1. Introduction and Opening Prayer
The speaker introduces his plan to comment on Hope and Heritage Ministries' video titled 'The Godhead Controversy' and opens with prayer.
Welcome back.Today, I'm going to comment on a recent video that was put out by Hope and Heritage Ministries.The title of this video was the Godhead controversy.I found that title intriguing, so I watched the video, thought the video was was interesting, so I will make some comments.Let me just say a couple things about Hope and Heritage Ministries.So, I've watched numerous videos that they put out, and I really appreciate some of the work they do on righteousness by faith, the sanctuary.So, they put out really good information.But, this this Godhead controversy I did find intriguing just because of the title of it.Before I comment on this, before I get into some of the clips on this video, let me start with a word of prayer, and then what I will do is show you the introduction to this video, so you
know what their purpose and objective is in making this video.So, let's start with a word of prayer, and then we will go to the first clip.Father in heaven, thank you again for the opportunity to to speak for you.Give me clear thoughts, Lord.Give me clear words.Be with those who listen.Bless them in Jesus' name.Amen.
2. Defining Godhead Versus Trinity
The speaker examines the video's stated goal of avoiding sides and critiques its failure to read the three biblical verses using 'Godhead,' arguing the real controversy is over the Trinity, not divinity.
You know, there's been a lot of discussion in the Adventist Church about the Godhead.You know, I've been around in the church long enough to see this topic get really divisive really fast.Certain of the controversial aspects of the 1888 message were handled in the days of Jones and Waggoner.So, rather than debating and basically joining into a fray and picking a side and and throwing a hammer down and saying this is and then alienating the other side, they intentionally just said, "Well, let's just read what theactual Bible says.Let's just That's it.Let's just base it off that."
So, why don't we do that here?
Let's do it.So, rather than debating and basically joining into a fray and picking a side and and throwing a hammer down and saying this is and then alienating the other side.
They intentionally just said, "Well, let's just read what the actual Bible says.Let's just That's it.Let's just base it off that."
So, why don't we do that here?
So, let's uh read a quote and we're going to go around
We'll just each do a quote and go in a circle.
Let's do it.All right.So, we've got some quotes here.
So, those two short clips I showed you really what they they're trying to do here is not pick a side.They they said they don't want to pick a side and alienate the other side.Um and they want to read from the Bible like they did during the 1888 crisis on regarding the law in Galatians.So, they they showed a little Bible clip on that.Um so, but I did notice that they didn't read a lot from the Bible.They wrote They read mostly from Ellen White, which I'm okay with full inspiration of Ellen White it it is I I believe.Um but they didn't read a lot from the Bible.They certainly didn't read the three verses in the Bible that speak about the Godhead and this is a Godhead controversy.And so, when you look at this Godhead controversy, first of all, what is the definition of Godhead?
Because that's important because that's what they're discussing here.And the definition of Godhead just simply is divinity or deity.It just is God.So, God is the head.Um so, divinity or deity, there's only three verses in the Bible that really use this word.But here's one of the problems.In the Seventh-day Adventist Church, many leaders today are teaching that Godhead and Trinity are synonymous.They're the same thing.You can use them interchangeably.And for a little while, I thought that, too, till I really studied this topic out.And so, let's take a quick look at the three verses that use the word Godhead because this will be important as we go forward here.Romans 1:20.For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made even his eternal power and Godhead or divinity.
So, if we throw the word Trinity in here, it doesn't make sense because even his eternal power and Trinity, so you see here just using that the way people are being taught now Godhead and Trinity are the same,it doesn't make sense, but divinity, it does make sense when you put that that word in there.In Acts 17:29, "For as much then as we are the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold or silver or stone graven by art and man's device."Again, if you put divinity in here, that divinity or deity is not like gold or silver or stone.We we we know that, but if you throw the word Trinity in there that the Trinity is like unto gold or silver, it just doesn't make as much sense, it doesn't flow as as nicely.So, Godhead means divinity.
And especially when you get Colossians 2:9 speaking of Christ, when it says "For in him dwelleth all the fullness of the Godhead or divinity bodily."So, in Christ all divinity dwelt, it wasn't a Trinity that was inside Christ bodily, it was divinity that was inside of him.And so again, the Godhead controversy exists because many leaders in the SDA church are teaching now that Godhead means Trinity.And I did notice that these brothers never used the word Trinity, I'm sure they stayed away from that radioactive word, but unfortunately, Trinity has become part of the fundamental belief within the SDA church.So really, maybe even this video might have been better if it was titled the Trinity controversy because that's really where the the controversy lies within the SDA church now, not the Godhead because people on both sides believe Jesusis fully divine.So, it's not an issue of deity or divinity, it's really the issue of the controversy.
What I want to do now is show you a short clip where one of the brothers on on this this panel here was was talking that this is very a very controversial topic, but he'll talk about the personalityof God a little bit.Um but let me just play this clip and I'll come back and comment again.
3. Questionable Sources on Arius
The speaker critiques the panel's use of a Vatican Digital Library letter about Arius, noting Arius's original writings were destroyed and that the 'created Christ' accusation comes from his enemies.
You know, I've been around in the church long enough to see this topic get really divisive, really fast.And people get up in war.And you know, one of all topics, it's a very important topic because Sister White actually comments about the personality of God as to us everything as a people.There's There's statements that she makes about this being a very important topic.
So, you could see from that clip there that this is definitely a divisive issue within the church.Um here they don't want to pick a side, they want to read from the Bible.But But here's the thing, sometimes you do have to take a stance because the personality of God, as he read, is everything to us as a people.In the days of Nehemiah, Ezra and some of the other scribes were reading the Bible and the law to the people.But notice what it says in Nehemiah 8:8.So, they read in the book in the law of God distinctly and gave the sense and caused them to understand the reading.So, it's okay to read quotations, but sometimes the people need interpretations of this and to just read things is not going to settle a controversy because people are using Ellen White on both sides.
The Godhead or what what the three verses in the Bible weren't even read and explained.They have to be explained to people.The personality of God has been changed since the death of Ellen White in the Seventh-day Adventist Church.So, who God is has been changed.So, this is a divisive issue, but we need to read and give people the understanding of what is being read.I'm going to spend the rest of my time mostly on in the beginning of this because I'm not going to comment on all the quotations they read.I will comment on a few that they used.But, they spoke about Arius or Arius.I pronounce it A-ri-us.And Arius is a very controversial figure, but we don't have any writings of Arius because they were all destroyed.Um, but I want you to listen to this because he's going to use a letter from the Vatican online library, um, you know, digital library, which is controversial.
Why are we going to the Vatican to get stuff about Arius?Those were his enemies.But, I want you just to listen that he does question this letter that he's reading, but he reads it anyway.And what it does is really, in my my mind, kind of skews people's thinking into that Arius believed that Jesus was created, and that is not a historical fact.That's what his enemies say, but today the same accusations are being leveled against those who believe that Jesus is the truly the begotten Son of God.But, listen to these clips.
There was another error that crept in, and you know, this one's been debated, uh, quite a bit.I I took some time to track down as close as I could a letter that was communicated by Arius.Now, this letter is addressed to Eusebius of Nicomedia, prominent bishop and an important supporter of Arius.The letter is preserved by later church historians.So, I want to give a little bit of grace that, you know, maybe over time this was possibly, uh, you know, mistranslated or something.Maybe, You know, obviously it's not primary source, per se.Um so, I'm always careful in in addressing history like that.
Now, did you catch that?He said that this is questionable.It's they use a questionable library.And if you notice down at the bottom here, this is the Vatican Digital Library, one of the enemies of Arius is actually being used.So, listen again to what he says.
Yes, the letter is preserved by later church historians.So, I want to give a little bit of grace that, you know, maybe over time this was possibly you know, mistranslated or something, maybe.You know, obviously it's not primary source, per se.Um so, I'm always careful in in addressing history like that.But
So, you can see the source is questionable, and it comes from the Vatican Digital Library.Why are we using this to teach Seventh-day Adventist what Arius was teaching back then?And I'm going to get into this a little bit more.But, if you go online and you even go on AIA or you Google it, what survives of Arius's writings is limited to quotation and excerpts preserved by his theological opponents.No complete work authorized by Arius exists today, because it was burned.It was destroyed.And our knowledge of his thought depends on these fragmentary sources.So, these are probably not the sources we should be using to to determine what Arius actually taught.Now, let's make it clear.Jesus is not created, but he's begotten.But, notice again this Arius error of Christ created is highlighted here in the attempt, I think, in my opinion, people that are Trinitarian are going to say, "Oh, non-Trinitarians believe that Jesus is created like Arius."
I hear that accusation all the time.But, I'm going to show you a video clip now from Judgment Hour.And this the title of it is established by force.It's worth your watch.It's a 2-hour video, but it really gives you the history of Sunday and the Trinity.And in this video, he's going to discuss areas and give you some historical excerpts that I think are very enlightening in terms of what Arius actually taught and the controversy that was going on.Not just a short little blurb that you heard in this um video from um the Hope and Heritage Ministries.But, take a listen to this and we'll come back and discuss this some more.
4. Nicaea History and Council of Force
A clip from Judgment Hour recounts the Council of Nicaea, the homoousios controversy, and how Constantine enforced the creed by force, exiling dissenters and burning Arius's writings.
A mere four years after the seventh-day Sabbath that stood as a sign of the worship of the true God was eclipsed by the new Sunday, the God the Sabbath was a sign of suffered the same fate as theday.In 325 AD, Constantine convened the Council of Nicaea.With over 300 distinguished theologians, priests, and bishops in attendance, the heart of the discussion was focused on defining the relationship between the nature of the Father and the Son and whether or not the Son had a beginning ofexistence.Several doctrinal views hinged upon this discussion.Namely, if Jesus had a beginning, he was indeed a true son brought forth from his father through some means unknown to man.But, in the eyes of the Catholic bishops, what made Jesus divine was that he had no beginning.And they commenced accusing Arius and those who believed like him of teaching that Jesus was a created being.
Also up for discussion was how to view and understand the Father and Son relationship.Is God the Father or is God both Father and Son?Are they one being or two?All these questions hung upon the meaning of a single Greek word.However, a great trouble arose since there are two terms in Greek of historical fame.The first homoousios, meaning identical, and the second homoiousios, meaning similar or like unto, had both of them a stormy history.The spelling of these words is much alike.The difference in meaning, when applied to the Godhead, is bewildering to simple-hearted believers.Nevertheless, those who would think in terms of homoiousian, or similar, instead of homoousian, or identical, were promptly labeled as heretics and Arians by the clergy.Yet, when the Emperor Constantine, in full assembly of the Council of Nicaea, asked Hosius, the presiding bishop, what the difference was between the two terms, Hosius replied that they were both alike.
At this, all but a few bishops broke out into laughter and teased the chairman with heresy.You see, the word homoiousios, meaning similar, would have the following implications.It would mean, one, Jesus is a distinct being separate from the Father.Two, he could have a beginning in time and therefore, three, be a real son.The word homoousian, meaning identical, would imply, one, Jesus and the Father are the same being.Two, Jesus could have no beginning and therefore, three, cannot be a real ontological son.The theological differences between these views is so vast they are beyond the scope of this video.Suffice it to say the differences between them are wide enough to warrant each party of accusing the other of heresy and idolatry.The Roman clergy claimed that Christianity had found in the Greek word homoousios, in English consubstantiality, an appropriate term to express this relationship.
Then the papal party proceeded to call those who would not subscribe to this teaching Arians, while they took to themselves the title of Trinitarians.An erroneous charge was circulated that all who were called Arians believed that Christ was a created being.This stirred up the indignation of those who were not guilty of the charge.Alexander, Constantine, and the other Catholics made no distinction between the words begotten and created, and so accused Arius, who believed Jesus was begotten, with the crime of believing that Jesus was created.To them, there was no difference, and so they accused Arius of denying the divinity of Christ.The 17th century theologian, Philip van Limborch, wrote, "And yet, notwithstanding all these things, when Alexander gives an account of the principles of Arius to the bishops, he represents them in all the consequences he thought fit to draw fromthem, and charges him, that's Arius, with holding that the Son was made like every other creature absolutely out of nothing, and that therefore his nature was mutable and susceptible equally of virtue and vice, with many other insidious and
unscriptural doctrines which Arius plainly appears not to have maintained or taught."This is also confirmed by Salminius Hermias Sozomen, a 5th century historian, which wrote of Arius's true beliefs.He, Arius, declared upon oath that he held the doctrines set forth in this exposition.It was as follows."Arius and Euzoius, presbyters to Constantine, our most pious emperor and most beloved of God, according as your piety, beloved of God, commanded, O sovereign emperor, we here furnish a written statement of our own faith, and we protest beforeGod that we and all those who are with us believe what is here set forth.We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, and his Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, who was begotten from him before all ages.God the word, by whom all things were made, whether things in heaven or things on earth.He came and took upon him flesh, suffered and rose again, and ascended into heaven.
Whence he will come again to judge the quick and the dead.We believe in the Holy Ghost, in the resurrection of the body, in the life to come, in the kingdom of heaven.B.G.Wilkinson adds, "It is doubtful if many believed Christ to be a created being.Generally, those evangelical bodies who opposed the papacy, and who were branded as Arians, confessed both the divinity of Christ and that he was begotten, not created, by the Father."True to form, Constantine finally settled this dispute the way he settled his other disputes, by force.The emperor exerted all his influence toward winning unanimous acceptance, and nearly succeeded.Only two bishops stood out against it.But two other senior bishops refused to sign the anathemas against Arius and were exiled.Encyclopedia Britannica wrote, "Overawed by the emperor, the bishops, with two exceptions only, signed the creed, many of them against their inclination."
Constantine regarded the decision of Nicaea as divinely inspired.As long as he lived, no one dared openly to challenge the creed of Nicaea.In the book A History of Christianity, volume 1, Kenneth Latourette wrote, "To enforce the decisions of the Council of Nicaea, Constantine commanded, with the death penalty for disobedience, the burning of all books composed by Arius, banished Arius andhis closest supporters, and deposed from their sees Eusebius of Nicomedia and another bishop who had been active in the support of Arius."
I will leave a link in the in the description of this video to that Judgment Hour video if you're interested in watching the whole thing.
5. Daniel 7 and the Arian Powers
The speaker connects the three horns plucked up by the roots in Daniel 7 to the Arian tribes that opposed papal doctrine, especially the Trinity, citing the 1888 Bible Readings for the Home.
Now, in Daniel chapter 7, there is the prophecy of the four beasts and the little horn power.I want you to notice, we're going to discuss something here about Arian powers.The ones that followed Arius' teachings.In Daniel 7 and verse 8, there's an interesting verse.I considered the horns, the 10 horns, and behold there came up among them another little horn.Before there were three of the first horns plucked up by the roots, and behold in this horn were eyes like the eyes of a man, and a mouth speaking great things.So, this is the man of sin, the Roman Catholic papacy that arose.But, notice that three of the 10 horns were plucked up by the roots.What does this mean?Well, when the pagan Roman Empire or Imperial Rome disintegrated in 476 AD, there were about 10 divisions of the Roman Empire.
So, what you have here on the left side are the seven tribes that survived, and then on the right the three horns that were plucked up by the roots.Now, why were they plucked up by the roots?And by the way, when I go outside and pluck up a weed by the root, that weed is not coming back.It's gone.It's been totally wiped out.Doesn't mean it doesn't have brothers and sisters that pop up, but these three horns, the Heruli, the Ostrogoths, and the Vandals were plucked up.I want to show you This is a copy of Bible Readings for the Home, circle 1888 edition, page 29.And you can find this on archives.org.You can get the whole book.Now, we cannot read this.If you take a magnifying glass, I can read this.But, what I did was I took the liberty to copy and paste and then to and then to enlarge what is found on page 29 of Bible Readings for the Home.
It says, "At what time was Rome divided into 10 parts?"Between the years 351 and 483.Remember, 476 was the fall of the Roman Empire.See read See Reading Prophetic History of the World, page 17, notes following question 25."After the 10 horn had had arisen, what was seen coming up among them?"So, this again, this is Bible Readings for the Home, 1888.And so now they quote Daniel 7 and verse 8, which we just read.Read, we consider the horns a little horn comes up among them, "Before whom there were three of the first horns plucked up by the roots."Now, notice what Bible Readings for the Home said in 1888."We must then look for the development of the little horn this side of AD 483."And so that 538 is when the little horn actually arose.And so it's giving you some information, but notice, "About that time, in fact, there was a pretentious power seeking acknowledgement of its claims.
As early as the beginning of the 6th century, that would be 500 AD, the bishops of Rome had become powerful enough to exert considerable of that influence at the Imperial Court, which ere long exalted them to a stationwhere they could command the kings of the earth."So, notice they The papal power here is starting to exert itself."There was one hindrance to their supremacy, the opposition of the Arian powers to the doctrines of the Catholics, especially to that of the Trinity.""These opposing powers were rooted up, the Heruli in 493, the Vandals in 534, and the Ostrogoths in 538."And so, here we have Seventh-day Adventists in 1888, Christ was getting ready to come, that we were teaching that the three horns that were plucked up by the roots, these were Aryan powers.This is a historical fact, but they were opposing Roman Catholic doctrine, especially the doctrine of the Trinity.
So, back in 1888, the early 1900s, we were teaching this, but we can no longer teach it because the church has reversed course and now has accepted the Trinity doctrine that this power has has codified and enforced.You saw in that video, if you go back and watch that video, Judgment Hour, the two institutions that were established by force is Sunday observance and the Trinity.People would have their tongue bored if they spoke against the Trinity, and they were referred to as Aryan powers because they believed what Arius taught.Although we don't even have any of their writings.When you pluck up something by the roots, we can't even go back and see what these Aryan powers believed, but we do know that they opposed the doctrine of the Trinity, um, very, very much.
6. Ellen White on Begotten Not Created
The speaker analyzes Ellen White quotes showing Jesus was neither a son by creation nor adoption but begotten in the express image of the Father's person, then plays clips of Batchelor and Veith equating begotten with created.
Now, what I want to do now is look at some of these quotations.There were two quotations especially that the brothers, um, were reading from when they began reading, but they did comment on these, so I will come on comment on these as well to give you a little bit of education.So, in this first quotation that he had commented on, and again, I'm only going to comment the one on the quotations they commented on, not all of them, but some of them.Who can anticipate the gifts of infinite love?And then John 3:16, "For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life."God's love for the world was not manifest because he sent his son, but because he loved the world, he sent his son into the world, that divinity clothed with humanity, notice the Son of God, his divinity was clothed
with humanity, might touch humanity while divinity laid hold of infinity.The Listen carefully.Though sin had produced a gulf between man and his God, divine benevolence provided a plan to bridge that gulf.And what material did he use?A part of himself.The brightness of the Father's glory came to a world all seared and marked with the curse, and in his own divine character, in his own divine body, bridged the gulf and opened a channel of communication between God andman.So, notice who came down?The Son of God came down, who was a part of himself.In this next slide, I highlighted that part that Ellen White is saying that the Son of God was a part of the Father.Okay, wasn't the same person as the Father, but he was his only begotten son.And she goes on because they used another quote, and this is strong quote because they he was making the argument, "Adventists do not believe that Jesus is created."
Brothers and sisters, I don't know of any Adventist that believe that Jesus is created, although there are there are people that have all kinds of crazy uh teachings.However, when you look at the non-Trinitarian movement, nobody believes that Jesus is created.I never heard anybody speak that except Trinitarians are accusing, just like the opponents of Arius accused him of they that he believed that Jesus was created.But notice this quote.And she says, "A complete offering has been made.For God so loved the world."Here it is again, John 3:16, "that he gave his only begotten son."And now she describes what that means."Not a son by creation as were the angels.Angels were made from nothing, nor a son by adoption as is the forgiven sinner."We're sons by adoption and creation, by the way.We are made from nothing and adopted into the family of God.
But listen how she describes the Son of God.But a son begotten, how?In the express image of the Father's person, and in all the brightness of his majesty and glory, one equal with God in authority, dignity, and divine perfection.And then she quotes um that verse we looked at earlier, Colossians 2:9.In him dwelt all the fullness of the Godhead bodily.And so, the Son of God who was begotten, notice she's using language from Hebrews 1, and we're going to look at that in just a minute.He was begotten, how?In the express image of the Father's person, and in all the brightness of his majesty and glory.So, notice carefully Ellen White here is highlighting, he's not a son by creation, so just forget about accusing people in the non-Trinitarian movement of believing he's created, although it still happens.He's not a son by creation, not a son by adoption, but a son begotten in the express image of the Father's person.
That's a quote from Hebrews chapter 1.And by the way, in Hebrews 1, it doesn't say the Father's person, it says in God's person.So, God is a person, the Father is a person, they're the same person, the Son is a different person.God is not three persons, he's one person.Now, notice here in Hebrews 1.Let's read it.God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spake in time past unto the fathers by the prophets.So, God is speaking, but notice in verse 2, hath in these last days spoken unto us by his son.Who is his son?He was begotten in the express image of his person.He's not a son by creation, not a son by adoption, but notice whom he hath appointed heir of all things.By the way, this is inheritance language.The Son inherited everything from the Father to include his divinity.
And this is lost sight of in the Trinitarian movement.But notice, a son he appointed his son heir of all things by whom also he made the world.And notice Ellen White quoted this, who being the brightness of his glory and the express image of his person.Whose person?God.God is a singular person and the son is in his express image.So there are two persons, the Father and the Son.That is what the Bible is teaching.That is what Ellen White taught.So notice, she says he's not a son by creation, that's a verb, nor a son by adoption, that's a verb, but a son begotten.That is a a past participle, which is a verb in the express image of the Father's person.So when you say someone is begotten, the verb is beget.And so he is begotten in the express image of the Father's person.
People will teach you today that begotten doesn't mean begotten in that sense when it comes to the Son of God, it just means unique or one of a kind.Notice, Ellen White's statement is a clear reference to Hebrews 1:1-3 and contradicts the SDA church's current position on the word begotten when it refers to Christ.And the Christian world at large takes the position that begotten, when it comes to Christ, just means unique or one of a kind.And SDAs have taken this position.Matter of fact, SDAs have now taken up arms, so to speak, against the Trinit- non-Trinitarian movement by accusing them of believing that Jesus is created, just like they did in in Arius' time.Now, there's not physical persecution, but along with Sunday laws back in the 1880s, 1890, there were also blasphemy laws.You could not speak against the Trinity or you would you would be um in in trouble if you did that.
Now, what I want to do now is show you two clips to show you that even major SDA evangelists do not believe that the Son of God is begotten and they equate begotten with created even though the Bibleand even though Ellen White disagrees with that position.So, let's take a look at these two clips and I'll come back again.
7. Refuting the Begotten Equals Created Claim
The speaker rebuts the evangelists' clips, arguing that Ellen White's use of 'begotten' as a verb contradicts the church's current position and points back to Hebrews 1.
Now, some are going to parse and argue with the words.They say, "Well, Jesus was not made.He was begotten."And he came out of the Father.And they try to make a an argument with semantics, but the fact is that if there was a time when Christ Jesus did not exist, and then through some act of the Father, he was brought forth, he wascreated.That That's all you can say.You can't You know, change the words and try to say, "Well, begotten is different than being created."If he's brought forth by the Father, if he goes from being non-being to being by an act of the Father, he's created.And so, that would mean that he's a creature, and he's not the creator.That's a very important point.
This looks like a just a comment.I'm not sure if they just want you to comment back on this is to the regard of the same that question.Um early one God non- non-Trinitarian movement teaches that only begotten son means Christ was birthed or generated by the Father.Monogenes in the Greek indicates unique one and only.I guess, what are your thoughts?
It does mean unique.It does mean one and only, one of a kind.He was from eternity.There was never a time when he was not.If Jesus is not God, we are all dead in our sins.Let no one touch the divinity of Christ.Now, if we look at the anti-Trinitarian movement, I don't believe in a Catholic pantheistic trinity.I serve a personal God and there are three powers in heaven and I'm instructed in the Bible to baptize people in the name of those three powers in heaven.So I serve a personal God, one who stands outside of his creation.If anybody wants to get rid of the Holy Spirit, sooner or later they have to get rid of Jesus Christ as the self-existent eternal God and they will have to make him a created being in order to beconsistent.If you get rid of Jesus as the self-existent deity, then you will die in your sins.
That is where I draw the line.If Jesus has become a created being, then please go and become a Jehovah's Witness and don't bother this church anymore.
So in those two clips, Doug Batchelor and Walter Veith, they both made reference to the fact that created and begotten is the same thing.That contradicts what the Bible is teaching and what Ellen White is teaching.He is not a son by creation.He is a the son that has been begotten in the express image of the Father's person.So how exactly that happened, I'm not even going to begin to try to explain that.I just have to go by what the Bible says that Jesus is the true only begotten Son of God.And that is a verb.It doesn't mean unique and one of a kind.That's what the Catholic Church has spread down through the ages and people have latched onto that lie and it's out even in the SDA Bible Commentary.But notice again what Ellen White, she compares Jesus being begotten in the in the express image of the Father's person, she's alluding to Hebrews chapter 1 where he he is the brightness of his glory and the express image
of his person and in Hebrews 1 that's God.And so Jesus in the is in the express image of God.He's not in the express image of a trinity.That just makes no sense whatsoever.
8. Christ's Divinity Based on Sonship
The speaker argues from Scripture and Desire of Ages that Christ's divinity rests on His sonship, warns of the Holy Spirit smoke screen, and surveys biblical witnesses to Jesus as the Son of God.
Now notice what Ellen White says about the beginning of the great controversy.Angels were expelled from heaven because they would not work in harmony with God.They fell from their high estate because they wanted to be exalted.And notice what Satan and the evil angels are doing.This fact the fallen would obscure that Christ was the only begotten son of God.So what is going on in the earth today is a continuation of what started in heaven, the warfare over the position of the son of God and now in the Christian world and even in the Adventist church, peopledo not recognize him as the only begotten son of God.This gets even deeper.Follow this.The false trinity premise is that Jesus divinity is based on the fact that he is the I am.And there's no quarrel, no contention.When man sinned, Jesus stepped in as our redeemer.
And matter of fact, Ellen White says Jehovah is the name given to Christ.So the same name has been given to the son as to the father.He stands as our only intercessor between God and man.So he can say I am the first and the last.You know, he is Jehovah in the fact that the father has given him that name.We find it in Exodus, the angel of the Lord God told them, Jesus speaking, you know, my name is in him.My name, the father's name is in the son.So you can't separate them.There's not a single Bible verse to support that Jesus divinity is based solely on him being the I am and the great I am and having no beginning.Because notice the words of the prophet Ellen White in Desire of Ages.When Jesus was talking to Martha, notice what she says here.
To the Savior's words, "Believest thou?"Martha responded, "Yea, Lord, I believe that thou art the Christ, the Son of God, which should come into the world."And then she says, "She did not comprehend in all their significance the words spoken by Christ."But notice, "But she confessed her faith in His divinity and her confidence that He was able to perform whatever He it pleased Him to do."So, what was His divinity based on?He was the Christ, the Son of God.That is His true source of divinity.He inherited all things from the Father to include His divinity.He is a part of the Father.In the closing events, same book, Desire of Ages, "In the closing events of the crucifixion day, fresh evidence was given to the fulfillment of prophecy.And new witness born to Christ's divinity.When the darkness had lifted from the cross and the Savior's dying cry had been uttered, immediately another voice was heard saying, 'Truly this was the Son of God.'"
New witness born to His divinity.What is it?"Truly this was the Son of God."His divinity is based on His sonship.And the the the doctrine of the Trinity seeks to obscure this.Because remember, the devil is trying to obscure that Christ is the only begotten Son of God.And even John 3:16 is being changed in the SDA Bible Commentary.This is sad, brothers and sisters.So, notice though, there is a smoke screen that people that believe in the Trinity will very often bring up when you try to say that Jesus is the true begotten Son of God.The The fallen angels are obscuring it, but the first thing they try to do is change the discussion from the Son of God to the Holy Spirit and accuse you of not believing in the Holy Spirit, which isanother smoke screen, another falsehood.Non-Trinitarians believe in the Holy Spirit, but they don't believe the Trinity's version called God the Spirit.
That's not found in the Bible.So, the nature of the Holy Spirit is a mystery, but when you see people trying to change the discussion from the Son of God to the Holy Spirit, understand that's a smoke screen.That's what they use in the military to try to keep you from seeing the real issue, and the real issue, that Christ is the only begotten Son of God.And again and again, Peter said it in Matthew 16:16, "Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God."Martha said it, "I believe that thou art the Christ, the Son of God."The high priest said it when he they were examining Christ."Again, the high priest asked him and said unto him, "Art thou the Christ, the Son of the blessed?"Even the high priest knew that if you claim to be the Son of God, you are claiming to be divine.
Matthew 27:54, which we read, they they would they feared greatly saying, "Truly, this was the Son of God."And it was the centurion and they that were with him recognized him and recognized his divinity as the Son of God.In the wilderness, or before Jesus went to the wilderness, at the baptism, "This is my beloved Son in whom I am well pleased."A voice comes from heaven.That's the Father.And notice in the temptation in the wilderness, Satan knew that he was the Son of God, and Satan is seeking to obscure that he's the Son of God, but notice in Matthew 4, when the tempter came to him,he said, "If thou be the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread."And again in verse 6, he saith unto him, "If thou be the Son of God, cast thyself down."Again and again, even on the cross, they mocked and railed at him, "If thou be the son of God, come down from the cross.
Verse 43, he trusted in God, let him deliver him now if he will have him, for he said, I am the son of God.Notice the words of Jesus in John chapter 8 verses 30 through 36.Jesus said, I and my father are one.Very famous verse.Very often people will quote that verse and stop.But notice what the rest of this passage says.The Jews take up stones to stone him in verse 31.Jesus said, you know what?I've showed you many good works from my father, for which of those works are you going to stone me?Verse 33, we're not going to stone you for a good work, but notice, but for blasphemy and because that thou being a man makest thyself God.They knew he was making himself God.How was he making himself God?Jesus tells us in verse 36.Say ye of him whom the father has sanctified and sent to into the world, thou blasphemest because I said I am the son of God.
So he's claiming to be the son of God and they full well knew that the son of God was equal with God and he was the true son of God and as a result, that's where his divinity isderived from.And so, when you look at presentations such as this and I appreciate these brothers for the work that they do and I listen to their presentations on righteousness by faith, the sanctuary, the advent message, but on this where
9. Concluding Appeal and Closing Prayer
The speaker concludes that the video should have been titled 'The Trinity Controversy,' cites an Adventist historian on the founders' beliefs, restates the begotten Son theme, and closes with prayer.
they titled this the Godhead controversy, I have to disagree with that title.The title should have been the Trinity controversy because that's where the controversy is.Because non-Trinitarians and Trinitarians alike believe in the divinity of Christ.Notice what an Adventist historian said in Ministry Magazine October 1993.Most of the founders of the SDA church would not be able to join the church today if they had to subscribe to fundamental belief number two on the Trinity.That is a sad commentary by a Trinitarian who is writing in Ministry Magazine which goes out to pastors and ministers.But notice the positions within the SDA Church non-Trinitarians believe in God the Father, they believe in the Son of God who by the way is begotten not created.We we discussed that and the Holy Spirit and the Holy Spirit is the Father and Son coming in the third person.
He coming in the third person.But notice Trinitarians believe that God is a unity of three co-eternal co-equal persons.So Jesus can't possibly be be the begotten Son of God.That is being obscured brothers and sisters.Christ was never begotten prior to Bethlehem according to many Trinitarians.By the way, in the Adventist Church there's probably eight or nine different variations of the Trinity.So it's very hard to address the Trinitarian belief specifically.Um there were three co-eternal co-equal beings prior to any creation.So again, I don't know exactly if you're a Trinitarian and an SDA, not exactly sure what version of the Trinity you actually subscribe to.Can't be the Orthodox Trinity because that would be out of harmony with with with the Bible and and the writings of Ellen White.But I had to speak clearly because remember in Nehemiah 8:8 it said, "So they read in the law in the book in the law of God distinctly and gave the sense and caused them to understand the reading."
So I think there's a place to describe some of these things and to explain some of these things.That's what pastors and teachers should do.But I will tell you right now if they had taken a position on either side of this, like they said in the video, they're going to alienate.But you know what brothers and sisters, truth has to stand on its own.We don't have a popular message.It's not in harmony with many of the other Christian churches of the land.But let me speak clearly again.In Hebrews 1:1, speaking of God and speaking of the Son of God, it says he is the that Jesus, the Son of God, is the express image of his person.But, Ellen White defines and tells us how that came about.He was begotten in the express image of the Father's person.And begotten here is she's not using it as unique or one of a kind.
She's using it as a past participle.It is a verb.Beget.He was begotten in the express image of the Father's person.And and this fact, remember, the aimed fallen angels would obscure that Christ is the only begotten Son of God.And brothers and sisters, that is being obscured today.And you will very often see this smoke screen that I mentioned to you that people will start accusing you of not believing in the Holy Spirit, which is just a straw man argument.So, I leave you with this quotation from Ellen White.She quotes John 3:16.A complete offering has been made for God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son.Not a son by creation as were the angels, nor a son by adoption as is the forgiven sinner, but a son begotten in the express image of the Father's person, and in all the brightness of his majesty and
glory, one equal with God in authority, dignity, and divine perfection.In him dwelt all the fullness of the Godhead bodily, and God here had here means divinity.That's what dwelt in Christ, and he is a part of God.That's who God sent to the earth.A son begotten in his image.Let's close with prayer.Father in heaven, thank you again, Lord, for the opportunity to present this.Lord, I presented a lot of information.I pray the people that listen to this will stop, listen, and then research on their own.There's much in this presentation for meditation and prayer in Jesus name.Amen.God bless you.