1. Introduction: Stories Told About Women
The video opens with how Muslim women and Western women alike are cast into stereotypes, posing the question of where these stories come from and what systems they serve.
According to the West, I need to be saved.From the men around me, from my religion, and from my culture.The Orient, the mysterious East.You wear nothing on your head.Muslim women have been told about us, to us, for centuries.Painting us as everything from temptresses to victims.Thank you, SIR.THANK YOU, SIR.White women staging in the cap strip tease is not actually But we're not alone in being cast in a story and jailed there.The West is no exception.Good girls and bad girls, wifies and femme fatales, come from the Madonna and the Well, if you say you haven't, you're a prude.You say you have, you're a Jackie Kennedy and Marilyn Monroe.Every single woman is one of them.Jackie, Marilyn, Jackie, Marilyn.As different as they may appear, these women are deeply interconnected.So, where did these stories come from?
And what systems do they serve?
2. Orientalism and the Colonial War on the Veil
Explores Orientalist art and Edward Said's concept, showing how European colonial powers used the veil to justify the 'civilizing mission' in Algeria and Egypt.
Today, the stereotypical image of Muslim women is the covered oppressed woman.But this wasn't always the perception.Before we were covered victims,we were undressed temptresses.These paintings were made by 18th and 19th century Europeans known as Orientalists, who imagined North Africa, South Asia, and West Asia as one exotic, mysterious Orient.Sensual and alluring, yet also backwards and dangerous.
And it wasn't just paintings.It was poems, novels, travel writing, academic study, an an body of knowledge built around a fantasy of the East that often had little to do with the reality itself.More than a century later, Palestinian scholar Edward Said would give this phenomenon a name, orientalism.This writing was an organized form of writing, like an organized science.And it seemed to me that there was a kind of repertory of images that kept coming up, you know, the sensual woman who's there to be sort of used by the man.The East is a kind of mysterious place full of secrets and monsters.Timeless Orient.As if the Orient, unlike the West, doesn't develop.It stays the same.The Orient these scholars described was a collective fantasy onto which Europe projected its desires, but also defined itself against.The Oriental is irrational, depraved, childlike, different.
Thus, the European is rational, virtuous, mature, normal.
And this difference would come to serve as the justification for the West's domination of the East.Once Europeans were no longer imagining the East, but occupying it,
desire alone was no longer enough.Empire requires some kind of mission,
and in the case of the French and the British, it was the so-called civilizing mission.The veil worn by women across the Muslim world as part of their faith or culture became evidence of civilizational failure, and the war on the veil began.
In French-occupied Algeria, authorities became obsessed with unveiling Algerian women, circulating propaganda posters like this,
and orchestrating public unveilings to symbolize the supposed emancipation of Algerian women under French colonial rule.In British-occupied Egypt, the Consul-General, Lord Cromer, said, "Egyptian women needed the British to liberate them from the oppression of Islam."At the same time, he charged school fees that made them inaccessible to young Egyptian girls.And back home in England, he founded the Men's League for Opposing Women's Suffrage.The goal was never the liberation of colonized women, but the reorganization of their societies under forms of patriarchy more compatible with empire.Over time, this new colonial fantasy of Muslim women as perpetual victims became frozen in the Western imagination.And would soon be picked up by a new white savior.
One with much less exposure to the reality.I mean, the difference between Britain and France on the one hand and the United States on the other is that Britain and France had colonies in the Orient.I mean, they had a long-standing relationship.There's a kind of a archive of actual experiences.In the case of the Americans, the experience is much less direct.It's much more based on abstractions.And nowhere would that fantasy become more powerful than after 9/11.
3. Post-9/11 Savior Narrative and Afghanistan
After 9/11, media coverage of Afghan women exploded, framing the war on terror as liberation and letting the West see itself as modern and free by contrast.
Vailed women hunched in the back of a pickup truck.I'm Laura Bush and I'm delivering this week's radio address to kick off a worldwide effort to focus on the brutality against women and children by the Al-Qaeda terrorist network and the regime it supports in Afghanistan.In the full year of 1999, there were a grand total of 37 broadcast media stories about the plight of Afghan women.September 1, 2001 to January 1, 2002, 628 story.After 9/11, the Muslim woman appeared in Western media not as fantasy, but evidence of oppression, of backwardness, that the intervention was not only justified, but necessary.This was the US's version of the civilizing mission, one that would be carried through the war on terror and arguably ever since.Let's look at what we're doing that's making women's lives in Afghanistan so difficult.If you've got, you know, this incredible poverty, you've got this militarism, you've got people with guns everywhere.
Women are deeply affected by that, and part of that is our responsibility.So, that's the part we could work on.But these stories were never only about Afghan women.They were also about what America imagined itself to be in contrast, modern, civilized, liberated.The oppressed Muslim woman became the perfect mirror through which the West could see itself as free.And more specifically, the Western woman.
4. Western Femininity: Domesticity to Consumerism
Traces Western ideals of womanhood from the cult of domesticity through consumer capitalism and sexualization, revealing self-surveillance and the internalized male gaze.
To understand this, you have to go back.
In the 18th and 19th centuries, when Orientalists were imagining women of the Orient in harems, the ideal European woman was domestic, modest, pure, maternal.She belonged to the home.A good evening, Mr.Bridgerton.Mr.Bridgerton.In Victorian England, this became known as the cult of domesticity.In France, Napoleon even legally positioned husbands as heads of the household through the Napoleonic Code.
Of course, these ideals mostly applied to middle and upper-class white women.And this is partly why the Orient fascinated Europe so much.Not because Europe was uniquely oppressive to women
or because the rest of the world was some utopia, but the climate at home shaped the fantasies Europeans projected outward.The harem wasn't a reflection of the Orient, but a reflection of Western desires, an imagined escape from the rigid moral codes of Europe itself.As capitalism evolved, so did femininity.Accentuate the good points.Ice-cold Coca-Cola.There's no waistline worry with Coke, you know.Arm yourself with a calorie counter, and you may find some surprises.By the 20th century, women are now engines of consumption.Fashion, beauty, Hollywood, entire industries emerge to sell women products and identities.The innocent scent of a cuddly clean baby that grew up very sexy.And eventually, women go from consumers to the product.Influenced by constant bombardment of media images, everyday girls are literally dying to be thin.In the '90s, it's in to be skinny.Then it's curvy in the 2010s.
Posing nearly naked, popping champagne.Botox, filler, BBL,
endless trends in what beauty is.Capitalism constantly reinvents what the ideal woman looks like because dissatisfaction is profitable.And what sits beneath it all is a constant sexualization.Once more implicit and now very explicit.Backlash immediately began flooding in due to the cover's sexual nature.Does she have a personality outside of sex?Genes are passed down from parents to offspring.My genes are blue.This is all packaged as empowerment.And liberation becomes increasingly tied to sexuality and consumption.
But the thing is once womanhood becomes something constantly performed for a watching culture it can become self-surveillance.It reminds me of a quote from the writer Margaret Atwood.She wrote male fantasy is male fantasy.It's everything run by male fantasies.Even pretending you aren't catering to male fantasies is a male fantasy.Pretending you're unseen, pretending you have a life of your own.Every day looking glass into a magic world.That you can wash your feet and comb your hair unconscious of the ever-present watcher peering through the keyhole.Peering through the keyhole in your own head if nowhere else.You are a woman with a man inside watching a woman.You are your own voyeur.And suddenly the Orientalist paintings start to feel strangely familiar.The same voyeurism.The same fascination with unveiling and undressing women.Europe was for me the first continent and place where I heard like nonsense about women's size and women age.
Where I grew up in Tunisia it's like we are always in the hamam, we are in houses, we dance together, women are naked, they are dressed, they are not dressed, they are fat, they are thin, they are old,they are young, who cares, you know?I discovered that what I always considered as the curse of Arab Muslim culture, which is this strict segregation between women and men, had also wonderful positive part, which is we didn't have a male gaze telling us how weshould look like and how Arab bodies should look like.
Femininity in the modern West has become deeply tied to consumption, visibility, and self-performance.Women are taught to experience this as empowerment.
5. The Veil as Threat and Manufactured Contrast
Shows how the veiled woman threatens consumer capitalism's logic of freedom, how shopping became a patriotic duty after 9/11, and concludes that both identities are politically manufactured. Ends with a Patreon thank-you.
And this is where the Muslim woman becomes useful again.Because if consumerism and sexualization are framed as freedom, then women who cover, who symbolize modesty or spirituality outwardly, become threatening to that system.No liking in this country.This is our home, too.What do you mean, "leave"?A bizarre anti-Islamic tirade caught
on camera after he called me a terrorist.He looked at me in my eyes and he said, "Why do you hate America?"When a mother wearing a hijab says that a woman randomly began to yell at her, she then tried to pour a liquid on her hijab and light it on fire.
The reaction to the veil is often far more emotional than rational.Because it's not just seen as cloth.It's seen as a rejection of the very logic of modern femininity and consumer capitalism.Oppression means the taking away of someone's power, right?What hijab does is it basically privatizes women's sexuality.That's essentially what it does.So, what are we saying when we say that by taking away or privatizing a woman's sexuality, we're oppressing her?
What does that mean?What does that saying about the source of a woman's power?We're saying that a woman is only strong if she's sexy in public?Yeah.Did I get it?The more oppressed the Muslim woman appears, the more liberated the Western woman appears in contrast.Which it brings us back to 9/11.In an essay called The Right to Fashion in the Age of Terrorism, the writer describes how in the aftermath of 9/11, people shopped less and felt put off by consumerism, which was not a good environment for an economythat was already approaching a recession.Suddenly, the nation began promoting a kind of {quote} right to fashion, where consumption became the right and duty of freedom-loving civilized people, and fashion as the ideal outward expression of such people.Five days after 9/11,
the nation still reeling from the shock, Vice President Dick Cheney goes on Meet the Press and says this.But I would hope the American people would in effect stick their thumb in the eye of the terrorist and and say that they've got great confidence in the country, great confidence in our economy, and not let what's happenedhere in any way throw off their normal level of economic activity.The ideal American citizen becomes someone who proves their freedom through shopping and consumer culture.So naturally, the veiled Muslim woman functions as the opposite image.She lacks individuality
and therefore freedom.But both identities are shaped by political and economic forces far larger than the women themselves.
We know it's broken when the same women who can rally for Iranian women to take off their hijab don't have a word to say about Palestinian women dying in child labor, of Palestinian mothers having their newborns decompose inincubators because of Israel.You know, that is not feminism.If you only care what a woman wears, but you don't care how she dies, then you are not a feminist.You are a propagandist.
None of this is to say that Muslim women live in a utopia with no struggles.But the quality of their lives is of no concern to the empire and its profits.The idea that Muslim women need saving comes from the need to justify imperialism abroad and confirm commodification at home.Western women are not free from social control.The forces acting upon them have simply become normalized.Fashion culture, beauty standards, sexualization, and endless self-surveillance.For women to continue buying into the system, they cannot see how it objectifies and commodifies them.They must see it as liberation.Two women manufactured against one another.One is sold as freedom, and the other as oppression.
We want to give a special thank you to our supporters on Patreon.Doing this work takes time, resources, and editorial independence.So, it wouldn't be possible without our supporters online.If you believe in what we're doing and want to be a part of this with us, you can join our Patreon.It's how we keep this going.