility of communication.Okay, that's a higher order question than examining some instance of communication.
Right?So you and I were having this instance of communication through the computer, right?Frago would say before you can even have that as a possibility, there's all these things that have to be the case.You see, very similar, very same type of argumentation that we saw with Kant.What are the preconditions for the possibility of communication?Just applying the same argument to a different type of thing.And so in this chapter of uh uh he will go on to make multiple types of arguments based on uh fraga based on argumentation of St.Augustine in terms of divine conceptualism.Now keep in mind this is key because my version of tag is a divine conceptualist version of tag.So just keep that in mind because we're going to have to locate these universals and all of these things somewhere.They're not.We can't locate them in the finite human mind.
Can't locate them in matter, but they got to be somewhere or somehow.They must be somehow or somewhere.And they must have some kind of existence in some way that allows them to continue to be irrespective of states of matter and time and space and flux because they don't change.Right?And let's use an argument from linenets here.Caesar crossed the Rubicon.That's an argument.That's an event that happened in history.And we're going to say for the sake of argument that it did happen, right?It's not made up or something.So Caesar did cross the Rubicon.If I were to write out that sentence, isn't it the case that no matter what happens in history or in the future, nothing's going to change the truthfulness of that proposition, right?It's never going to not be the case that Caesar crossed the Rubicon.Right?So this is this is called the argument from the eternality of truth from linenets that you can't equate propositions or the truthful the truth value of propositions to matter or to to physicality because physicality matter.
It's always in flux.But even the propos even the truth value of that sentence will never change.It's never going to not be the case that that happened.And since that's the case, obviously these kinds of objects, abstract objects, numbers, right?Seven coconuts is not identical to the number seven.It's the same point being made, right?That's all we're saying here.So Faser's excellent argument in that chapter is that these types of things don't operate.And you've heard me make this argument.That's why I was at le I'm at least going to give Faser a lot of props for making the argument that I make there which is again Austinian and Wenitzian.Yes, it is.Which is that all of these types of things are interlocking universals, possible worlds, words and predicates, indirect argumentation, laws of logic, concepts, right?
These types of things don't just exist in a vacuum.
They can't just be momentary figments of the human mind.Where are they?What are they?This is why we need a some type of omnisient omnipresent mind that grounds and interlocks them.You could saythere's no other options.You see, now I know you're going to say, "Oh, well, this doesn't prove that the the Christian God."We'll get there.That's going to be the last objection.But right now, we're just dealing with the objection that you can't move from the preconditions to God.But what I'm arguing, and by the way, uh, Faser doesn't exactly talk about preconditions.He almost kind of does when he talks about Fraga's section about what's necessary for thought and communication.That's pretty much what we're talking about here, right?We're not just saying Kant's categories only relate to the mind, though.they relate to the mind and the world.Right?
So, we're affirming a kind of realist position that has to we're saying that a form of realism has to be the case.We're not going to argue for Plato, but we're saying that there is some kind of realism that with all of these types of objects which don't exist in a vacuum.They inter interlock as a phaser says there must be some form of divine conceptualism that makes them coherent and coherent amongst themselves that gives them explanatory power and gives them justificatory force.Right?They don't change into the o opposite of themselves.Why not?Because they're grounded in the divine mind.The divine mind is invariant.It's immaterial.It's omnisient.It's universal.Right?It's everywhere.God's mind's not over there.He doesn't lack facts.Right?So, the omnis are a great point that we want to bring in to show that that's how we ground these objects now.
You say, "Well, I don't buy that."Right?We know atheists, we know you don't buy that.But what we're showing is that our paradigm can give a coherent explanatory justification for these things, how they are, where they be, how they do, what they is.Okay, that's what we're saying.Now you say, but that doesn't prove it.Again, we're comparing two paradigms.the atheist paradigm in this example versus the paradigm that we just gave.Right?You may not like this, but this paradigm that I just gave of the divine mind grounding these universals, showing how they interlock, how they relate to a world separate from God, etc., etc., etc.This is giving a coherent explanatory justification.The atheist paradigm, by contrast, can't even get off the ground.Not only can it not give a justification, the materialist atheist perspective as an example has no uh explanatory par power power, has no coherence.
It cannot even explain the how the poss how these objects are even possible.It negates the possibility of knowledge at all.That is the argument.You see the comparison of two rival paradigms is the argument.That's what the atheists, the opponents, even even the evidentialist apologists, even they don't understand that that's the argument.

19. Objections: Evidentialism and Made-Up Logic

Critique of evidentialist apologetics as inconsistent with classical foundationalism, followed by refutation of the claim that laws of logic are invented social constructs using the eternality of truth.

So, let's move on to the next objection.Um, let's move to the evidentialist apologist, right?Cameron Soyuzi or whatever his name is.These kinds of guys.Yo, it doesn't prove anything.You guys are just like removing evidences.That's totally a misunderstanding.In fact, evidences have a very important place in the apologetic.We don't put them in the wrong position though, right?We don't put evidences ahead of the best arguments that we have.That would be foolish.And it's very easy to show that evidential apologetics is a complete failure because it just assumes the very things that Hume calls out that are not answered.Right?What what did sellers say about the myth of the given?Right?How do you have access to a an epistemically privileged position?You don't.Nobody does.And since nobody does, right?If we're classical foundationalists and evidentialist apologetics is based on classical foundationalism, there's never going to be any way to follow through the parapetic axiom and justify the things that they believe in without appealing to the things that they
believe in.But that whole system evidentialism and classical foundationalism is built on that the the belief that you can't do circular arguments.Right?So again circular arguments are both valid and invalid in different cases and in different situations in first order natural language first order logic lower order logic it's invalid to make circular arguments.This is the basic mistake of T dump the other day.But at a higher level, they're unavoidable.That's the point.And that's the point that the evidentialist doesn't understand.You see?So all we have to do to refute Stefon is the same thing that we would do to refute the evidentialist, the evidentialist apologist.I'm saying which is to say as Hume said you guys are inconsistent and you also are allowing things that are not as certain to be the starting point
2:43:11 - 2:43:13
for what should be more certain.
2:43:13 - 2:44:12
In other words, if God exists, God is more certain than the laws of logic.God is more certain than any of these abstract principles that you are appealing to.Right?because he's the ground of those things in the Christian paradigm.So, how are you going to use things that he's the ground of as if they were more certain than him and then say that God's existence is 98% certain, 95% certain.So, mathematics is more certain than God's existence.What a stupid argument.All any smart atheist has to do is point out that you've already conceded your point because now the real god of your system is logic and math and logic and math are more certain than God.And if that's the case, then your god is not ultimate.This is the stupidity and folly of evidentialist apologetics.It's literally trying to argue stuff that has been refuted 500 years ago.
And all you have to do is read David Hume understand the parapet parapotetic axion can't be proven has to be assumed.So it's circular.So either admit circular arguments
or give up your foundationalism.And let's look at the other uh uh boxes that the uh empiricist will be stuck in.Right.What did I list?If you look at the debate with Stefon, Stefan is an empiricist just as much as the evidentialist apologist is an empiricist most of the time.And I said, Stefan, if you're an empiricist, how are you going to avoid this?Applies to Aristotle.It applies to Aquinus.It applies to every evidentialist, every classical theist, and every classical foundationalist.You will never get out of these boxes.The myth of the given, the problem of the external world, the problem of induction, the status of material objects, and that there's no properly basic beliefs.You can't solve those things without appealing to those things.And if you do, that's circular.And you're no longer a classical foundationalist because you don't believe in circular arguments.
It's actually pretty simple when you understand the strength of Hume's critique.And the low IQ people are going to be like, "You're human.This is a is this you're just David Hume, dude."No.David Hume's argument has nothing to do with David Hume.I'm not Aristotilian because I'm using an argument from Aerosol.I'm not Vanilian because I'm using an argument from Vantel.Doesn't matter.It's just really low lowle objections.Thank you for those super chats.Uh so feel free to um continue that.We got 260 live tonight.Welcome everybody.We're covering the top 10 bad objections to tag that are all based on misunderstandings and low-level slow boys.When the slow boys come out dripping that drool off of that chin trying to trying to respond, wipe that dribble, boy.
Uh so that's how we would respond to the evidentialist.The evidentialist is in the exact same boat as the arisatilian, the tomist, the classical theist, the classical foundationalist.They've not responded to David Hume.And when Faser writes his book, he never responds to David Hume's central critique of the parapotetic axiom itself on its own grounds.on your own grounds.How do you know that the only thing that is in the intellect is first in the senses?That principle itself cannot be proven from sense data.But if you start with sense data, you're going to have to prove that from sense data.It's very simple.And father deacon's paper that we've cited and linked a million times makes the same point from all the places in Aristotle where Aristotle begins with basic empirical sense data.Guys, come on.You got to have a better apologetic.That's why Cameron, by the way, when I asked Cameron to debate, Cameron Soy Tusi, I said, "Let's debate."
When when IP backed out, when they said, "Oh, you're too mean.We're not going to bait you.You're too mean.I said, Cameron, what what training do you have?What is your degree in?He said, photography.I mean, I I meant what is your philosophic training?Right.He says photography.Exactly.Right.No wonder.
And I was going to try to apologize and make up with with Cameron because uh I would like to be on good terms with him, but I mean, he literally thinks Matt Dillah Hunty won our debate.That's how soy this guy is.I mean, he literally can't grasp what a presuppositional argument is.They think that it means that you don't do evidences.Bro, the transcendental argument is an evidence.It's the ultimate evidence.It It requires evidences.This is just like basic misunderstanding.And they don't want to talk to you.They're not interested in trying to understand this stuff.All right.So, so the last objection was the evidentialist uh uh claim.They're stuck in the position of Hume.They don't understand the critiques of Hume and that we all ultimately rely on circular argumentation at a certain level.It's unavoidable.Um,
next, let's deal with the argument, uh, I think Tump made this one.The laws of logic are made up, dude.They're contingent.They're just things that we invent.They're social constructs that work.This one is really, really laughable.Uh I mean, who actually believes that the laws of logic are made up?Uh who believes that Mandelro sets are made up, right?If you do any reading on that subject, what's immediately apparent is that there are a whole host of really complex mathematical things that many mathematicians, engineers, and even scientists will speak of as discoveries.Manor broad sets are just the easiest way to disprove this because we couldn't really lay them out until we had computers that had the processing power to demonstrate the insane level of patterns as we zoom in or zoomout to you know these really extreme depths.So what that shows right away very simply is that a mandler set as an example like everything else in mathematics that is discovered.
It's not invented.It's not made up.It's discovered.
And who actually thinks that I mean think how silly this is.I was I was uh I went out and and uh I disco I noticed I lifted a rock and I found the laws of logic there.really obviously not.When something like laws of logic or really abstract things are worked out or or argued, they're discovered and their truth value as we saw from the liveness argument is not contingent upon any material thing.
And all of these objects that we've talked about, the abstract objects, numbers, laws of logic, universals, by definition of what they are, they do not have the properties of variance and flux, materiality, temporality.They're not restricted to any area and space and time.Right?Let's invoke once again Linets's argument of the the eternality of truth.That alone disproves this stupid argument.Right?Will it ever not be the case that Caesar crossed the Rubicon?So it's universally the case that truth value will never change.No matter what happens in the physical flux world, seven coconuts does not equal the number seven obviously.So we can easily dispense with that really low IQ stupid objection.

20. Objection: TAG Doesn't Prove Trinity

Response to the objection that TAG proves only a generic god, arguing that the system is based on revelation, that Odin copy-paste fails, and that worldviews are limited to a small number of starting options.

Next, let's get a little more sophisticated.So, the the that we're getting more and more that that was the last of the low IQ objections.Let's get a little more sophisticated here with Wait a minute, dude.Your argument doesn't prove a trinity.Your argument proves perhaps some kind of mental god or some abstraction.Maybe there's like a universal computer or we're in a simulation and the simulation includes within its programming transcendental categories.Now, on the surface, this kind of sounds like uh a good objection, right?It's similar to the argument that we heard earlier that I can come up with a universe that's coherent and therefore your position uh doesn't work.But my argument wasn't premised merely on coherence.The argument was premised on coherence and explanatory power and justificatory force.We were saying that was included in what we expect of a worldview or a paradigm.
The worldview or the paradigm needs to show that in ethics, metaphysics, and epistemology there's coherence, explanatory power, just victory force.That is the argument.So, the claim, well, how do you prove a trinity and why not Odin, right?This is where it gets funny because you'll get the guys that are like, well, dude, what if I just took every one of your metaphysical things, right?The the grand metaphysical structure of your worldview and I just stick in Odin, dude.Gotcha.Well, there's a problem with this.First of all, this whole system is not based on abstract speculation.It's based on revelation.We believe and defend what is revealed.What is revealed is the triune God, not Odin.Okay?That's what we're here to defend.So that metaphysical structure that we have as our inheritance from our church fathers from Maximus, John Damascus, the Capidosians, all these uh Christian philosophers who give us our grandiose metaphysic that happened in history that comes down as a
deposit part of our paradigm, part of the deposit of our revealed faith.You see, so you can't bastardize, copy and paste all of that into Odin.It doesn't work.And by the way, as I said earlier, evidential arguments have their place.I can bring in evidential arguments at this point because I'm going to say my worldview is what's revealed in scripture.The Old Testament predicts in probably 150 plus places the coming Messiah.Says nothing about Odin.Right?Remember, we're not arguing for a mere conceptual scheme, some mindscape.We're arguing for a God who stepped into time and space.We're arguing for the whole Christian paradigm, including the doctrine of creation, including the incarnation and redemption, including the history of the church.That's all part of the paradigm.You see, so at this juncture, it is valid to bring in historical arguments, evidential arguments.Right?When I start saying that there's all these prophecies about Christ, that's part of my paradigm.
that discounts copy and paste with Odin.And by the way, nobody believes if you were to literally start just think how silly this would be.Uh Odin is the second person of the godhead.Odin stepped into time and space and became incarnate and died 20.Nobody believes that.That doesn't work for you.Nobody believes Odin is a uh ultimate unity and uh triad reality.No, that's not.So it's obvious that this type of argumentation is purely theor theoretical and actually just copy and paste bastardizing the Christian metaphysic.So it doesn't work.So you say why a trinity one because it's revealed just simply put our ultimate circularity and the point where our argument stops is revelation.We can't go any more fundamental any more uh uh meta than that.That's the ultimate meta.That's the ultimate stopping point.The ultimate foundation, the ultimate presupposition, the ultimate precondition is divine revelation.
And this relates then to you have to disprove every worldview.No, I don't.Because this is again a mistake.Uh that was the first mistake right of not understanding higher order and lower order argumentation.When you confuse those two that's when you might think I have to disprove every single worldview.No.All I have to do is disprove given what my argument is.So don't straw man my argument.If you want to deal with my argument, my argument is that every worldview has basic assumptions in ethics, metaphysics, and epistemology.You're very limited in the number of steps you can go in each one of those domains.For example, is reality uh created or uncreated, right?Is it eternal or does it have a beginning in time?Is knowledge possible or impossible?Is there an external world or not?

21. Limited Worldviews and Monad/Diad/Triad

Demonstration that all worldviews reduce to limited either-or starting points, and that human predication necessarily uses unity, duality, and triad, setting up the argument for why the Trinity is unique.

Uh are there objective ethics or not?So I can structure a bunch of either ors and every step that the theoretical opponent takes will determine the rest of that system down the road down the line.Right?So for example, if my opponent says that, as most of these people do, um knowledge claims are purely relative, ethics are relative.Okay, those are really strong claims that will determine the rest of that worldview.I mean, that's pretty much a dead-end box right there.And that's most people, right?But as you can see, you're you are actually very limited.There aren't very many.I mean, I can I could even boil it down to one thing or many things.Is reality ultimately one or many or both?You're limited in those options.And in fact, most religious worldviews out there, most of them are either monist or dualist.
So when we understand that this is actually how worldviews function that every worldview by necessity can be boiled down to very limited either or starting points.There's not an infinite number of worldviews.The variations in worldviews are down the line.Let's give an example.Most worldviews as we said are monist or dualist.If you have basic presuppositions in your metaphysics of monism or dualism, that's going to condition pretty much everything else in the rest of the worldview in a lot of ways, right?For example, uh everything is one, man.Let's let's use monism.That's going to condition and necessarily determine the way that I view knowledge claims.I'm not going to turn around and be like, well, everything is one, but I'm a distinct being who has knowledge.No, I'm also part of the one.Right?So, monism, pantheism, these are very strong uh determining forces in the paradigm when we make those kinds of statements when we have those kinds of views.
Now, granted, a lot of people are inconsistent, right?So they're not always going to be consistent, but that has nothing to do with whether they what the fact that a person believes, for example, that all reality is one, but I'm a distinct individual, that's inconsistent.That doesn't mean that he actually has a unique worldview.He doesn't.There's countless people who have this goofy, inconsistent worldview.So I could take it in either direction.And I could say, well, if everything is one, then you're part of the one and you don't actually know that you are a distinct you.So that's a fundamental contradiction, right?That's pretty obvious as a right.So there's a limited number of steps that anybody could take.There's not an infinite number of worldviews.Literally, you could you could boil it down to um something or nothing, right?Basic metaphysical things, right?
Do things exist or not, right?I I could just list any number of really easy eitherors that will determine where you have to go in your worldview.And every worldview of necessity has some limited number of steps that it can go in any of those basic kinds of questions.It's unavoidable.And literally that's all I have to do.Now why is that?Because reality is structured a certain way.For example, everybody will be forced to use basic concepts like unity, duality, multiplicity, right?One 2 3 4 up to 10.There's no other ways that we do and describe things than those types of things.This will lead into our argument later, right?So everything is classed in terms of one thing distinct from other things.That's unity and multiplicity.The one and the many, right?And all of the numerals are classed under
one 2 3 4 five 6 7 8 nine.If we have the uh the Arabic numer numeral system
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10.Let's take something like the tetraus as an example.When we have this basic numeral system, any type of distinctions or categories that we make of things are going to involve these basic 10 principles.It's unavoidable.unity, distinction.Distinction requires two, a diad.A diad leads to a triad.Right?Now, you're going to say, "Yeah, but we don't all accept uh Pythagoras.We don't all accept that there's a tetract.I know that there are theoretically other systems and other types of geomet.But for human predication, the possibility of human predication, what did we just say in Aristotle and Kant?What do we have?We had unity, universality, particularity, distinction, quantity.Any type of predication of quantity of unity, distinction, particularity, one and many must use this type of system.You must use unity, duality, distinction, many.It's unavoidable.
One, two, three are universally basic and necessary.They're unavoidable.There is no possibility of predication that is meaningful that does not use one, two, three.I am distinct from you.One, two.
When we start building up from that, that's many.Four, five, six, seven, a billion.Okay.To say that object is red.That cat is on the mat.The cat is green on the mat.the picking out a specific cat.Cat picking out a specific type of thing that shares in catnness that is singular from a universal one among many number.Number is being brought into this equation.Do you see this one cat amongst many cats unity distinction two diad
now even far eastern philosophies amazingly were able to pick up on the fact that these universal principles like one and two unity diad are all pervasive they underly language thought reality, the natural world.And so, as you could see, you you could see why they would come to think that reality itself is some kind of mystical tension of diad.Hence, yin-yang, right?Opposing forces, night, day, male, female, black, white, one, zero.Yeah.you know, yinyang, constant dialectical tension, push and pull of all reality, right?This is what characterizes all Far Eastern philosophies.Okay?Now, and you can see why they would think that because they're looking at the world, they're looking at these different types of things, numbers, even if you go back to the uh Bavagita and this kind of stuff.They're looking at these higher order principles and they're saying there's ultimate unity and there's ultimate this that.
So they would come up with answers like everything's one, everything's two, or it's all just chaos flux, right?The different types of options you give.You see the Greeks doing the same type of thing.Everything's fire, everything's water, everything's permanence, everything's flux.Oh, it's all just chaos atoms in motion, right?Atomis, whatever.The point is that all of these descriptors and universal narratives are still utilizing universal categories that require ultimate unity and ultimate distinction
or the principle of distinction itself.That's diad.You see this is how we're going to get to trinity in a minute.But I'm just trying to show you that anytime we predicate remember Aristotles substance quantity quality relationsubstance one thing quantity one thing maybe two things three things quality type of thing relation next to that thing this thing next to that thing relation two thingsand from two you build up to three and on to everything else.So all numbers are collapsible into 1 2 and three and the first 10.And what I'm saying is that it doesn't matter about other theoretical mathematical systems.I'm not even debating that.I'm just saying that for communication and the preconditions that we mentioned earlier whether Aristotle's preconditions or Kant's preconditions some of those preconditions are things like quantity which require unity and division or distinction or diad and from diad you
get all the others you see

22. Trinity Surpasses the Diad: Lossky

Vladimir Lossky's argument from Gregory of Nazianzus that the monad set in motion and the diad transcended point to the triad as perfection, showing why single-hypostasis and dualist theisms collapse.

that's why we're going to make the argument next which is that trinityis unique because trinity as Maximus will say surpasses the diad.What if we just said God's a unity?What if we just said God is a diad?I'm going to read a few quotes here that I think adequately explain why this doesn't work.
First quote comes from um the excellent book of uh Vladimir Losski mystical theology of the Eastern Church.Uh then we're going to look at Staneloy and then Maximus and then the orthodox philosopher I am Andre of Orthodox apologetic theology.So here's the argument that makes which I think is good.He says in the spirit of St.Gregory of Natsanzus uh we will speak of his oration on baptism.St.Gregory says no sooner do I conceive of the unity or the one when I am illumined by the splendor of the three.No sooner do I distinguish them that I am carried back to the one.When I think of any other than the one, I think of the three.I think of him as the whole and my eyes are filled in the greater part of what I am thinking of escapes me.I cannot grasp the greatness of the one so as to attribute a greater greatness than to the three.
When I contemplate the three, I see but one torch and I cannot divide or measure out the undivided light.Our thought must be in continuous motion.This is Loski pursuing now unity and then pursuing once again threeness and then returning again to the unity.I must swing ceaselessly between the two poles of the antonyomi.Right?One or three in my human mind and all of our human minds is still an antonyomi.Keep that in mind.Antonyomi
in order to attain to the contemplation of the sovereign repose of the three-fold monad, however, is what we're after.He he says, "I'm still stuck always in this antinomy when I'm trying to have the sovereign repo repose of the three-fold monad."How can the antonyomi of unity and trinity be contained in any image?How can the mystery be grasped say by the aid of an idea uh be it that of movement or of development?St.Gregory Nazi's conscious adoption of the language of Plotinus here can delude only those who are unimaginative and pedestrian in their souls who are incapable of rising above mere rational concepts.those who ransacked the church fathers for traces of platonism or riatilianism.Rather, St.Gregorian Nasanzu speaks to the philosophers as a philosopher so that he might win philosophers over to the true contemplation of the triune God.Quote, "The monad is set in motion in virtue of its richness.
The diad is surpassed for the deity is above matter and form."So diad is usually predicated or or universalized from diads in nature tunis matter and form.Right?This is this was typical in St.Gregory Nazi's day is that diad is a fundamental feature of matter is what Maximus and and Gregory Nazi will say.Whether that's the case we can be that can be debated but regardless we'll come back to that later.So he goes on to say, "The Godhead does not dwell within bounds, nor does it spread itself indefinitely.The one would be without honor if it were uh soul and if it were alone, right?If we just had a soul hypothasis, a singular hypostasis god.This would be a holy quote Judeaic uh notion.And if we had an ultimate triad or only threeness without unity, we would have helenism."Now remember what we saw in Basil in the phaser talk.
What does Basil say about Aristotle's prime mover argument?Basil says that it necessitates if if you really believe in actis purist the unactualized actualizer then God has to eternally actualize and move something something outside of itself.Faser says namely eternal prime matter in Aristotle's argument.So Basil says act as purist is stupid as a defining character of God because it means that God must have an eternal matter to move.That means that matter is now eternal and takes on a divine character or excuse me property or attribute namely eternality.Now you have a two-headed god.You have the eternal prime mover and prime matter.That's his eternal complement.Now you're a dad.So you see how easily the eternal monad becomes the eternal diad.And this is true actually of any of the philosophical systems that might restrict God to a single hypostasis.If he's God and lord from all eternity, what's he God and lord over?
If he's eternal mover, act as purist from all eternity, what's he eternally actualizing and moving other than himself?Oh, eternal matter, eternal worlds, eternal creation.Really?So now you have a two-headed God.God and the world, the eternal world that he's moving.That's a d that's Basil's argument.Hexamaron 2.Read it.Read it to not your view.You don't believe what Basil says.Now I'm situating this within my larger argument about monad diad triad.I'm just pointing out that very easily a single hypostasis god can collapse into a diad because he has to have a creation eternal over which he's lord
for the word god and lord to be sensible.Right?This is partly what what origin argues.But now let's get back to triad monad diad triad.Loski goes on to say we glimpse a a uh we gain a glimpse of the mystery of number three that the deity is neither one nor many.Right?So we're not we're saying that god is not identical to unity or multiplicity.The divine perfection goes beyond the multiplicity of which duality is the root.So here's why we don't believe in a diad.Right?Monad diad.This is multiplicity.This is division.This is to move from unity to distinction.Right?
All number will will originate from as I just said earlier unity to duality.Right?All numbers then extend from that.
We recall then that diatic systems the interminable diads of the Gnostics and the platonists right these dualisms are he he's basically saying that they're untenable.All the dualistic systems of the platonist, same stuff I just showed you in the arisatilian argument, those are untenable.They're stuck.Thus, we need something that moves beyond the diad of division and distinction to transcendence and perfect triunity.And uh Loski says when we express oursel in terms of number here the divinity has no need to manifest its perfection per se to itself or to others.God is the triad the trinity and this fact can be deduced from no principle or explained by any sufficient reason for there are no pres uh principles or causes or sufficient reasons anterior to the trinity.You hear that classical theist?Do you hear that classical foundationalist triad is the name which unites and things wait triad the name which unites things united by nature and never allows those which are inseparable to be scattered by a number which separates namely
by two.Gregory Natsanis says two is the number that separates and divides.Three is the number that transcends separation.The one and the many find themselves gathered and circumscribed ultimately into the trinity.That's why it can't be an ultimate hypothic singular god.That's why it can't be a diad.Has to be transcended in the triad.When I say god, Gregory says, I mean father, son, and spirit.Godhead is neither diffused beyond these so as to be introduced a multiple uh multiplicity of gods nor is it yet bounded by a smaller compass than these so as to condemn us for the povertystricken conception of deity inmonotheismuh be it Judaizing or be it helenism St.St.Gregory of Nazanzus is not seeking to vindicate the trinity of persons before human reasoning.Rather, human reasoning is grounded in the trinity.

23. Maximus and Staniloae on Triune Communion

Maximus's commentary on Gregory explaining the movement from monad to diad to triad as logical not temporal, followed by Staniloae's argument that only three persons maintain distinctive unity and love.

We must ask then whether the idea of number can be applied to God.whether we do not thus submit divinity to some exterior determination or to a form proper to our understanding such as the number one or the number three.To this objection, St.Basil says we do not count by addition passing from one to another to the many to increase for we do not say that one 2 three and then we add a third.I am God the first and the last.He's just saying that God is beyond the creative conceptions of numbers and and numeric.We are not equating God to the number one or to the number three.Now we have never even at the present time heard of a second God.We adore God of God confessing the individuality of the three hypoases and we dwell in the monarchy without dividing the theology into fragments.
In other words, there is no question here of a material number which serves for calculation and is no wise applicable to the spiritual sphere where there is no quantity or increase.The three-fold number is not as we commonly commonly understand it a quantity.God does not possess quantity when it relates to the indivisibility.uh when it relates to the indivis indivisibly united divine hypoasis the sum of which is always the unity three is always one and one is always three it expresses the ineffable order within the godhead the contemplation of thisabsolute perfection this divine planitude which is the trinity the god who is personal and who is not uh a single person confined within himself we see a pale shade of the trin Trinity when we consider right human relationsthis is going to rel lead us to the next
insight which is from Maximus.Maximus commenting on the exact same section.This is in questions and doubts
for writing of this.Gregory of Nazanzus says, this is Maximus commenting on Gregory, the Trinity is perfect.It is the Monad having been moved on account of multiplicity and diad which is through matter and form from which bodies exist having been transcended being defined as triune or triad on account on account of perfection.For it is the first that transcends the composition of the diad.So we don't believe that God possesses any composition.We don't believe that God is a pure unity or a diad.And so the only option is triad.And Maximus comments on Gregory.He says Gregory does not give us the cause of being of the divine blessed trinity.So he's not trying to say that this is how God came to be.That is beyond cause and beyond reason.Rather, Gregory is giving us the cause of our being that we are led by the hand to the most truthful reverence of the triune God.
For just as we understand the author of existence from the essence of beings, so also we are mystically taught the mode of existence of the most ineffable divinity from some symbols found in existing things.That is to say, the holy divinity itself moves us into an acknowledgement of itself and provides pious starting points in order for us to have the courage to examine the mode of God's extraordinary existence.And so it is said to be set in motion.So in other words, he's talking about the movement from monad diad triad, right?We're not talking about a temporal movement.The setting in motion is the logical order of how we're understanding one, two, three in the trinity.That's all he's saying.It is the cause of our movement in terms of our knowledge of it.It moved itself in us towards the knowledge of him by the things that exist.
He's saying so the monad having been moved and the diad being transcended is not something that happens in time and space.Right?It's outside of time and space.It is said because the divine nature is perceived to exist outside of any composition or outside of any time.And thus being defined as trinity on account of perfection.It is said because being itself is not without wisdom and life.Wisdom and life being the son and the spirit.God being being it the father here identified as being itself.The son being wisdom spirit being life.Understanding that's from the 150 chapters too that Gregory Palamos covers this.Understanding this, we recognize wisdom as the son and logos of God and the spirit as life.Therefore, our soul which is created in the image of God is a little trinity is also observed to have noose logos spirit.
Maximus is saying that we see trinities little triads in nature.These suggest to us the highest level triad father, son and spirit.And he's saying that there's a movement that is of necessity and limited.Not a physical movement, but a movement from monad diad transcended by triad.Now, what about how does this prove our god?How do we know that?Two more quotes.Next, we're going to move to Stano.Stanlo is going to make a similar point that Andrev is going to conclude with.This is uh uh page 73.In the communication of divine life, St.Serel of Alexandria attributes a special role to the Holy Spirit.He communicates to human nature first of all the power to receive subsistence in the person of the word who overcomes the laws of an endlessly repetitive nature.But the spiritual force exists only where there is full communion.
The Holy Spirit then communicates to human nature the power to rise again by a new conquest of the laws of nature.The Holy Spirit communicates to spiritual to this communicates this spiritual power because he is the spirit of communion.Full communion exists moreover only where duality is overcome.If one person who does not communicate being loses the certitude of existence by being lost within nature, two persons likewise risk being submerged in a monotony or in nature through an exhaustive closed selfish communion between the two.Only in the existence of a third person does it make it possible for the maintenance of a continual freshness for each of the three persons as well as for any uh possible pairing of the persons.It is only in the existence of three in the triad that they do not become confused with one another nor are they totally separated from one another.
Only a third person maintains distinctive unity, breath of love, etc.between two persons who can change as partners.Thus the movement that we're talking about from the father through the son and the spirit.This eternal communal movement, eternal manifestation of the energies, right?The father eternally loving the son and the spirit.
It is only in overcoming duality that life is thus truly rich and in God infinite and limitless.Christ receives the spirit as man because as man he is received into the perfect communion of the triad.So through him we too might be received into triune communion through grace.Lastly we will look at Andrev the argument that he makes on this same point.

24. Andreev: Trinity as Eternal Love

Andreev's argument that only the Trinity avoids necessary creation, that divine love existed eternally between persons without a created order, and that barren monotheisms cannot explain a God of love.

He says, "Even though there are in both the Old and New Testaments general dogmatic truths, nevertheless, the truths of the New Testament are more clear and deeply and spiritually rooted and free from elements that we find in theOld Testament under the veils, right?The symbolism of the Old Testament.So things are made more manifest, more clear in the New Testament."That's all he's saying.Some revealed truths in the Old Testament were expressed more covertly and some of the more spiritually developed Old Testament people were forced to ponder these things such as the mystery of the trinity which is indicated in the OldTestament.Right?We see the word and the spirit mentioned in the Old Testament.He says the Old Testament prophets were uh were revealed they revealed the son himself.Right?Present day Hebrew scholars unjustly affirm that the Old Testament had no indications of the Trinity.
In fact, the Trinity, as you know, we we we've discussed it many times, indicates the Trinity in many places.But it is impossible not to see in the Old Testament an undisclosed understanding of the special powers of God, the word of God, and the spirit of God, the appearance of the triune God to Abraham and the threevisitors, etc.Now, he's going to talk about strict monotheism.The essential point in the Christian teaching about God is that the revelation of the dogma of the Holy Trinity preserves the inviability of the Old Testament teaching of God's unity and adds in a special new insight a highlyethical character which was not clear in the Old Testament.Nor could it have been present in any other system of monotheism.Then he goes on to say, "The blessed trinity is what is unique here.Strict monotheism witnesses very little to the purity and loftiness and ethical worth of the religion that is preaching it.
For you can imagine for yourself uh some religion of the pre-Christian antiquity somewhat Greek philosophers here talked about a highest level of unity a highest being etc.But it still is inefficient because whether it's Plato or Aristotle, these monotheisms either turn into pantheism, dualism or barrenism.Only Christianity through the disclosure of the the dogma of the trinity has given a solution to the timeless question of the nature of the one God in himself.Only Christianity discloses the truth that God in his essence one has definite realities of existence outside of his relationship to the world.All right, this is back to the Aristotle issue that is he is tripersonal and since he is tripersonal in the eternal fullness of his inner life uh it from all eternity it is unknown to us but it existsapart from the world.In other words, God would eternally be in a perfect triune communion whether he had created the world or not.
Therefore, he's not dependent on the world.Not explaining the very essence of the mystery of the trinity.This essence center distinction the dogma of the trinity clarifies for our mind something concerning the divine being namely that there is in the divine being activity that is eternal that does not depend on the world.The only theology that believes this is the trinity and the this is literally the only one out there.You see that's why we're unique.There is in this uh divine being in this triad doctrine uh an activity unique to our theology that teaches that it is not dependent on the existence of the world.There are conditions for its manifestation.Right?Father, son, and spirit.In other words, although an understanding of the triune God is exceptionally difficult, still an understanding of his uh bare unity is more difficult.In other words, we can't just believe in a single hypothesis.
Besides it the theoretical meaning, the doctrine of the Holy Trinity has an ethical meaning.Through the mystery of the Trinity, Christianity taught mankind not only to respect God with reverence, but also the doctrine of love, to love God.Through the mystery of the Holy Trinity, a new idea was disclosed that God himself is love, most lofty and ideal love, an exhaustible fountain of love.Augustine said, "The mystery of the tr Christian trinity is a mystery of divine love.If you see the Trinity, you see love."The mystery of the Trinity teaches us that divine love was manifested not only in the created order or in the contemplation of the created world, but that it appears in its most perfect infinite fullness in the very bosomof the divinity.In other words, father, son, and spirit with the eternal movement and sharing of love shows that our God, our view is the only one that doesn't have a necessary created order to reflect it or to have love or
to have honor or lordship.Any of the strict monotheistic positions require a world that God lords over or is God of.and the diad systems don't work.What's your only other option?Triad.He goes on to say, "The life of love resided from all eternity in God, the eternal communion of the love of the father, the son, and the spirit.Thus, it can be absurded that the barren monotheism of all the ancient religions, not impregnated by the revealed truth of the trinity, did not and could not have a true understanding of divine love.And by extension, it leads to a necessary creation.You see, the main distinction between the strict monotheism of contemporary Judaism and the Christian faith consists in the basic doctrine of divine unity and trinity.Right?the divine essence.Only in Christianity through the revelation of Christ himself uh do we understand and know that God is love and only here do we know what love is as expressed by Toltoy.
I wouldn't use Toltoy but um God subordinated all the laws of Moses to the law of love.It was always the law of love though so we're going to bypass Toltoy.To understand this idea of a God of love is impossible.It is impossible in barren monotheism.For whom did God love?Only himself.Only in the mystery of the Trinity does it initiate us into the complete profoundity of divine unity.Divine unity being too vast for man's mind.It gives us to understand that divine love was never inactive.There wasn't a point when God didn't love and then when he created the world, he began to love.Nope, we don't believe that.It never remained without manifestation because of the doctrine of eternal manifestation.That's only taught in orthodoxy.By the way, there was never a pure self-love, but the father always exteriorly loving the son and the son exterior loving the father and the spirit.
Right?
and thus pointing to the eternal divine communion of the persons of the trinity.The complete depth of love of the divinity for the race of man is thus elucidated for us in the light of the most holy trinity.Mystery is also the foundation of the whole teaching of the Christian doctrine of redemption.So what we see is that we are immediately forced to the doctrine of the trinity.The trinity is only taught in Christianity.And that leads us directly to the unique doctrines of Christianity.That's how we get from monad diad triad.Again, there's no other systems that teach this.Right?So there's no outs for the the speculative atheists and the guys, what if I said this?What if I came up with this?Right?That doesn't work because those systems don't have any historical grounding.They don't exist.They're copy and paste jobs.
You can't just make up a worldview.It doesn't work.But that's how the atheists and these guys think because they collapse as Kant did what God does in our paradigm.They collapse it into the human mind and thus the futility and stupidity of atheism.

25. Side Objections: Preconditions Just Are

Refutation of Matt Dillahunty's claim that preconditions just are without justification, showing the contradiction with his empiricist demands, and the scientism objection that atheists cannot even make sentences.

So um I think we were on eight or nine but that was the big media objection of how does it prove triad?So take all those arguments that I gave an hour ago about universals and how they interlock.Combine that with the last hour of what I argued for monad diad triad and what we just read from all of our theologians.Then you get our unique paradigm that ours is the true religion.There you go.Uh a couple other kind of uh side objections that atheists might pull out.Um, remember Matt Dah Hunty said, "Preconditions just are.I don't have to justify them.They just are."Again, Matt himself said, and many atheists say, "You shouldn't believe in anything unless you have an empirical justification for that."And then Matt turns around and says, "I have no empirical justification for preconditions.They just are."Those two things don't work.
If I can have an ad hoc rescue, then I can just say God is.I don't have to prove God.I don't have any arguments for God.God just is, right?No atheist would allow me to do that, Matt.All of them.They would call me out.You can't do that.That's ad hoc.Dude, you just did that for preconditions.Okay.Therefore, that's not a good argument.It's not a good argument to just say they just are.Just are what?Preconditions just are.Logic just is.As Father Deacon always says, just is what?What are you talking about?Like you have a strict view of what you can say does and doesn't exist.
Logic just is what is matter?Is a particular is a mental state.What what is it?What is it that just is you see?
So we see that the uh this bad argument of well preconditions just are they just are what they don't have to be justified.Uh says who right it's you guys who say that you should only believe in things that are empirically demonstrable and justifiable.That's Matt's common constant refrain.That's why he doesn't believe in God.Then he turns around and says that he has no problem believing in laws of logic and all these things that just are that are not material.that can't be justified.That is a stupid contradiction.It's very simple.The argument is very simple.You're you got to be consistent on your paradigm with your own views.There you go.Um
another couple arguments that were made um you appeal to revelation and not to science and facts.Again, atheists in their paradigm are appealing to and believing in things that are not proven, known, or demonstrable by science and facts.Right?This basic scientism objection, one of the dumbest objections of all.You believe in things that are not justified by sense data, right?You actually believe in a bunch of superstitious things on your own worldview that you can't justify, right?To make a sentence, a simple sentence, as Fraga says, requires a bunch of metaphysical things to be the case.None of those metaphysical things to that have to be the case have been proven by you when you make a sentence, atheist.Right?And so if that's the case, then they can't even make a sentence.That's how bad atheis atheism is.You can't even make a sentence, bro.
It's that bad.So when they do do this stuff, when they do make a sentence, they say the cat exists.The cat evolved, right?Some like this, right?The cat evolved.Let's use this as an example.
The cat evolved.Right, Mr.Atheist, don't you understand?As Fraga pointed out, to make a sentence, multiple things have to be the case that these symbols have meaning.That these symbols have a meaning that's invariant over time.That these symbols refer to abstract concepts.That abstract concepts can be related one to another, right?That they express truthful propositions and truth values.That this statement says something about things in the external world.That there's a sayer who's saying this, right?some self, some person who has objective experiences of things in the external world that universals are the case.All of these things are simpleam.I mean and more you could list more.You could keep going and listing more and more things that have to be the case just to say your dumb sentence.And you have not proven those things.They're assumed their preconditions.
But remember 99% of these goofballs believe that you should only accept what can be empirically demonstrated.That's all you can believe in.Really, all of those things that I listed for this sentence to be the case can't be empirically proven or demonstrated.
You can't even make sentences.That's why tag is so devastating because that's what tag is calling out.You need a paradigm and a bunch of things, preconditions, universals, etc.to be the case, whole bunch of metaphysical things that you think are gobbledygook and magic that you can't prove to be the case to make a sentence.That is why this is nuclear strength apologetics truly and genuinely.And that's why you're doing a disservice when you when you present Cameron and all those clowns bad arguments based on evidentialism.All right, let's let's look at let's go.

26. The Popcorn Ball and Continuity Transition

The popcorn ball analogy showing how universals, preconditions, and laws of logic interlock and require God as the precondition for preconditions, followed by transition to the continuity argument against Judaism, Islam, and Protestantism.

If you have the phaser book, I recommend chapter 3.It's really the only good chapter in the whole book.Uh but chapter 3 is a good analysis of the question of universals.Okay, so if we were to if we were to boil down universals, numbers, laws of logic, right?And we could include preconditions or transendal categories in the same type of class of stuff.I would argue some people might take issue with that, but I think they're all kind of in the same boat, in the same ball.Let's use the the the big uh popcorn ball analogy here.We're going to make a popcorn ball.We're going to stick all of these types of things together.Let's put um numbers, concepts,
universals,
preconditions,
laws of logic.
Um
uh you you could if you wanted to we can put possible worlds in here for the sake of argument if we want to just to be really thorough.This is our big popcorn ball, right?We're going to take all of these types of things, the numbers, the concepts, the preconditions, the laws of logic, the possible worlds, the universals, right?These are all these these unique types of things that we pointed out that are not reducible to matter.We don't exactly know what these are in the sense of like give me some exhaustive definition of what a universal is.Nobody can do that, right?That's a that's like a a lot of times atheists will try to pull this trick where they're like if you don't give me like a perfect omnisient exhaustive definition of what a universal is I won't accept it.Nobody can do that and nobody expects that of anybody.
So that's like a that's like a trick that they play.Now what we're saying what I'm saying is that all of these these unique abstract types of things which are preconditioned they have to be the case.Remember they don't operate in a vacuum.There's no numbers that exist apart from universals, right?Universals don't exist apart from uh preconditions uh for the possibility of speaking or communication or language, right?Those don't exist apart from concepts, right?There's a logic, an order to concepts and language, right?They operate in tandem with the laws of logic.These things operate in tandem with preconditions for predication, speech, communication and language.Now if we think about all of these as phaser notes as interlocking,how can this be?How do we bust justify the big popcorn ball of these things?How do we make sense of that?So now again, if you remember, if you remember from the beginning of the chat, we were looking at lower order logic, higher order logic.
Now we're moving it at what?One meta step higher.We're moving up another step and we're saying we got all these types of things that are preconditions for lower order statements, sentences, knowledge.How do we justify these?There's nothing wrong with asking that question, right?Because we're we're saying that all knowledge claims to have the possibility of knowledge rests on these things being the case as preconditions.So all the more do we need to give a justification or a grounding or explain how these things are.Well, there's not a whole lot of things that can work to string all of these pearls together to make all these things cohhere
and to ground them and to give them sense and coherence.Now, if we have a divine mind, well, what do you know?That just perfectly seems to work, doesn't it?Right?An omnisient mind, by the way, not just a force, but a personal being.An omnisient mind can unify and ground and you could say locate these types of things, right?And make them work, so to speak.The mind of God is where you could say these things are patterned and located if you want to, just to be simple.God's mind because he's omnisient because he's omnipotent.He's omnipresent.He is how these things are universally the case.They're invariant and how they apply to the temporal here and the now because the created world is patterned on the loi patterned on these things in the divine mind.
God is the substrate.The divine mind is the superructure that houses, strings together, interlocks and makes all these cohhere.So in other words, God is the precondition for the preconditions.That's the argument.Now, you could say, well, uh, what if I believe in a God who's omnisient but isn't omnipresent?Uh, well, that wouldn't work.All the omnis go together.Okay?So, you're not going to be able to like deny one of the omnis or deny that he's a personal god and have that work, right?Because you need to relate those things to this world.This world can't be eternal matter.It's got to be a created world.That's the Christian paradigm we're saying.now enters in all of those unique distinctions of orthodox theology and Maximus' teaching logos loi.Now we get specified in terms of how that theology answers those higher order dilemmas or problems that we might run into, right?
Because that if we if if we've got the argument to this point, somebody would say, "Well, okay, well, maybe I accept all that, but like what about uh you know, like why why can't I just be a platonist?"Like what if I So now we would look at the problems in Pltonism and how Plonism and why Maximus modifies Neoplatonism and the Loi doctrine to be a specifically personal god.That's where we get to the really difficult the final problems in this.Now, I'm not going to tell everybody they need to read this, but basically in order to avoid the problems of neoplatanism or the last refuge perhaps, well, maybe I believe all this, but creation is an eternal generation.No, this negates the possibility of knowledge.We need creation to be a real potentia in God.We need uh in the creative world to be done on the basis of God's free will.
Hence the essence energy distinction.You can't have free will and God without potentia and inner gaya and free will.God have uh god has the real potentia to create and not necessarily to actualize all of his uh potentia.And we need uh we need a god who is not equated to or identified with the world but yet at the same time is the basis for the world.Hence the orthodox doctrine of the energies.All of which solves a lot of these basic fundamental philosophical problems.Right?We don't have the ads uh dialectical problems of Roman Roman Catholicism.Thus, orthodoxy is unique, right?It alone presents the theological truths triad in its pure form which solves all of these philosophical problems and dilemmas.Why does man have all these problems and philosophical dilemmas?because he won't believe and rejects the true God.That's why what's the big issue between Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Protestantism?
Uh it's a question of continuity because everybody in this sphere agrees uh for this for this moment we're going to set aside the Roman Catholics.By the way, uh we'll get to Roman Catholic issues later, but for right now, we're going to look at the religions of the book, or at least the religions that don't have uh the focus to be something holistic,but the focus is primarily the book.And that's going to be Judaism, uh Islam, and Protestantism.So, there's commonalities there in those three.And after many many years of interacting with these different systems, I think I've discovered kind of a a unique angle that most people don't go down when it comes to this argument as to who's in continuity.And that's what we're going to look at tonight.Because you'll notice because Judaism, Islam, Christianity, Abrahamic faith.We're all quote Abrahamic faiths.
So, but are we?And who is fundamentally part of the Abraimic tradition will be a big determiner of who's in continuity with the Old Testament.But guess what?Not just the Abrahamic covenant, Mosaic covenant.who's in actual continuity with the Mosaic covenant.And then not just that, but the Davidic covenant and then the covenant or excuse me, the promises and prophecies in Isaiah and Ezekiel and in the minor prophets because guess what?There's also a lot of promises as to things that we will see in the messianic era or in the uh uh era in which the fulfillment comes about that's mentioned in the Old Testament in the law and theprophetsand hinging it on this question because that's what I've noticed that it always comes down to is so crucial because if you are not in continuity with Abraham and Moses, then you're not the true religion.
And if we know the New Testament very well, then we know that a lot of the debates that Jesus has, for example, in the book of John are primarily about, are you in continuity with what came before?Because we have these promises, Deuteronomy 13, Deuteronomy 18, anybody that comes along in the future as a prophet, as a revealer of dreams, mystical omens, etc., uh prophetic warnings, predictions, all of those.There's one stipulation from Deuteronomy 13 that's repeated in Deuteronomy 18, and that is that they have to teach in line with what came before.You can't have a new thing out of accord with what came before.So, the big issue between Judaism, Islam, and I'm going to throw Protestantism in here, is are you actually in continuity with the Old Testament, with what came before?Because it's my contention, and it is the Orthodox contention, that there is no such thing as the Abrahamic faiths.
From the vantage points of of those religions, they see themselves as inheritors of the Abrahamic tradition.But according to Paul in Galatians, there's only one way to be the seed of Abraham, and that is Christ.So without Christ, you're not the seed of Abraham.And you're not the seed of Abraham uh just because you say, "Well, we honor Abraham, right?"And we're going to see that there's some uh crucial elements that Islam has discarded which biblical revelation speaks of as eternal, everlasting, and necessary.So, this is going to be a kind of a surprise argument.And you might have heard me bring this up in a few of the debates with the Muslims.It didn't come up in every debate, but seems like it came up in maybe two or three.And let's start with Islam because, you know, in my experience with these debates, and I'm not an expert on Islam.
I've not debated every Muslim.Um, everybody says debate so and so.And 90% of the time it's somebody that we've already asked or actually debated.So, uh, you don't have to remind me of all the various Muslim apologists.I know who they are and all that.And it's not really a question of uh are we willing to do it.It's just that you know after a while it's sort of like we've reached out to all these people and we didn't get much of after the four or five debates we did nobody seems to want to do anymore.So what is then the key issue that I noticed over and over and over in all these Islamic debates?It's not just a lack of knowledge uh of the Bible or the text.It's a fundamental just sort of like no idea what's going on in the Old Testament.

27. Islam, Corrupted Texts, and Temple Continuity

The Quran affirms the Torah and Gospel are not corrupted, undermining Muslim claims of textual corruption, followed by analysis of how temple, priesthood, and sacrifice permeate the Old Testament.

And on the one hand, I understand that Muslims will say, "Well, we go to the Quran because the Bible was corrupted and we don't trust those texts, but we do trust the Quran."However, as we have pointed out many many times in many many debates, the Quran says that it is not corrupt that the uh biblical texts are not corrupted.For example,
I can barely see this.I can't see what my notes say.Sora three three I think it is
surah 3god there is no god but he the living god the self-subsisting he sent down the book in truth confirming what was before he sent down the truth the the Torah and the gospel okay so sent the Torah thegospel
And then we have again in surah 10
uh 37.The Quran could not be fabricated.Rather it is a confirmation of all that came before of what came before.An elaboration of the book in which there are no doubts from the Lord of the worlds.Talking about the Torah.Okay, now there's more.I think there's another one.
There's another one.Uh, let's see.
There's one more I'm missing where it says that the
gospel is not corrupted.
If somebody remembers this one in the chat, put it in the chat.If Kai, if you're around, you could put that in the chat.I always forget.I thought I had all these marked, but there's at least three statements.Uh, if you look at Sam Shimoon's debate with Shabir Lee from a long time ago, uh, the one I'm trying to think of is like the first one, right?Um,
where are we deleting comments?What's going on?
Is it surah 547?Let's see if that's it.I might have missed uh marking one of them.I still can't see.
F.This doesn't This is ridiculous.Okay, five.There we go.547.Let's see if that's it.
Oh, yeah.I think this is it.Yeah.Okay.Yeah.Thank you for that.I forgot.I forgot to mark this one for some reason.Let's look at the notion of continuity.Okay, so continuity between the covenants is conceived of in terms of uh one after another building on one another.Right?So in other words, the uh noic covenant builds on the Adamic covenant and it's fundamental to I think biblical theology.I I don't know what Islam's view of covenants is, but uh in terms of Christianity and Judaism, there's the conception that God relates to man uh through covenantal relationships.And these are uh covenants that are dual.They're they're binary, two parties, but God is the one who initiates the covenants, right?It's not it's not usually a man initiating it and God being like, "Oh, okay.God initiates the covenant, right, with Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, David.
And these covenants build on one another and they have unique theological elements, angles, uh, expansions, so expansion pack covenants, you could say, that go along with each covenant.So from the Orthodox Christian perspective, it is it is uh so clearly a a a line of continuity that it's very bizarre for us to conceive of the Islamic conception of uh a a line of prophets.thought where in all of this is the temple, its priesthood, its altar, its sacrifice, and its ministry.Right?So for us, there's no way for us to make sense of or explain what Jesus is doing, what the New Testament is all about without all of those elements that come out of the mo Mosaic covenant.Literally, I mean, it's just so fundamental to even the New Testament theology.Let's take for example the book of John where it says Jesus is the lamb of God.
How could we conceive of this idea without Passover?Makes no sense, right?So the Exodus narrative, Passover, just in that line, behold the lamb of God that John the Baptist says is contained this whole idea of the Passover.So it would make no sense to stress discontinuity or to toss out the Old Testament or to think that the Levitical priesthood, the altar of sacrifice, the ministry of the temple, which by the way, the temple is notjust this temporary thing where okay, so there's a temple and then uh it just goes away at some point.Oh, we don't need that anymore, right?Babylonians come and they destroy the temple.Romans come and destroy the temple in 70 AD.Oh, we don't need that anymore, right?That was done away with.And and I'm not meaning to be rude to people who are uh Muslims or whatever, but it's so fundamentally based around an ignorance of what's in the Old Testament that I can't conceive how people think that they could
say they're in continuity with the prophets when a gigantic portion of the Old Testament of the Torah is about the Levitical ministry.It makes no sense at all.I mean, it's like they had no idea what was going on with the temple and this stuff.And if you're going to say that, oh, the Jews made up the temple and its ministry, that's crazy because this is this is a gigantic chunk.The almost the entirety of the book of Leviticus.So, that's just made up.It's a corruption.By the way, the Quran as we just saw does not say that it's full of imagine say uh if you think about Deuteronomy, Leviticus and Numbers, okay, and Exodus, gigantic portions of this are Levitical law, rules, Mosaic administration,temple uh cere tabernacle ceremonies.Imagine thinking that that was a corruption of Pharisees or whoever.So in other words, what 70% of the Torah?
So basically we'll take Genesis elements of the first few chapters of Exodus.Um and that's about it.So that's what 25%.30.So 70% is what?Corrupted made up stuff.And on top of that, how ridiculous when a gigantic portion of the Quran early on is all of these weird rules that are obviously very similar to the types of ceremonial rules that you would get in Leviticus.Okay?So, first of all, it makes no sense to say that you're in continuity with these books.We'll say the five books of the Torah first when about 70% of that is stuff that you're not in continuity with and or you say is made up or a corruption.So let's say Torah, we'll say that first.We're going to guesstimate at about 70% is about uh we'll call it rituals relating to the temple tabernacle and its administration.
Okay.So let's start with that.So we got the Torah.We're going to say about 70% of that.Now when we come to the other books let's say the let's take the historical books of the Bible in the Old Testament.Let's say uh you know Judges uh 1, 2, Samuel, Kings, um we'll say the Psalms as well, the historical books.Well, the Psalms are not historical books.That's lurggical worship books.Let's say the historical books.Okay.Now, the Quran cites the historical books uh not explicitly extensively that I've read, but like it it summarizes entire sections that come up in the historical text, right?like uh David uh you know going and fighting so and so the ark doing this story here and there okay but a big portion also of the historical books revolves around incidents relating to the worship of Israel theark okay this is like huge portions of the of first Samuel right where where does Samuel go as a child he is sent to learn in the temple to learn what?
To learn the administration.Okay.Right.Okay.So, the historical books.
Now, it's true that uh Joshua and Judges uh there's not a lot to do with temple and tabernacle yet because this is prior to the temple temple and tabernacle uh because it has to be established in the uhJerusalem.And Judges and Joshua are about conquering the land, which they don't actually conquer the whole land yet in Joshua, right?There's still some cities left.And then in Judges, we know it's the time of the judges before the kings.
So, we aren't yet to the point where we've built uh we have a movable tabernacle, but we don't have the temple yet.So, we're going to say uh let's see the historical text.Let's say about
we'll say 50% in some way of the historical text relate to in some way stories about temple, tabernacle, ark of the covenant, priesthood, Levites, feast days.Okay, we'll say about 50%.So the historical books we got about 50%.Okay?Because there's other stories that don't directly relate to that.But as I was I was rereading uh Samuel this last couple weeks and I finished with 1 Samuel, uh I noticed, you know, the stories of David's life.Obviously, a lot of them are are parallel in Christ, right?And this is another thing that we're going to get to in a minute about typology.Typology is a is a crucial thing to this whole question of continuity.But I mean, just think of the stories of David going and eating the showbread.Uh, the showbread relates to the temple.

28. Temple References Across the Old Testament

Percentage analysis showing that roughly 50-70% of the Torah, historical books, Psalms, and prophets relate to temple worship, making Islamic and Protestant claims of continuity incoherent.

So, you see what I'm getting at here, right?Not every story, uh, but we're going to say about 50% because when Saul kills the priests, that relates to the temple.Okay.So, let's look at next is Psalms.All right.So, Psalms, we've got David's lurggical worship.Where are the psalms supposed to be sung?Where do you think this?Well, we know in chronicles what this is all about.This is made for the temple.So this is the lurggical worship services of the temple.So in one way all of the psalms also relate to the temple but not directly.Certainly not every single psalm is about the temple.Many of the psalms are about David's own life, his persecution.And we know the persecution of David is a type of the persecution of Christ.David often records his descent into Hades and his resurrection, vindication by God.
Those are all also types of the life and ministry of Christ, death, brow, resurrection.So, I think we could say to be fair, uh I'd say 50 to 75% ofthe Psalms in some way relate to the temple or its worship service or its administrations.Uh next, let's move to the other section.Um well, we could say the other wisdom texts, um some of the wisdom texts relate to the simple, but not that many because they're not mainly about the worship of God.Uh so here we're talking about Proverbs, Sierak, uh Wisdom of Solomon, right?These books, okay, some of these books, but not that many.We'll say maybe 20 30% of the wisdom texts relate to the temple.So not not a huge portion here, but we do want to include it because it is part of the Old Testament.All right.So, let's get to next to the uh prophets, major and minor prophets.
Now, if we think about this, it still is difficult to conceive of this being um something disconnected from the temple and the tabernacle.And remember, we can't rely on this weird argument that the Jews corrupted all the texts and added references to temple and tabernacle.I mean, this makes no sense, right?So let's say uh let's think of our major prophets.Uh if we think about Isaiah, Isaiah has a lot of prophecies that relate to feast days.And in the messianic prophecies of Isaiah, he talks quite a bit about the messianic era.And those are quite often connected to Mount Zion, the temple, the law, and its administration and its worship.Now, one of the key texts that's going to be important for today's talk will be the latter chapters of Isaiah where he predicts gentile priests.Interesting.How could there be gentile priests ministering to God's flock?
Doesn't even seem possible.And yet, we have that.So, um, we have the prophecy in Jeremiah that the ark of the covenant will go away.Now, a Muslim might take that and say, "Haha, you see the ark of the covenant will go away."But we're also told that the ark is everlasting in other texts.So how can the ark of the covenant go away and be everlasting?Interesting.Seems like a contradiction.Or there's another way to reconcile these texts which I will argue obviously points to orthodoxy.So uh prophets two classifications as you guys probably know major prophets minor prophets.minor prophets, smaller books, right?Uh Hosea, Amos, Zechariah, Obadiah, Habachok, Naam, etc.Minor prophets, major prophets, Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel.Let's think about Ezekiel.Okay, Ezekiel's prophecies uh are a lot of them early on are about uh uh the sins of Israel.Obviously uh we talked a lot about the uh in Ezekiel 1 up to Ezekiel 10 we have the references to the trinity uh all the time we have the references to uh one like the son of man who
rides the chariot that is the logos himself before pre-incarnate
but then when we get into uh middle Ezekiel chapters those are about uh judgments on Babylon and then we get to the end what do we have at the ending we have predictions of a temple and elaborate referencesto its administration.So what are we going to say here that 30 40% of Ezekiel is I mean if you looked at all the texts right what corrupted made up because we have predictions for example in uh the dry bones chaptersabout the resurrecting of the land of Israel.Ooh so you see that's right back to the temple and its administration.The latter chapters of Ezekiel deal with a new temple where we have seemingly uh impossible things.A door where the Messiah enters and yet the door never opens.It stays shut, right?Ezekiel 44.These odd statements of the design and so forth.Uh statements where the nations are healed from the trees in this new Jerusalem.
What is all this about?If the Old Testament temple, priesthood, altar, sacrificed, administration, etc.doesn't matter or God has forgotten this or it was tangential, it doesn't know.So, we're going to look at some key texts, but I would say uh to be fair about, you know, if we were to take the whole scope of Ezekiel, Jeremiah, what would we say here?I don't know maybe um maybe 40% 30 to 40% in some way relate to uh the temple and its administration.So let's review here what we have from our Old Testament.And by the way, if we if we were to think about the minor prophets too, right?I mean essentially the whole book of Zechariah, the whole book almost every chapter relates todescribing the messianic era with the imagery of temple, tabernacle, sacrificed, priesthood, incense, altar, etc.Now, don't forget the book of Revelation because guess what?
It's worded and uses all the same imagery of Ezekiel, Daniel, and Zechariah.You cannot understand the book of Revelations without understanding in depth Jeremiah, Daniel, Ezekiel, especially Zechariah.In fact, you could argue that Zechariah might be the most the book that's the most parallel to the book of Revelations in the Old Testament.So let's review this real quick because this is very crucial to our argument.

29. Textual Evidence and People of the Book

Church fathers and manuscripts prior to Islam verify biblical texts, refuting corruption claims, followed by the distinction that Orthodox Christianity centers on the incarnate Logos rather than the book itself.

In the Torah proper, we could say about 70% will relate to in some way the temple, its altar, priesthood, its administration, etc.And again, remember when we say the temple ministration, we're talking about the whole of it.We're talking about the showbread.Okay?The blessed bread.Wonder what that's about.I wonder what that's a type of.We're talking about the lampstand.which becomes the manora which becomes what's on every orthodox altar in our view.Okay, we are talking about the imagery.Remember this is a holistic thing.The temple had all kinds of beautiful imagery carved palm trees, angels, all this stuff.Okay, iconography, right?Again, so we're going to say about 70% of the Torah.We're going to say historical books roughly 50% in some way relating to maybe less maybe 40%.Right?And then uh we've got Psalms we're going to say 50%.Wisdom text not that much maybe 20 30%.
Prophets 30 to 40%.So again Torah gigantic portion.What did we explicitly say see the Quran saying about the Torah?It was not corrupted.It was given by God.Now this is another point to keep in mind.There are plenty of texts in terms of textual studies for centuries before Islam, right?We don't have to go through medieval monks in the 1300s to get to what Bible church fathers are using.Right?So, we'll say 6th 7th century rise of Islam.Don't you think that there are gigantic portions up here?See all this?All of this, these church fathers, these two rows of 40 volumes of church father, 38 volumes of church fathers.Okay, 95% of that is prior to Islam.So in other words, let's set aside the actual textual manuscripts.We could reconstruct the text of the Bible, probably all of it or most of it, just from writings of the church fathers quoting the Bible prior to Islam.
That's not the only source of the text.Okay?But church fathers recording things is one way that we go and validate texts and compare texts.There's also actual texts, various manuscript traditions.I'm not arguing about inspiration or anything that we're setting that aside for the moment.We're just looking at basic points about uh prior existing texts versus what Islam today now claims.Not what the Quran claims, but what does Islam now claim in their apologetics, right?Almost all of them run to Bartman and they run to all the liberal textual higher critics, which is against the Quran.Okay?If the corrupted text stuff was true, why was nobody saying this at that time?Why was the Quran saying the opposite of that?And again, it's not up in the air like we don't know.There are copies of the texts, New Testament, LXX, Septuagent, Maseretic, these are all prior to Islam.
It's not like we don't know what the text said.Right?Do you see this is not a rocket science point.This is kind of a simple point here.So the the corrupted text argument falls apart because Christianity and Judaism have texts older than Islam that are authentic that can be verified.That's what I'm trying to say here.And so it should be really transparent that the very recent argument of a lot of Muslim apologists to claim that the Bible is a corrupted text is that a recent argument.It is not the argument of the Quran itselfand the texts of the New Testament and the law are older than the Quran.Do you do we not understand this?And so it it's missing the whole point when we talk about continuity with the texts.The whole question between the these religions is who's in continuity with the actual text.
That's it.And today we're talking primarily as we said about Islam, Judaism, and Protestantism.And we're going to notice what I think is the strongest argumentuh to settle the issue to show that Orthodox Christianity and we're going to look at Rome in a minute.The problems there because there's a unique point I want to make about the Roman Catholics why they don't really work here.But we're setting this aside because there's we're going to see some elements that are missing that Orthodox Christianity has that definitively I think proves continuity that these three are missing.And the fact that they're missing these key elements is itself the crucial argument to disprove Islam, Judaism, and Protestantism.And what do what do we begin to notice as the the commonality between those three?The book.The book, the religion of the book.Now, what do we mean by that?
Because obviously we have the Orthodox Study Bible.We have the book.But there's a big difference between uh what Protestants, Jews, and Muslims say at mean what they mean by people of the book versus the way we would say, "Yeah, okay.We're people of the book."But for us, it's not primarily a book, right?It's the incarnate logos that the book talks about.That's the focus of the religion, not the book.Okay?The Old Testament, the focus was the book.The fulfillment in our view is the book pointing to Jesus.So we don't go back to the book when the book was pointing to Jesus.You see the difference there?Now that doesn't mean that we can't say the Bible is the word of God, these kinds of things because it is because the Bible is a revelation of the personal logos.Okay?It's not a perfectly inspired physical text.
We don't believe that.Why is that?Because we don't possess any original text.Nobody has what Moses wrote.Nobody has what Paul wrote.What we have is copies of those things over various centuries.And there's a huge amount of unonymity between those copies.That's one of the things that we always point out which is a great attestation to the veracity of the text that unlike any other text in history especially that far back that old right the new testament for examplehas the greatest amount of veracity amongst textual variants that versus any other ancient text at all blows it away right uh compared to Plato uh compared to Aerosol compared to you know old you know Gilgamesh epic or whateverRight?So those are those are things to keep in mind which relate to this topic but they're not the main issue.So what's the main issue that we're getting at here?
Okay.So as we saw from our list there uh how is it going to at all make any sense to say that you're in continuity with this book when so much of this book is about things that you're notin continuity with.Now, we just gave one example of percentages that I'm just kind of guessing loosely about.But let's look at some other things, some other uh important arguments here.

30. Melchizedek: Priesthood Before Aaron

Genesis 14 and Hebrews 7 show Melchizedek's priesthood predates and surpasses the Levitical priesthood, with Abraham tithing to the greater priest, establishing a type of Christ's eternal priesthood.

Let's go back to Genesis 14 because this is a crucial argument made by Paul in Hebrews, assuming Hebrews was written by Paul.Melkisedc, the king of Salem.Now, if you don't know about MelkiseDC, we make a big point of this because in the Orthodox view, he's not uh a madeup person.He's not Jesus.He's a real God.He's a saint and he's painted as his own icon and so forth.So, we know he's not Jesus, but he's a type of Jesus, but he's a type of Jesus in a unique way.Let's see.King of Salem, by the way, that's Jerusalem.So, this is prefiguring the religion that will be in Jerusalem way ahead of time, right?Because we're at Abraham's day.This is before the Exodus, before the conquering of Jerusalem, before Joshua and all that.But MelkiseDC is a king of Salem.This is the same place, Jerusalem.
And what does he bring out?Bread and wine.Well, I wonder what that is an image of.I wonder what a priest of God.So, this key argument from Hebrews, this is before Levitical priesthood.Aaron does not exist yet.Aaron is in the loins of his father Abraham.He doesn't exist yet.Aaron is where we get the Levitical Aeronic priesthood.Aaron doesn't exist yet.And yet who does Abraham submit to, give obeasance to, tithe to in an act of deference to Melkisedc.This is the very argument that Hebrews makes.Blessed be and then and then he gets a blessing from Abraham.I mean, excuse me, from Melkisedc.Blessed be Abraham, God of God most high, possessor of heaven and earth.Blessed be God most high who has delivered you your enemies into your hand.And Abraham gave a tithe of all of his gifts to Mechisedc.
Now key po uh key point here in this text is to note again we have before the ironic priesthood before Moses even exists the giving or an already existing priesthood the priesthood of Mechisedc this mysterious figure which wedon't see much about him other than these sort of uh sparse Old Testament references and then the references in Hebrews.I should have had Hebrews already pulled up, but
all right.So, let's go to Hebrews 7 where this text is executed.This story is executed from the New Testament apostolic perspective explaining its meaning.For this Melkchisedc, king of Salem, priest of most high God, met Abraham, returning from the slaughter of the kings and blessed him to whom also Abraham gave a tenth of his portions, he tithed to him.King of righteousness and then king of Salem, king of peace.Now, people get confused because it says without father, without mother, without genealogy.Doesn't mean he's an eternal person.It just means that the Old Testament doesn't list his genealogy.Right?Throughout a lot of the Old Testament, we get genealogies because we want to know who descended from who.But the argument is being made that providentially there is no listed genealogy.Not because it's some demigod, but because it was a type of Jesus, right?
Having neither beginning of days nor end of life, but he is made like the son of God.And he remains a priest continually.So Melchisedc is an actual historical person and his priesthood is a type of Christ priesthood.How do we know that Christ is a priest after the order of Have you read the Psalms?Right?What does the writer of Hebrews go on to argue?Now let's just actually read this because my argument is actually in Hebrews 7.It's not my argument, but it's a fitting argument to refute Islam, Protestantism, and Judaism.Now concerning how great this man Mkisedc was to whom Abraham the patriarch gave a tenth of his spoils.Indeed those who are sons of Levi received the priesthood.So now he's contrasting the priesthood of Mechisedc to the priesthood of uh the of the of Moses, the Mosaic covenant of of Aaron aka the Levitical priesthood.
Those who are the sons of Levi, Levitical priesthood, receive this priesthood and have a commandment to receive tithes from the people according to the law.But uh that is from their brethren.though they have come from the loins of Abraham but he whose gen genealogy is not derived from them so in other words mechisedc is not a levitical priest but he's a divine priest so how do we make senseof this the argument of Hebrews is that it is a type a foreshadowing of the gentile priesthood that would be in Christ the priests of the new testament are priests after the order of mechisedc that's the point herewe are And the Protestants, by the way, we're going to see.I know every Protestant is going to say, "We have the priesthood of all believers, friend.We have a priesthood, not a ministerial priesthood, friend.
The priesthood of all believers."I know the Protestant view.We're going to get to that in a minute.Just hold your horses.Hold your horses, evangelical man.Now it says now he whose genealogy is not derived from them from in other words Melkisedc does not have any connection to the ironic priesthood the Levitical priesthood yet he receives a tithe from Abraham the greater of themechisedc excuse me the greater of the ironic priesthood or the the ironic lineage right Abraham is the father of those under the Mosaic covenant because they come from Abraham.Do you understand?You guys follow me so far?So the lesser Abraham is tithing to the greater is the argument here.In other words, because the Levitical priests were in the loins of Abraham, the Levitical priests in a way were tithing to Mechqueisedc.The lesser ties to the greater, not the other way around.
So if the Levitical priests were in the loins of Abraham hundreds of years before Moses and Aaron were born and Abraham tithed to the greater Mechisedc then the order of Mechqueisedc is greater than the Levitical priesthood.Now this doesn't mean that Levitical priesthood was evil or that it was bad or that it didn't relate to Jesus.Guess what?Blow your mind here.Both Mechqueisedc and the Levitical priesthood are types of Christ.They both point to Christ in different ways and in different senses and in different types.But the argument of the apologetics here in Hebrews is that the priesthood of Mechisedc is greater than the ironic priesthood.Doesn't mean the ironic priesthood was bad, but it had a certain point.It had a certain purpose for a certain time.That's the argument here.
And as you see the argument, even Levi, who receives tithes from the people of Israel, paid tithe through Abraham, so to speak, for he was in the loins of his father Abraham, when Melkisedc met him, Abraham, the needfor a new priesthood.Therefore, if perfection could come about through the Levitical priesthood, for under the Levitical priesthood, the people received the Mosaic law, what further need was there for another priest who would rise according to the order of Mechisedc?Who are we talking about here?Jesus, and to not be called according to the order of Aaron.Other words, if there was another priest that came along and the Levitical priesthood was superior to the Melkisedc priesthood, then the new priest that came along would be of the order of Aaron.These are pretty simple arguments here.But he of whom these things are spoken, Melkisedc, belonged to some other tribe from which no one has officiated at the altar.
Okay?Nobody in Israel was officiating at the altar according to Mechisedc.That's the point here.For our Lord arose from Judah, of which Moses spoke nothing about priesthood.Okay, there's no mention of the Judeaic priesthood in the old in in Moses.And yet it is far more evident if in the likeness of Melkisedc there arises another priest who has come according to the law not according to the law of a fleshly commandment talking about the Moses the ceremonial Mosaiclaw but according to the power of an eternal life in other words the power that Christ possesses is superior to the ironic priesthood because it's the fulfillment of the ironic priesthood.The ironic priesthood like Melkisedc himself is pointing to another fulfillment.Thus the citation from the Psalms about Christ.You are a priest forever according to the order of Melkisedc.Who is that talking about?
That's from the Psalms.David is not a priest according to the order of Melkisedc.Hello Jews, Muslims.What is that Psalm talking about?I wonder who could it be that is a priest after the order of Melkisedc?I mean there's not that many options, right?I mean, how many people have even been thought of as a potential fulfillment of this?

31. Psalm 109 and Eternal Priesthood

Psalm 109/110 as messianic prophecy of an eternal priest after Melchizedek's order, Christ's ascension to eternal intercession in heaven, and the Protestant inconsistency regarding sacrifice being finished.

And so in Orthodox Study Bible, that's Psalm 104 9.
Or is it 1094?I get it mixed up.1094, excuse me.
The Lord has sworn and will not change.You are a priest forever according to the order of Mechisedc.So, who do we think that Psalm is talking about?Okay, nobody thinks that David was a priest.He's not.Okay, he's a king.And usually, most of the time, there's a couple uh uh examples where the three-fold Old Testament office is there's a person who occupies two, right?You might have somebody who's a prophet and a king like David.Uh you might have somebody who's a prophet and a priest uh like uh Samuel.Um but there's not anybody in the Old Testament typically speaking who is prophet, priest, and king, right?This three-fold office.This of course is a big point that we make about Christ because the Messiah we would say whenever the Messiah comes due to all of the Old Testament messianic prophecies the Messiah uh must fulfill these three offices right
because there's so many prophecies so many messianic prophecies about what he will do who he is what his job is what he will accomplish etc that all of those prophecies can be subdivided into his uh fulfillment of officeof priest prophet andSo but again crucial point here when we read this psalm 109 let's go to that
who do we think is talking here and this is a very powerful argument in the book of Hebrews that the writer is making and remember the context of Hebrews is people who want to go back to ceremonial laws.Oh, we we got to have the chauffear.We got to have the the ceremonies of the temple.Uh because you know Yesua, you know, like the Messianic Jews think this way, right?Oh, you have to the superstitious like you must use the word Yoshua because it has a special power that Jesus doesn't have.It's a silly superstition, right?
But in Psalm 109 for the for for our interpretation the interpretation of the New Testament over and over and over this dialogue that's written by David is a prediction of prophecy that is not and cannot be primarily onlyabout David.The Lord said to my Lord, "Sit at my right hand until I make your enemies your foottool.You will rule in the midst of your enemies.I have begotten you from the womb before the morning star.Was David begotten before the morning star?You are a priest forever according to the order of Melkisedc.Nobody thinks David was a priest forever according to the order.There's nobody that teaches this.Maybe some weird cult somewhere thinks that this is talking to David.And uh I did hear a story one time that uh some Mormons believe that they are some kind of descendants of I mean this is whatever that's not what it's not about Mormons.
Okay, Psalm 109 is not about Mormons.I can assure you that.U but literally other than some weird Mormon interpretation, nobody thinks that David is a priest after the order of Melkisedc that I've ever heard of.Thus, this has typically been classed as a messianic prophecy.As far as I know, Jews still think that Psalm 109 or 110 in the Maseretic is a messianic prophecy.But as the writer of Hebrews is arguing and other because this Psalm uh 110 is cited multiple times in the New Testament, right?And uh rule uh sit at my right hand until I make your enemies your foottool.The New Testament always interprets that of the ascension, Christ's ascension into heaven.That's when he sat at the right hand of the father to rule and to begin his ministerial priesthood.So keep in mind when Jesus ascended I don't Protestants I don't know if you didn't catch this Protestants did you catch the fact that when Jesus ascended Hebrews says he's also doing the temple administration in heaven in the
true temple.
So there's still sacrifice being offered the eternal sacrifice being offered.Do you understand this?It was when Jesus died on the cross, friends, he said, "It is finished."And when he said, "It is finished, there is no longer any need for sacrifice.It is finished, friends.The temple was cracked.The veil was rent."Right?I know.I know every I've heard it a million times.I know what you think.Okay?You don't have to repeat to me that you think the veil being rent and it is finished means that there's no such thing as sacrifice anymore.Yet wait a minute, every Protestant cites the New Testament where it says become living sacrifices.You are my offering, Paul says.Wait a minute.But so is it finished or is there still sacrifice?Why does Paul say I I in my own body am fulfilling what is lacking in the sacrifice of Christ?
What?Yes, that's what Paul says.Now, Paul doesn't mean that there's inherently anything lacking.But what he means is that the mystical body of Christ, the church, will live out the life of Christ.If you know from our lurggical cycle when you go to church when you go to the divine liturgy there's a a church calendar you are living out Christ's life every year likewise the Christian is we believe that weare living out the life of Christ in our lives not just one year but our whole life right cycles of cyclesso if Jesus is an eternal priest because he was forever the second person of the godhead there.It's an eternal oath and priesthood.The eternal covenant it is called.Then it is not finished in the way that you as a Protestant say.Do you see how this refutes you yourself?Wait a minute.
It's finished.But what?He's an eternal priest.What do you mean it's finished?
Uh, the Lord has sworn and will not relent.You are a priest until it is finished or a priest forever.
He was not made a priest without an oath.The oath, you are priest forever.
And yet every Protestant in his folly rejects the idea of the Eucharist as an offering.
For such a high priest was fitting for us.Uh excuse me, verse 25.He continues forever with an unchangeable priesthood, eternal offering goobers.Therefore, he is able to save because he always makes intercession.A priest intercedes.Now, every Protestant out there, friends, we're going to have intercessory prayer tonight at church.Come on down to the church.Oh, we're going to have intercessory prayer for sister so and so.She's got cancer.Intercession.That's an action of an existing priesthood.So, wait a minute.You don't actually believe in it is finished.Nothing else need be done.Well, then why why are you interceding if it's finished?Why do you have to repent if it's finished?Okay, so you don't actually think that it's finished actually means what you think it means.You see, you're not consistent with what you think it means because you still believe in priestly offerings, intercession.
But guess what?And some boomer Protestant woman tried to scold me in the comments today.She's g She's going to get scolded right back because she said Hebrews 13 does not mean what you think it means.Oh, really?Well, tell me what it means.I'm sure you know.Hebrews 13 does not mean what I think it means.Well, let's see what it says.Okay.So, uh hopefully everybody sees the argument, the line of argumentation uh so far.

32. Hebrews 13: We Have an Altar

Hebrews 13 declares Christians have an altar from which tabernacle servants cannot eat, the Eucharist as an eternal offering, and the gnostic iconoclasm underlying Protestant and Muslim rejection of material worship.

Then we have this uh important statement at the end of Hebrews 13 and the benedict benediction.Now may the God of peace by the way this is like the blessing of the old testament.So the author of Hebrews is doing a priestly blessing a benediction.May the God of peace who brought our Lord Jesus Christ up from the dead, the great shepherd, the of the sheep through the blood of the eternal covenant.
So it's an eternal covenant.Does that make sense?It's ever being ever presented.That's what happens in the Eucharistic liturgy.Okay?So Protestants have a huge problem with this.Okay?Just like they have they just as much as a a problem they have with the real presence, they have equally as much a problem with the idea of the Eucharist being an offering that the church or that Christhimself offers to God.And yet that's what our liturgy tells us.Thine own of thine own we offer unto thee.
All right?So it's an everlasting eternal covenant.But let's go back.We have an altar, an altar from th from which those who serve in the tabernacle have no right to eat.So again, remember the purpose of Galatians, the purpose of Hebrews was to show the superiority of what Christ has brought and the inferiority, not because it was bad, but because what it was about has now come.In other words, the argument is that ceremonial laws, the temple, the tabernacle, the altar, the animal sacrifices, the rituals, the feasts, they're not bad.It wasn't given by an evil god.They were temporary.And their whole purpose was pointing to the reality that we have now.Doesn't mean it's all xed out and done away with.That's another stupid Protestant idea.Jesus didn't say that it's all done away with.I have come to destroy and ex out the Old Testament.
And yet, how many Protestants and evangelicals think this?Not all of them, but many of them.But notice, and it also applies to Islam, eternal priesthood forever according to the order of MelkiseDC.It's not made up and corrupted by Jews and Christians.We didn't make this up.It's in the text.We have an altar from which those who serve in the tabernacle, that is the Jews that serve at the tabernacle, they don't have a right to eat at this altar because they're still under and believe the ceremonial Mosaiccommands in the sense that they're not fulfilled in Christ because we still believe those commandments have value and relevance.Okay?We don't believe as orthodox that all the ceremonies and all that is just dumb and useless, wiped away and uh oh, none of that means anything.God didn't care about that.It was just sort of this thing that happened.
And uh then Jesus came and he's like love or whatever who's like this mean God or whatever the Old Testament like he gave all these rules and then Jesus came and he's like peace and love or whatever, right?No, that's idiot low IQ, you know, DMT bro stuff.We don't that's not what we think.But notice the argument here.We in the church have an altar that we eat from.Now, this boomer woman in the comments, I'm not joking, and it was so dumb I just deleted the comment.I just blocked it.She says, "That ain't talking about what you think it is.That's all.It's spiritual.It's a spiritual altar and we spiritually eat."Then how come uh immediately after this was written all the Christians that we can go read in the first second century how come they believed was out about the Eucharist?
How come they didn't spiritualize it?Why do they say have your Eucharist under your bishop?
Why do they teach that it is the real body and blood of Christ?the real body, blood, soul, and divinity of Christ according to St.Sirill.They don't spiritualize it.No, you spiritualize it because the ethos of Protestantism is gnostic.It is fundamentally iconoclastic like Islam because there is some notion, some fundamental assumption that God is opposite matter.God is antimatter.He's not not antimatter.Not like a Dan Brown novel, but against opposed to matter.Okay?Because somehow matter is tainted.It's bad.It's lesser.Right?These are all Gnostic ideas.And why do they think that?Because of some weird interpretation of you shall have no engraven images.That's it.Because the Old Testament says not to have graven images.All of these people have thought that God is opposed to all images.Even though the very chapters of Exodus where he says that he also says carve a bunch of images in the temple.
So I'm not trying to be mean to people.It's my catchphrase now.My uh comedian catchphrase which I didn't even it just happened.Not trying to be mean, dude.Right.But this is not a difficult point here.Most of what we're talking about is based in ignorance.Okay?And I'm Christians too.A lot of Christians so-called, right?Ignorant of what?Ignorant of the Old Testament.The root problem here for uh the Muslim and a lot of the Protestants is ignorance of what the Old Testament actually says, what it actually teaches.But particularly when it comes to critiquing the Muslim position, I just can't understand how they have almost no they don't they just don't get this argument and this point.Do you understand that you can't say that you follow the law and the prophets of the Torah and then turn around and say 70% of it is made up, corrupted heresy?
It's just it makes no sense.

33. Liturgical Elements and Sola Scriptura Problem

New Testament contains liturgical elements like candles, benedictions, and creeds, yet no letter describes how to worship, exposing the sola scriptura dilemma and the false presupposition of low-church apostolic Christianity.

especially given the fact that the Quran says it is not corrupted.
Now, we see then that the the argument of the writer of Hebrews is really what I'm honing in on.And that is that in the New Testament, we do have the continuation of lurggical elements that did not pass away.For example, in the book of Acts, we read about them having many candles, lights, that's lurggical lamps.That's candles for vigils.We read about benedictions that we just saw at the end of Hebrews.That's a lurggical event.Okay?We read about Paul in his epistles citing various early creeds and hymns.Those are lurggical elements.Do you understand that?So the point is that to the Protestant, there is no New Testament letter that tells you how to worship.Do you think that God uh wants us to make up the way that he that we want to worship?Do you think that's a a principle anywhere in scripture that God uh sort of do DIY?
Okay.Is there anything like that at all ever?Now remember Protestants, you guys believe that so Bible alone.So before the Bible was put together in the canon, the later centuries of the church, the Bible as we know it, everybody's just what copying scrolls and doing the best that they can.Okay.So how do we do the worship in the church?Now this is important because this is where there's this assumption on the part of the Protestant reformers as well as Islam and other groups.This doesn't really apply to Judaism but for uh Protestants and to a degree Islam.The assumption is that there's this LCD lowest common denominator lowurch religion that the apostles established.There's a low church uh seed teaching.Okay.And every pro there's every protest has different ideas about what it is.But it's it's a total presupposition.It's a false presupposition, but it's it's it's every Protestant's presupposition.
And the only way that it differs from the uh Muslim is that the Muslim thinks that there was this uh basic monotheism that Jesus taught that got corrupted.Okay.Protestants it's this basic Christianity that got corrupted in the early church.Okay.So basically the same idea just differing in the degrees of the basic gospel to the Protestant.What is the basic gospel?Is it the necessity?Do you have to be baptized?Is it faith apart from works?Is it just belief in Jesus?And they think that these home churches is the justification.So basically it's like well the New Testament says they're home churches and therefore they didn't have a liturgy.They just met together and they had a meal and they prayed and they read the Bible.Okay, that's what most of the Protestants think is going on.Is that what happened?Uh did you read Acts 15 perhaps where there's a council and there's a decision made that's binding on the churches?
That doesn't seem like something that lowurch home church groups do.I have never heard of a home church group having a council that binds all the I mean this is silly, right?And if I say something like this, some goober Protestant will say, "I'm part of a home church group and we have a council that binds all the home churches."I mean, come on.Nobody ex Nobody believes that your home church can bind another home church to your decrees.This is silly.
So there's a fundamental question of structure and of liturgy that is seemingly absent in the New Testament text.Now when it comes to structure there's a little more right we have more about church government in the New Testament where we have mentioned the episcopate the diacinate and the preseterate or priesthood.Okay.So, we do have these three words and these offices in the New Testament and we've done talks about a succession all that.We're not going to do that today.But the ministerial priesthood is in in our view principally represented in the bishop, the priest and the diacinet.Again, three levels of office mentioned in the New Testament we believe is the succession to he who hears you hears me.Right?Jesus says to the apostles.The apostles then go out.That's what's so important.What's in the book of Timothy, right?Paul says to Timothy, "I laid hands on you.
You don't lay hands on anyone else unless they're good men.Be sure and test them because the laying on of hands transfers the Holy Spirit."Clear as day what he says to Timothy.He says, "You are appointed as the authority in Ephesus."Protestants, did you read that?And then he says, "You lay hands on someone after you.They will lay hands on someone after them.Apostolic succession.He who hears you hears me.Jesus breathes on them.Whoever sins you remit, they remit it.Whoever sins you retain, they retain.That's not Protestant at all.Totally contrary to the entire spirit and ethos of Protestantism.So what is fundamentally missing in the Protestant ethos here?By removing the Bible from its context of liturgy and making it a book alone religion like Islam, like Judaism or Talmudic Judaism, it has now exercised itself from the ethos of the religion and the community which gave them
the book acted as if the book is independent of the community and the ethos of worship, the liturgy.And now it has this book alone, but the book doesn't tell you how to worship.Now, does God care about how he's worshiped?Let's see.Leviticus 10, the pro profane fire of Naab and Abaiu.Nadab and Abaiu got creative.They were charismatic worship service people.I love you, right?And they want to offer incense their own creative way and they took fire, put it in, and they offer profane fire because God did not command them to do this.So fire went out from the Lord and devoured them, and they died that day.So God seems to care about the way that he's worshiped, doesn't he?There's no do diy.Now, if there's no DIY and God cares about how he's worshiped, why Protestants is there no letter of Paul of how to do the liturgy?
Again, doesn't it matter?It seems to matter.Where is the list of do this first, do this second, do this, this, do this this way.There's not there is not.There's letters like Corinthians that are critiquing the problems, but there's no lurggical service.Now, let's take a let's move over to an example of where this is a problem.Let's say so in my past, I went from evangelical to reformed.And one of the reasons that, not the only, but one of the many reasons that I was interested in the reformed church was because they were the first that I ever heard in the Protestant world talking about thisproblem of worship.Hey, wait a minute.God doesn't just let us DIY.You can't just do whatever you want.There's a certain way to do it.God's not the author of confusion.So, how do we worship?
Well, the reformed Protestant, the the classic reformed argument is we can't worship God in any way other than how he wants us to worship him.Because how do we do that?
Well, uh the only thing in the Bible Okay, so this is not a goober Protestant thing for you to come in here and start yelling and get get out of here, dude.Well, so in the reformed view, the idea is well, the only the only book that we have in the Bible about worship is the psalms.And so there were Protestants who said reformed who said you can only sing psalms.Other reformed split with them because in the New Testament we have statements about sing hymns and spiritual songs.So wait a minute, can we sing sing hymns or are we only allowed to sing the psalms?Right?This is a reformed debate.I'm not joking.It's called Psalm only.What about instruments?There's Protestants and reformed and Calvinist Puritans who think you can't have instruments.So again, the point is that it's not clear in the New Testament.
And the New Testament was never intended to be its own standing thing because it goes along with the Old Testament.And it goes along with not just the Old Testament temple, but the the synagogue service.So the synagogue and the temple influence the way that the church's worship developed.So again, you see the problem here that uh if solos scripture is true, it isn't it curious that we don't have an actual worship service in the New Testament or in the Old Test that we're told how todo it in the New Testament way.And every single Protestant has his own idea and his own cult and his own sect that they make up about how to worship.

34. Ancient Liturgies and Temple Imagery

Ancient liturgies from the first and second centuries confirm continuous liturgical worship, followed by temple imagery showing baptism as fulfillment of the laver and the Eucharist as fulfillment of showbread and sacrifices.

This is a key point for orthodoxy because not only do we have liturgies that arise from without question all liturgical scholars agree that the ancient liturgies arise from the apostolic post-apostolic period the ancient Roman liturgy the ancient liturgyof St.Mark and Alexandria liturgy of St.James, right?These are ancient liturgies from the first and second century.And guess what that style of worship is?Well, it's lurggical worship.It is not lowurch do-it-yourself worship.In fact, from the earliest days, there is already the continuity of the Old and New Testament seen in the visual iconographic representations of vestments, altar, eukarist, ordered lurggical service, antipal singing in the New Testament.Where does that come from?from the Old Testament.Thus,this book, which you see me reference all the time,
Orthodox worship continuity between the synagogue, the temple, and the early church.Key text.Key text.Why?What's the argument here?Because
if we knew our Old Testament, if we knew the Torah, if we knew it well, when we went to church, this all comes alive.You see it everywhere.
By the way, uh guys, if you would hit like and share.Also, um
remind you that I uh Jamie and I and uh Father Vladimir, we will be speaking at my event in Orlando.You can still get tickets for the Orlando event there September 3rd.That is coming up pretty quick, but there's still tickets left.So you can still get tickets and it's a little more because uh there's more speakers.Um Kotel I think might speak for a few minutes the beginning and then we got uh me doing my little uh jokey thing and then we will have um Jamie do her presentation uh then Father Vladimir and thenme and then we'll have open forum and book signing.So, it's going to be a fun evening.Uh 4 pm to 10 p.m.if you want to come out to the Orlando event.There is the link.Uh so, come meet us.Come hang out.And uh yes, there will be liturgy at church.
I will be going obviously to Father Vladimir's church.So, uh yes, that's available as well.And um yeah, I drank a whole bunch of espresso.Like I I downed a whole thing of espresso before I did this.So that's why I'm over here burping.But also fish, if you take fish oil, right, it does that to you.Okay.So, all right.So, we did Meisadette.We talked about uh the New Testament worship.So, what's the point of all this?Well, the point of all this is to say then that let's let's look at this.
Let's take a look at the temple here and its administrations and get an idea of uh Oh, we don't want to go to the Jehovah's Witness website.Forget that.Uh let's see.This might work.Maybe we get a good idea from this.See if I could blow this up.
No, it's like every cult's got their Why are we getting all the cult stuff?No, we don't want Jehovah's Witness.
Oh, these Protestants always love this kind of stuff.They go crazy with this.The irony, of course, is that all this stuff is pointing to what the Orthodox Church has, but okay.So, uh, here's the temple.Hopefully, you can kind of see that.Maybe I can make this bigger like this.Let's do it this way.All right.
So, let's start with this one.
So you'll notice that out you have the uh altar for the burnt offering out here, right?And it's outside the temple and uh Christ of course is crucified outside Jerusalem.So there's multiple many ways in which the altar of burnt offering uh refers to what Christ does on the cross.If you remember uh the recent talk that surfam Hamilton and I did um he went into some interesting and it might not have been that one.It might have been a couple talks back with Sarapin but he went into a lot of the uh elements of the the Levitical burnt offering and the sweet sweet smelling sacrifice.Then of course we have the labor uh and of course the priestly labor of washing obviously that for us is about baptism right all all of these things in the temple and tabernacle.You notice the Protestant exes Jesus typically says, "Oh, uh, that's all just Jesus."
And we agree it's about Jesus, but it's not just about Jesus.It's also about the New Testament sacraments that Jesus instituted.And one of those would be baptism.And so for us, baptism is not just a symbol because guess what?In the Old Testament, they were just symbols.Okay?So the Protestant unwittingly undermines the force and import of the New Testament rituals being a fulfillment of Old Testament rituals.The Old Testament rituals don't just point to the person of Jesus.They also point to the sacraments that he instituted.And they don't just point to like symbol to symbol.It's symbol to fulfillment, symbol to reality.So every time a Protestant argues that baptism does the exact same thing as circumcision, he's undercutting.It is a there's a a parallel, but it's the fulfillment of circumcision.Remember the religion was intended to go to the whole world.
Not everybody in the world could be circumcised.Duh.Okay.But everybody in the world can be dunked in water, right?So the simplifying of the means, the matter of the sacrament doesn't mean that there's a low church and it's just bread, water, and wine.It's simplified to be available to all, but it's a reality that is brought to all that the Old Testament symbolized.It is pointless to go from symbol to symbol.
So the Old Testament washings and circumcision are symbols that point to the reality that baptism actually accomplishes.Otherwise, the movement makes no sense from symbol to symbol.How can the New Testament rituals be fulfillments if they don't do anything different than what the Old Testament did?That's just a symbol, friend.It's just a symbol, friend.Okay.But the Old Testament was all symbols.So what?
Again, the Eucharist is not merely a symbol because the animal sacrifices were symbols.The animal sacrifices point also to the Eucharist which is not just a symbol.It is the flesh and blood of Christ.You must eat my flesh and drink my blood and then you have eternal life in you because it is the flesh and blood St.Israel says of some random guy.No, of the God man.The second person of the Godhead.The angel of the Lord.The angel of the Lord is not a creature.He's the second person of the eternal son of God.That is the angel of the Lord.Same person, identical, same thing.And all these rituals, guess what?Jesus gave the rituals.
Jesus wasn't created by God.his human nature.He created his own human nature.Okay?And this temple also symbolizes his created human nature.Do you see the inner gold and the outer stone according to many of the church fathers?The inner gold his divine nature.The outer stone his human nature.And remember symbols are polyvalent.They don't just stand for one thing.All the low IQ, bad arguments, all the dumb heretics, they always think words only have one reference.They only mean one thing.Okay.Well, the temple stands for a bunch of things.It is a type of Mary.Mary had God within her.She gave birth to God the son.So Mary is a kind of temple.Paul calls the New Testament writers call the church the temple.So the temple is a type of the church meaning the people but also meaning the entire collective universal body of Christ.
All of the people who are in Christ is also the temple.Right?

35. Temple Implements and Their Fulfillment

Walkthrough of temple furnishings including the ark, showbread, lampstand, and carved images, showing how each prefigures Christ, the Eucharist, and Orthodox church architecture, refuting iconoclastic readings.

When we go inside this temple uh let's see if we can find these pictures.Not very good.This one might be a little better.I can barely see that.See if we can zoom in on this thing.
Okay, let's see if we I can barely see that myself.So,
let's see.
Okay, if you notice here, let's see.
So, when we come into the temple, you can barely see it, but there's supposed to be uh the table of showbread or the mana.And the table of showbread was a reminder of the prov provision of God in the wilderness.Okay.How does Jesus exedute uh the mana in John 6?Well, he says it's the Eucharist, right?So, notice then you have the the altar, excuse me, outside uh the labor of washing before you enter in.When you enter into the temple, then you're in the holy place, right?So, the outer portico, we're going to go through different uh meanings of this in a second here, but outside is for the nations, right?uh only Jews could enter into the holy place and then only the high priest could enter into that inner holy of holies there.And we're going to see what that symbolized in a minute.
But uh so we notice the implements inside the temple.We have uh carved images all over the walls.Notice the walls have I can't I can barely see what it is in this picture.It looks like uh you know angels and stuff, right?So like cherubam, saraphim, right?Uh-oh.Images.Uh-oh.Uh-oh.So clearly the ten commandments are not forbidding all images because there's images in the temple and not just that the ark is an image and it's got images of saraphim on top of it.So we have the table of showbread and the showbread as we said was a uh the the bread of the presence the bread that reminded them of God's provision in the wilderness uh the mana and then that obviouslyfor us would point to the eukarist as well and then we have uh the altar of incense uh the church has retained incense because in the book of revelations if you read chapters 4 5 and 6 you'll see
that from our vantage point.John is looking into heaven and seeing a temple worship service.He's not just seeing random uh in coat uh disorganized visions.He's seeing a worship service.And in our view, when he says the beginning of the book, I was in the spirit on the Lord's day, John is saying, I was worshiping on Sunday.I was at the in other words, I was at the divine liturgy on Sunday.Right?And he might have been, you know, alone in the aisle of Pabosmos, but he could still have a worship service because he's an apostle, right?And what's he see?He sees into heaven and sees a heavenly liturgy.He sees people wearing vestments.He sees incense.In other words, he sees them the saints in heaven that were martyed offering as incense
the prayers of the saints on earth.So every day some Protestant says to me,"Wh do you believe in the prayers praying to saints?"Well, we don't pray to the saint as if it was a god.Okay?We are asking the saints to intercede for us because they are in heaven involved in a heavenly worship service, right?Everybody follow that.If you don't, we can go to the text in a minute if you guys aren't familiar with it.But for now, let's just set that aside.We'll look at the apocalypse in a minute.So we see this here and then uh the incense and there's also the lampstands.Who does John say is the represent?Well, the lampstands represent angels.They represent the seven spirits of God which Isaiah talks about which are divine energies according to Isaiah.What is Isaiah 11?uh and then it represents the seven churches of Asia Minor in his letter and it represents the bishops of the churches, the angels of the churches.
Okay, so in our view it stands for all those things.But the lampstand is primarily an image of the church, but it's also an image of the tree, the tree of life.It's also an image of the cross.It's also an image of the universe.And I covered that in my video I just did the other day about the symbolism of the tree of life.Okay, everybody remember that?Well, so th those are all things clearly in our view that point to the New Testament.They point to the work of Christ.But one key point where we depart from the Protestants is that the Protestant thinks that there's some sort of like denigrating aspect to any of this carrying over into the worship.So it has to be like this mental thing.Oh yeah, sure.All of that stuff points to Jesus and his work.
But friends, Jesus said it is finished.There's no longer need for a temple.There's no longer need for sacrifice.There's no longer.And yet he turns around and says, "We must give ourselves that sacrifice.We must give ourselves to be a living temple."Exactly.So what does Peter say?I saw him on the holy mount.Uh-oh.So you're saying, "Wait a minute.Peter in the New Testament says that when he saw Jesus transfigured, it was the holy mountain."Uh-oh.That means that in the New Testament, there's still holy places, sites, locations that are uniquely holy.A holy place.Protestants don't think that way.Friends, everywhere is holy.There's no holy place.Everywhere is holy.Really?Why does Peter say, "I saw him on the holy mount."
Now, there are still holy things.What does it say in the book of Acts?They brought cloths from Paul's body and laid it upon those who were possessed and the demons left.Those are called relics.So the New Testament has relics.So the New Testament has over and over and over things that we see as part of the Old Testament service.And so we come up with this uh important question that the New Testament in just in terms of the text itself doesn't immediately resolve.And the question is what elements of the Old Testament worship service and liturgy carry over?What about an altar?Does an altar carry over?What about a priesthood?Does a priesthood carry over?What about bread?What about wine?And you could say, "Well, okay, but bread and wine are mentioned in the New Testament."Yeah, but how are we supposed to interpret bread and wine in the New Testament?
Is it just a symbol?Is it a real presence?Is the bread and wine supposed to be the climax of our worship service?Or is reading the Bible and the preacher standing up there in his business suit the climax of the worship service?You see how this is uh interpreted very differently between Protestants and Catholics?I mean, excuse me, Protestants and Orthodox.And we're going to get to the Catholics in a minute because I said we would get to that.But uh I'm gonna have to go to the little boy's weevery room because I drank a whole bunch of coffee.So hold your horses.Don't go anywhere.Uh once again, you can watch my uh music video about mind control, which doesn't make any sense in terms of what we're talking about, but it's right here handy.So don't go anywhere.But I do have to wee wee.
I'll be right back.
be bing.
baby.
Hey
Hey,
hey,hey.
All right,
back to the temple.

36. Holy of Holies and Heavenly Liturgy

The Day of Atonement ritual as type of Christ's eternal self-offering in heaven, and the Orthodox teaching that the earthly liturgy is joined to the heavenly liturgy through the incarnation.

So, uh, we have here
in the Holy of Holies, as hopefully most of you guys know, the holiest of objects, the ark of the covenant, and of course, the Ark of the Covenant had the pot of mana, another reminder of the mana inthe wilderness.It had uh Aaron's rod, a tree that blossomed miraculously.The tree of the cross, the tree of life.Again, the tree imagery.I just covered this.But inside the ark was the ten commandments, right?the tabular, the tablet word of God, the uh pot of mana, again, the miraculous bread, uh the reminder of Exodus, and Aaron's rod that blossomed.All of those for us point to Christ.Christ is the tree that blossoms, the the tree of life.Christ is the mana according to John 6.And Christ is also the ark of the new covenant.Uh because he is Emmanuel, God with us.The ark was the presence and power of God with the Israelites, right?
And that for us is a type or a foreshadowing of the incarnation.It's also a foreshadowing and a type of the Virgin Mary.Mary the thecos obviously is the ark who had within her the son of God.She was uh the presence of God amongst the people uh by being the uh mother of God, right?And having acquiescing to in the annunciation when Gabriel visits her, yes, let it be done according to me according to thy word.So another element though that's often missed that the book of Hebrews makes a big deal about is the yearly feasts of the Jews, particularly the day of atonement.Because on the day of atonement, as you guys know, the way it worked for the Jews was that the priest, hopefully you guys know this, the high priest, right, is the only one who could enter into the inner
sanctum.So the inner sanctum is that little door, the the little inner inner thing, right?So only believing Gentiles could be outside the temple.That's the uh portico of the nations.You could say the inner place, Jews, only Jews could walk into the temple.And then only the high priest could go into the holy of holies and that only once a year.And he uh by the way if he messed up might die, right?So they would attach a rope to him.They would uh he had little bells on the bottom of his vestments so that they could listen and make sure he's still jingling.And if there was no jingling, uh oh, we might have to pull him out cuz nobody can go in there.And also you couldn't uh only Levites could touch the ark.Right?So there's these these strictures put upon uh who can do what.
Again gigantic portions of the Old Testament deal with this.So then the uh ark of the covenant as we said uh is was also called the mercy seat.Right?This is the meeting place of God with men.Again Jesus incarnate is the meeting place of God amongst men.uh he's Jacob's ladder, right?All these Old Testament images are pointing to Christ.But what we're talking about here is the day of atonement and the idea that on the day of atonement, the high priest, as you could see here, would take the blood of the sacrifice.He would walk into the inner sanctum and then into the holy of holies and he would sprinkle the mercy seat with the blood of the sacrifice to quote provide atonement for the people.Now, even the Old Testament tells us that the blood of goats and bulls doesn't plate God.
The blood of goats and bulls doesn't actually achieve forgiveness of sins.So, what was the point of all this?Is it just made up?Is it just pagan stuff?No.If we read the book of Hebrews, we know very clearly what the point is.The point of this was to explain what the Messiah would do throughout his whole life and ministry.And so, not only would he come to be born and dwell amongst men, but he would also complete the duties of a high priest because he's the eternal high priest, the priest after the order of Mechisedc, who alsofulfills the priesthood of Aaron.And just as the ironic high priest would go into the holy of holies and accomplish atonement in a symbolic way on the day of atonement every year for the Jews.So Jesus when he ascended into heaven, this is the argument of Hebrews, get this, would ascend into not just the sky, not just the heaven of space, but the heaven of heavens, the third heavens, God's throne, and achieve
an eternal atonement by eternally presenting himself to the father eternally on the eternal altar of sacrifice in heaven where he eternally officiates as high priest and as sacrifice.That is the meaning of the temple for us.And it doesn't go away.It is still the case
because in the eukarist we are participating in that same thing that is going on in heaven.So in other words, what's going on on earth in the temple and tabernacle was a type of the heavenly liturgy and worship, the eternal liturgy and worship.And in the New Testament, we believe that the church is the reality of heaven and earth meeting.It is the same service.The liturgy that's going on on earth is the same one, not a type, right?Old Testament is pointing up to what's going on in heaven.New Testament, because Christ is incarnate, it's joined.So the liturgy on earth is the liturgy in heaven.That's the Orthodox view.See the difference there?Thus, when we read the apocalypse,

37. Revelation as Heavenly Liturgy

Revelation chapters 4-6 describe a heavenly liturgy with lamps, vestments, incense, and elders, showing saints in heaven offering the prayers of saints on earth, validating Orthodox intercessory prayer.

let's go over here to the apocalypse and we'll see what I'm talking about.We'll start uh dang it in five
or maybe we should start in four
because if we notice as John is moving uh through his descriptors in uh four, five, and six he's describing what he sees.These ads are so annoying.In heaven, I was in the spirit.Behold, I looked a throne in heaven.one who sat on the throne.Obviously, we know it's from the rest of the epistle that this is uh Jesus.And remember in uh Revelation 1, John describes Jesus when he appears to him exactly the same way as Ezekiel describes one like the son of man, the glory of God that he met.Ezekiel says he saw the glory of God, the second person of the Godhead on a one like the son of man on a throne.Who is that?I wonder.So hard.So hard to figure out.I can't I wonder who he's talking about.And he who sat on the throne was like again the descriptors of uh from Exodus, the Jasper, the Sardius, etc.
Emeralds, all of the uh rubies and whatnot description.And then he sees the elders in heaven, the saints that have gone on.They have crowns of gold, okay?Halos, uncreated uncreated light.We see the throne uh lightning proceeding, thundering, voices, seven lamps.Okay, this is a liturgy.The lamps, the seven lamps before the throne.This is the lamps that we saw in the temple that we just looked at.In other words, the temple on earth is a symbol, a little miniature, a little model of what was in heaven.Because remember Paul says that Moses received the pattern of worship based on what was in heaven.The whole argument of the New Testament and the Orthodox church is that the reality of the worship that the Old Testament temple was a type has come in Jesus in the New Testament in the church.It's the same thing as what's in heaven.
That you see that's the argument.So Muslims where is any of this?Where is any of this in your theology?We'll get to the uh points again about the altar and the throne.But look, so in heaven, what does John see?Well, he sees lamps.He sees uh uh a throne.He sees uh elders.Uh and let's move to five.So are you noticing that he's seeing lurggical things?This is stuff from the temple, guys.Temple stuff.Levitical stuff.Do you not know this?Okay.Then he sees uh the lamb one on the throne opening up seven seals.We know these are the seal judgments.Who is it on the throne?It is the lion of the tribe of Judah.It's Jesus.Okay, everybody knows this hopefully.Uh we see by the way uh he's described as the lamb.Where does the lamb imagery come from?
Passover.The lamb of Passover.Worthy is the lamb.Again, does none of this makes any sense if you don't have Levitical Exodus history in mind, right?Okay.So, he sees this uh his blood, the blood of the sacrifice of the lamb, all Levitical imagery.He has made us to be kings and priests, priestly imagery, temple imagery.Uh I know that Muslims don't accept this.This is against the Protestant.This was the point I said Protestants, we would look at, why do you pray to saints?Why come you pray to saints?That's pagan.We don't pray to the saints.I'm going to show you why we do what we do.
Okay.So, he sees a giant.This is a worship service.Okay.They're doing worship.They're not doing crazy charismatic worship.They're not flopping around and acting like retards and dogs, are they?No.They're doing lurggical worship.It's singing.It's antipol.Right.Then he sees uh cherubim, living creatures.They start participating in the worship.He sees angels.He sees what is on the temple walls.He sees the reality of what the temple was simp sign signifying.Do you understand that?Okay.So key texts here Protestants.This is for you guys because I get this asked this every day.Now the lamb opened the seals.Uh okay.Come and see.Behold crown conquering.Okay.We see war and conflict on the earth.
martyrs.Then he opened the fifth seal and I saw under the altar the souls of those who had been slain for the word of God and for the testimony.They cried out, "How long, oh Lord?"Okay, again, Protestants, do you not realize this is a worship service?You think this is just people like flopping around acting like charismatic goobers in heaven?No, it's a service.It's divine liturgy.Okay.And they're praying.Who are the saints, the martyrs praying for?They're praying for vengeance for the saints persecuted on earth.Okay.Then they're given a robe.Oh, that sounds like liturgy.Okay.Then we see moon turn to blood.Okay.
Okay.Then we have the ceiling.
Uh oh.
Then we go back to five.I forgot the text in five here.
Now when he had taken the scroll, the living creatures and the elders fell down before the lamb, each of them having a heart with golden bowls of incense.So the saints are in heaven offering bowls of incense, which are what?The prayers of the saints.So the saints in heaven, the martyrs that have gone on are offering as incense in heaven.prayers of the saints on earth as we just saw in the in the other chapter.
This is why we believe that the entire church on earth and in heaven is part of the same worship service.So in other words, it's like me saying, "Hey, St.Athanasius, pray for me because he's there in the service.That's it.That's that's what all you people divided over, all you Protestants are mad about.You think it's pagan."No, it's not pagan.It's right there.It's the same lurggical worship service.And David, by the way, in the Psalms speaks to the angels in the liturgy, in the worship service.So, if you understand the context, all this makes perfect sense.Nothing to do with paganism.Nothing to do with contacting the dead is a sorcerer.That's what they always think.Okay?It's none of that.So what's the uh conclusion here?

38. Orthodox Church Elements Carrying Over

Specific elements carried from temple and synagogue into Orthodox worship including altar, iconostasis, vestments, incense, and tabernacle, with archaeological evidence from ancient house churches.

Let me show you this.
All right, let's just do it this way.
So in the Orthodox church then you'll notice thatuh as an example
here.
So the for us then here are some of the elements that we believe do carry over not arbitrarily but according to ancient Petristic tradition from the earliest times you will find the church worshiping in a eucharistic sacrificial altarway.And I can barely see this.I wish I could make this bigger, but you'll notice that you you see we have similar things to what existed in the temple.And in fact, you'll notice the structure and look of every Orthodox church is actually very similar to both the synagogue and the temple.And that's on purpose.And so you'll notice there the uh the eukarist then has the prime place in the worship service.And so it is seen to be the uh offering.And not only that, we've actually maintained we've retained the idea of things being set off as holy.So if you look over here, you'll notice that not everybody has the right and the authority to just walk up there and worship and do whatever they want, right?
You can't do that.Only men are allowed on the altar and only a male priesthood qualifies as a priesthood according to the order of Melkisedc.So you'll see then these that that behind the aonostasis.The reason there's there's an aonostasis there is that that's a tradition where the church had an altar and even ancient churches have this rail or this guardway.Okay, from the earliest centuries that sets the eukaristic altar off from the congregation.Okay.and and Protestants just simply don't know that this actually goes way back.And I've covered that article many many many times.Uh I'll share it again for you guys because it always comes up.Um I think it was a Catholic guy that wrote it but uh
it's about how the early home churches you can look at archaeology show that they were uh lurggical.So this is no I don't want to promote Tim Staples talking about it.Uh, it's on it's on OrthoChristian somewhere.
Here it is.The Eucharistic liturgy in the ancient house churches.So, go and check this out and you'll see that a lot of times what they do is convert a a rich person's villa.Okay?And then they would mark off the altar area for the Eucharist.Right.I've got that too zoomed in.Sorry about Let me fix that.So
there.Hopefully you can see that.
So I can barely see that.
So if somebody's uh some rich person had a house church and they converted, right?This is where we get basilas from.It's like rich people converting their houses into churches.Okay.And then you have um
there's another picture that's actually better than this one if I can find it.Let me put this in the chat for you guys because there's another picture that shows how they had the Eucharist, the altar and everything kind of marked off as separate.But you you can begin to see how uh this is based on that's not it.the idea that we should still retain the idea of things being set apart and holy in the New Testament.Right?This is not a purely Old Testament idea.The New Testament has carried over.That's not it.I think it was on some Catholic guy like a Catholic lurggical scholars website and he has a picture where it shows the way that they would set off maybe it's this guy.See who this is.They would set the uh they still had an alter is what I'm trying to say.
No, that's not it.See if we can find it.
That's not it.I don't know.I can't find it, but somebody can find it cuz uh somebody this has been copied a million times on a bunch of different websites, but if we can find the original article be best.Is it the call to communion guys?Maybe.Uh nope, that's not it.
Is it that?No, that's not it.It's like a Catholic website talking about it's some Catholic liturgy guy.Like it might have even been a Catholic bishop.I don't remember.Does anybody know the article I'm talking about?Does anybody find it?No, that's not it.Anyway, I don't know.I can't find it.But
hopefully you get the point what I'm trying to say.Um.Oh, maybe it's this one.No, that's not it.Maybe it's it's something.Oh, maybe that's it.
No, that's not it.
Oh, it's a specific I know what it is.It's specifically about home churches.Is that right?What the?
Yes, I think this is it.This is it.Yeah, this is it.
Okay.So, here's the original.That's probably the same one, though.
I thought this had it marked off for I've seen another illustration where the altar would be in the early church.I wish I could find that one.I don't remember where it is.But anyway,
maybe it's this one.
H.
Oh, maybe it's this one.
No, that's not it.Anyway, I give up.But I mean, we can you guys realize we can read people from the first and second century like we can go read Ignatius, Erynaeus, Justin Martyr, Tutoleian, and we can see how they worshiped.Okay?And and they all describe it as a lurggical worship.Okay?So, like this shouldn't be that this shouldn't be that controversial.I wish I could find that one.uh thing where they had ityou could you could see in the house churches how they had it divided where the uh altar was um anyway but back to the point uh when it comes to the Orthodox church that's the whole purpose of theeconostasis uh in the in the west it was a rail right so they had the uh communion rail uh the the the Latin right churches the western right orthodox still have the rail.
Uh but even in the ancient western rights of the first thousand years is it if you look at the old ancient churches and what what's still exists in terms of architecture uh they actually look like Orthodox churches toothe ancient western churches ironically.So, but um
uh I don't like this website, but this looks like they're making my point that
the setup of our altar comes from the Old Testament.And that's why again we still have the altar because as we saw Hebrews 13, we have an altar that we eat from that the priest at the tabernacle have no right to eat from.Paul describes the New Testament meal as the Eucharist as an offering.He uses offering language in his epistles and in Corinthians.Uh the offering is identified as the body of Christ in the book of Hebrews as an eternal offering.We also see in the New Testament that uh by the way, I'll get to the super chats in a second, guys.Um
that this this is an an ordered worship service, right?It's not a DIY thing.And we see that the priesthood continues in the New Testament as a priesthood after the order of Mechisedc.

39. Hebrews 9: Old and New Worship

Hebrews 9 describes old covenant regulations for the earthly sanctuary, and the differences between old and new worship including the rent veil, bloodless sacrifice, and bread and wine replacing animal blood.

And uh just briefly read this.Uh in the first covenant as the old covenant, there were regulations of worship for an earthly sanctuary.The tent was prepared, the outer one, the lampstand, the bread of the presence as it called the holy place.This is everything I just went through.Um he mentions what was inside the ark.Uh this is all from Hebrews.One of the neat things about orthodoxy is that our traditions go back not only to uh early Christianity but in terms of uh in some cases things before Christ.The setup of the temple for example we read about the temple in Exodus uh and about it in the book of Hebrews.This guy's making the point I was just making.You will see that some of the things from the temple are still existing in our church.As with the first covenant we have regulations about our worship in the earthly sanctuary.
The divine liturgy is celebrated in the same way across the entire planet.It has been for centuries.And we uh have this facing east.I forgot about the facing east.That's something that is common as well.Uh the domes, the icon screens, etc.We have uh the two tents, particularly the sanctuary where the lady gather, the narthx, and the nave.And we have lampstands.We have tables.The altar is the uh the table of the eucharistic altar.Only the priests and alter boys uh can go behind the aonas to the table.Um, we have the incense.We have the tabernacle which is contains the new covenant.That is the body and blood of Christ.The So, for us, you if you look at a Jewish synagogue, you notice they have the Torah uh in the the little tabernacle thing.For us, it's the Eucharist that's in the tabernacle because we think we're participating in and eating the living Torah.
We think that Jesus is the living Torah.Um, around the altar are the representations of the cherubim.The round discs are carried around in the procession of the altar.By the way, the round discs uh are the fans, right?They represent the uh angels participating in the liturgy.And if we if you notice, we just saw in the book of Revelation, John was talking about the angels, the cherubimmen, and the liturgy in heaven.
There are differences, however, between the worship then and now.So, Protestants, keep in mind, because Pro, you're just a bunch of Judaizers.You're coming up with ceremonies, traditions of men.No, no, no.There's differences.So, not everything carries over.There's differences.Messianic Jews, Hebrew roots, cult.Okay.Not everything carries over.Some things don't carry over.There's some differences.The second tent that is the altar, the altar, holy altar is no longer covered by the curtain.In the service, there is a curtain, but in the service, the liturgy, the curtain opens.That's because the veil is rent.So, Protestant there, the veil is rent.There's no longer no no the veil is rent in the service.
During each service, the people then see into the holy of holies.That's why it opens.That's the meaning of the veil being rent for us.The priest no longer takes blood and offers it for himself and the heirs of the people.The priest takes bread and wine.What did Melkisedc bring out that we saw in Genesis 14?Bread and wine.and offers a bloodless sacrifice.The New Testament sacrifice is not a human sacrifice done over and over and over as Protestants think we're doing in our liturgy.It's called a our rational knowetic worship.The gifts become the body and blood of Christ and they're offered to the people in order that we all may be cleansed of sins.So, I don't know who this is.This is a article that came up.Uh it's just a kind of a brief overview.It actually doesn't go into the the symbolism in depth, but if you do want to read this little brief thing, here it is.
And remember guys, too, uh Lewis's video is a really wellpresented long version of that.Okay.So, if you want the full reference, here's Lewis's video on the continuity between the Old and New Testament in terms of worship, which is a crucial point, not just for Protestants, guys, but also for Islam.And how does it relate to Islam and Judaism?Well, this is the final clincher point we want to get to here for this whole talk.But yeah, you're going to have to give me a second because my computer is about to die.So, let me plug the computer in.I'll be right back.
Baby
also remember if you want to go deeper into the temper temple tabernacle stuff uh Sarapim Hamilton and I have done um I don't know like five different episodes together where we go pretty deep into a lot of that.So, uh, if you enjoy this discussion, this topic, uh, definitely want to go check out the discussions that, uh, Sarah from Hamilton and I did, and you want to check out, uh, Lewis's video here that I'm going topull up,
uh, that makes all these same points here.

40. Lewis's Video: Priesthood and Malachi

Lewis's documentary demonstrating continuity between synagogue, temple, and Orthodox liturgy, including Malachi 1:11's prophecy of incense offered among the Gentiles fulfilled only in liturgical Christian worship.

So, let's see.
So, you'll notice like uh uh here comes the ads that was actually a perfect uh example of something that you wouldn't expect.
So, you'll notice,look at that Orthodox bishop.Well, he just happens to look just like example of the priest.Now there's some differences because uh there's some difference of influence right not everything that uh orthodoxy doesn't completely bear the stamp of u the Hebrew tradition it also has a uh influence from uh Bzantium.So there's there's a Byzantine stamp of influence as well as the Hebrew stamp of influence too throughout the history of the church.Uh but that's only natural for um an institution that is primarily uh gentile, right?But coming out of its true Hebrew roots.So we would say we're the real Hebrew roots movement, right?Not these crazy cults.But um that's just one example, right?Let's see some other examples that uh so uh Lewis in this video does a great job of pointing out all kinds of objects um in the New Testament iconasis.
Here he's using the fans that I mentioned uh which are um angelic representations that go back to Exodus the cherubim.Um he gives the tabernacle referencing the mana.You could reference the ark as well.Uh, let's see what else did Lewis pick out in this video.Um, I'm just using a couple examples.Here's where he was showing uh the synagogue andthe the uh the Torah.
So let's So you'll notice here that in the synagogue, right up where the the holy place, you could say in the synagogue is where the the the tabernacle of the Torah, right, is put behind the the veil.And that for us that corresponds to there's the Orthodox liturgy and you'll see that the stasis.Well, the altar would be up there, right?So, here's the a a parallel with the gospel being read like the Torah, you see.
So, let's see what else.
Uh, antipal chanting.That's a lurggical element that I mentioned.Uh, we So, a lot of this I've already covered.Um, he goes into the Eucharist and this is a great documentary, by the way.So, I highly recommend that says the blessings, right?Uh Paul gives the blessings at the end at the Orthodox church at the end.You get the priest gives the blessings.So, it's the same things.All of this stuff again, and this is a key point that I wanted to get to in Lewis's video.
Okay.
The notion of priesthood.Okay.Uh, and this icon here is the icon that I chose for my uh video as well.And it's the famous icon, Christ the high priest, because Christ the high priest refutesthe three opposition, the three opposing views in the title, right?Islam, Judaism, Protestantism.There is the royal priesthood of all Christians, which is a participation in the eternal Melkazedcian priesthood.1 Peter 2:9, Christ is the one who offers and is offered as a high priest.Hebrews 8, John 18, as the lamb of God.Uh, this is a controversy in early Bzantium that I've covered many times.Sacramental priesthood typified in the bishop.Malachi 111, Acts 1:20, 1 Corinthians 10:16, and Malachi 1, incense will be offered all over the world to the na to the God of Israel.How is that possible?Remember in Leviticus that we just saw, you can't just up and do whatever you want.
Oh, I'm going to start my own little worship service over here, right?I'm a I'm a Pacific Islander.I'm going to start my own little worship service because it says in Malachi that the na that far off nations, islands will worship the God of Israel.Oh, well, that's just doing whatever you want.No, you can't just do whatever you want.You can't just offer sacrifices and incense as you want.And yet Malachi says, right, incense will be offered all over the world to the God of Israel.How is that possible?It's not possible in the ironic system because incense can only be offered lurggically in the temple.And yet the prophecy says that it will be all over the world.And that's just one example.Okay?There are so many prophecies throughout the minor prophets, right?Of all of these all the nations.We've covered that many, many times over.
You go watch my old videos.I'm not going to rehearse all that.Uh of the uhthe gentile nations worshiping the God of Israel.But we want to look at a couple here because of what they say in terms of lurggical worship.So this says Malachi 1, it's a a section where it describes daily lurggical pre priestly offerings.Okay, that's the context if you read Malachi 1.And we know this famous messianic prophecies.Okay, so this is not we don't it's not like we don't know what Malachi is talking about.We cited it multiple times in the New Testament about the coming Messiah.For as the rising of the sun to its going down, my name will be glorified amongst the Gentiles, and in every place incense will be offered to my name as a pure offering.My name will be great amongst the Gentiles.
How is incense a lurggical offering that is only done according to Levitical law by the sons of Aaron?How is that going to be done by the Gentiles in all the nations?It seems impossible unless oh what do you note Jesus is the fulfillment of this and Protestants we have a description of lurggical worship incense in the New Testament in the messianic era.This is a prediction of the church.
But your churches, Protestants don't have offerings and you don't have incense.How is this fulfilled in you?
Anyway, Lewis goes on to describe the laying on of hands as a transferring of authority, which I covered earlier, the priesthood.Uh, and let's see what else.Mentions new covenant priesthood.All right, that's enough.Got to get all these boomer ads going.Um, get this off of here.Stand this woman's face.Talking about butt cheeks.Get this out of here.What the heck?

41. Continuity: Judaism, Islam, Protestantism

Comparative analysis of hierarchical priesthood, sacrifice, feast days, and temple imagery across Judaism, Islam, Protestantism, and Orthodoxy, showing only Orthodoxy maintains full continuity with Old Testament worship.

All right.So, this is a helpful graphic here again from Lewis.I can barely see this.So, he says,uh, Judaism, Islam, Protestantism, and then orthodoxy being the apostolic, right?Questions of continuity, discontinuity, and conclusion.What about a hierarchical priesthood?Okay.Judaism kind of.Yeah, they would still argue for that.Uh, but what's a key point against the Jewish position here?Uh, where has the priestly offering been for the last 2,000 years?Now, I read Genesis 49, and Genesis 49 says that when Shiloh comes, one to whom the nations look, it says there won't be
a house of David.So the removal of the Davidic throne is a sign the Messiah has come.
Judah as a lion's wel from the prey my son you have gone up he bows down he lies down as a lion as a lion who will who will rouse him the lion of the tribe of Judah thescepter will not depart from Judah that is the kingly rule nor the lawgiver until Shiloh comes and to him will be the obedience of the nations in other words when you see the departure of the rulership of thehouse of David when that's gone then you'll know that Shiloh has come because the nations will look to him.Okay, that's the Messiah.What happened when Jesus came?Well, in 70 AD, the Jews lost the priesthood and the kingdom.There's no king ruling.There's no ironic priesthood.Where is it?Where has that been for so long?
Oh, well, you see, there has been a priesthood.And there has been an offering to God's name amongst the Gentiles.Malachi 1:11.There has been an altar built even in Egypt in Syria and all the places where were formerly God's enemies.Do you remember Isaiah?There will be an altar in Egypt to my name.How could there be an altar in Egypt?You understand that if we're Jews, you can't build altars like you can't just do whatever you want.Okay?
The altar can only be in Jerusalem.You can't build your own altar.Do you This is not too difficult.It's not that hard of an argument.Right?
Again, uh I'm I'm going to just assume that you guys can go watch the other videos that we've done countless times about how the church itself is a proof of uh Christ as the Messiah, right?Because one of the things that is said dozens of times over in the Old Testament is that when the Messiah comes, the Gentile nations will worship the God of Israel.And uh what do you know?When Jesus came, that happened.And the Davidic lineage ends in the sense of a ruling king because we think Jesus is the final Davidic king, right?And uh when what do we read in Isa Isaiah 19?Somehow it says Egypt and Assyria will be together with Israel as God's people.What?How can Israel be together with Egypt and Assyria?One of the three, a blessing of the Lord, my people Egypt.Blessed are my people Egypt.
Blessed are my people Assyria.Blessed is Israel, my inheritance.What?That's crazy.Unless Oh, yeah.There's an altar in Egypt to the Lord as Isaiah 19 predicts.Now, the other text I wanted to get to again, there are dozens of predictions of the gentile church being a sign of the Messiah.
That means that the last 2,000 years church is the fulfillment of that.There's only one that fits that.The Orthodox Catholic Church.What does Isaiah say at the end of Isaiah, this curious text?Gentile priests.How is that possible?
And I'm also pointing this out because again, do you not see uh Muslims?None of this even makes any sense with what you're talking about.You don't have priests.You don't have an altar.You don't have what we're talking about here.
I know their works and their thoughts.I will gather all the nations in tongues.They will come and see my glory.I will set a sign amongst them.Amongst them, those whom uh who escape, I will send them to the nations, to Tarsish and Pull and Lud, who draw the bow, to Tubal and Jan, to the coastlands who have not heard about my f.This is the gospel.The apostles going out preaching the gospel.They will declare my glory among the Gentiles.They will bring your brethren for an offering out of all the nations
and I will take some of them for priests and Levites.Whatpeople amongst the nations are being brought as an offering to the God of Israel.my glory amongst the Gentiles and I will take some of them for priests and Levites.
You are a priest forever according to the order of Melkisedc.Now remember there will be an offering of incense amongst the Gentiles to the God of Israel.There will be an altar in Egypt where Assyrians and Egyptians and Israel will all worship the same God.How can you have an altar in Egypt?and gentile priests taken from amongst the nations to become priesthood.That's not possible in the Jewish law and Protestants.Where's your incense and your priesthood being offered that's offering to the God of Israel?It's all spiritual.It's all spiritual.Well, how come nobody understood it's all spiritual until Luther and Calvin and your guys, right?How how come everybody took this to be a lurggical phenomenon for so many so centuries century after century where we have hierarchical priesthood existing in Judaism and orthodox Christianity according to Lewis's graph here.Okay.Uh does that exist in Islam?

42. Gentile Priests and Isaiah 66

Isaiah 66's prophecy of Gentile priests and Levites, Isaiah 19's altar in Egypt, and Genesis 49's departure of the Davidic scepter as signs of the Messiah, all fulfilled only in the Orthodox Church.

Absolutely not.Does it exist in Protestantism?Absolutely not.So, who's in continuity between the Old Testament, what's in the Torah and the prophets, and the and the New Testament religion?Because remember Deuteronomy 13, Deuteronomy 18.Whatever comes, that's new revelation supposedly has to be consistent with what came before.Okay?So, we're looking for the things that carry over.We're told that priesthood is eternal.We're told that there's an eternal everlasting Israel.There's an eternal Sabbath.There's an eternal priesthood, an eternal offering, an eternal covenant.Okay, where is this?Because it's in it's got to be in continuity.It's got to be in continuity with what the promise to Abraham was as well.Who is the son of Abraham truly?Well, according to Galatians, it's Jesus, the one to whom all the nations look.
Where's the lurggical worship?Does Islam have it?Nope.Protestants?Uh, not really.So again, commonality there.The idea of atoning sacrifice, does that exist in Judaism?Yes.Islam?Absolutely not.Does it exist in Protestantism?Uh, not really, but maybe.Just the finished work of Jesus, friends.But no continuing notion of sacrifice, even though they turn around and admit there is a continuing notion of sacrifice.Give yourselves as living sacrifices to Jesus.Intercessory prayers are sacrificed, right?Do we have feast days?Not really.Islam?No.Judaism?Yes.Orthodoxy?Yes.And guess what?Helpful indicator here.Some of the same feast days.Pentecost.Pentecost is in Judaism.Pentecost.It's in orthodoxy.Pusca.It's in orthodoxy.Pusca.Passover in Judaism.There's helpful indicators there to tell you who's in continuity.Do Protestants or Muslims have that?No, they do not.
The notion of uh symbolic temples with imagery and a layout.Does that exist in Islam?No.Protestantism?Not really.Maybe Anglicanism a little bit.Does it exist in orthodoxy?Yes.The notion of divine imminence Islam?No.God is not in the this world.God is not imminent in Islam.Right?Yet the Old Testament says countless times over Muslims with the theophanes which are presifiers of the incarnation.Again, you guys are just completely ignorant of what the Old Testament actually teaches.You think you're in continuity with it and you're totally ignorant of what it actually teaches because there's countless instances of theophanes which I've covered in countless live streams.So divine eminence which is clearly taught in uh the Old Testament and in the law and the prophets is it taught in Protestantism?Yeah, they they teach it but they don't believe in a real presence or anything like that.
They're iconoclastic like Muslims.So not really um restricted accessin terms of ley and heterodox Judaism maybe.I'm not sure why that's xed out, but the idea exists from Judaism, but they don't have a temple, so maybe that's why Lewis put an X there.Um, Islam, and by the way, there's not a priesthood, right?I mean, Jews might argue that they can resurrect the ironic priesthood.Uh, maybe some kind of DNA stuff.I don't know.But like, we're arguing that the priesthood has always been there.You see, you see the point of this argument?Where's your priesthood?Protestantism, um, no, doesn't really have that unless it's some kind of reformed church, maybe.Uh, Orthodox Christianity, yes.Ritual elements, Judaism retains it.Islam, I mean, I guess they have a couple rituals, right?But not really.Um, Protestants minimized.So, again, uh, the principles here are pretty clear.
So crux of the argument is
yeah I think I covered all my notes.The only thing I didn't really get into was uh what Jesus does in the Gospel of John in terms of arguing about continuity with the Pharisees, right?Because Jesus is consistently arguing that, you know, he worships the same God as the Old Testament, right?the father.He's he's in continuity with the worship of the Old Testament in that it's the same God and father that gave the Jews the law.And in fact, key point in the New Testament, Jesus is who gave the law, the Mosaic law in our view.So, who's consistent?Well,

43. Roman Catholic Critique and Abrahamic Faiths

Critique of Roman Catholic natural theology and the Abrahamic Faith House, showing from Galatians that only those in Christ are Abraham's seed, and that generic monotheism does not constitute continuity with the Old Testament.

Let's take a look.Now remember, in order to be in continuity with the Old Testament, you can't throw out the elements that are the key indicators of the covenant and the continuity.So, we can't throw away all of these things and say, "Oh, I'm in continuity.are you?How can you be if you don't have the priesthood or the high priest himself, Jesus, the priest after the order of Mechisedc?How how can you think you're in continuity without that when it's so fundamental to the Old Testament texts?It's a very simple argument.So when we look at
altar, priesthood,temple, holy sight, liturgy, sacrifice, incense, holy water as in holy washings, right?Does any of this exist in Islam?No, it doesn't.So you're not in continuity with the Old Testament.That's the point.So you're not the true inheritor of the Old Testament.You are out of continuity.Only Orthodox Christianity is in continuity.The last point then aboutthe uh uh Roman Catholics that I wanted to mention was oh well you see aha Jay we you can't pro this argument functions in no way against the Roman Catholics because uh you know they also have this ideaof priesthood.Okay.Well, that's true, but
what is a key uh terminal flaw?
Well, the Vatican has opened up a common faith center.They support this.This is uh Francis'scommon worship center thing that he got together with remember when he got together with the grandmom and they drew up this the document that God wills all the world religions document and then that birthed the idea of theuh Abrahamic faith house center that they're going to build or they have I don't know if they built it yet to open in 2022.So, I don't know if it's open yet not or open yet or not, but uh the article from the Vatican notes that when uh old Frank met with the Grandom, they talked about their shared values.This here's the hideous looking structure that they're building here.You know, it's always looks like some sort of uh space stuff, right?Like some nasty uh ridiculous dystopian sci-fi novel.
whenever they build this uh world religion crap, it's always like this ugly sci-fi looking stuff, right?So, and as you guys know, we've covered Nostraat, we've covered the Vatican 2 uh notion ofuh generic theism, natural theology a thousand times over.remember their whole ethos, their whole thing with how they've taken natural theology is to mean, oh well, we all have the you believe in one God, I believe in one God, we all believe in the same God, whichis actually a fallacy, right?I have one mother, you have one mother, we all have one mother.Is that true?No.It's an obvious fallacy.And I can't understand why Trent and all these people can't understand this, right?Just because you say one God does not mean that we all believe in the same God.Just like we all come from one mother doesn't mean we all come from the same mother.
It's a really simple point.And yet the whole absurdity of this as if because all of these three religions call themselves Abraimic, they're they are therefore Abrahamic.No, they're not.I mean, has no one read Galatians?I'm baffled by this.Do you get to be a child of Abraham because you say, "I worship the God of Abraham."No.Okay.That that that's not that doesn't make the cut.What does Paul say in Galatians?This shouldn't even be up for debate.It's very bizarre to me that so many Roman Catholics are making this ridiculous natural theology argument.Are you a child of Abraham simply because you say I worship the God of Abraham?Uh, no.Because who are the children of Abraham?Who does Paul say, "Brethren, I speak to you in the manner of men.Though it is only a man's covenant, if it be confirmed, no one knows or adds to it."
Now, to Abraham and his seed, the promises were made.Who is Abraham's seed?According to Paul, it's Jesus.So if you don't have Jesus, you don't have his seed.You're not you're not one of Abraham's seed.That's the whole point of Galatians.
The whole point of this chapter is to say that you're not Abraham's seed by being merely externally circumcised or biological descent or by just saying, "Oh, I'm Abraham's I'm Abraham's seed."Or by following the religion of Hagar.None of those things make you that.According to Paul's argument, and I'm saying this to the Roman Catholics because the Roman Catholics are the ones saying that we're all monotheists because so we all have the same Abrahamic faith.No, we don't.The only people who have the Abraimic faith are those who follow Christ.That's it.No one comes to the father by but by me.Did Jesus say, "Oh, but unless you're a follower of Muhammad, then you can still get to the father because you believe in one God."No.The one God, the father, is only accessed by the high priest of the covenant, the son of God.
There you go.So, all of this is canceled out in the Roman Catholic view by their stupid argumentation and acceptance of the ridiculous natural theology idea that because we all have a monotheistic faith that therefore we all worship the same God.
It's ridiculous.It's completely stupid.And Paul's whole argument hinges on the fact that you only have access to the one father through the son.For you are all sons of God, the father through Jesus.No, there's no other wayin Jesus.There's not Jew or Greek or whatever.If you are Christ's, then you're Abraham's seed.There is no generic monotheism that makes you Abraham's seed.There is no such thing as an Abra Abrahamic faith house of the world religions.But in the Pope's program, there is.And that tells you that that religion is false.That alone should tell you that religion is false.
Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

THE BEST EVER Cumulative Case for the Trinity