1. Introduction and Legal Disclaimers
Introduces the telehealth policy learning series and explains that the session will focus on court cases. The speaker also gives legal and financial disclaimers before beginning the main content.
Hello.Welcome to CCHP's 300 series on telehealth policy Learning series.Today we're going to talk about court cases.Now, in previous sessions I have talked about the influence of legislation or regulations and board guidelines on how telehealth policies develop.But also court cases can have an impact on what happens with telehealth policy as well.
Few disclaimers before we get started know that any information provided in today's talk is not to be regarded as legal advice.It is strictly for informational purposes.CCHP always recommends that you consult with legal counsel if you're interested in formal legal opinion.And know that if I happen to mention a company or show some type of product, CCHP has no relevant financial interest arrangement or affiliation with such an organization.
2. How Court Cases Shape Policy
Reviews the main ways telehealth policy is created through legislation, regulation, and administrative action. Then explains why court cases can influence policy beyond malpractice concerns.
So as most of you probably know, and SCCHP has gone over in previous series, the way that telehealth policy can be created, most people are probably familiar with like legislation creating it.So Congress or your state legislature passes a bill and it impacts telehealth policy.Regulation is usually the implementation of that policy, maybe by some administrating agency that has the duty to administer the policy or implement the policy, such as if Medicare legislation was passed that impacted telehealth, CMS has to like implement and they'll issue regulations.Same thing with Medicaid programs.And then there are also administrative actions.So decisions that may be agencies such as like CMS or a Medicaid program may decide to like craft telehealth policy or change it and like dictate and like how what's being reimbursed and what will be covered.And also, you know, regulatory boards, like licensing boards, so those policies can also be administrative action too.
But today we're going to focus in on court cases because court cases can also have an impact on like, what can be used in telehealth or how telehealth policy is crafted and what can happen with telehealth.
Now, most people, when they hear court cases in telehealth, they automatically think of like, malpractice.And yes, they can influence telehealth policy on some level.For example, if there are a lot of telehealth malpractice cases, which they're not so far when this is being recorded on February 2022, they can make premiums go up because perhaps carriers think that there's greater risk there, so they increase the premiums just to offset things.So yes, there could be an influence that malpractice cases have on telehealth.In some way.
But there are other cases that really impact how laws change, how regulations may be implemented or what might be implemented.And they lead to development of policies that really impact telehealth on a wide scale.
3. North Carolina Dental Board Antitrust Case
Describes the Supreme Court case involving the North Carolina Dental Board and the FTC over teeth whitening rules. The speaker explains the antitrust reasoning and the importance of oversight when board members are market participants.
Here's an example when it's the North Carolina State Board of dental examiners versus the Federal Trade Commission.This was 2015 Supreme Court case.And what happened, the background on this was the North Carolina Dental Board basically issued a rule or regulation that said that only professional licensed individuals, dentists can do teeth whitening.
My understanding of the case that there were cosmetologists who were offering in North Carolina, they were obviously not dentists.And the dental board said, no, you can't do that.That'll be illegal.The FTC said, well, wait a minute, this is you infringing on, on trade.So they filed an action.
The Dental board like tried to fight against it.And it was case that went all the way up to the Supreme Court.And the Supreme Court ruled in favor of the ftc.Basically what they were saying was this was within the FTC's power to monitor because the dental board members were market participants who were benefiting from suddenly this limitation put on the marketplace.So basically they were saying, like, the people who had like a benefit to gain from these limitations were in control of this.
And that was something that was not going to happen or could not happen, was a violation unless certain safeguards were in place.And those safeguards that they cited were like oversight over the board or its members in some way, such as, like another state administrating agency, which North Carolina did not have.
4. Teladoc Challenge to Texas Rules
Connects the North Carolina case to telehealth through Teladoc's challenge to Texas Medical Board rules requiring in-person exams. The section explains how the dispute led to legislative and regulatory changes that removed the face-to-face requirement.
Now you look at this case and go like, wow, this is way far from like telehealth.We're talking about teeth whitening.So what, how can this like, relate to like telehealth policy?
Well, in 2015, using this case, Teladoc, which is a telehealth company, went against the Texas Medical Board on antitrust case because the Texas Medical Board was issuing rules that required physicians to conduct in person physical exams before diagnosis and treatment lab.Now you look at that, that kind of eliminates a company like Teladoc who is strictly a telehealth platform.They're not conducting your person visits.And they said that the Texas Medical Board, by issuing this a requirement, they were doing what North Carolina was doing in that they were creating a favorable environment for themselves because board members were active participants in the marketplace.Now the board, Texas board members are saying, like, no, we have legislative oversight or we have oversight from like another agency.
So this board was like, so this case was going all the way through the judicial channels and the Texas Medical board lost in U.S. district Court and it was put on appeal.However, the parties kind of drew back a little bit and they said, let's see if we can work out a solution so we don't like, you know, take it on to the next level in court.And basically they came to a resolution where the state legislature like passed legislation to remove the face race requirement and the medical board revised the rule in 2017.Essentially, Teladoc won their case.This had significant this case on teeth whitening from North Carolina had a significant influence over policy in Texas related to telehealth.
This is just one way in which court cases do have significant impact on development of telehealth policy.
5. Why Court Cases Matter
Wraps up by emphasizing that court cases can shape telehealth policy in important ways. The speaker encourages viewers to monitor legal developments and directs them to CCHP for more information.
You do also need to keep your eye on court cases, not simply because of maybe malpractice concerns, but the fact that it could help shape policy down the line in some way.So hope this has been helpful to you.And this is like another bit of information you can add to your knowledge around telehealth policy and how it is created and developed.If you have more questions or you want more information around telehealth policy, please visit the CCHP [email protected] Thank you.