1. Responding to the Plagiarism Accusation
Dan introduces the accusation against him and explains how he first encountered the report. He outlines the document’s claims and sets up his response to the alleged plagiarism.
I have been credibly accused of plagiarism.Hey everybody, I'm Dan McClellan.I'm a scholar of the Bible and religion.And an awful lot of people who are feeling the intuitive pinch of cognitive dissonance in light of the West Huff situation are trying to self-soothe by calling me out.For instance, evidently being a Mormon is a graver sin than plagiarism.But a lot of folks are saying what if someone went through all of your scholarship to try to find plagiarism?And I have said be my guest.I hope you find something.And then this last Sunday I was in the middle of a live stream when someone messaged me and said, hey, have you seen this?And provided a screenshot of this tweet by an account that goes by Dan's _ end.And I hope that's a clever play on the cozy clothing company Lands' End.
But it says in case anyone is interested, this report shows dozens of verified instances of plagiarism in Daniel McClellan's work, source comparisons and citations included.And then there's a link to a document that's being hosted on Adobe's website.And I have added that link to my Linktree if you want to go see it.And this is the document, Attribution and Originality in the Published Work of Daniel O.McClellan, A Report on Plagiarism and Self-Plagiarism, Anonymous Report, November 15th, 2026.And this is obviously produced by AI.And it is an attempt to try to find within all of the publicly available scholarship that I have provided through my uh, through academia.edu, through other sources.It's an attempt to go through there and find plagiarism.And there are two different of texts that are evaluated in this report.And the first in which it identifies two instances of plagiarism is entirely false and just a hallucination by this AI.
And we'll go through that.But the other counts 22 occurrences of self-plagiarism between two other published works of mine.And that's actually where there is a case to be made.But the case that is to be made is one that I don't think the person who produced this report really understands.But the first instances are between this paper of mine, a re-evaluation of the structure and function of two Maccabees seven and its text critical implications that I wrote as an undergraduate student at Brigham Young University and then publishedin a student journal when I was the editor of that student journal and I think 2008.And the other text that I'm going to be accused of having plagiarized is G.W.Bowersock's Martyrdom and Rome from 1996.
2. Why the Bowersock Claims Fail
He walks through the report’s examples involving G.W. Bowersock and argues that they are not plagiarism. Dan explains why the AI misread paraphrase, context, and scholarly dating arguments.
So let's take a look in the report where they actually documents the plagiarism.Here is the first documented instance of plagiarism.And we have an image here that shows Bowersock's text on the top and my text on the bottom.And the label at the top says the same temple absence argument, a comparison of the argument and its attribution.So the sentence that is being shared here from Bowersock says in a work that celebrates in almost every chapter the second temple at Jerusalem destroyed in AD 70 as still standing, doubtless reflecting an obsession on the longer originaltext, the two tales of resistance utterly lack any reference to the temple.And here Bowersock is talking about the story of Eleazar's martyrdom and the story of the mother and her seven sons.Now, we go down to what I said in my paper.In 2 Maccabees 7, there is also a complete absence of any mention of the temple, which is peculiar considering Antiochus's forced consumption of pork, as far as it is attested, occurred within the Jerusalem temple.
Now, the fact that there is an unusual absence of any mention of the temple in chapter 3 has been noted by many scholars, and it's not the intellectual property of G.W.Bowersock.It is not his copyrighted intelligence.This is something that a lot of people have noted on their own, that I noted on my own.And as you can see, there's not any kind of direct or indirect relationship between the way this fact is stated.So really, this AI evaluation just decided that I must have gotten that from Bowersock somehow because Bowersock says it, and then I said it in a completely different way and in a different context as well.Uh so this is nonsense.This is definitely not plagiarism in any way, shape, or form whatsoever.But now we're going to go on to a slightly different claim, which is not about plagiarism, but which is ostensibly a claim about me not understanding Bowersock, or at least ignoring Bowersock.
So here we have page nine, an earlier date proposal and a later originality claim.Read the conditional proposal beside the claim about earlier scholarship.So we have incomplete sentences here, which is not irrelevant, but Bowersock on the top says they could even be associated with the Roman Empire after A.D.70.Now, what's wrong with what I said?Well, I said to this date, no scholar has undertaken to explain the implications of chapter 7 as an interpolation or provide a date for it.And then under that, the AI evaluation says, uh Bowersock had proposed a possible post-70 setting 14 years earlier.Now, the idea here must be well, Dan was wrong.Dan was not original in providing a date for this.Bauersock provided a date.But did he?Let's take a look at page 11 in Bauersock and I'm going to give you the whole paragraph.
The stunning resemblance of the resistance shown in the two stories of the second and fourth books to the resistance shown in various Christian martyrdoms has led many to believe that these accounts reveal a Jewish tradition that surfaced hereto provide the inspiration and model for what came later.Certainly one can readily admit that they were a primary justification for including books of the Maccabees in the biblical apocrypha and they were undoubtedly much appreciated by the apologists of the early church.But since there is no reason to think that the two accounts reflect the historical time of the Maccabees, what time they do reflect is anyone's guess.In as much as they do not make reference to the temple and seem to be additions to the narrative, they could even be associated with the Roman Empire after AD 70.Now, in my paper, I was actually making the case that that is a good time period to date Second Maccabees chapter seven as an interpolation.
Now, this is a paper I wrote almost 20 years ago and there's been criticism of my paper, particularly by Jan Willem van Henten, um, whom I've interacted with a few times and I haven't revisited the argument.I don't know that I would stand by it anymore.However, this paragraph is not arguing for a date for the interpolated seventh chapter of Second Maccabees.It's just saying it could even be this late, whereas I am saying I would like to argue that it is this late and here are all the reasons why.So, the notion that I falsely claimed originality because Bauersock already arrived at that conclusion is also laughably wrong.This AI analysis got that entirely wrong.So, let's look at the last purported occasion of plagiarism of Bauersock.We're actually staying in the same sentence.The two proposals for a date after 70 CE compare the shared date boundary and the different degrees of certainty.
We have above Bauersock, they could even be associated with the Roman Empire after AD 70.And then we have my argument, the preponderance of evidence favors a date after the destruction of the temple in 70 CE.Below that, the post 70 proposal appears in both discussions of the martyr narrative.So earlier, the AI analysis says I ignored Bauersock and was not aware that he had already proposed a date.Here, the AI analysis is saying I stole the proposal of that date from Bauersock.But no, I didn't because Bauersock did not propose it.He just said, hey, this is even possible, but we don't really know.And I said, here are a bunch of considerations that make that the most likely conclusion, not because Bauersock said it, because that's the conclusion I arrived at after doing the research that I did for this paper.So the notion that this is plagiarism of any kind whatsoever is absolutely laughable.
In absolutely no sense whatsoever did I ever plagiarize Bauersock in any paper I have ever written or published or concocted in the night.That's just asinine.
3. Admitting Self-Plagiarism in Publications
Dan turns to the real issue: overlap between his 2021 chapter and 2022 monograph. He acknowledges the self-plagiarism, explains why it happened, and says he will check with publishers about any contractual concerns.
But that brings us to the credible accusations of plagiarism and the particular type of plagiarism.And these accusations involve two published works of mine.The first is an essay I published in this edited volume, Life and Death, Social Perspectives on Biblical Bodies, which was published in 2021 and edited by my dissertation supervisor, Francesca Stavrakopoulou, who invited me to take a small chunkof my dissertation and rework it into this paper for her edited volume, Forming Divine Bodies in the Hebrew Bible, which takes some of my doctoral dissertation and reworks it into a paper about Forming Divine Bodies.The other published work is my 2022 open access monograph, Adonai's Divine Images, A Cognitive Approach, which is a revision of my doctoral dissertation.So that brings us to what kind of plagiarism is going on here.As we see on page 12 of the AI analysis, self plagiarism, the 2021 chapter and the 2022 book where I am accused of on 22 different occasions drawing words, phrases, or individual sentences from my doctoral dissertation in both
the 2021 paper as well as the 2022 open access monograph.And I'm not going to go through each and every instance, but you can see here on this page you have a catalog of all the occurrences of plagiarism.The first two, as I've already shown, are asinine.And then the other 22 are instances of shared language between the paper and the monograph.Now, this is real plagiarism.It's called self plagiarism and it would have all gone away if I had actually just added a footnote to my 2022 book saying some of this research has already appeared in a different form in this paper that waspublished in this edited volume in 2021.Now, I was actually dealing with the manuscripts for both of these close to the same time period.I should have been aware of that.I should have added the footnote that pointed that out.
If I had done that, there would be zero issue whatsoever, but I did not do that.And that is a lapse on my part.But what it's not is an ethical violation of any kind whatsoever.It's an issue of transparency and potentially a copyright issue.And that brings up where I am going to hold myself accountable beyond acknowledging that there was a lapse there.I should have noted that there was overlap with some of the language that appeared in the paper from my reworking of a smaller portion of my doctoral dissertation.But there is potential that this could be a violation of one or both of the contracts that I signed for the publication of the paper as well as the open access monograph.I have reviewed both contracts to the best of my ability to understand the language of publication contracts.I don't see any problem.
However, I'm not the judge of that.And it just so happens that in a few days I'm going to be sitting down with the very editor of SBL Press to whom I submitted my proposal for my 2022 open access monograph for other things.But I'm going to talk to them about this.I'm going to say, is there a breach of our contractual relationship in this?What do you need me to do to make you whole?And then I'm going to go over to the TNT Clark editor, and I'm going to do the same for them because I'm going to a Biblical Studies conference and a lot of the academic Biblical Studies publishers are goingto be there, both acquisitions editors and other editors and other representatives.So I will have an opportunity this weekend to go find out what I can do to make them whole if they decide there is any breach of any kind whatsoever, which they may not.
They may say, I don't care because this is not an ethical violation.This is not plagiarism of someone else's intellectual property.This is not me falsely representing something to the public apart from accidentally failing to be transparent when it comes to the relationship of the research I published in the 2022 monograph to a paper I published in the 2021book.So that was a lapse on my part.I should have been more transparent.I should have been cognizant of the fact that I had just published this paper and there was overlap in some of the language.That's on me.I take responsibility for that and I'm going to find out this weekend how I can more fully take accountability for any issues that might arise as a result of the overlap in language between these two publications.
4. Apology, Accountability, and Follow-Up
He apologizes publicly, takes responsibility for the lapse in citation, and says he will report back after speaking with the publishers. Dan closes by revisiting the deleted post and briefly wrapping up the situation.
So to the public, I apologize.I wasn't aware that this overlap in language was there.I should have been aware.I wasn't.I will do better.This will never happen again in any sense whatsoever.I did commit self-plagiarism, which is a different kind of plagiarism, but is plagiarism nonetheless.And I will take full and complete ownership of that.I will take accountability for that.I will make things right.When it comes to the Bowersock plagiarism, those claims are laughable.That's absolutely not true in any sense whatsoever.But let's revisit that post.Here is where I said, happy to see the best AI could do searching all my work for plagiarism is 22 examples of me using the same words, phrases, or sentences between my 2022 book and a 2021 paper inan edited volume because evidently I failed to note the paper was drawing material from my dissertation.
But then you'll note that below the image is gone.It says this post is from an account that no longer exists.And if you try to go to Dan's End, uh the account no longer exists.They deleted their accounts.And it's not because they did the work they came to do.It's because I shared this immediately.And all the people who went and looked at it said, this is meaningless and came back and said, good job, dude.You did nothing.And that content creator thought better of this account and just went ahead and deleted it.So it seems like this may not yet be Dan's _ end.But it's in the post, obviously.At some point, someone will discover all of my nefarious schemes and plots.But to recap, I have been credibly accused of plagiarism, specifically self-plagiarism between a chapter in an edited volume and the published revised version of my dissertation.
And I am going to take full accountability for that, and I apologize to the public again for that lapse in citation, in my citation practice, in potentially causing problems for one or both of the publishers of these works.And I will report back to you within the week on what I discover when I go talk to these publishers.Thanks everybody so much for watching.I appreciate your support.And the fit for this video has been Rogue and Gambit forever.