1. Supreme Court Term Opens With Major Cases
The segment introduces the Supreme Court's new term and the broad range of issues on the docket. It also brings in legal contributor James Sample to discuss the biggest cases to watch.
The Supreme Court is opening its new term with some major cases.The justices will hear arguments over voting, guns, immigration, abortion, and religious freedom.Meanwhile, the court's also facing several appeals from President Trump.Let's bring in ABC News legal contributor James Sample for more on all that.So, James, what cases are cases are you watching most closely this term?
2. Climate Lawsuit Against Big Oil
James Sample explains the climate activists' case against big oil and the key legal question of whether the lawsuit can proceed. He also discusses standing and the broader issue of state and local regulation versus federal authority.
Well, today starts out with a case involving climate activists versus big oil.That is a huge case.Justice Alito has recused from it.And in the lower courts, the climate activists got the go ahead to go ahead with a lawsuit challenging on on basis of damage to the economy, damage to the environment, the the harms of big oil.If the question before the court is not whether or not the merits of the case should be decided in favor of either side so much as the question is whether or not that lawsuit can proceed.As you mentioned, this term there are already 30 cases granted, Diane.Major cases involving climate, guns, religion, and of course, the election coming up.At the moment, there are no major election cases on the docket, but we expect that they will come fast and furious with just 4 weeks remaining until election day.
The The companies in that climate case say that federal law bans state-level lawsuits like this.So, are they going to have standing to bring this?
Well, certainly so far the the states the climate cases have in found standing.I E, the states have passed these laws and brought these lawsuits.The companies are clearly harmed.The companies will have standing.The question is really whether or not states can and cities can impose national standards on oil companies for damage that you might argue should be regulated at the federal level.
3. Second Amendment Fight Over AR-15 Bans
The discussion turns to Illinois and Connecticut's bans on AR-15-style rifles and the constitutional questions behind them. Sample focuses on whether the Second Amendment protects these weapons and how the Sandy Hook context shapes the case.
The court's also set to consider Illinois and Connecticut's bans on AR-15-style rifles.Gun advocates say people have a legal right to have these.We're going to hear about the Second Amendment during this case.So, what are you watching for in those arguments?
The question is not whether or not guns are allowed at this point.The question is whether all guns, including AR-15s, are allowed.The case arises in part, as you mentioned, out of Connecticut, where Sandy Hook occurred, and where the ban that is in was in place, or would be in place if this law were to be upheld, grew out ofthe the Sandy Hook massacre.The question is really whether going to be whether or not there are five justices who believe that either AR-15s are within the scope of the second amendment, or whether states have the right to regulate AR-15s, even if theydon't have the right to regulate other guns in other contexts.
4. Immigration Cases and Detention Policy
The conversation shifts to immigration cases tied to Trump-era enforcement, including third-country deportations. It then examines whether long-term undocumented residents can be detained without bond.
There are also some major immigration cases tied to the Trump administration's enforcement.What are you watching for there?
Just in the last few weeks, we've already seen major rulings in regarding so-called third-country deportations.Scenarios where individuals are deported to countries where they have no ties whatsoever.The next big case coming down the pipe in immigration is the context of whether or not individuals who may have entered unlawfully, but have been in the United States for long periods of time, even without no criminal withouta criminal record, can be held in detention without any bond.
5. Big Picture Stakes For The Court
Sample closes by stepping back to discuss the Supreme Court's changing role and the rise of the shadow docket. He argues that the major theme of the Trump years is the scope of executive power.
When you look at the docket as a whole, are there kind of big picture stakes you see for this term?
Certainly, the big picture stakes the changing Supreme Court, I mean, the first Monday is a tradition that goes back to 1917, when the court has opened its session, but with the emergence of the shadow or emergency docket, reallymost of the major rulings from the court are now coming on this sort of truncated procedural basis, without oral argument, with limited briefing.So, these cases, there've been about 30 grants so far.The major question is really the question during the Trump years is the scope of executive power.
Interesting.All right, James Sample, thank you.