Transcript

Use with ChatGPT / Claude Auto-scroll A

1. Opponent Testimony Introduction to SB1

Gary Daniels of the ACLU of Ohio introduces himself and provides opponent testimony on Senate Bill One, describing it as a confusing mix of provisions aimed at inflaming culture wars.

0:00 - 0:40
thank you chairwoman chairwoman rogner Vice chair Serena ranking member Ingram and members of the Senate higher education committee thank you for this opportunity to provide opponent testimony on Senate bill one my name is Gary Daniels I am hererepresenting the ACLU of Ohio like its predecessor last session Senate Bill 83 Senate bill one is an often confusing and contradictory mix of language and Provisions that appear to have much less to do with actual policy than itdoes to inflame culture wars which for many decades have targeted our colleges and universities with limited time I want to concentrate exclusively on the ban on all diversity initiatives and the attacks on the First Amendment rights of faculty

2. Critique of DEI Ban and Vague Definitions

Daniels argues the bill lacks any definition of diversity, equity, and inclusion, meaning scholarships, outreach, and recruitment efforts for veterans, disabled students, and underrepresented groups would all be banned. He calls on supporters to amend the bill to clarify what is acceptable versus illegal.

and instructors the ACLU of Ohio believes the most glaring problem with sb1 and its ban on so-called Dei efforts is this bill contains zero definition of diversity equity and inclusion whether by Design or oversight the end result isthe same that is with almost nothing to limit anyone or everyone's interpretation of Dei it means everything is on the table for banishment some supporters of sb1 continue to frame this as merely a ban on racial quotas butsuch quotas are already illegal have been for a long time and nowhere in s sp1 is its language limited to this concern so what exactly will the general assembly banwi passage of s sp1 here's a short non-exhaustive listOhio's universities offer scholarships to traditionally and currently Marg ized and un and or underrepresented people in communities for example scholarships exist to exclusively benefit military veterans physically disabled students and victims of human trafficking among many others but not
after passage of sp1 the same is true for any and all Outreach efforts one might think it is a positive thing for a university to look around see the demographics of their students and staff are not reflective ofsociety around them and then make efforts to diversify so they revisit and redouble their Recruitment and Retention efforts again not quotas just a recognition their past and current practices have fallen short so using just one example perhaps Theincreased recruitment efforts at Ohio high schools with largely black and brown students or rural students or first generation college students or maybe it is something as simple and effortless as including language on an application and employment paperwork readingsomething like all are encouraged to apply regardless of race sex religion National orientation or national origin sexual orientation military status or physical uh ability all of this and much more is diversity equity and inclusion in action all of
it is apparently so objectionable and distasteful it must be totally banned as is required under sb1 proponents of sb1 Fain surprise when opponents claim this bill requires widespread banss of each and every every diversity equity and inclusion effortproposal position and more they Proclaim opponents are reading too much into it but all we're doing is reading the actual bill language as cited in my written testimony but not repeated here in person but if all these banand prohibitions are not the goal of s sp1 supporters then the answer is simple amend the bill to make it abundantly clear to all involved what is acceptable versus what is illegal again a great place to start wouldbe actually defining diversity equity and inclusion for the purpose of this bill I'm sorry with the time limited I can't get to the uh the First Amendment academic freedom part I would be happy to uh certainly uh uh

3. Q&A: Academic Freedom and First Amendment

In response to Senator Ingram, Daniels explains how the bill's intellectual diversity requirements would force professors to treat all viewpoints as equal, likely causing instructors to avoid topics like slavery and the Holocaust, violating First Amendment protections for academic freedom.

expound on that in a Q&A but I want to be mindful of everybody here who's waiting patiently uh to testify on the bill thank you for that and uh thank you for your testimony are there any questions forthis witness uh Senator Ingram I do just want to ask about the through the chair just the the academic fre Freedom piece yeah uh through the chair uh uh to ranking member Ingram um so you know other peoplehave have said um the problem here today and voiced it I mean when you look at and I cite this in my testimony um you know that that campuses have to ensure the fullest degree of intellectual diversity quoteum and that they must remain committed to expressing intellectual diversity as defined in the bill um well that sort of upsets everything in the classroom uh uh um environment people have given examples of for instance we heard about
slavery the same would be true of the Jewish holoc cost of of the 20th century uh Jim Crow laws and reconstruction and post Civil War that you know people are going to feel compelled under the bill lest theiryou know bosses get the SL their funding slashed for the University uh to to treat every single instance every single lesson every single thing is voiced as equal um because you know and you know some people might sayno no again you're reading too much into it um but you know especially when the threat is the the funding get slashed for the University um you can be sure that one of two things is going to happenactually it's going to be one thing people are going to avoid those subjects all together they're not going to want to try to navigate um these icy waters um and and decide you know what is it that big
government finds acceptable to say in in class and what is it that big government says is is not acceptable so that right there the academic freedom here the First Amendment right to academic freedom um reinforced Court decision aftercourt decision you're compelling the speech of the professors and the instructors and saying this is how you must teach this this is what you must say um and at least under current case law um you know that's not

4. Q&A: Indoctrination Language Contradictions

Responding to Senator Liston, Daniels examines the bill's vague 'indoctrination' prohibition and highlights contradictions, such as supporting the Ohio Constitution while abortion is now a constitutional right in Ohio. He warns such speech restrictions can be a double-edged sword.

something that that complies with with the First Amendment rights of those instructors very good Senator Liston thank you chairwoman um and thank you for your insights uh this part I get stuck on and I'd love to hear whatyou think if from a sort of ACLU but legal perspective is the shall not see seek to indoctrinate any social political or religious point of view and we've gotten stuck on that word indoctrinate a number of times umso are you able to like I don't know what that means if there's anything within the code or within the world that has given us precedent to interpret that any differently um uh through the chair to uh SenatorLon um you know you know I can see both sides of this um I don't think for instance universities have any business of saying hey you should Vote for This candidate um because everybody that supports the other candidates
is going to be naturally upset uh we all understand that uh but to give you an example of the contradictory and confusing language in in Senate bill one um under the part you know titled controversial beliefs or policiesyou know it it it you know offers this list not limited it makes clear but it offers a list I I'm sure is meant to be helpful to say you know one of the things you can't talk aboutis abortion uh but you can voice support for the US Constitution and the Ohio Constitution well in Ohio we have a constitutional right to abortion now so which is it can universities voice support for this or are theyforbidden from voicing support of it Senate bill one is trying to have it both ways and so you know indoctrination what exactly that means to to whomever you know that can become somewhat confusing but we don't see it
as you know um something that you know when when we think of of efforts like this I think sometimes we think about um the speech we like uh that might be limited uh but you know it's it canbe a double-edged sword you know there there can be very natural reasons why you don't want public offices um you know governments local small state universities uh to be offering up uh opinions about everything under the sun uhand uh you know because it can be you know it might benefit you but you know always think about how essentially uh your worst enemy or Foe would use that as well so we've chosen not to concentrate particularlyon that but we do have I think the same concerns basically uh that you're also voicing very good thank you all right any additional questions seeing none thank you for your testimony today next up we have uh jar
Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Chief Lobbyist Gary Daniels testifies on Senate Bill 1 on Feb. 11, 2025.