Transcript
Use with ChatGPT / Claude Auto-scroll A
Introduction to the Investing Through the Cycles conference, followed by an analysis of Bitcoin's typical Q4 midterm-year dumps and historical bear market lengths.
Hey everyone and thanks for jumping back into the cryptoverse.Today we're going to talk about the first investing through the cycles conference.We'll also go over Bitcoin a little bit here as well as we are getting our typical dump into Q4 of the midterm year.If you guys like the content, make sure you subscribe to the channel, give the video a thumbs up, and also there is still time to get your ticket to the ITC conference.It is starting today.It's actually starting uh this afternoon.There's also going to be a lot of talks tomorrow.If you can't make it today, you can scroll down here.You can see all the speakers that we have.Uh we also have the agenda posted as well um for the 20th, the 21st, and for some of the ticket holders, uh the 22nd as well.So, I do hope to see you guys here.
And one thing to think about when when you're at the conference is to remember that we've got people that will express bullish views and bearish views, but that the goal is that you leave understanding the different points ofview so that you can synthesize that into your own view.That is the goal of the conference and I hope that we are able to accomplish that.Now, with that said, Bitcoin right now is trading at around $60,000.Okay.Now, what we're seeing happen right now isn't that crazy.I know it it feels like it is, right?Like, it feels like this time is different, but remember, Bitcoin normally dumps at this time in the cycle.Q4 is a time that Bitcoin in midterm years, Bitcoin's just allergic to midterm years and especially the fourth quarter of midterm years.I don't know exactly why, but it's an observation that we've been able to make many, many times.
And so I know it was really easy to sort of dunk on these views, especially during the rally in January and February going into May and then obviously even easier to dunk on it going into September.But it does go to show you that the fourth quarter of the midterm year is always a really difficult a really difficult time.And if you zoom out, what you'll notice with Bitcoin is that February, the summer, and Q4 tend to be when lows occur, give or take a month, right?Sometimes the low, the final low ends up being in January, sometimes it ends up being in November.Um, sometimes the February low ends up being in late January rather than early February.So, it's not an exact science, but in general, you would expect a February low, a summer low, and a Q4 low.Sometimes can be off a little bit, right?
Like in 2014, 2015, we saw Bitcoin bleed all the way into about mid January.And that was a that was actually a pretty long bare market.I know a lot of people think that that if we go to a new low, it would it would sort of break things, but if you look at the length of this bare market so far, it's been about58 weeks, right?It's been about 58 weeks.Now, it might be tempting to look at the last couple and say, well, the last one was 54, the last one before that was 52, but we also had a bare market in 2019 that was around 37.And we also had a bare market that a lot of people ignore that actually started um back over here in November of 2013 and it lasted arguably 59 weeks and on some exchanges it actually lasted 90 weeks.
Right?So even if you just take the January low as the low instead of the low that came later that swept that low in August that was still a 59w week bare market.So I I don't want people to like to lose sight of this and to say well you know it has to be October or it has to be Jul there there's interpretation right like there's there's variance that canoccur.It's not an exact science right it just simply isn't.And so with Bitcoin right now, what you're also seeing, we just added this new chart to the website.If you look at the ETF flows going into the IPOs, you can see that the ETF flows going into the SpaceX IPO bottomed out around 20 days or so after the IPO.And so you can see going into the anthropic IPO, we're also potentially going to see the same thing.
back then they actually leveled out for a bit and that allowed Bitcoin to bounce for a few days arguably but eventually it it did in fact go lower.
Explores how gold and commodities lead Bitcoin's lows, examines onchain risk metrics like MVRP Z-score, and discusses the realized and balance price levels Bitcoin historically touches in bear markets.
Now I am a big believer and I know some people might not agree with this but I actually do think that metals are telling you where Bitcoin is going to go and what it's going to do.I know it's easy if you're in crypto and you're you sort of have a blind eye to commodities, but there is a reality that it's pretty typical for things like gold to bottom before Bitcoin in midterm years.So if you look at 2022 for example, Bitcoin bottomed or sorry, gold, if you zoom in over here, gold bottomed in late September.Bitcoin did not bottom until November, right?And if you go look at 2018, for example, gold bottomed in August, Bitcoin bottomed in December.So for me, as long as I see metals continue to drop, it's hard to be bullish, right?Right?I mean, like, like I want to be, but we also have to recognize that it's Q4 of a midterm year.
What's happening in the crypto industry right now is not that different from what we've seen before.The main difference is that we had a more apathetic top, but that also happened in 2019 as well.And then it eventually led into the pandemic induced recession, which led into money printing, right?And going into that recession, you know, it certainly felt really really bad.But I've actually argued a lot that like what if what if we're kind of repeating something similar where you like sweep a high and then you sell off into the actual cycle low, right?Like what if we're just repeating that?And I know like the pandemic is not the best comparison, but it kind of lines up.Now, you could also look at 2015 and see that there was a sweep of a prior high that then led into the actual capitulation low.
So, I just want people to be open-minded about this stuff and to say, you know what, a lower low could easily occur, right?I mean, if you look at I if you believe that commodities kind of show the way, you can kind of see what I'm talking about, right?because gold had a low in Q1, had a low in the summer, and then now it's printing another low in Q4.Even if you look at other random things like Netflix, for example, Netflix had a low in February, a low in the summer, and now it's trying to find a Q4 low.If you look at stable coin market cap, you'll see the same thing.This is a little bit different because um the the February low and the summer low were basically at the same level, but the Q4 low, we don't know where stable coin market cap is going to bottom at.
But because it's breaking down, it would be some justification for, you know, thinking that, hey, like maybe Bitcoin's just going to follow what what all these other things are doing.And and that's okay, right?I mean, that's okay from a from a draw down perspective, right?If you look at Bitcoin ROI after the cycle peak and you go say peak out to the next peak, this is this is still a really common time for capitulations.Do you guys remember the 2014 comparison we made earlier 2014 2015?Like this is around the time that Bitcoin went into that final capitulation.You see, and if you look at it through the lens of the year-to-date ROI and we average out prior midterm years, right?If we average out prior midterm years and look at 2026 and we can overlay one standard deviation onto that, you'll see that, you know, it's kind of a normal time for Bitcoin to show weakness just because it bottoms
sometimes earlier.It's still often weak, you know, around this time frame.And like you can see that this is I mean we also kind of got out of this range at one point before and then went back to it.I know these things can be scary, but I think there is some justification.And when you combine all of it into an onchain risk metric, you know, one of the big things about onchain data that I think a lot of people get a lot of flack for is that a lot oftimes people use onchain data as a way to always be bullish because you can actually use onchain data in a way to always make it sound bullish.Because if there's a lot of people buying, it's going to make the onchain data look crazy and then people are going to use that as a reason to say, "Look, it's bullish."
But often times when we get to extremes, it's easy to pretend like the bull it's easy to pretend like the actual bearish things are bullish.And when we get to the extremes in the bare market, it's easy to extreme the or pretend like the really bad things that are happening are bearish.What I want to draw your attention to is the fact that onchain risk has historically bottomed below current valuations.So to say that this time is different is simply ignoring what happened every other time in every other bare market that Bitcoin has had.So I will repeat that.To say that this time is different is to say that all the other capitulation lows were diff were are somehow going to be different than this one.But the thing is is all these prior lows that occur with the onchain risk occurred when the onchain risk was below 0.1.
We're currently at 175.And if you look at something like the MVRV Zcore, the actual capitulation lows tend to occur below zero and it's currently at 27.So what you're seeing right now isn't really that different from what we've seen before.And one of my favorite charts that I've I've showed you guys a ton is the realized price and the balance price.And to show how Bitcoin dropped below the realized price at the end of 2018, it was actually around now.If you zoom in, Bitcoin dropped below the realized price on November 19th of 2018.And last cycle or sorry in in uh 2022, we actually dropped below it in June.got back above it and then finally stayed below it for a while starting in November.So, it's November now.And I just want to remind people that the realized price is at it's actually just below $54,000.
And that might sound like a scary number, but it's actually what's happened before.We've also seen Bitcoin historically go to the balance price as well, which is actually a bit lower than the realized price.But I don't really want to hammer that one too much because until we get below the realized price, it seems like a silly exercise.Furthermore, if you look at the balance price, there's actually been a trend towards not even necessarily touching it this coming time.So, I don't want to put the number in people's heads too much because I'm not really sure, but it is just a a reality that hey, this might feel different than prior times, but it actually is really thesame.
Compares Bitcoin's current behavior to its average performance after rate hikes and government shutdowns, arguing the current dump is historically normal despite feeling painful.
And if you look at how Bitcoin has behaved after the first rate hike in a rate hiking cycle, and you just simply look at the average of the last two, Bitcoin's generally tracking what it normally does after thefirst rate hike in a rate hiking cycle.On average at this point, Bitcoin has dropped or the ROI from the rate hike has been about 082.We're currently at 79.Again, on average, they end up bottoming out at a value at a 68.So about 32% down from where the rate hike occurred.That doesn't mean we're going to track the average, but if you look at the last two, you know, if you if you look at the last two and you compare it to where we currently are, we're kind ofright in between, right?right in between what happened after the first rate hike in a rate hiking cycle during the last two events.
And then if you look at what Bitcoin has done after a rate hike in September of a midterm year, you can see we're also sort of in between.And if you look at where we are now with the average, this shows you that Bitcoin is doing almost exactly what it historically does on average after a rate hike in September of a midterm year.I know it is tempting to use things like the RSI and the MACD and all that stuff to justify things and talk about like bullish divergence, but the reality is that Bitcoin is also dependent on other things.And sometimes those indicators fail.There's a reason why I don't talk about that stuff that much, right?There's a reason why I don't ever mention like head and shoulders or inverse head and shoulders.It's be it's not that that it never works out.
It's just that the win rate on it is so low that I don't believe that you're going to benefit any more than just flipping a coin.That's why I don't talk about that stuff.That's why I talk more about things like momentum because momentum can make a big difference, right?Momentum is a is a thing that's important.And if you're not familiar with what I'm talking about, an asset that is going up is more likely to continue to go up than an asset that is not.So if there's one asset going up and one asset going down, a lot of people will sell the asset going up to buy the asset going down.But usually what happens is the asset that's going up keeps going up and the asset that's going down keeps going down.That's why it's often a mistake to sell winners to buy losers.
There's a reason why the winners are winning and there's a reason why the losers are losing.Arguably, one of the main reasons why Bitcoin is losing right now is because we are likely going to tighter monetary policy.And I remember this feeling at the end of 2018.It felt almost exactly like this because what happened is we were basically pricing in peak hawkishness at the se at the December FOMC when the Federal Reserve released the summary of economic projections.They projected out two rate hikes in 2019 and Bitcoin sold off essentially into that FOMC meeting, right?We also have a government shutdown coming up.So you guys remember how we talked a little bit about the IPO for Bitcoin and what it normally does going into the IPO.You can see it it tracked it and but when you once everyone's watching it, you got to look at something else.
And the thing that I think makes sense to look at now look at we can maybe have a chart for the FOMC, but there's also a potential government shutdown occurring right around the next FOMC.And if you look at what what Bitcoin's currently doing compared to the average performance of Bitcoin going into government shutdowns, it's actually not that different.And if you go through each one, um, you can kind of see what I'm talking about, right?So if we compare the current one to 2013, you can see, you know, it's kind of a similar pattern.If you look at it, 2018, very similar.That's early 2018.Here's a later time in 2018.You can see Bitcoin sold off into the government shutdown.Here you have late 2018.Bitcoin sold off and then sort of bottomed out before the government shutdown.Here's 2025.That's a little bit different.
That was a bull market year.And then 2026, you can see it sort of held on, then sold off into it.And then later 2026, it sold off into the government shutdown.So on average, Bitcoin is doing what it normally does.So think about it like this.Bitcoin is dumping in Q4 of a midterm year.We have to ask ourselves, is that what normally happens?Does Bitcoin normally go down in Q4 of a midterm year?Yes.Yes, it does.That was a great question.I'm glad you asked it.Does Bitcoin normally drop going into a government shutdown?I don't even know if we're going to have one, but does it?Yes, it does.Does Bitcoin normally drop after the first rate hike in a rate hiking cycle?Yes, it does.Does Bitcoin normally drop after a rate hike in September of a midterm year?Yes, it does.
Does Bitcoin normally go to the realized price in a bare market?Has it always gone to the realized price in a bare market?Yes, it does, right?I mean this is what this is what it does.So there's a reality of Bitcoin is actually doing exactly what it always does after these events take place.But we've conditioned ourselves to believe otherwise because when you're going through it, it feels really, really bad.Think about it like this.When the markets are going up, it feels like they're never going to go down.And when the markets are going down, it feels like they're never going to go up.It's played out a lot in the past, right?These are patterns that we we see happen in the crypto space over and over and over again.And I think it's better to recognize them than to pretend like they don't exist.
Reviews the Bitcoin supply in profit/loss chart and potential downside targets, then wraps up with conference logistics, ticket information, and closing remarks.
That's my assessment, right, of of let's just take these into consideration.I know it I might sound crazy saying, well, this is what Bitcoin normally does after a rate hike in September of a midterm year, but we can look at it and say, you know what, maybe it wasn't thatcrazy, right?Maybe maybe it wasn't that crazy to talk about what does Bitcoin do going into a major IPO when we first launched this a few weeks ago.Now everyone's talking about it.And when everyone talks about it, I would I would go to something else.That's why you won't find me talking about it too much now because I'm like, well, it was valuable to me when it was just this channel talking about it, but now on Twitter, everyone's talking about it.You know why everyone's talking about it?Because now it played out, right?
And now they be like, "All right, well, now it looks more bullish."Don't be afraid to confront indicators if they go against your bias.Don't be afraid, right?It's okay.And you know, one of the most favorite charts of mine by far is the Bitcoin percentage of supply in profit or loss.It's a beautiful chart.And you might say, well, this is different, Ben.Like this never happens before.Like Bitcoin like they they've crossed again.Like they crossed earlier in the summer and now they've crossed again.Okay.Well, has that ever happened before?It happened in 2022, right?I mean they crossed in the summer and then they crossed again in Q4.So and even in 2014 you can see they crossed in September and they kind of uncrossed again and they this happens right?Bitcoin does this stuff.This is normal.It is normal for Bitcoin to drop this amount.
It would be normal for Bitcoin to go into the low 50s.What would actually be abnormal is if it doesn't go too much below that.Bitcoin could literally go to the 30 to 40k range and still be within the realm of historical standards, right?I'm not saying it has to go that low, but when you look at 2018 and 2019, Bitcoin also found support at 6K throughout the year and then the actual low ended up being between 3 and 4K.So it always sounds scary and no one who talks about it has ever, you know, they're sort of viewed unkindly, but I it's a consideration that we have to at least think about.Okay.So if Bitcoin loses 60K here and and we go down, then every other asset's doing it, right?I mean, gold's putting in lower lows, silver's putting in lower lows, Netflix putting in lower lows, the NASDAQ itself has gone below the summer low.
The S&P is below the summer low.So, I keep asking myself if the S&P can go below the summer low and the stock and the NASDAQ can go below the summer low and gold can go below its summer low and silver can go below itssummer low and stable coin market cap can go below its summer low, why would Bitcoin not?Why would it not?That's what I keep asking myself.So, I hope these views have been helpful to you guys this year.And um I got to go get ready for the conference.I'm looking forward to seeing you guys there.We're going to have a lot of great speakers.I'm looking forward to meeting a lot of you.Um I think it's going to be a really great weekend.There is still time to get a ticket if you don't have one.Um uh so if you just go over to get tickets, you can you can get a ticket before the conference starts.
We do have uh a few more openings um for, you know, for especially for tomorrow.Today we got we're going to we're going to be pretty packed, but uh we still have some room.So, make sure you get a ticket if you are especially if you're in the area and you just want to come and and hear some different opinions.Still time to get your tickets.Thank you guys for being here and I hope it's a good conference and I hope it's a conference that investors can look forward to potentially annually where we can come together and try and assess the market from anobjective perspective and to say you know what we want to learn about what's going on in the markets.We don't want to assume that we have all the answers.That's why we bring together people that hopefully can provide opinions on the market that maybe open our eyes to seeing things to seeing the market in a way that we maybe previously did not imagine it right.
And so that is my hope for the conference.And if we can do that, then I think the conference will be a success to go and listen to people who have different opinions and not just about Bitcoin, right?Other markets as well to listen to different opinions and to say, you know what, we're going to be open-minded.And why are we open-minded?Because there's not a single one of us that is right about everything.Especially me, right?There's not a single one of us that's going to be right about everything.And as I speak, you can see that that the Bitcoin is now actually below $60,000.So, I think the the conference timing is actually pretty good.Uh it might have been it might have been a little bit better actually if I had it another month from now.Um but I think I think about late November is is is pretty good as well.
So, I look forward to seeing you guys there.Thank you for for being here.And if you want to view the live stream, then become a member of the YouTube channel.just join it and that'll be live streamed.For the ITC members, we'll we'll we'll sort of package up the the videos and try to upload them uh you know within the next week or so.And if you don't want to do that, if if you don't want to join ITC Premium or you don't want to join the YouTube channel because you got other things to do, that's completely fine, right?Like I get it.We're going to upload it all like we're going to upload a lot of these talks for free the week of December 7th, right?So you won't have to wait that long.Just a few more weeks.That'll give us time to sort of package everything up.
But if you want to try to view it live, uh I actually got to go right now in a few minutes and make sure we can get that set up.If you want to go view it live, make sure you join the YouTube channel and you should be able to see the conference live and that'll be starting here in uh in just a few hours.So, thank you guys for being here and I will see you next time.Bye.