# Dr. David Dube: Author, Former Dep. Speaker of MP Legislature &  former HOD of Human Settlements

**Channel:** Mitv Network
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BF_od5oQEk4
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/BF_od5oQEk4

## Chapters

- 0:12 — Introduction and Book Background
- 4:22 — Land Deals and Arrest Context
- 13:30 — Political Pressure and Early Conflicts
- 26:57 — Threats, Hawks Inquiry, and Case Origins
- 37:46 — Hidden Interests Behind the Case
- 52:55 — Exoneration, Legal Action, and Closing

## Transcript

**[0:12] Speaker A:** Welcome to the state with Talani Dub. It's so good again to have you. And today we've got a very important guest who has written a book. We'll read more. We'll talk more about this book. And he's known in the province of Bumalanga. He's been an HOD of the department of uh was it human settlement and eventually the deputy speaker of the province of Bumalanga. Now we've have Dr. Dub. Dr. David Duba. How are you doing?

**[0:38] Speaker B:** I'm okay. Thank you.

**[0:39] Speaker A:** Good to see you. Baba

**[0:40] Speaker B:** Simia.

**[0:41] Speaker A:** Thank you very much for finally get to to to come through. We we've been trying to get hold of you but eventually you you come.

**[0:49] Speaker B:** Yeah. and and we appreciate your time and energy that you've come to to to to see us here on the state.

**[0:56] Speaker A:** Thank you so much.

**[0:57] Speaker B:** Now, why why I was really interested in you and and then is that uh when we finally started to communicate our office with you is you were you about to uh release a book. Is this your first book? Let's start there. Is this your first book? No, no, no. You've written a couple of books.

**[1:15] Speaker A:** I have written many many books.

**[1:18] Speaker B:** Many books. Okay. But I only published seven books.

**[1:22] Speaker A:** Seven books. Okay.

**[1:23] Speaker B:** This is number seven.

**[1:24] Speaker A:** This is number seven.

**[1:25] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[1:26] Speaker A:** This is completion.

**[1:27] Speaker B:** Yeah. It's done. Done. Done and dusted.

**[1:30] Speaker A:** All right.

**[1:31] Speaker B:** Um I completed this book in June.

**[1:35] Speaker A:** Okay. June this year.

**[1:37] Speaker B:** This year.

**[1:38] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[1:38] Speaker B:** I started this book in 2023, but I just took notes. I was not necessarily writing.

**[1:50] Speaker A:** I was taking notes of what was happening which I will explain what happened.

**[1:55] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[1:56] Speaker A:** So I then completed this book during the same June I completed another book. So

**[2:06] Speaker B:** two books.

**[2:07] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[2:07] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[2:09] Speaker A:** All books are done.

**[2:11] Speaker B:** This book has got more than 700 pages.

**[2:14] Speaker A:** I see. I see. I was reading through it. I couldn't finish it but

**[2:18] Speaker B:** sure

**[2:19] Speaker A:** it has got more than 700 pages.

**[2:21] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[2:23] Speaker A:** Then um the second book

**[2:26] Speaker B:** it's also thick I chose not to publish it now.

**[2:31] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[2:32] Speaker B:** The reason why I chose not to publish that one is because of the unfortunate situation of the passing on of former deputy president David Mabuza. Oh, okay.

**[2:47] Speaker A:** Yes. In that book, he's the main character.

**[2:51] Speaker B:** Oh, okay.

**[2:52] Speaker A:** Exactly. So, when he passed on,

**[2:56] Speaker B:** so you halted that.

**[2:58] Speaker A:** I did exactly that because I did not want to become insensitive

**[3:04] Speaker B:** and people would say you're opportunistic about it as well.

**[3:07] Speaker A:** So, I withheld that book.

**[3:09] Speaker B:** Then I continued with this one. M

**[3:12] Speaker A:** there's a reason why I continued with this one.

**[3:15] Speaker B:** Tell me why politically infested.

**[3:18] Speaker A:** Yes. The reason why I titled that book,

**[3:25] Speaker B:** it's because there's a case that I was undergoing.

**[3:30] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[3:31] Speaker B:** The state charged me and prefer charges against me in 2020.

**[3:39] Speaker A:** 2020. Yes.

**[3:41] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[3:43] Speaker A:** October 2020, I was arrested.

**[3:46] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[3:48] Speaker A:** Then the case started proper in 2021.

**[3:52] Speaker B:** Sorry. Hold. Who Who's arresting you? The police.

**[3:55] Speaker A:** The hogs.

**[3:56] Speaker B:** The hogs.

**[3:57] Speaker A:** Yes. They arrested me

**[4:00] Speaker B:** for reasons that I explain in the book

**[4:05] Speaker A:** which I explain also in the book that I was unduly arrested.

**[4:11] Speaker B:** Okay, listen. My arrest was not correct.

**[4:14] Speaker A:** Okay, let's start here now. Um, case number MCC 18 stroke 21.

**[4:21] Speaker B:** Who opens this case?

**[4:22] Speaker B:** Is it you?

**[4:25] Speaker A:** So that case m The title,

**[4:28] Speaker B:** yeah,

**[4:29] Speaker A:** has got two cases,

**[4:31] Speaker B:** right?

**[4:32] Speaker A:** The first case is the one of Nell's Bridge.

**[4:36] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[4:38] Speaker A:** It's also reflected in the book.

**[4:40] Speaker B:** What was happening in the case of Nellspridge?

**[4:42] Speaker A:** It's about a piece of land that the Department of Human Settlements

**[4:47] Speaker B:** Mhm.

**[4:48] Speaker A:** bought on behalf of the Emalachini municipality

**[4:53] Speaker B:** in So hold on. The department of

**[4:56] Speaker A:** human settlement

**[4:56] Speaker B:** which is the provincial department.

**[4:58] Speaker A:** Exactly.

**[4:59] Speaker B:** They bought the land in Emalashian.

**[5:01] Speaker A:** Yes. On behalf of Emashi.

**[5:03] Speaker B:** On behalf of Were you now the HOD at the time?

**[5:06] Speaker A:** I was the HOD.

**[5:07] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[5:08] Speaker A:** Now, how did you come to know about the land of Malashin?

**[5:13] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[5:15] Speaker A:** The former premier of Mumalanga by then who was Mr. David Mabuz,

**[5:23] Speaker B:** right? is the one that sent the letter to former MEC Madala Masugu.

**[5:32] Speaker A:** Okay. Yes.

**[5:33] Speaker B:** So, we did not know about this until the premier sent the letter to the Department of Human.

**[5:39] Speaker A:** What is the letter saying buy this house or buy this land?

**[5:43] Speaker B:** Yes, we must buy the land on behalf of Emalashini so that it can be transferred into a Malashin.

**[5:51] Speaker A:** Okay,

**[5:51] Speaker B:** we did exactly that. But we had to follow due processes.

**[5:56] Speaker A:** Okay. Hold on. How much was the land?

**[5:58] Speaker B:** The land um has got different figures.

**[6:02] Speaker A:** Okay. All right.

**[6:03] Speaker B:** Which were discussed in the court of law and the ultimate figure that stood in the court of law

**[6:12] Speaker A:** that the department had to pay for.

**[6:14] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[6:15] Speaker A:** Was 37.5 million.

**[6:18] Speaker B:** 37.5 million.

**[6:20] Speaker A:** Yes. 37.5 million. Was this the initial uh uh land land cost?

**[6:26] Speaker B:** No. What came out from the from the court was that the real owner

**[6:33] Speaker A:** was selling the land cheaper to a particular buyer.

**[6:40] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[6:41] Speaker A:** Now they had their own discussions.

**[6:43] Speaker B:** Yes. And from those discussions, what came out was that those that had the same agreement on that piece of land at Malakin,

**[6:54] Speaker A:** then after acquiring that land, they then approached the department

**[7:00] Speaker B:** and they had a figure of 38 million.

**[7:05] Speaker A:** Okay. Now the team that the department set up

**[7:09] Speaker B:** had to negotiate on behalf of the department instead of paying 38 million which the seller was asking that the department department must pay

**[7:21] Speaker A:** yes

**[7:21] Speaker B:** the department through its negotiating team

**[7:24] Speaker A:** yes

**[7:25] Speaker B:** succeeded to pay 37.5 million instead of institute of the

**[7:32] Speaker A:** so 500 less

**[7:33] Speaker B:** yes

**[7:33] Speaker A:** okay

**[7:34] Speaker B:** the 000.

**[7:35] Speaker A:** Yeah. The department saved 500,000 there.

**[7:38] Speaker B:** All right.

**[7:40] Speaker A:** Now

**[7:42] Speaker B:** from there while we were not aware I did not know

**[7:48] Speaker A:** then the case which we ended up being charged for

**[7:52] Speaker B:** right

**[7:52] Speaker A:** was that land of Imal

**[7:55] Speaker B:** the one for 37. Yes. The type um the case number is Nellbridge 2 33 stroke two stroke 2013.

**[8:09] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[8:09] Speaker B:** That is the one that we then had to deal with.

**[8:13] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[8:13] Speaker B:** Of Emma.

**[8:15] Speaker A:** That's the one that we paid 37.5.

**[8:18] Speaker B:** Oh, all right.

**[8:18] Speaker A:** Instead of 38 million.

**[8:20] Speaker B:** Okay. And that's the one that the paper work

**[8:25] Speaker A:** because there's always paper

**[8:27] Speaker B:** trade. Yes.

**[8:29] Speaker A:** If you get it, it comes from Emma.

**[8:33] Speaker B:** It goes to the office of the premier.

**[8:35] Speaker A:** Then the premier

**[8:37] Speaker B:** send a letter to the department of human settlement

**[8:41] Speaker A:** to the MEC.

**[8:42] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[8:43] Speaker A:** Who was Mr. Matala Masu

**[8:45] Speaker B:** at that time? Yes.

**[8:46] Speaker A:** Yes. Then Mr. Matalamasu as the political head of the department then sent the letter from the premier to the head of department of human segment

**[8:58] Speaker B:** that being me.

**[9:00] Speaker A:** Then the instruction of the MEC was that purchase the land on behalf of Emalashi.

**[9:07] Speaker B:** Now what we then did which I did which is procedural.

**[9:11] Speaker A:** Yes. I ran because it had to go to the supply chain management. The letter that we got from the department from the office of the premier and from the department via the MEC to the H1 was sent to the relevant chief directorate who then send it to supply chain management

**[9:35] Speaker B:** to deal with all logistics

**[9:36] Speaker A:** and payments. But before payment

**[9:40] Speaker B:** I had to set a team.

**[9:42] Speaker A:** That team which was in existent at the time

**[9:47] Speaker B:** then had to go and negotiate with the new buyers of that land and those are the ones that now were selling the land to the department.

**[9:58] Speaker A:** Okay. The departmental officials succeeded to then persuade the the sellers to say we will not be able to pay 38 million but we can pay 20 37 million. That's how it it ended. That is now

**[10:16] Speaker B:** the case one now.

**[10:17] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[10:17] Speaker B:** The land number one.

**[10:18] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[10:19] Speaker B:** All right. The land number two

**[10:20] Speaker A:** is the one at Melo.

**[10:23] Speaker B:** Okay. So there were two two properties

**[10:24] Speaker A:** two pieces of land. Yes. The one

**[10:26] Speaker B:** also a farm also in MO. Now also in that one

**[10:30] Speaker A:** so now the department is buying for municipality.

**[10:36] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[10:36] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[10:37] Speaker B:** How the municipality in MLO through a resolution

**[10:42] Speaker A:** right

**[10:44] Speaker B:** made a request to the department of human settlement

**[10:47] Speaker A:** and that they have identified a piece of land

**[10:50] Speaker B:** where they want to develop

**[10:52] Speaker A:** but that piece of land belongs to a public owner. Okay.

**[10:58] Speaker B:** And then they said department because you have got a program of phase in where you have got to build houses for people.

**[11:08] Speaker A:** Mhm.

**[11:09] Speaker B:** We request that you say you buy this land for us but we've got valuers.

**[11:16] Speaker A:** Okay. They evaluate the land.

**[11:17] Speaker B:** Exactly. Then we also as a department sent our own valuers to go and valuate.

**[11:23] Speaker A:** They came with different figures.

**[11:25] Speaker B:** Okay. Then we opted for the lesser figure. The lesser figure was 82 million.

**[11:34] Speaker A:** 82 million.

**[11:35] Speaker B:** 82 million.

**[11:36] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[11:37] Speaker B:** Now, we then said me and H the the um CFO after

**[11:45] Speaker A:** we had a discussion.

**[11:46] Speaker B:** Mhm.

**[11:47] Speaker A:** We said how much are we having budgeted for for pieces of land?

**[11:52] Speaker B:** Okay. We then realized that we only have got 32 million.

**[11:58] Speaker A:** So you and the CFO were you the HOD now discussing the budget?

**[12:01] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[12:02] Speaker A:** Yes. We don't have 82 million.

**[12:05] Speaker B:** We have got 32 million.

**[12:08] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[12:08] Speaker B:** We will never buy that piece of land for 82 million.

**[12:12] Speaker A:** All right.

**[12:13] Speaker B:** Then I set up a team to go and negotiate. Then the one that was leading the team is the CFO. He already knew that we only have got 32 million.

**[12:26] Speaker A:** In their discussions with the with the seller, they ultimately agreed that they will accept the 2 million.

**[12:36] Speaker B:** Sure.

**[12:37] Speaker A:** So from that we saved 50 million. So the state say was saved 50 million. So from the discussion between yourself and the and the CFO, you you save the department.

**[12:49] Speaker B:** Exactly.

**[12:49] Speaker A:** Human sentment 50 million.

**[12:51] Speaker B:** Yes. Sure.

**[12:52] Speaker A:** Exactly.

**[12:53] Speaker B:** Hopefully you got bonuses after that.

**[12:55] Speaker A:** Oh no, no doubt at all.

**[12:58] Speaker B:** So I can tell you all pieces of land

**[13:02] Speaker A:** were purchased correctly, procedurally and we follow the law to the letter. Now Dr. D I I I I get that but now I just want to find out with what you are saying and I see it on this p on the book you are talking about the saving of 50 million

**[13:19] Speaker B:** but then you were then chased there's so many things people were chasing you on the matter what was going on then people were chasing you or

**[13:30] Speaker A:** yes

**[13:30] Speaker B:** what was going on

**[13:32] Speaker A:** all right you see this book

**[13:34] Speaker B:** right

**[13:35] Speaker A:** the alaporn of

**[13:37] Speaker B:** the alaporn I like that

**[13:39] Speaker A:** it's like a Yeah.

**[13:41] Speaker B:** Yeah.

**[13:42] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[13:45] Speaker B:** I reflected on the shenanigans.

**[13:48] Speaker A:** Yeah.

**[13:48] Speaker B:** In Pumala

**[13:51] Speaker A:** and those shenanigans made me to write this this book.

**[13:57] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[13:59] Speaker A:** Is this the book you withdraw?

**[14:01] Speaker B:** No, no,

**[14:01] Speaker A:** no. It's another one.

**[14:02] Speaker B:** It was it was published in 2019.

**[14:05] Speaker A:** Okay. So, this is talking about the shin that are happening in Bumala. Okay. No one took me to court.

**[14:11] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[14:11] Speaker A:** I challenged everyone

**[14:13] Speaker B:** that if there's anyone that has got a problem with the content in the in this book,

**[14:19] Speaker A:** let them come so that we can go to court.

**[14:22] Speaker B:** Right?

**[14:22] Speaker A:** No one came

**[14:23] Speaker B:** to this day.

**[14:25] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[14:25] Speaker B:** Now I then say even this book

**[14:30] Speaker A:** I invite anyone to take me to court. M

**[14:34] Speaker B:** I'm not afraid because the content that is here is factual. It's not fabricated. Now your question is what made people to come after me? When we come back then we talk more about that right here on the stage with Kani Dub.

**[14:52] Speaker A:** The soul of BMW. Where will you find it?

**[15:06] Speaker A:** Please go and subscribe on my TV network. Follow us on all social media networks and like, share, comment right here on the state with Talani Dubet. Welcome back on the state with Talani Dub. We are with Dr. David Dub. No relations to Kellani Dub by the way. I must go through that as a claimer. Dr. You're telling us I was still asking what made you people learn now or take you to court. It's about politics.

**[15:38] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[15:38] Speaker A:** You see um there's this book by Robert Green.

**[15:44] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[15:46] Speaker A:** He outlines a number of rules there.

**[15:49] Speaker B:** One of those rules there he says he must never outshine the master.

**[15:54] Speaker A:** Okay. Because once you outshine the master,

**[15:58] Speaker B:** you'll find yourself in trouble.

**[16:00] Speaker A:** Exactly.

**[16:01] Speaker B:** You know, I did not plan to outshine anyone.

**[16:06] Speaker A:** But circumstances and also what you are and knowledge

**[16:14] Speaker B:** and experience will also make other people to have views about you about you.

**[16:21] Speaker A:** Absolutely. which those views will be contrary to what you represent

**[16:27] Speaker B:** because they will feel inferior. Some of those people will think that you are now profiling yourself and or maybe you become more better and stronger than them.

**[16:40] Speaker A:** Then they'll automatically come after you. Okay,

**[16:43] Speaker B:** that also is in that book the alapones of

**[16:47] Speaker A:** all right

**[16:48] Speaker B:** so I can say my life had been one of challenges

**[16:55] Speaker A:** okay

**[16:56] Speaker B:** and uh I don't create those problems

**[16:59] Speaker A:** they come to me

**[17:01] Speaker B:** then I must find a solution to deal with those problems

**[17:05] Speaker A:** I did exactly that

**[17:06] Speaker B:** okay

**[17:07] Speaker A:** now in response to your question as I said those are politically related matters

**[17:14] Speaker B:** in this book. If you can check chapter nine.

**[17:18] Speaker A:** Okay, let's go to chapter nine. I like that.

**[17:21] Speaker B:** Yes, chapter nine.

**[17:23] Speaker A:** You know, in this one I say it was a rough ride.

**[17:30] Speaker B:** And while it was a rough ride, I mentioned 10 important matters.

**[17:34] Speaker A:** Yes. And all those 10 important matters are those that were accumulating

**[17:43] Speaker B:** which then led to the case.

**[17:45] Speaker A:** Exactly.

**[17:46] Speaker B:** But take me to chapter like the first matter. I'm not going to go through all of them or maybe two that were you could relate people would understand.

**[17:56] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[17:58] Speaker B:** There is a matter that involves school.

**[18:02] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[18:03] Speaker B:** Who's who school now? So somebody who's at home

**[18:06] Speaker A:** Mr. Timber is a well-known businessman in Bumala.

**[18:10] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[18:13] Speaker A:** He interacts with people.

**[18:16] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[18:17] Speaker A:** He was a good friend of the former deputy premier Mr. David Mabuza

**[18:26] Speaker B:** for former premier.

**[18:28] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[18:29] Speaker B:** Oh okay. The deputy president. And then he was also still the same friend of the deputy the former deputy president Mr. David Muz who ultimately passed on.

**[18:41] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[18:41] Speaker B:** May his soul rest in peace.

**[18:43] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[18:44] Speaker B:** So Mr. Gula had relationships with him.

**[18:47] Speaker A:** All right.

**[18:49] Speaker B:** As a friend. It is known in the province that they were friends

**[18:55] Speaker A:** because there were gatherings where they could go.

**[18:57] Speaker B:** Okay. For instance, there's a an organization that Mr. Skoola opened and um apparently Mr. Mabuza sanctioned that organization.

**[19:13] Speaker A:** They called that organization Pratt.

**[19:16] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[19:17] Speaker A:** So it came out that they had a relationship.

**[19:22] Speaker B:** All right. Another example that they had a relationship was in one birthday session of Mr. Mabuza

**[19:32] Speaker A:** at Masoui school was also there.

**[19:36] Speaker B:** Oh okay.

**[19:37] Speaker A:** But there are a number of instances. So it's known that they were friends. Now one day I'm in the office as the HD. I was working there. I got a call from the then premier who was Mr. David Mabuza. He says come to me. I say where are you? Because I'm in the office. He says come to my place. Now

**[20:02] Speaker B:** this is the state house.

**[20:04] Speaker A:** No not the state house. I had to leave everything. I had to go to the farm. I asked him the

**[20:10] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[20:10] Speaker A:** Okay. I went there. When I arrived there, because we used to be very very good friends.

**[20:18] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[20:20] Speaker A:** When I arrived there, the modalities of greetings and all that were not there.

**[20:27] Speaker B:** It was a changed man, I then realized that there might be some problems here which I don't know. M

**[20:35] Speaker A:** his statement as he opened up to speak he says I'm told you don't want to pay people

**[20:42] Speaker B:** in the department

**[20:45] Speaker A:** then I was taken a back who are those people that I don't pay and for what reasons

**[20:51] Speaker B:** and then he explained to me that there is a project that belongs to timber school I don't want to pay why am I not paying am I sabotaging business people or what

**[21:05] Speaker A:** then I said no I did not sabotage anyone and I'll never sabotage anyone and I don't know about this matter of Mr. schooler because he did not come to me as an H1

**[21:16] Speaker B:** absolutely

**[21:17] Speaker A:** then he says to me go and pay you know I left that place being a dejected man

**[21:24] Speaker B:** cuz I could not understand but then I had to come to the department then I called the departmental officials, those that were literally involved.

**[21:38] Speaker A:** That is from the technical diretory.

**[21:41] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[21:42] Speaker A:** Then they sent me an official that was physically involved in that project.

**[21:47] Speaker B:** Then also from the legal director who had to ensure that all legal aspects are correct. I called them to the office. I said I'm told that we don't pay people and in particular the project that belongs to Mr. School. What is happening?

**[22:05] Speaker A:** Then the technical person says no we could not pay because we wanted information documentation proof

**[22:13] Speaker B:** we could not get it.

**[22:14] Speaker A:** Yeah.

**[22:15] Speaker B:** And as a result we cannot pay until we get the documents.

**[22:19] Speaker A:** We had been asking him to bring the documents he could not. He could say bring but he could not. M m.

**[22:26] Speaker B:** So we are still waiting for that. Then I asked the legal person.

**[22:31] Speaker A:** What is the legal issue here?

**[22:34] Speaker B:** Yeah.

**[22:34] Speaker A:** Then they told me that we cannot pay if there's no contract and the technical division is asking for information so that we can get the information then we can compile a contract. So until then we cannot. So what what what what so as you got you gathering your team you find that this is not done and then obviously you have to write it to somebody

**[22:58] Speaker B:** to say listen this is what we are finding out

**[23:01] Speaker A:** you are told to pay these people but these are not followed

**[23:05] Speaker B:** yes then I then said legal let's draft a letter draft a letter and bring it so that we indicate all the things that we need from Mr. school.

**[23:16] Speaker A:** We wrote everything. Then we sent the letter.

**[23:20] Speaker B:** I also called the then premier at a time when I arrived at No,

**[23:26] Speaker A:** there is there's a reason why Mr. School was not paid. The department had been asking for information which Mr. Skoola did not bring. M

**[23:35] Speaker B:** until we get that information

**[23:39] Speaker A:** we will not pay

**[23:40] Speaker B:** because we cannot pay something that we don't have document documentation

**[23:47] Speaker A:** for that project because we need to account properly. So as a result until Mr. Scooter gives us the information that is is needed we cannot pay.

**[23:58] Speaker B:** So that's how the case started. Now

**[24:00] Speaker A:** the case has got other issues that started

**[24:03] Speaker B:** but then this is a matter

**[24:06] Speaker A:** I write about it. So from those 10 issues

**[24:09] Speaker B:** Yeah.

**[24:10] Speaker A:** that made it is a culmination

**[24:14] Speaker B:** to come to the case now.

**[24:15] Speaker A:** Yeah.

**[24:16] Speaker B:** And then there's another one.

**[24:18] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[24:19] Speaker B:** Um we had a director general.

**[24:22] Speaker A:** Yes. Who was the director general at the time?

**[24:24] Speaker B:** It was Dr. Nam Keys.

**[24:27] Speaker A:** Oh Dr. Yes. I remember. I remember.

**[24:29] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[24:31] Speaker A:** Um she hardly had two months in the in the province in one strat plan session

**[24:39] Speaker B:** right

**[24:39] Speaker A:** at Sabi. Then um she wanted reports from people. They were giving reports then HOD's now.

**[24:48] Speaker B:** Yes. It was my turn.

**[24:50] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[24:51] Speaker B:** To present the report. When she started to speak, she said the HOD from a human settlement that being me

**[25:01] Speaker A:** is being misled by the departmental officials,

**[25:04] Speaker B:** right?

**[25:05] Speaker A:** And they give wrong information.

**[25:08] Speaker B:** Then I said when I had to respond that it cannot be true because you only have got hardly two months in the province who told you that the departmental officials are misleading the HOT. I can assure you the H is not being misled because every information that comes is being verified correctly.

**[25:29] Speaker A:** What did they do? What did they say now to you after you you stood up?

**[25:32] Speaker B:** You know in that session it was tense had strat plan

**[25:38] Speaker A:** for officials.

**[25:40] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[25:42] Speaker A:** Then um they said I must apologize.

**[25:46] Speaker B:** I did not. Around 5:00 on that same day, the then premier, Mr. David Mabuza

**[25:55] Speaker A:** called me. He said, "You have disregarded the director general. I want you to apologize outright."

**[26:05] Speaker B:** Yeah.

**[26:06] Speaker A:** I said, "I cannot apologize for something that I did not do wrong."

**[26:10] Speaker B:** What is it that I've done wrong?

**[26:13] Speaker A:** He continued to say, "I undermined the director general." I said, "I did not." M

**[26:18] Speaker B:** and as a result I will not apologize. Then he hang up the call.

**[26:22] Speaker A:** So that's another matter.

**[26:24] Speaker B:** So were you on the phone and he hang up on you?

**[26:26] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[26:27] Speaker B:** Cuz I said I did not and I will not apologize for being correct

**[26:32] Speaker A:** and while the director general was not correct.

**[26:34] Speaker B:** Absolutely.

**[26:35] Speaker A:** Yeah. So you see I'm like this if I believe in something and I have checked that it's factually correct

**[26:43] Speaker B:** I would rather die with my truth

**[26:46] Speaker A:** instead of giving in and doing the wrong things. So I am like that.

**[26:51] Speaker B:** So is this also on this matter these matters are also covered on the case

**[26:55] Speaker A:** as you say.

**[26:56] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[26:57] Speaker B:** But then let me also say that

**[27:02] Speaker A:** in one instant he called me Mr. Abuzza to the state house.

**[27:07] Speaker B:** Yes,

**[27:08] Speaker A:** we were discussing in that in our presence was Mr. Andre Kam.

**[27:13] Speaker B:** Okay, I remember the name.

**[27:15] Speaker A:** Yes. When I arrived there, they started to throw me with allegations.

**[27:22] Speaker B:** And then they said actually that's Mr. Muza that I must resign as a deputy chairperson of the province because I was the deputy chairperson. At that time you were the deputy of him now.

**[27:36] Speaker A:** Yeah, I was the deputy chairperson of the province

**[27:40] Speaker B:** in thec

**[27:42] Speaker A:** I was also the deputy h speaker of Malang

**[27:46] Speaker B:** at the legislature.

**[27:48] Speaker A:** Yeah.

**[27:48] Speaker B:** Now he says I must resign as the deputy chairperson

**[27:54] Speaker A:** because him and Mr. Kamet had their own arrangement.

**[27:59] Speaker B:** So the deal was that if I resign Mr. becomes the deputy chairperson.

**[28:06] Speaker A:** I knew

**[28:06] Speaker B:** without conference just automatically.

**[28:08] Speaker A:** Yeah, I knew about that.

**[28:09] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[28:11] Speaker A:** Then I said I am not going to resign.

**[28:14] Speaker B:** He became very furious. You know he's used to when he speaks people listen.

**[28:20] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[28:20] Speaker B:** So I don't when I know I'm correct

**[28:24] Speaker A:** and I knew I was correct. I said I will not resign. I will only go to conference and then complete my term.

**[28:34] Speaker B:** Absolutely. Yeah.

**[28:35] Speaker A:** Before that I will never resign because there's nothing wrong that I am doing to the ANC

**[28:40] Speaker B:** and I'm not there's nothing wrong that I've done even in the department and also in the legislature

**[28:47] Speaker A:** as a result I will not resign. He became furious. Then he started to call me names and all that. We were done. We lost it. Me and him.

**[28:59] Speaker B:** So this is where it really broke off. This is what broke the camera.

**[29:03] Speaker A:** Exactly. Between the two of you.

**[29:04] Speaker B:** Yes. Then he said to me, "He is going to destroy me." Those were the words that hit me. That how can this man say he's going to destroy me?

**[29:17] Speaker A:** Then I asked actually the the railways that used which I wrote about in this book. In this book? Yes.

**[29:24] Speaker B:** In this one, the alapoons. I wrote about it here.

**[29:28] Speaker A:** And I also write about it in that in that book.

**[29:31] Speaker B:** He said,

**[29:36] Speaker B:** "Yeah, but then I said, you see, you cannot tell me that you must say yes."

**[29:48] Speaker A:** So then when I was ready to say no, no, no. M I said I asked him what are you saying?

**[29:58] Speaker B:** Then he says no not physically I'll destroy you.

**[30:04] Speaker A:** Those words were harsh.

**[30:05] Speaker B:** Very harsh. Yeah.

**[30:06] Speaker A:** Yeah. I left that place state house. I left.

**[30:11] Speaker B:** So now

**[30:11] Speaker A:** then on that same day

**[30:14] Speaker B:** apparently he sent the late mama letter to look for me.

**[30:20] Speaker A:** Yes. And then also another member who was in the legislature, Joan Mukacho.

**[30:29] Speaker B:** Yes. Yes.

**[30:30] Speaker A:** To also look for me because he knew that I was close to those people.

**[30:34] Speaker B:** Absolutely.

**[30:34] Speaker A:** They all looked for me. They could not find me.

**[30:37] Speaker B:** What Joan Kacha did was to call some of my friends to ask where is Dub

**[30:43] Speaker A:** because we cannot find him. Yeah. They told him that they don't know where I was. cuz I went to somewhere to sit down to reflect that this man said he's going to destroy me.

**[30:57] Speaker B:** You know once he says he's going to do something his words follow action his actions.

**[31:03] Speaker A:** Absolutely.

**[31:04] Speaker B:** He does that.

**[31:05] Speaker A:** So you you wanted to find out whether

**[31:07] Speaker B:** how do you deal with this thing now? It's a it's a threat.

**[31:11] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[31:11] Speaker B:** Okay. So how do you deal with it? Yeah.

**[31:13] Speaker A:** I had to be cautious in whatever I do. M

**[31:18] Speaker B:** I limited my movements,

**[31:20] Speaker A:** your traveling,

**[31:21] Speaker B:** my interactions with him. The last time I spoke to him over the phone was in 2014.

**[31:30] Speaker A:** Yo,

**[31:30] Speaker B:** 2014 when he said to me, he called me that I am sabotaging or I was sabotaging the Gangala region regional conference that took place

**[31:45] Speaker A:** as a deputy now. Yeah, that took place at MLO.

**[31:49] Speaker B:** Mind you, I was a deployee that was running the session on behalf of the province

**[31:55] Speaker A:** in that regional conference.

**[31:58] Speaker B:** Now I asked him why are you saying I have sabotaged

**[32:03] Speaker A:** the conference because I did not

**[32:06] Speaker B:** who told you? He mentioned two names

**[32:09] Speaker A:** and those two people were in the youth league as the chairperson of the youth league then

**[32:14] Speaker B:** and the secretary of the youth league. I also have them in there

**[32:18] Speaker A:** in the book.

**[32:19] Speaker B:** Yes. I said I did not.

**[32:21] Speaker A:** You see as a result those things that were accumulating were matters that were affecting me personally.

**[32:32] Speaker B:** But what then triggered this case that I had to go through?

**[32:36] Speaker A:** Yes. Is that what I want to get to to say how how does this link now to the case?

**[32:41] Speaker B:** Yeah. In 2012,

**[32:45] Speaker A:** the hawks came to the department

**[32:49] Speaker B:** in the provincial department.

**[32:50] Speaker A:** Yes. In the department of human settlement.

**[32:52] Speaker B:** Yo,

**[32:53] Speaker A:** they came 2012.

**[32:55] Speaker B:** Then they had a a a a warrant of seizure to to search everything. They took computers and gadgets of people. So the movie that we are seeing today with Abui and the guys had happened in Bumalang.

**[33:11] Speaker A:** It had been happening in Bumalang.

**[33:14] Speaker B:** Now that was the beginning

**[33:18] Speaker A:** of my ordeal.

**[33:20] Speaker B:** This is back in 2012.

**[33:21] Speaker A:** 2012.

**[33:22] Speaker B:** Sure.

**[33:23] Speaker A:** They came there. Then in 2013 I was invited by the Hawks.

**[33:32] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[33:33] Speaker A:** At Sunlam building in Alpra.

**[33:35] Speaker B:** Yeah. This is their hold of their office.

**[33:37] Speaker A:** Exactly.

**[33:37] Speaker B:** Right.

**[33:38] Speaker A:** When I arrived there, they had a series of questions that I had to respond to.

**[33:45] Speaker B:** I took those questions. I left.

**[33:49] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[33:50] Speaker B:** On the 17th of April, I then went back with my package because that was in April when

**[33:58] Speaker A:** So now you went to go and answer these questions, right?

**[34:01] Speaker B:** Yes. on the 17th of April.

**[34:03] Speaker A:** M

**[34:04] Speaker B:** I then went back to the hogs with my package having responded to all their questions.

**[34:11] Speaker A:** Every single question, every single allegation,

**[34:14] Speaker B:** okay,

**[34:14] Speaker A:** I responded to I attach even documentary proof I gave it to them. They signed off for that.

**[34:22] Speaker B:** The one that signed off for that package which were two files, my file and the one that I gave to the hawks.

**[34:29] Speaker A:** Yes. So that anything and everything that is there must not change

**[34:33] Speaker B:** please

**[34:35] Speaker A:** and every single page

**[34:36] Speaker B:** must be a signature

**[34:37] Speaker A:** exactly

**[34:37] Speaker B:** for an initial

**[34:38] Speaker A:** that's what I initiated every single one of them

**[34:42] Speaker B:** then I remained with my file I gave it to the hawks then I thought it was the end of the matter

**[34:49] Speaker A:** what happened next

**[34:50] Speaker B:** yes I'm going there

**[34:53] Speaker A:** then guys must get the book then in 20 in the same 2013 is

**[35:00] Speaker B:** Mr. Tabu Mash.

**[35:02] Speaker A:** Yeah.

**[35:03] Speaker B:** Who is in the department of human settlement who was in the supply chain management while I was at the legislature. He comes to me. I was a legislature and a deputy uh speaker.

**[35:21] Speaker A:** So you a deputy speaker and also a deputy

**[35:24] Speaker B:** chair chairperson of the province.

**[35:26] Speaker A:** Yes. He comes to me. That's Mr. Mash now

**[35:29] Speaker B:** to the legislature to my office. He says, "I've got a challenge here."

**[35:35] Speaker A:** The SIU has written a an affidavit on my behalf.

**[35:42] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[35:42] Speaker A:** Referring to him.

**[35:44] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[35:44] Speaker A:** That they wrote on his behalf.

**[35:46] Speaker B:** And they wanted him to sign so that he accept what they wrote there.

**[35:51] Speaker A:** What have they written in the in the in

**[35:54] Speaker B:** allegations against me

**[35:56] Speaker A:** against you? So, so the SIU writes a letter,

**[36:01] Speaker B:** give it to him

**[36:03] Speaker A:** to say sign here.

**[36:04] Speaker B:** Yeah.

**[36:04] Speaker A:** And in same in said doing he's incriminating you.

**[36:08] Speaker B:** Exactly.

**[36:09] Speaker A:** Wow.

**[36:09] Speaker B:** Now he says to me when he comes there they gave me this and I don't agree with this

**[36:17] Speaker A:** because that's not factually correct.

**[36:19] Speaker B:** Yeah.

**[36:20] Speaker A:** What do I do? I then said it was simple. I said you know the truth. Just do what you think is truthful. I am not going to advise you to sign or not to sign. Use your conscience. Then he said thank you. He went back. He never signed that.

**[36:42] Speaker B:** What happened to to that?

**[36:44] Speaker A:** It fell off. Then

**[36:47] Speaker B:** sure

**[36:48] Speaker A:** that is 2013. M

**[36:50] Speaker B:** that's when I got the letter or the allegations from the or

**[36:56] Speaker A:** so the case now started. Now when you look at um the case that I'm talking about

**[37:05] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[37:06] Speaker A:** Um there's a the case number there.

**[37:10] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[37:11] Speaker A:** The case number it's in the book.

**[37:13] Speaker B:** All right.

**[37:13] Speaker A:** Is the one.

**[37:14] Speaker B:** Is this the case number? No. No. No. That one is I'll explain that one.

**[37:19] Speaker A:** Okay. is

**[37:20] Speaker B:** the one now that

**[37:22] Speaker A:** culminated into our arrest.

**[37:25] Speaker B:** But that's where it started

**[37:27] Speaker A:** 2013. It's called case nitrate case number two 33 stroke 2

**[37:38] Speaker B:** stroke 2013.

**[37:41] Speaker A:** Oh yes. Okay.

**[37:42] Speaker B:** Day that's how this matter started.

**[37:46] Speaker B:** I did not know about this matter. So there's a journalist that opened the case, but he opened the case, but someone the the story and ran with it. And that person is the one that I call the hidden owner

**[38:07] Speaker A:** of the case

**[38:08] Speaker B:** of the case.

**[38:09] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[38:09] Speaker B:** And it is there the hidden owner of the case. Um,

**[38:14] Speaker A:** so the hidden owner of the case, actual fact gets the journalist.

**[38:19] Speaker B:** No, the journalist goes and opens the case.

**[38:21] Speaker A:** Yeah. But they were not friends.

**[38:24] Speaker B:** They're not friends.

**[38:25] Speaker A:** No.

**[38:25] Speaker B:** So he the minute the journalist open the case, then the hidden owner of this case still the case now against you now.

**[38:33] Speaker A:** Yeah. now because in this case all the people

**[38:41] Speaker B:** that this person wanted to deal with were there.

**[38:45] Speaker A:** Sure.

**[38:45] Speaker B:** Now that's how then the shenanigans started. That's where we all because all the people that this person did not like now

**[38:55] Speaker A:** were in one function.

**[38:56] Speaker B:** Yeah. In one pool.

**[38:58] Speaker A:** So they were dealing we were dealing with a a proper case

**[39:01] Speaker B:** but there's somebody behind the case.

**[39:02] Speaker A:** Yes. Now the person has an opportunity to deal with all of us.

**[39:07] Speaker B:** So all of you are under one charge.

**[39:09] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[39:10] Speaker B:** When we come back we talk more right here on the stage with

**[39:15] Speaker A:** the soul of BMW. Where will you find it?

**[39:29] Speaker A:** Please go and subscribe to my TV network. Follow us on all social media networks and like, share, comment right here on the state with Galani Dubet. Welcome back on the state with Galani Dub. We are with Dr. David Dub. He's he's just unpacking what is on this book guys. If you want to go, go out and read it. It's available. I'll tell I'll ask him where is it available at the end. But tell me you were still explaining about the now you here's a list of people who are have are being charged they all in one sector they are all in one faction per say

**[40:07] Speaker B:** in one basket

**[40:07] Speaker A:** in one basket so now you can almost deal with these people who is one person that is in this basket with you

**[40:16] Speaker B:** well um you have got advocate bongo

**[40:19] Speaker A:** okay

**[40:19] Speaker B:** that was there and also others those that were linked to the to this person before.

**[40:26] Speaker A:** Okay.

**[40:26] Speaker B:** Now they had their own fallout.

**[40:29] Speaker A:** I see on the book you also mentioned Panoni.

**[40:32] Speaker B:** Yes. Petony is the one who was leading the negotiating team that went to negotiate on behalf of the department in that pieces of that piece of

**[40:44] Speaker A:** buying of the land.

**[40:45] Speaker B:** Yeah. So we bear witness now to what really transpired in terms of the management performance act.

**[40:52] Speaker A:** Yes. because they had to deal with those matters procedurally.

**[40:55] Speaker B:** Okay. Yes.

**[40:56] Speaker A:** But then I realized when I arrived when we had the court case now running when he was a witness,

**[41:04] Speaker B:** I did not know that he was going to be a witness. Actually, he's the one that called me um two weeks. Actually, it was not long after I was arrested. It was in November 2020. He calls me says I want to talk to you. Can you come to me?

**[41:24] Speaker A:** I then went to his place. When I arrived there, there were only two issues that he wanted us to discuss.

**[41:32] Speaker B:** The first one was that because of this case, he is not involved and he's not going to testify.

**[41:43] Speaker A:** Okay. I did not know about that. Then he gave me he showed me a message that the prosecutor um advocate Henry Numalo

**[41:58] Speaker B:** yes

**[41:59] Speaker A:** wrote to him he showed me that's what Mr. showed me

**[42:05] Speaker B:** he explained there. So he said I'm not going to testify but already I realized that there's a problem here. The other matter that he wanted us to discuss was about the forthcoming conference at a time were supposed to fill two positions where the then chairperson Mr. David Mabuza

**[42:30] Speaker A:** had to leave the position of chenhip because he was now elected into the national executive

**[42:37] Speaker B:** executive. Okay.

**[42:38] Speaker A:** As a deputy president of the

**[42:41] Speaker B:** So he's talking to you as what now?

**[42:44] Speaker A:** He wanted he wanted us to to form a strong team

**[42:48] Speaker B:** in alliance now.

**[42:49] Speaker A:** Yes. To contest.

**[42:50] Speaker B:** You were contesting 2012 or 2017.

**[42:53] Speaker A:** That is 2020.

**[42:55] Speaker B:** 2020 now.

**[42:56] Speaker A:** Yeah. He wanted us to because there was a special conference that was supposed to come.

**[43:01] Speaker B:** I remember that special conference was needed. Yes.

**[43:04] Speaker A:** Now you know in that session

**[43:08] Speaker B:** Mr. Yuni said something that opened my eyes.

**[43:15] Speaker A:** You see when Mr. speaks Peter

**[43:18] Speaker B:** must listen attentively.

**[43:19] Speaker A:** I know. I know. He speaks in parables

**[43:24] Speaker B:** and when he speaks like that he is helping you about something or he's saying I'll be alert.

**[43:32] Speaker A:** A good listener will get something out of what he's saying. That's when I realized that there's a problem here.

**[43:41] Speaker B:** Actually he opened my eyes to say oh there's something that really really this case is politically motivated. Yeah. Yeah.

**[43:51] Speaker A:** That's how I got it. 2021 2022. Here comes a policeman uh Moa.

**[44:03] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[44:04] Speaker A:** He says this case is politically motivated.

**[44:08] Speaker B:** Confirming what I suspected. A policeman, the lead investigator. Is he saying it in court or is he

**[44:16] Speaker A:** he told he he he spoke about that in front of my lawyer after we were from the court.

**[44:24] Speaker B:** So with your representative right here and he says this

**[44:27] Speaker A:** yeah that this case is politically motivated. M

**[44:33] Speaker B:** then he explains I said oh okay then as I want to continue on this meta politically motivated

**[44:43] Speaker A:** which then led to this title in 2023

**[44:49] Speaker B:** in the court when this lead in lead investigator Vincent Mumer Colonel Vincent Mumer M

**[45:01] Speaker A:** when he was in that stand witnessing on behalf of the state, my two lawyers asked him,

**[45:09] Speaker B:** they put it to him.

**[45:10] Speaker A:** Yeah. That this case is politically motivated. He said no.

**[45:15] Speaker B:** How that was the first one was the lawyer of Mr. Sing Advocate

**[45:22] Speaker A:** Sing. He told Simai also that this case is much politically motivated. it it came out in the court when the lawyer on behalf of advocate I don't know whether it's attorney or advocate one of the two his name his title

**[45:47] Speaker B:** his legal rep asked Vincent Mua who was the lead investigator

**[45:55] Speaker A:** that you said this case is politically motivated

**[45:58] Speaker B:** he denied it my lawyer also Ask them same question.

**[46:04] Speaker A:** Yeah. Ask the same question. Attorney to Mr. Gama.

**[46:08] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[46:08] Speaker A:** He says, "You came, you told us in my presence that you said this case is politically motivated. Can you confirm that

**[46:16] Speaker B:** he denied again now? I I I want I I get you. I get you. But I want to get to time is just farf flying. We should have this on a two-day thing." Um, you talk of the upper deck and uh, yes, what what is this? The upper deck crew and uh, who's the upper deck crew?

**[46:37] Speaker A:** Yeah, let me explain that. This case

**[46:40] Speaker B:** had anyone involved. Everyone

**[46:43] Speaker A:** had a slice. They all had their target.

**[46:46] Speaker B:** You had lawyers who were targeting

**[46:50] Speaker A:** Singayo. You had also not only sing there's also a lady who who is also in the legal fraternity.

**[47:01] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[47:03] Speaker A:** You also had got a business people.

**[47:06] Speaker B:** Sure.

**[47:07] Speaker A:** Who had an interest in that case

**[47:11] Speaker B:** because they had to deal with some of their people there.

**[47:14] Speaker A:** You don't you then have a people in the religious sector. M

**[47:23] Speaker B:** because there were two religious people there.

**[47:27] Speaker A:** Sure.

**[47:27] Speaker B:** They wanted to deal with them. So everyone was there.

**[47:30] Speaker A:** So everybody's dealing with each other.

**[47:32] Speaker B:** Then we have got journalist.

**[47:35] Speaker A:** The journalist who also had an interest because the case was opened by a journalist. How did I know that the case was opened by a journalist?

**[47:44] Speaker B:** It's this year a couple of months now. M

**[47:49] Speaker A:** um this journalist wrote in a WhatsApp group.

**[47:54] Speaker B:** Yeah.

**[47:56] Speaker A:** He then confirmed that he is the one that opened the case. I did not know. Then I said, "Ah, it's you who opened the case." Yes.

**[48:02] Speaker B:** He confirmed that it's him who who opened the case. This Nellis Bridge case number 233 stroke 2 stroke 2013.

**[48:13] Speaker A:** Yes. So you have got lawyers, you have got

**[48:18] Speaker B:** journalists, you've got business people, you have got academics because I'm an academic.

**[48:23] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[48:23] Speaker B:** There are scholars who also had an interest

**[48:26] Speaker A:** in this thing.

**[48:27] Speaker B:** In this thing,

**[48:28] Speaker A:** so all of them had to sit down and listen what's happening.

**[48:33] Speaker B:** So when upper deck

**[48:35] Speaker A:** now I'm going to that one. The lawyers

**[48:38] Speaker B:** the lawyers who were against those

**[48:40] Speaker A:** Yeah. had to sit down. They also brought that had to sessions with some of those people.

**[48:46] Speaker B:** Right

**[48:47] Speaker A:** now they were meeting either at upper deck and also they were meeting at

**[48:57] Speaker B:** garden pavilion.

**[48:58] Speaker A:** Oh okay.

**[48:59] Speaker B:** At govern pavilion

**[49:01] Speaker A:** there are pe there are people there. Yes. I don't want to say person but there are people there where they were sitting there staying there and they also playing planning there.

**[49:11] Speaker B:** Oh

**[49:12] Speaker A:** then also at upper deck that's where they used to meet some of those people the business people and all that.

**[49:18] Speaker B:** So they were meeting also planning you know in each and every uh session after the court then they could sit down and reflect and even before they were doing that. So everyone had a stake. Everyone wanted to know. Everyone wanted us in jail.

**[49:37] Speaker A:** Sure.

**[49:37] Speaker B:** That's why they were plotting. There's also a WhatsApp voicemail

**[49:43] Speaker A:** that was doing the rounds. If I still have it, I'll send it to you

**[49:48] Speaker B:** where lawyers were talking about another lawyer

**[49:52] Speaker A:** that the lawyers could they they wish that that lady could have implicated one of those accused who is a lawyer.

**[50:03] Speaker B:** Sure. Then it did not happen. She did not do that. She used the conscience. She did not accept that she must be influenced by other people to destroy a life of another one. Now all of those people, the upper deck people and also those at uh govern pavilion, they were reporting at the one that I call the hidden owner of the case

**[50:31] Speaker A:** of the case.

**[50:32] Speaker B:** So those are the people that were plotting.

**[50:34] Speaker A:** So this was the team the whole all this team is reporting to the hidden owner of the

**[50:39] Speaker B:** Yes. You see the journalist also

**[50:45] Speaker A:** were one one one particular journalist who was writing against us all along particularly me.

**[50:53] Speaker B:** But the other journalist there were those that were honest who even wrote that h this case has collapsed. Then they decided not to continue.

**[51:04] Speaker A:** But this one was the one that was busy writing. Do you think the journalist was being paid?

**[51:12] Speaker B:** You know, people say stories about that.

**[51:15] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[51:16] Speaker B:** Yeah. They talk about that.

**[51:18] Speaker A:** Um, I cannot confirm it.

**[51:21] Speaker B:** So, I will not say I know about that.

**[51:23] Speaker A:** But there's one journalist

**[51:25] Speaker B:** that I know.

**[51:28] Speaker A:** He he said to me, he was requested to write a story about me. That was in 2018.

**[51:38] Speaker B:** M

**[51:39] Speaker A:** and I write about that and uh in that I indicate the story of a journalist and the brown envelope.

**[51:48] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[51:48] Speaker A:** So the people the upper people and also the the upper and the govern pavilion people were in cahoots. Everyone wanted a stake

**[51:59] Speaker B:** on this case. I salute the people from Kualala.

**[52:04] Speaker A:** Yeah. Right. You know those people were objective reporting clearly the truth.

**[52:10] Speaker B:** So became now the the true sense in analyzing your case.

**[52:16] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[52:18] Speaker B:** So that's why even after the case came to its logical conclusion

**[52:23] Speaker A:** on the 2nd of December 2024.

**[52:28] Speaker B:** Yeah. It was only the people from SEBC particularly those that are attached to

**[52:35] Speaker A:** who were writing the truth about this case pound for pound.

**[52:41] Speaker B:** So the case as I say everyone had an interest and the interest

**[52:50] Speaker A:** most of them were in cahoots with the hidden owner of the case.

**[52:55] Speaker A:** Do we say do you say who's the hidden owner of the case of the case?

**[52:59] Speaker B:** I have I have a whole chapter

**[53:01] Speaker A:** on the hidden owner. Now

**[53:03] Speaker B:** yes I explain the tendencies of the hidden owner of the case. Those tendencies that I explain about are those that everyone knows that they know they all know

**[53:14] Speaker A:** who the hidden owner of the case is. Okay.

**[53:17] Speaker B:** At the end of the book in the last chapter.

**[53:19] Speaker A:** In the last chapter.

**[53:21] Speaker B:** Yes. I then give the name of the hidden owner.

**[53:26] Speaker A:** Ah, I see it.

**[53:28] Speaker B:** But

**[53:29] Speaker A:** you must get the book cuz it's here.

**[53:31] Speaker B:** Yes. I I I then the the description of the hidden owner.

**[53:36] Speaker A:** Yes.

**[53:38] Speaker B:** Is clearly about the person they all know. M

**[53:41] Speaker A:** then at the end of the chapter I then say you are my name's sake

**[53:48] Speaker B:** we know what's happening

**[53:51] Speaker A:** but I will forgive you and I'll allow life to go on but only the good lord will be there because revenge belongs to the almighty not us.

**[54:04] Speaker B:** Well if you say you are the namesake what does that mean? You are my namesake.

**[54:08] Speaker A:** Yeah you are my namesake. It's known. It's known. So they all know my name and then automatically they will know who's the hidden owner of the case.

**[54:17] Speaker B:** I get you.

**[54:18] Speaker A:** The one you

**[54:19] Speaker B:** the one that you

**[54:21] Speaker A:** the case and made it his.

**[54:23] Speaker B:** No.

**[54:23] Speaker A:** Because on the

**[54:28] Speaker A:** at the end of November.

**[54:30] Speaker B:** Yes. They were celebrating at govern pavilion

**[54:37] Speaker A:** right

**[54:38] Speaker B:** before before the the outdated.

**[54:41] Speaker A:** Yes. The end of November.

**[54:44] Speaker B:** Okay.

**[54:44] Speaker A:** Then on the 1st of November they were sitting somewhere now

**[54:49] Speaker B:** together with the hidden owner.

**[54:51] Speaker A:** Ah

**[54:52] Speaker B:** celebrating that we are going to jail.

**[54:56] Speaker A:** So they knew the verdict.

**[54:57] Speaker B:** That's what they believed. Yes. Right. You see the truth will always prevail.

**[55:04] Speaker A:** On Monday the 2nd of December, that's when now

**[55:09] Speaker B:** the verdict was read.

**[55:11] Speaker A:** This was in Middberg, right?

**[55:12] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[55:13] Speaker A:** In Middberg. We were all exonerated one after the other. They read the verdict.

**[55:20] Speaker B:** Clear, clear, clear. That's how we were all exonerated.

**[55:25] Speaker A:** Dr. Dr. do just in closing. So now you've you've cleared your name has been cleared all over these years.

**[55:32] Speaker B:** Are you suing the state?

**[55:33] Speaker A:** Yes. My lawyer has advised that we must take actions and they are the ones that are busy with that matter now

**[55:42] Speaker B:** because in anything that was happening I was never implicated by anything. Even all all witnesses that were from the state, no one said I have done anything wrong. To give an example, I gave an example of Mr. Mashil where something where the SIU wrote a statement statement against me that he must sign. He said no.

**[56:10] Speaker A:** In that case when the court was in session,

**[56:14] Speaker B:** yes,

**[56:15] Speaker A:** one of the witnesses of the state, Mr. Tular Mlay.

**[56:19] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[56:21] Speaker A:** Was invited here to to give a testimony there. A statement on his behalf was written. They wanted him to read. The prosecutor

**[56:33] Speaker B:** advocate said read this. Mr. Mang looked at that. He said, "I am not going to read this because it is not mine. I did not write this statement."

**[56:43] Speaker A:** You write in court.

**[56:45] Speaker B:** In court. She refused to read the statement that the prosecutor gave it to him. He said no.

**[56:52] Speaker A:** He said then they asked him do you think that what that's now my lawyer asking Meling

**[57:00] Speaker B:** is this man supposed to be here? Madang said I'm surprised that the man is here.

**[57:06] Speaker A:** Sure.

**[57:07] Speaker B:** He does not belong here. He has done everything to the to the to the letter. Even one of actually all all all um witnesses also said I'm surprised that this man is here. He's not supposed to be here. All of them.

**[57:23] Speaker A:** How much you suing the state for?

**[57:25] Speaker B:** Well, uh it's a couple of

**[57:27] Speaker A:** I'm closing.

**[57:29] Speaker B:** Oh, no. The lawyer knows that.

**[57:31] Speaker A:** The lawyer knows that.

**[57:32] Speaker B:** I suggest that

**[57:35] Speaker A:** you can engage my lawyer. If you're saying they're suing the state, are you suing the department or you suing which entities?

**[57:43] Speaker B:** You see, there's this interesting story.

**[57:46] Speaker A:** The department does not have a case against me,

**[57:49] Speaker B:** right?

**[57:50] Speaker A:** The department did not open a case against me. Actually, the the the witnesses from the department were saying there's nothing wrong about this man. It he it did everything according to the law.

**[58:02] Speaker B:** Right? Even the public service commission exonerated me that there's nothing wrong that Dub has done.

**[58:11] Speaker A:** It was only the the prosecutor whom I write about in that book who was pursuing a matter that was not there.

**[58:23] Speaker B:** Yeah. And then the other matter that I must say

**[58:29] Speaker A:** the state destroyed us my family and my kids

**[58:34] Speaker B:** but we have forgiven because we don't believe that we must bear crudes against anyone. So this book actually these two books

**[58:46] Speaker A:** while you're closing tell us where where can we find it? these two books.

**[58:50] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[58:51] Speaker A:** If you want to know anything about you must get these books.

**[58:56] Speaker B:** Um they are with me.

**[58:59] Speaker A:** So where do we get them? Where do we get if

**[59:01] Speaker B:** directly from me?

**[59:02] Speaker A:** We there's no outlets. So we must get you

**[59:05] Speaker B:** not up to so far.

**[59:06] Speaker A:** All right. Give give us the the the context because somebody might be at home and say if you don't want them they'll be calling you all the time. They want the book. I know Babazi from BMW said he wants the two books already.

**[59:18] Speaker B:** Yeah. Yeah,

**[59:19] Speaker A:** they can get them directly from me. My number it's 072

**[59:25] Speaker B:** right

**[59:26] Speaker A:** 550

**[59:28] Speaker B:** right

**[59:28] Speaker A:** 5LE8 that is me I repeat 072

**[59:35] Speaker B:** 550 5LE8 they can get this book from me so I invite anyone

**[59:46] Speaker A:** who might have problems to take me to court

**[59:49] Speaker B:** anybody who's got a problem with content that is here

**[59:52] Speaker A:** anyone also as I said I wrote two books

**[59:57] Speaker B:** the one that speaks primarily about Mr. Tamuza

**[1:00:02] Speaker A:** is the one that I withheld.

**[1:00:04] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[1:00:04] Speaker A:** But this one, the one that speaks about the case

**[1:00:08] Speaker B:** is the one that I used.

**[1:00:10] Speaker A:** Yes. Now you said to me that number that case number

**[1:00:15] Speaker B:** Yes.

**[1:00:15] Speaker A:** is the number that they were calling in the in court

**[1:00:18] Speaker B:** in the docket.

**[1:00:20] Speaker A:** Yeah.

**[1:00:20] Speaker B:** Okay. But the actual number is the one two this NLP spread

**[1:00:27] Speaker A:** case number two

**[1:00:30] Speaker B:** 33 stroke two stroke 2013 and the one in MLO so I lumped them

**[1:00:38] Speaker A:** in that one

**[1:00:39] Speaker B:** baba again Dr. Uh Du thank you so much. I think time is has just flown and you can see if you want to get this is a perfect book for you to know and understand Pumalanga. It's a politically infested one. You have to get the book and get to understand. He's given you his context and we say thank you again for coming through in the state. We're looking forward to the other book when it comes out. Please come through and also think really appreciate it for

**[1:01:05] Speaker A:** I'm the one that appreciate everything that you're doing.

**[1:01:08] Speaker B:** I really appreciate it.

**[1:01:09] Speaker A:** Thank you so much

**[1:01:09] Speaker B:** again. Thank you very much for tuning in on the state with Tani Dub. You can follow us on my TV network and also follow us on any social media network. It's the state with Tani Dub on all social media network. Remember, you've got 24 hours in a day. 8 hours we are working, 8 hours we sleep. What are you doing with your other 8 hours? Thank you for watching. Bye-bye.
