# Brexit's economic impact: What the data reveals | Ed Conway analysis

**Channel:** Sky News
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdQ4gEdopng
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/OdQ4gEdopng

## Chapters

- 0:01 — Project Fear Predictions vs Actual Outcomes
- 2:01 — Doppelganger Analysis and Big Brexit Numbers
- 6:28 — Trade Decline and the EU Cliff Edge
- 9:34 — Energy Prices and UK Competitiveness
- 12:52 — Migration, Revised Data, and Perspective

## Transcript

**[0:01]:** There's been so much talk, hasn't there, around this about what has been the impact of Brexit? What are the potential benefits or otherwise of getting a closer union in the future? Let's just kind of have a look through all of this, take a step back as much as we can, try and ignore the politics, just talk about the economics, talk about the data to the extent that we have it. And should we start with project fear? Do you remember project fear? You know, that moment in 2016 where we were all told that the impact of Brexit was going to be very severe on the UK economy. It's worth just doing a little bit bit of a kind of ready reckoner on you know those those predictions. So the Treasury came out do you remember this? The Treasury came out and said if the UK voted to leave the EU there would be basically an enormous recession.

**[0:41]:** The economy would go down by 3.6% GDP would go down by 3.6% just if there was a shock. If there's a severe shock you're talking about 6% a 6% dent in the economy which at the time precoid seemed you know pretty terrifying. So what actually happened? Let's have a look at GDP and where it actually ended up over the two this is the two years after voting to leave the EU. Instead of falling it grew and so it wasn't as bad. In fact, it was kind of all right in that period. Um as we'll see, you know, there's provisos to all of this stuff. But nonetheless, that was what that's a comparison with what those reports were uh kind of prognosticating. Unemployment they said was going to rise. Unemployment up by kind of 1.6 2.4% in a shock scenario. What actually happened to unemployment? It fell.

**[1:25]:** it actually fell. So, that's kind of good news there, isn't it? Uh, similar thing with house prices. You see kind of where this is heading, don't you? The the Treasury said there's going to be a house price crash. House prices going down 10%, 18%. What actually happened? House prices actually went up. They went up by 7%. It's actually since then that house prices have started uh to come down. The one area where actually the forecasts weren't that far off was what would happen to the pound. And the Treasury said, "Look, we think the pound might fall by 12%. It might be fall by 15%." What actually happened, it fell by 10%. So, not not far off on that one.

**[2:01]:** But all of these ones, massively offbeam, but here's the thing. Okay, at this stage, you're probably thinking to yourself, "Okay, well, that's that's interesting." But I've been hearing all these big numbers about the impact of Brexit. Brexit's caused a 4% fall in the economy. It's called a caused a 7% fall in the economy. Where do those come from? Well, let me show you this. Okay, so do you remember around the time of the referendum, there were various different organizations. There's Oxford Economics, Open Europe, um Economist for Brexit, um they forecast there would be a rise in UK economic growth as a result of Brexit. You can see basically every other economist out there said there was going to be a fall and you know there's some economic logic to that saying if you're imposing barriers on your nearest trading partner which is kind of Brexit to some extent represents that then you're going to have more friction and that's going to kind of be bad for economic growth.

**[2:49]:** That's the kind of economic theory anyway. Um and almost all economists said that was going to be the case. Um more recently, so that was back at the time of the referendum. More recently, there's been this big paper from the National Bureau of Economic Research in America saying that they think actually where it came out was around 7ish%. It's a big number. Big number. And the OBR, by the way, um the Office of Budget Responsibility, they say around 4%, but what they're kind of doing is they're looking at a lot of other people's forecasts and they're saying, "Okay, here's here's something that's more or less in the middle." 4%. Nonetheless, 6% 4%. They're big numbers. So, how do you get to that? How do you get from a situation where project fear says it's terrifying and actually the economy grows to a situation where you've got lots of economists saying no, the economy is weaker as a result?

**[3:34]:** Well, the answer is you use something called a doppelganger. And what a doppelganger means is basically saying here's how a bunch of other economies have done over the last few years and then you compare it to the UK. So this is economic growth in a selection of other economies that before 2016 looked a bit like the UK but after 2016 kind of started to diverge and then compare it to the UK. So you can see this happening can't you? You can see how those lines are kind of intertwined there and then all of a sudden they start to diverge and the divergence there well that is your kind of sevenish percent that is the cost of Brexit according to a lot of economists looking at this and there's there's there's a variety of people doing these kind of doppel doppelganger uh bits of research and you can do the same thing so that's economic growth the economy is

**[4:24]:** weaker than it would otherwise have been according to the research um and you can also do the same thing for investment and that's to some extent I would say and clearer for investment. Here's investment in a range of different economies. Um, and then compare it with the UK. Bring the UK on. You can see they diverge quite a lot. Although actually some of the divergence is happening before, you could argue before 2016. But here's the issue with this. Okay. So, so Doppelganger research, this line here, which is the kind of the path that we might have taken. um it assumes that you're basically kind of saying the UK economy would have been a bit more like X or Y economies. And that's tricky, isn't it? Okay, because basically if you look at economic growth in recent years, so that's the G7 and how we've done.

**[5:11]:** You can see that charts kind of similar to the last one. GDP per capita, various there's the pandemic, various different economies, Japan, Germany, France, Italy, Canada. There is an outlier here, okay? But it's not the UK. So this is actual economic growth. It's not nothing theoretical about it. It's actual economic growth and how it's done in recent years. The UK is kind of middle of the pack. It's not like we're suddenly much worse than everyone else. In fact, we're kind of a bit better than, you know, France or Italy, for instance. And there is an outlier here, but the outlier is America. And this is the issue. Think back to that doppelganger chart I was showing you a second ago. Think back to that line going up like that and the UK down there. You can kind of ignore all of these ones. A lot of that is basically because America has had such extraordinary growth in recent years.

**[6:00]:** And so whatever comparison you're making between the UK and the rest, the UK doesn't look that good as a result. If you get rid of the US from the doppelganger, then all of a sudden that you know where we might have been is not quite as high, but it is higher. And that's the key thing here. the impact of Brexit. It's hard to see how there hasn't been an economic impact. I'm going to show you a few charts on that in a second. But the big question of whether it was really kind of 6% or maybe a few% that's the interesting one. Okay.

**[6:28]:** And this kind of mostly comes back to a few kind of questions, three questions about what's going on here about this analysis uh on Brexit. Firstly, you know, was it really Brexit? Was the UK declining in various ways anyway? And here's one way of looking at it. This is showing you the amount the extent to which we've been at the top of the pack when it came to services exports around the world versus goods exports. Okay, so goods physical stuff, services ideas and you know consultancy and accountancy and stuff. And when it comes to servant services, the UK has you can see all the way back to 2005 has basically been nearly top of the pack. We're we're really good at, you know, selling our services around the world, but goods are ranking in terms of being the, you know, this is the top countries in the world for for selling goods.

**[7:15]:** So, basically, China's right at the top. The UK has gone down and down and down and down and down the rankings. And maybe there was a Brexit effect, but if you kind of take a step back and look at that chart, what do you see? You see that we're kind of in secular decline because we're making less stuff and sending it out around the world. So one argument is to say this stuff was happening anyway and you know maybe Brexit has had an impact on it but let me show you. Okay so I I think actually looking at the charts Brexit definitely has had an impact and you can see this in a few ways. So first of all this is showing you the extent to which countries around the G7 so again it's another one of those G7 charts have been rising in terms of their goods trade growth.

**[7:55]:** And up until 2016, that's the moment of the referendum, the UK was kind of I wouldn't say we're kind of like top of the pack, but we're kind of often high up there. So trade growth wasn't all that bad over that period. Physical things making stuff and sending it around the world, but look at what happened after the referendum. Look at the red line in relation kind of ignore the pandemic period, but look at where the red line is in relation to everything else. We've gone down to being essentially having the lowest growth for the production and export of stuff around the world. We're just not sending out as much stuff as we used to. And that relationship does seem to have changed since co another area. And by the way, at the time of the referendum, a lot of people were saying, you know, think of those charts we had right at the start.

**[8:41]:** There's going to be this enormous cliff edge and we're going to have, you know, terrifying economic outcomes in the future. That never quite happened, but there was definitely at least one place you can see a cliff edge, and this is showing you the extent to which the UK is sending trade out into Europe. It's the UK share of EU imports. So everything the EU is importing, here's how much of it comes from Britain. And at the moment, the end of the transition period when this stuff actually kicked in, we did suddenly have a cliff edge. And critically, that line just kept going down. Okay. So, it does seem like all of a sudden we're sending less stuff to Europe. Whereas Europe, this is the amount of stuff coming um from Europe into the UK. That's stayed pretty constant throughout because the UK kind of has basically left its kind of doors open when it comes to trade uh from Europe.

**[9:27]:** The the EU hasn't so much. Um and that's part of what you know people hope to address uh in this this summit.

**[9:34]:** Um there's a second kind of question mark which is okay, there's all this other stuff going on. For instance, you've got energy prices going up a lot. The UK has the highest power prices anywhere in the industrialized world at the moment. Look at that bar up there. And here's a way of testing whether that is really what's going on. So is the fact the UK is kind of weaker basically because we've got really expensive power. You can do it. It's a slightly complex chart, but it's kind of really useful way of testing it. This chart plots the extent to which power prices have gone up there versus the extent to which goods prices or goods exports have kind of gone down. So basically you'd expect the UK to be around there if it's all about power prices. But here's how it actually looks. Okay, so there's various different countries around the EU.

**[10:19]:** Actually the country that's had the biggest increase in power prices in recent years, that's Sweden. Okay, but where's the UK in this? the UK is there. So you can see the power prices actually they've kind of gone up in line with most other countries uh around most other kind of developed economies but the goods exports look at that there's a sharper fall in trade that that dot is lower than everyone else's a sharper fall in trade. So I find that kind of interesting. It's not just the power prices, but you know, it's a part of it, but it's not just the power prices uh that do the explanation. The third other thing that people kind of were asking themselves, okay, is this because the UK is kind of just, you know, doing more or less in line with Europe? Everyone in Europe is struggling right now.

**[11:06]:** Is the UK more or less in line with the rest of Europe? That's a useful test for, you know, whether Brexit has made a big difference here. And what you can do here is basically look at all the different sectors of the economy and the extent to which they're becoming more competitive over here. So if there if these dots each of these is a different part of the economy, you know, manufacturing, making chemicals, all of these different things. If you're in that place, that's good. You're becoming more competitive. If you're in that place, that's not so good. So how does the UK fare? Look, there's Germany at the top. France, the US, you can see that the US getting more competitive. France, certain parts of the economy getting more competitive. How about the UK? It's a slightly depressing picture, isn't it? Because you can see more of these bubbles are in negative territory than are in positive territory.

**[11:53]:** And so, you know, if you're kind of like talking about what this is, you know, there's optical equipment in here, oil and gas there, footwear. These are basically less able to compete sending their stuff out around the world. And so you do have this divergence, the UK just getting less competitive. And that particularly goes by the way in the kinds of sectors we really want to get more competitive in things things like semiconductors, advanced chemicals. If you look specifically at those sectors, the industrial strategy sectors that everyone wants to do better in Europe has actually been doing quite well. So in terms of the amount being exported around the world into Europe. So from Europe to towards Europe and then from Europe outside Europe. See those bars those exports are going up. Now look at the UK. So UK exports of important things that we think is you know going to be important in the future advanced equipment they are going down.

**[12:48]:** They're going down. And so that's a cause of concern uh as well.

**[12:52]:** So there's all of that within the economics. The one thing by the way that we haven't mentioned so far which obviously we should cover is migration because clearly with migration there was an impact. Have a look at this. This is showing you flows of net migration into the UK uh from the EU from outside the EU. That's the red line there. Outside the EU end of the transition period new migration rules come into place. Look at what happens. EU migration, net migration goes to below zero. Non-EU net migration, I mean, it goes through the roof. That's totally unprecedented. Uh, and we're only now seeing that kind of coming down sharply. There is no doubting that that was a consequence of Brexit because we suddenly had control over those that's take back control of our migration rules and then all of a sudden things shift. And of course, you know, the pandemic, post-pandemic period is is there, but nonetheless, we've never seen anything like that uh in the UK.

**[13:46]:** Two final things, okay, worth just noting. First of all, we have so remember how we started off with those lines that were going up and the UK was kind of doing quite badly with everyone else. Literally, just in the course of the last few days, we've had new data out from the government saying, "Oh, maybe our assessment of productivity, which is one way of measuring this stuff, was a little bit pessimistic." And if that's the case, so there's the US. Remember how the UK was kind of around there before? The new estimate. Look where it puts the UK. Look at that. So maybe it turns out we're not actually doing that badly. And we've yet to have that reflected in the official figures. And so all of the analyses over how much of an impact of Brexit there was, maybe they need to be revised.

**[14:32]:** So that's kind of interesting. But the final thing to note, okay, is just to take some perspective. there's been so many numbers, you know, on the impact of Brexit. What hopefully this has shown is that perhaps it's not necessarily, you know, there's definitely an impact, but it's not necessarily as big as you're hearing uh those big simple numbers, but let's just take a bit of perspective. If you look at the amount of economic growth in the economy just over the past two years, a lot of it comes from services. That's kind of the stuff, you know, brain power stuff, finance, uh and the rest of it. Retail that's there, manufacturing, a small slice. The Bank of England recently said that it thinks about a fifth of economic growth just in the last couple of years is sectors that are related to AI. Some people think it might be even bigger than that.

**[15:16]:** So how much do you think the impact of what has been talked about around this summit, all of those different measures making the UK slightly closer to Europe, allowing us to get kind of food and other items in and out more quickly, what do you think that kind of difference that makes? It makes about 0.4 four percentage points of difference to GDP which looks roughly like that. That's kind of a best case scenario of the impact of a deal at this summit. And well, you see the picture there in comparison with other parts of the economy, it's really quite small. And some economists would say, okay, that's worth it. But other people would say, look, the UK, you know, it's partly thanks to a more liberal approach on regulation on AI that the UK has strong uh AI economic growth at the moment. So you see how it's not straightforward.

**[16:07]:** There is definitely an impact and you can see it from many of those charts of Brexit, certainly on trade, certainly on kind of high-tech stuff. But was it as big as had been predicted at the start? Is it as big as some of those numbers that are bandied around? And would the impact of those measures that we're talking about at the moment make an enormous difference or would they be quite small?
