1. Introduction and Historical Premises
Speaker outlines the lecture’s focus on the painful incident in Ali’s time, offers disclaimers about level of detail, and states theological premises regarding the Sahaba and Muawiyah.
So today, inshallah, as I had promised you, we're gonna continue talking about the problematic issues that took place in the time of Ali.And today we're gonna talk about, really, there's no question about it, the single most difficult and awkward and painful incident in the entire first generation of our tradition.And as I have said many times before, but just in case somebody's only listening to this one lecture, always have to make this disclaimer.We are int, not going to go into a lot of detail.And I explained why in my previous lectures, as Allah says in the Quran, that is a generation that has gone by in the past.That's a generation that has gone.
They have to answer for what they did.You have to answer for what you do.And I also mention again that we definitely have a premise.Some would call it a bias.And that's fine.
We have a premise, and that is that we believe theologically that the Sahaba are a respected and righteous people and that none of them would intentionally do something against the interest of the Ummah.And we also believe that the Sahaba are good human beings.But this doesn't mean that they are sinless.It means that they may commit sins, but overall their good is much more than their any mistakes that they might have made.And the sins that they make, insha Allah is trivial compared to the good that they do.And as well, there are instances where you can make Ijtihad, you can figure out, try to figure out what's best, and sometimes you'll fall into mistakes.So we need to be very careful when it comes to the Sahaba and especially Muawiyah.We're gonna talk a little bit about him as well.In today's lecture.
We have a huge, if you like, dichotomy.We have two strands, even within our own Sunni Islam, that especially when it comes to the figure of Muawiyah, that some people go to one exaggeration, making his status more than it is, and others go to the other side and they criticize beyond what is acceptable.And we are inshaallah in this lecture, I will follow the middle path.And we believe that all of the Sahaba radiallahu anhumwaraduan, all of them, that includes Muawiyah.But we also believe that not all of the Sahaba are of the same level, that Sahabah have different levels amongst themselves.Like Allah says in the Quran, and.
2. Sectarian Bias and Sahaba Status Levels
Discussion of Qur’anic distinctions among Sahaba levels, Muawiyah’s late conversion status, and how Sunni and Shia historiographical lenses shape their narratives of early Islamic events.
This is explicit, not equal, are those who embraced Islam before the conquest and who fought Jihad before the Conquest.
They're not equal.Those who embraced Islam and fought.
They are a higher level from those who embraced Islam afterwards than the conquest of Mecca.And then Allah says both groups.Allah has promised Jannah to them.And Muawiya radiallahu an he definitely is of those who converted.When did he convert?
No, that is wrong.When did Muawiyah convert?
After the conquest.After the conquest of Makkah.One of the last batches of congress, as we are going to come to.And so no one ever, in our tradition of the classical history, no one ever said that Muawiya is of the elite of the Sahaba.He is of the Sahaba, but he is not of the elite of the Sahaba.The people who fought at Badr Bayat Al Ridwan, the people who were in Khandaq.No, he was not there.He was in Mecca.He embraced Islam at the very end.Another important disclaimer that unfortunately we have always had from the very beginning of our writing down of knowledge, sectarian understandings of history.
What do I mean by this?These incidents define Sunnism and Shi'.Ism.These incidents define Sunnism and Shi'.Ism.
So when a Sunni writes about these incidents, automatically they have a premise.And that premise is the Sahaba are righteous people, so they will interpret things in a certain manner.And when the Shi' I historians write about this timeframe, they automatically have a premise.And that premise is anybody who opposes Ali is not even a Muslim or a very, very, very bad Muslim.And so the whole lens of history is tainted.
And we all know, at least those of us who are involved in these things, which of the two sides is always emphasizing these points of history?Which of the two sides always brings up this period in history?Which are the two sides?The Shia side.Right.
Because for us, as I keep on saying, why don't we bring it up that much?For multiple reasons.Number one, our religion is independent of what happened in this time frame.That's the main point.What happened didn't happen.Our theology does not change Aqeed Iman in Allah.Does that change about what happened behind the Sahaba?Iman in Quran, Iman in Day of Judgment, nothing changes.Correct.Our Aqeedah is not based on what happened after the death of the Prophet.
It's history, not theology.Now as for the other group, their theology is early history.Their entire.And that's why the average Shia is 100 times more aware of these incidents than the average Sunni, because this is their religion for them.This is how they define themselves.
They know who said what, and Ali did this, and Fatima did this, and Abu Bakr did this, Umar did this.And some of it might be true, some of it exaggeration, some of his lies.And the average Sunnis, like, I don't know, I mean, that's what they know because their religion is based on the Quran, on the Sunnah.It's not based on these incidents in history.So don't be surprised to discover that the earliest books ever written about these incidents, who wrote them?
3. Abu Mihnaf Legacy in Early Historiography
Overview of Abu Mihnaf al-Lutī Ibn Yahya as the pioneering Shia historian whose works on Karbala, Siffin, and other events became foundational but are deemed fabrications in Sunni tradition.
The Shia side.Now what's going to happen when the first guy is already writing from that perspective?It's a domino effect, right?And so unfortunately, even in Sunni sources, unfortunately, sometimes we have reports that are not coming from our sources, but simply by virtue of the fact that there was nothing else.And these guys filled in the blank.
And you know, this is not an advanced class.Nonetheless, I'll give you one name that even students of knowledge of history should know.That there is one particular historian from the Shi' I side who wrote around 20 booklets.And I mentioned him when we talked about the Karbala.I mentioned him when I talked about the Karbala because he has the first booklet on Karbala ever written.
He wrote it.And all of the narrations of the Shia about Karbala go back to this one book.Every story and every.The arrow pierced and the water was deprived and so, and so died and this and that.The whole tragedy comes back to this one booklet.
The same guy, his name is Abu Mihnaf Lut IBN Yahya.You should memorize this name.And it is well known.Every single, even beginning student of Islamic history knows this name because he is the first Shia historian.He died 157.Ah, that's like similar to Ibn Ishaq.150, right?Ibn Ishaq died 150.This is even before Imam Malik's death.Abu Hanifa is around this time, right?Imam Shafi' I after this.So this is very early on.And again, what are they interested in?Our scholars are writing Seerah and Hadith in this time frame.Our scholars, Ibn Ishaq, what is he writing?The Life of the Prophet.Their scholars are not that interested in that timeframe.What are they interested in?Maktal Hussain.That's the booklet, right?
The Mawka Jamal, the Battle of the Camel.Right.These are all titles of Abu Miqhlaf Nuzhri Bin Yahi.He has these booklets and these booklets will were the first things ever written about Sifin.He wrote an entire book on Sifin.
A whole book on the Battle of Siffin.We're doing another book on Jamal, the Battle of Camel, another book on Makhtal Hussain.That's the thick booklet that he has.Another book on Maqtal Ali and whatnot.Because again, for them, that is their religion.
Now, as for.And of course, this person has been studied, you know, throughout history.Many PhDs and dissertations have been written just about this person.I have in my house a number of PhDs and dissertations just about Abu Mihnaf and about his reports and about how it impacted even Sunni history books.Now, this person, Abu Mihnaf, has zero credibility in our tradition.
Imam Al Bukhari, Daru Qudni Ibn Adi.Everybody of our tradition said this person is a well known fabricator.He's a storyteller.He just gives stories.He's not reliable.
But guess what?Most of the stories that we know of this time frame, they go back to him.Including some stories that perhaps some of you also heard, such as the details of the arbitration between Abu Musa and between Amr Ibn Al Aus, for example.That's a whole coming from Abu Mehnaf, coming straight from him, Ruth Ibn Yahya.So we have to be extra careful when it comes to these.
When it comes to these stories.Now, of course, our talk today deals with Muawiya and what happened between him and Ali.
4. Muawiyah's Rule and Early Caliphal Tensions
Covers Muawiyah’s conversion, appointment as governor of Syria under Umar and Uthman, his effective administration, and the first signs of conflict with Caliph Ali after Uthman’s death.
And as Ibn Taymiyyah clarifies that Muawiya was of the very last batch of converts, those whom the Prophet technically freed.Remember when he said, leave today, you are all free.That's the last batch of converts.That's the very last batch of converts, the tulaqa, the very last batch.And Ibn Taymiyyah writes that Muawiya was always considered a better person than his father.Who is his father?Abu Sufyan.Right.Abu Sufyan was also of this batch of tulaqa.Muawiyah, his Iman and Taqwa was better than that of Abu Sufyan.But Muawiya's older brother had even more status in the eyes of the Sahaba and the Prophet than him.And his older brother's name was Yazid.So Muawiya's son Yazid was named after his older brother.Okay?Is that clear?So Muawiya's son is named after his brother.His brother is Yazid.Then his brother dies.Then Muawiyah has a son.
Muawiyah calls him Yazid.So Yazid was the one who was appointed by Umar IBN Khattab, in fact by Abu Bakr.Sorry, even by Abu Bakr.As soon as Damascus was conquered, Abu Bakr appointed.
Well, Abu Bakr hadn't been alive at the time, but talk had already begun.Umar was the one in his era appointed Yazid.And then Yazid passes away.Natural death.And so Umar appoints Yazid's younger brother Muawiya to be the what, the governor of Damascus and Sham entire, which includes Jerusalem, basically all of Syria.
Now Muawiyah, therefore he was based in Sham essentially for the entire caliphate of Umar Al Khattab and Uthman.That's 22 years.And in those 22 years he establishes a infrastructure and a smooth line bureaucracy that no other province is able to do.And there is no question he was an effective politician.You know, some people are born to be leaders and he is definitely as well born to be a leader.
And his leadership has always been top notch in terms of managing, in terms of running what is assigned to him.And you know, all you need to see is that look, in the time of Umar and Uthman Radiallahu Anhum, how many complaints came about the governors of Kufa, about the governors of Basra even there's just a Rolodex.Everybody goes in and out.We didn't get into all those details.But I'll just tell you that every few years a major complaint the people of Kufa said and most of them are not valid complaints, right, because the people are finicky.But Muawiya never had that problem.He ruled and he was an effective ruler.There was never a major complaint against Muawiya throughout the time frame of Umar IBN Khattab and Uthman IBN Affan.Now why is this the case?Well, a number of reasons are given.
Some of the scholars say that there's no doubt that as well, one of the main reasons would be that some of the greatest of the Sahaba, they settled in Syria.So Mu' Ad IBN Jabal went to Damascus, Ubaidah Ibn Al Samid went to Damascus, Abu Darda, all of these great Sahaba, they settled in Damascus.And so because they settled in Damascus, so there's been this trickle down of their knowledge.Secondly, Muawiyah himself was indeed a very effective Siasi person of politics.And there's no denying that he knew how to run a bureaucracy and a government.
Thirdly, another reason is given, this is interesting and that is that the people of Damascus by and large were the most cultured of all of the cities that the Muslims were ruling, because Basra and Kufa were brand new cities, they were established by the Muslims and the people that were living there were a whole, if you like, hodgepodge of different types of people.They don't have their own culture and civilization.Many of them are never living in cities before.Their own culture is not as refined as that of the people of Syria and Damascus.They're living on the Romans.
So as it is the Syrian people because they had been ruled by the Romans, right?Because remember Syria was conquered from the Romans and Syria was basically, it's one of the main intellectual capitals, Damascus.So the Muslims coming in, the people of the city are not like the country folk, they're not like the village dwellers.They are a civilization.And so because of this as well, there's not that much chaos, there's not that much, you know, craziness in this land as it is compared to the other lands.
So Muawiyah therefore is basically effectively running the entire province of Syria for more than two and a half decades.Then the fitna happens of Uthman and the death of Uthman takes place.And this is when the first tensions began to arise between Ali Radiallahu an and Muawiyah.What happened?And I'll be very, very simplistic, I'm not going to go into a lot of detail and I do apologize, but that is what I strongly believe.The less we say, the better it is.So this is going to be a very, very quick, if you like, summary.The first signs of tension came when Ali sent a governor to replace Muawiyah.So Ali chose another person to be the governor with a small entourage, with the letter stamped and sealed and basically said, you're in charge now and Muawiyah has to step down.Now the question arises why would he even do that?
And the response to this is frankly, we don't know.There's millions of reason, not millions, a few reasons are given, a lot of reasons given.But the fact of the matter is we don't know what was in his heart.Why would he do that?Now the common interpretation, which is taken as a fact by non Muslims, which is ridiculous from our perspective, but it is what you will find in every book written in English and unfortunately many books written in Arabic and Urdu and other languages.
The common misunderstanding is that the reason why did this was because the Banu Hashim and the Banu Umayya were always rivals in Jahiliyya.Now this is true.In Jahiliyya, the Banu Hashim and the Banu, basically the Umayyads, the Banu Abd Al Shams, the Banu Abd Al Shams of the Ban Umayya, they were rivals and there was always tension between them.That's true.But there is no indication that Ali did this because of that reason.
And this seems to be something that is being read in by outsiders and non Muslims.So what is the reason?Allah knows best?What we do know, however, is that after the death of Muawiyah and the assassination, sorry, the assassination of Uthman Aliya essentially changed almost all the governors, in fact, all of the major governors.So it's not just Syria.
Perhaps he's just turning over a new leaf.Perhaps he's just bringing a whole new administration so that things can run smoothly now from his own perspective, there might also be Allah knows best.Perhaps some people have said, and Allah knows best, that there was a fear that since Muawiyah and Earthman are cousins, so Uthman and Muawiyah are from the same Banu, Umayyah, Banu Abd Al Shams, they're from the same Kabila, and they are basically a cousin once removed.So they're very close together and they were actually close in life as well.So perhaps some ulama say there was a fear that Muawiya might do something if he was left in power, but then he did something even though he was asked to leave.So Allah knows best.But there is a theory that there was a fear that if he remained in power, things might get worse.
So Ali tried to ask him to leave, but then that obviously did not work.It made things worse.In any case, we do not know.
In the end of the day, we don't know what was inside Ali's heart, what was the reason, but he has the right.I mean, he's the Khalifa.And for whatever reason, I mean, even if he didn't get along with him, whatever, this is his right as the ruler, as the Khalifa.I mean, sometimes in order to run the company, if two people don't really get along, they move, they're shifted in departments.That's what happens.
So whatever reason, we don't know, Ali sent the governor with the entourage Muawiyah heard, he intercepted the governor before they entered Sham and troops were sent out and the governor was basically told, you are not welcome, go back.So the governor that was appointed by Ali is stopped physically.No harm, nobody is hurt, but they're stopped.And they're told, you cannot go, come in, go back where you came from.And so obviously this is.Now, this is effectively a type of.A type of rebellion or.Yeah, I mean, essentially like you're not going to accept what Ali is.Is saying.Now.
Before even Ali could do anything, Aisha's situation and Talha and the others started arising in Basra.So he had to pause everything when it comes to Muawiyah and go and deal with that situation in Basra which we talked about last time.Okay?Now, in the meantime, Muawi begins to call for the revenge of the death of Uthman.And one of the relatives of Uthman, Radiallahu Anhu, had gone to Damascus with the shirt that Uthman was wearing when he was killed.
Along with this is gruesome, some of the fingers of Na', Ila, Uthman's wife, because, remember, when the sword came down, Na' Ila attempted to protect Uthman and her fingers were cut off.So one of the relatives of Uthman, he's basically now going back to Muawiyah, who's another relative of his, and he has these tokens that this is, we need to get the revenge for the killing of Uthman.And so Muawiya says publicly that we demand the vengeance or the diya or the dham.Basically, the blood of Uthman has to be avenged.And these items become public displays in the main Ummawi Masjid.
Everybody should see them.Now.Can you imagine the visual impact that's gonna have, how it will make people emotional, legitimately feel angry?Something has to be done.Where are the killers of Uthman?How could they still be walking?And again, there was this notion, and some of it might perhaps be true, that many of the mobs that were involved in the death of Uthman were now on the side of the Ali.And that also Aisha brings it up and Talha and Sa'.Ad.So there was this notion that the very people that were involved are basically on that side.
And there might be an element of truth, but obviously it was greatly exaggerated as well.So Ali Radiallahu Anh has to pause everything, go and deal with the issue of the battle of the camel, the Jamal deal with Aish Radiallahu, Anahu Talha and the other Sahaba over there, and that is in Basra.And when that is done, now he has to figure out what to do with Sham, with Syria.And he decided that there is no other alternative than to march from Basra all the way to a Sham, from Iraq to Sham, because this is basically rebellion.And you cannot run a country if one of the most significant provinces is not in your control.
And so Ali marched with his army towards Assyria and he eventually camped in a plain, a large area outside of basically Damascus by a few days journey, called Sifin.
5. Battle of Siffin: March, Negotiations, and Fighting
Ali’s march to Siffin, attempts to avoid combat during sacred months, back-and-forth peace efforts, and the eventual outbreak of battle with its ethical rules and heavy Muslim casualties.
So the land is called Sifin.And it is known to this day that land and Sifine is where the battle took place.This marching took place in the month of Dhul Hijjah, which is our month right Now, Dhul Hijjah of 36.Ah, 36 Ah, right.So 1400 something years ago.Okay, 1401 years ago in this very month of Dhul Hijjah.Now what is the month of Dhul Hijjah?Haram.
What does that mean?No fighting.What is the next month?Muharram.What is Muharram?
Also the same.Right.So Muawiya gets, sorry, Ali gets to Sifeen in Dhul Hijjah.And it is of the Ashul Hurom, it is literally Dhul Hijjah.And so now begin a long series of back and forths lasting for weeks.
And it's also the sacred month, so nothing can take place anyway.And it is said that a number of prominent Sahaba visited both sides, attempting to avert a battle.So famous Sahaba, from Ibn Abbas to Sa'dsun, Ibn Abi Waqas, many of the famous Sahaba, they are worried that this is going to eventually become a battle, which it does for these few weeks.They're trying their best that it doesn't happen.And Abu Hurairah himself visited Muawiya and he said that Alamatuqatil, why would you fight?This is the Khalifa.Are you rejecting him to be the Khalifa?And Muawiyah responded to him.I know that Ali is better than me, Afdal Mini, and I know that he is more entitled to the Khilafah and I'm not contesting his position.Now this is very, very important.
Muawiya was not saying I am the Khalifa.He never said this until after the death of Ali.This is something that is very clear and no historian worth his salt says otherwise.This is without a shadow of a doubt that Muawiyah was not claiming that Ali's Khilafah is illegitimate and I should be the Khalifa.Rather, what he is saying is, and this is what he told to Abu Hurairah, that I will be forced to fight him until he hands over the Qatala to Uthman or he deals with him himself.
And when he takes vengeance for the death of Uthman, then I shall join the rest of the people who have given him allegiance.So it is very clear that Muawiyah is saying I feel obliged as the senior most political authority that's related to Uthman, that it is as if it's my responsibility.Now that's what he's basically saying, that it's my responsibility to make sure that Uthman's death is avenged, that the people who killed him are brought to justice.And last week I already mentioned why this was effectively impossible.And Ali felt that it would cause a great civil war.
War and he was hoping there would be no other civil war with Aisha and Muawiyah.Turns out their civil wars happened here and it didn't happen on that side.And, and Ibn Taymiyyah also mentions that, that Muawiyah's camp had this presumption.Perhaps some of it might be true, as I said, that the killers of Uthman were literally in the camp of Ali.Now we don't, we cannot believe the killers of Uthman would be in the camp of Ali.
But what is without doubt true, those thousands of mobs that were outside of Medina, many of them are now in the army of Ali.And this is something well known.You can read the books of history, some of the main leaders of the instigators, what not.Now why he did this and whatnot is honestly it raises a whole can of worms.But as we had said that there's Ijtihad that he, the both camps did and Allah knows the reality of why they did this.
Nonetheless, from the side of Muawiyah there was the presumption that number one, the killers are on the other side.And number two, if we don't fight, what happened to Uthman is going to happen to us.So there was an element of self defense as well.Nonetheless, Ibn Kathir writes that the emissaries went back and forth throughout all of the Ashur Al Huram and until it was clear that really there's not going to be a breakthrough, that both sides there cannot, there's no compromise being reached.And so when Muharram finishes and Safar begins, so within a few days of Safar, Ali Radiallahu Anhu basically announces that there is no chance for reconciliation.
So be prepared.And this is following the Sharia.And especially when you're fighting a Muslim, you do not surprise attack.So Ali basically says that it's clear 7, 8 weeks, 6 weeks have gone by.We are not reaching any impasse and we're going to have to deal with this matter basically by war.
And this is as I said, a very traumatic incident for all of us from both sides, because this war was not accidental, unlike the battle of the Camel, which we can really very easily say that there was no intention for war.But in this case there is no getting out of it that when the negotiations did not transpire, then both sides felt there's no way other than actual fighting.And this is the very first intended civil conflict in Islam.And our Prophet predicted this as we'll come to.And he said, the first time the sword is unsheathed within my Ummah, it will never be sheathed back.
This is a Hadith prediction.The first time the sword is unsheathed within the Ummah, it will never be put back.And we have constantly seen inter Muslim fighting and wars.And even now as we speak, one nation is fighting another nation and one is bombing another and whatnot.And this is the reality of the Ummah since the time basically of this incident.
Nonetheless, so on the 6th of Safar, Ali announces that there's no point in negotiations and prepare.So on the morning of the seventh, Muawiyah's side was the first to attack because they felt if they don't attack, we're gonna be attacked.And so on the morning of the 7th, which was a Wednesday, Muawi, his forces attacked in the grounds of Sufim and the two armies fought incessantly for three and a half, four, some say five, some say six, some even say seven days.They continued to fight Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, some even go on Monday, Tuesday.But Ibn Kathir, others say that basically on Saturday it finished like three and a half or four days.
But they only fought during the day, they did not fight at night.And Subhanallah, this is at one sense you're sad, at another sense you're happy.Both sides would stop for Salah time.Both sides would stop for salah time.Both sides would pray janaza over the dead.
Because obviously what's going to happen, they're Muslims, both of them, right?There was an understanding that no person who turned his back and fled would be pursued and killed.Because this was from both sides perspective, not the type of offensive war that takes place in Ghazwat in fighting against the enemies and whatnot.There was understanding that if a person is wounded, you're not gonna kill him.There was an understanding that there's no ghanima, there's no taking of war booty.
Both sides are acting in a manner that is actually, we can say Islamic to the greatest extent possible, even as they are fighting one another.And that is not going to be replicated ever by the way.That is not going to, I mean this level of at least there is an element of basically, you know, fairness right on both sides that is not going to be replicated ever after this.Nonetheless, the armies basically did not.There is no clear victory.
There is no clear victory on either camp.And the numbers involved, our books mention staggering numbers.Ibn Kathir says this is Ibn Kathir who's one of our most famous historians.120,000 were on the side of Ali and of this 120, 40,000 were killed and 60,000 were fighting on the side of Muawiyah and 20,000 were killed.So Ibn Kathir who is one of our mainstream historians is estimating the number of casualties at 60,000 dead wallahi.This number by the way, there are numbers that are more than this and the numbers are less than this.I just gave you one.This number is just mind boggling.More Muslims died on the battle of Sufin than all the Muslims who had ever died since the beginning of Badr up until pre Sufin fighting against the Kuffar.This is the reality.
On one day between the two Muslim armies, more Muslims died at the hands of Muslims then all Muslims who became martyrs from Badr and UHUD and Khandaq and Azab and Khayya, everything and Qadisiya, right, and Nahawa, I mean everything combined.And this one battle eclipses all of those.And this is the, and this is the reality of what is going to.It's a foreshadowing of what's going to happen in the.
6. Prophetic Hadiths and Martyrdom of Ammar
Examines prophetic predictions about Muslim internecine fighting, the limited Sahaba participation, and the story of Ammar ibn Yasir’s death as a divinely meaningful sign.
Now I have to point out this is Ibn Kathir, he's saying 60,000.
Others say 50, 40.But still, I mean, okay, even if it's 40, I mean subhanallah, just, you know, what can we, what can we say?That's a huge amount of people on both sides.And our Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi wasallam predicted this.Pretty much all the scholars of Hadith understand this Hadith I'm about to quote as being a prediction of Sufin.Obviously our Prophet didn't say the battle of Sufin but there's a Hadith and Sahih Muslim.Our Prophet said Hadith is inside Muslims authentic, right?The day of judgment will not come until two large groups of people from my Ummah, two large groups from my Ummah will fight one another.Despite the fact that their call and message is the same.
Their message and call, their banners and their rallies, their understanding is exactly the same.But two, two massive groups of my Ummah will be fighting one another despite the fact that in reality there is no ikhtilaf.Because here's the sad point.It's not as if Astaghfirullah Ali was saying, I'm not gonna take vengeance for Uthman.As we explained last week and two weeks ago, he had his own ishtihad of how he would do that.
It never actually happened because he's dealing with all of these issues, right?But the method, it's not as if he is saying, I don't care.We're not going to take vengeance for Uthman.We showed.I demonstrated that Ali and his sons were protecting Uthman to the very end, that he was on the side of Uthman that he wanted.And he tried his best.But.So the dawah was Wahid, da, Wahuma, Wahid.Their call is the same, but tempers flare, emotions got involved.Ijtihad was done on both sides, and this reality took place.
And another point also, as we mentioned, one of the brothers asked, but this means that how many of the Sahaba died actually?Subhanallah.Most of the Sahaba refused to unsheathe their swords in this battle.Especially the elite of the Sahaba, even those that were physically on the sides, many of them refused to actually kill another Muslim, Muhammad ibn Siddin, who is one of the greatest Tabi'.Un.
He's a student of Abu Hurairah.Muhammad ibn Siddin, he died 110 hijra.Mohammed ibn Siddin said, so he's a Tabiri.When the fitna reached its peak, when the two battles were fighting, there were 10,000 Sahaba alive, but less than 100 took part in the battle.Then he said, actually less than 30.
And you can reconcile this.Less than 100 of anybody who had seen the Prophet.And less than 30 of the elite of the Sahaba, less than 30 of the big names participated.The bulk of the Sahaba, the bulk of them refused to fight another Muslim, even if their hearts were on one of the two sides.Like, in the sense they support one side against the other, but they're not gonna reach blows, they're not gonna kill.
And many of the Sahaba, they specifically said to either Ali or Muawi that we cannot go this far.I'm not going to unsheathe my sword against another Muslim, right?Even if I support you, again, this cause or whatnot, but not this.So the actual number of Sahaba who are on both sides, we said less than 30 of the famous ones.And maybe 60 of those whose names were not even, you know, because in Hajjat al Wada, how many Sahaba?100,000, right?Of those groups that we don't even know their names, the people who saw the Prophet, and of them, Maybe there were 60, 70, maybe.And of the elite, less than 30.However, there was one in particular that became the big name in this battle, and that is Ammar IBN Yasir.That is Ammar IBN Yasir.
Ammar IBN Yasir, of course, is one of the most famous of the Sahaba.His father, of course Yasir, whom I'm named after, was the first martyr, male martyr in Islam.His mother, Sumayya, was the first martyr.You all know the stories go back to the very beginning of the Seerah.Ammar himself was taken and dragged and tied up and tortured to the point of he could not even think straight and he could not even understand what he is saying.That's how bad he was tortured.And he was a teenager.Like he was literally in front of him.It's a really tragic story.Went over this in the Seerah, how many years ago he's seen his own mother and father die in front of him, tortured to death.
Now they're taking him, the poor kid, and they begin to torture him to death as a teenager.And he's a teenager, so he buckles under the pressure and he praises the gods and says whatever they ask him to say.So they let him go.And he comes running to the process, you know, bloodied and bruised and what?He comes running and he says, ya rasoolallah, I've destroyed.I'm destroyed.You know, what happened?And so he says that I was tortured to the point of I didn't even know what I was saying.And then I just said what they wanted me to say.So the Prophet said, how do you find your heart?
So he said, it is still firm in iman.My heart is still firm in Iman.And so Allah reviews Surah an Nisa.We recite it to this day.It's in the Quran, right?
This is what.What Ammar said.What Ammar said is in the Quran, mutma innum bil iman.In the Quran, that Allah is saying that whoever says Kufr, except the one who was forced and his heart is mutma in bil iman.So he made that exception for all people.So Ammar was the one who opened the door for that exception.So Ammar is that teenager who then migrates to Abyssinia, comes back, migrates to Medina.So he does both migrations.So he's of that status, participates at Badr.So he's a Badri and Uhud and Khandaq and Hudaybiya.
So he is of the elite of the Sahaba, the highest category of the Sahaba.And one day the Prophet said to him, and this hadith is mutawatir.It's in so many books of hadith, Bukhari and Muslim, they all have it.One day the Prophet said to him, Woe to you or careful means be careful, be careful or woe to you.As we say, the group that has rebelled is going to be the one that will kill you.
This hadith is authentic like the sun.The group that has rebelled will be the one that will kill you.
Now, Ammar IBN Yasir was a staunch ally of Ali, the right hand man of Ali from the beginning.And he participated in the battle of Sifin.And at this stage he is now around 90 years old.Now around 90 years old.He's in the battle of Safin now.
And he.And in fact it is said that he had his spear and he was putting his spear on the ground, like, you know, hitting it, hammering it and saying, I fought with the Prophet three times with this very spear and this is the fourth time, you know, I'm going to be using this spear.So he's on the side of Ali against the side of Muawiyah.And on the third or fourth day the battle, he felt that this was his last day.He just felt it.It's a premonition.These are people.Allah gives them these feelings from Allah.He felt that this is it, I'm gonna be dying.So he called his servants or whatever.He said, bring me some milk.They said, why?He said, the Prophet said to me, milk will be the last thing you drink before you die.So I want to fulfill that hadith.
So milk was brought to him, he drank it and he went into battle and he was killed.
Now which side killed him?
So the death of Ammar IBN Yasir became a sign because all the Sahaba knew the hadith.All the Sahaba knew the hadith.In fact, Ali himself picked up the body of Ammar and let it in.
7. Sufin Arbitration and Rise of Khawarij
Describes how Qur’anic arbitration halted the fighting, critiques of Abu Mihnaf’s account, the vague truce terms, and foreshadows the Khawarij split emerging after Siffin.
Janaza again, because this is now a sign that which of the two sides is more closer to the truth right?
Now, how did the other side interpret this?How did the other side interpret it?Because the hadith is known, isn't it?The hadith is well known.The Prophet said it.
In fact, in all likelihood he said this more Than once because we have so many sahaba.When the masjid is being built, of Quba Masjid of the process being built multiple times, he said, woe to you, O Ammar, the Bagiya group is going to kill you.
How did the other side interpret this?Well, Subhanallah, where there's a will, there's a way.Where there's a will, there's a way.And this is the reality of all of us, all of us, that when we want to find a way out, we'll find a way out.When somebody came to Muawiya and said to him that Ammar has died today and the Hadith said that the Bagiya group is the one going to kill him and our group killed him.
So what was the response of Muawi?He said, woe to you.We're not the ones who killed him.The ones who brought him to the battle are the ones who caused his death.Flipped it around 180.
The ones who brought it to the battle are the ones who brought around about his death.And Ibn Kathir narrates this from Muawi and said, this is a very far fetched interpretation of the Hadith.The point though, we have to be very clear here.
Muawiyah did not intend to reject or disobey what the Prophet said.He had an interpretation that some would label far fetched.Ibn Kathir himself says hada taweerun baeed.That's like bizarre this Ibn Kathir saying this, right?That's just not very.
But these interpretations are in reality coming from some type of iman.Do you understand what I'm saying here?Like he does not want to be the one that is Ba'.Gi.And this shows that he has some iman that he does not want to be the one that's rebelling.
And so he's trying to reason with himself, justify to himself, how can I not be the one.So then he brings out this interpretation and Allah will account him for his niyya, right?Innaman Amalu bin Niyad.Whether it's right or wrong, Allah Azzawajal is so rahim.He judges people based on niya and not based on actual being correct or not.And there are many instances, such as the man of the Bani Israel who felt that if Allah resurrects me, I'm gonna go to Jihannam, so I'm gonna make sure Allah never resurrects me.Hadith is in Bukhari, right?And so what does he do?He tells his children, when I die, burn my body, incinerate you know cremation was not known to the Arabs or cremation was not common.So he thought, if I cremate my body, Allah cannot resurrect me.
And this is Kufr, isn't it?Because you're thinking that you can outwit Allah, you're smarter than Allah, you can go.So he said to his children, cremate my body, distribute the ashes everywhere.And so then I don't have a problem of yaw al Qiyamah, I'd rather not have your Mul Qiyamah.So Allah caused the wind to bring all of the ashes.Said the man stood in front of Allah on the day of judgment.And Allah asked him, this is in the Hadith.Allah asked him, why would you do this?And so the man said, I'm scared of you.And being scared of Allah is Iman.
And so Allah forgave him because of his fear.Now this Hadith is a principle is derived that Allah bases judgment on what On Niyya.The guy's action necessitates a rejection of Allah's power.But he is not doing it that ah, I'm smarter than Allah.He's a simple guy.
His mind was like, you know what, I'd rather not face Jannah and Jahannam.Let me just live this life and forget about it.I'm worried about Allah as punishment, so I'd rather not face it.Simple minded guy.Now I'm not saying Muawi is not simple, he's very.
But I'm just saying the point is that what was this man judged on?And that's my point.No matter how far fetched Muawiyah's interpretation is in his heart.He did not want to be the Bagi group.And that's why he's finding a way out.That's not me, that's them.And in that finding way out is Iman.Because he does not want to be the Bagi group.And Allah Azza wa Jal will obviously judge people on their intention.So in any case, so Ammar's death really caused.Ammar IBN Yasser's death really caused the climate, if you like, to change.And it is said on the next day, basically the fighting ceased.On the next day the fighting ceased.How did the fighting cease?This was the infamous incident that took place that Muawiyah decided to tie their Qurans.Now pause here.In those days, in those days Qurans were massive scrolls, massive pieces of paper.
Not like the nice little pocket Qurans that we have here.These were huge parchments, right at times bigger than this table, maybe massive size.So they decided to take some of these, you know, leather parchments and paper and tie it to their lances and spears and raise it up high, raise it up high to show respect to the Quran that, look, I cannot use my weapon to fight you.Now the Quran's on there, I can't use my own invite you.And they began to say that, let us now stop this fighting and turn to the Quran to judge between us the arbitration from the Quran.The Quran will judge between us.Now here we have one of the riwa' at of Abu Mihna Falut IBN Yahya, who basically blames Amr Ibn Alas for this tactic that he says this was a deceitful tactic, that Amr Ibn as saw that he was losing and so he did this.
And this is Abu Mihnaf.It's not something that we consider to be valid.Nonetheless, when the Quran was raised so Ali Radiallahu's troops could not fight because you have the Quran there and this is in our religion, we all know we respect the mus'.Haf.We all know this, right?The mus' haf has the utmost respect.
That's why, you know, we show respect to the actual copy of the Quran.We have to have wudu to touch it.The woman in Mensah should not touch it.We don't put it on the ground.All of these things we know we show respect the actual mus'.Haf.So when the mus' haf was raised up, Ali's troops as well lowered their lances.They're not going to fight.And Ali Radiallahu Anhu said that I am the first person to take the Quran as the guide.I'm the first person to take the Quran as the arbitration that I am not going to say no to this.
And so eventually what was decided was that each group would pick one judge, one ambassador, and these two judges are ambassadors.The there's arbitration would take place and the two of them would figure out how to resolve the tension.So Ali chose Abu Musa Lash' Ali, Abu Musa ash' Ali and Muawiya.He chose Amr IBN Al as Abu Musa Al Ashari and Amr IBN Al As.Now, the fact of the matter is that details of the arbitration are vague in every report other than Abu Mihnaf's one.
And the version that many of you have read and heard is coming straight out of the Abu Mihna version of history.And we don't accept that version in Abu Mihna's version, you all know what happened.And that was essentially.That's the wrong version.Amr tricked Abu Musa al Ashari.
This is the version that is well known and popular.Everybody hears this version, that Amr is portrayed as a cunning, evil, sly politician and Abu Musa is portrayed as a naive simpleton.And this is not correct.The both of them were intelligent and the both of them were politically savvy.This is simply not correct.But Abu Mihna's version has this.This twist and whatnot.And I'm not even for those of you who don't know, there's no need to mention, I know many of you know the.The details of his version, but this is not found in the other books of history.Rather, what appears to be the case is that the conditions seem to be generic, that fighting is going to cease, that for the time being, Muawiyah can remain in Syria and Ali is basically in Iraq, that the two of them are not going to attack the other side, there's not going to be any more war, and that we need to now do further discussions to bring about a full resolve of the tensions.
Essentially, the truce did not flush out the details of how the truce would take place.The truce was simply.Both sides were tired of killing one another.And they said, you know what, we just have to stop this.We're not going to fight.You each stay in your realm and whatnot.And there probably was this notion and there are reports that, okay, next year we're going to meet again and we're going to get.But both sides got busy other matters, and they never went to war again.But they never quite solved the tensions as well.And Ali was eventually assassinated by the major problem that took place after the battle of Sufin, which he had to deal with for the next three years.
8. Sunni Appraisals of Muawiyah's Caliphate
Reviews Sunni scholarly consensus that Ali held the stronger claim, affirms Muawiyah’s political motives did not deny Ali’s legitimacy, and defends Muawiyah’s character and intentions.
And that's one of the reasons why he couldn't deal with Muawi as well.And that is the issue of the Khawarij.We'll talk about that inshaallah next week.Inshaallah next week, next Wednesday will be a little bit of theology, a little bit of history, and that is the Khawarij.And by the way, that's very important because it deals with the modern ISIS and Al Qaeda and all of that as well, because these are manifestations of the Khwarij as well.
So after this, of course, Ali and Muawiyah, they never went to war again, but they never actually solved their tension.And eventually, within three years after this, Ali Radiallahu is Assassinated.And after this, Muawiyah then declares himself to be the Khalifa.As long as Ali was alive, Muawiya never challenged his status as Khalifa.He never came under him technically, he never gave him the Bay'.Ah, he never gave him the oath of allegiance.And he kept on saying that when you resolve the Uthman issue, I'll give you the oath of allegiance.So theoretically he's acknowledging that Ali is the Khalifa, but he is saying I can't give you my oath until you solve that problem.And that problem was never solved.Aliya is killed.And so Muawiyah then declares himself to be the Khalifa.So let us briefly comment a little bit about this battle of Sufin and how we are to interpret it.
Ibn Taymiyyah writes that by unanimous consensus of the Ulema of Islam, Ali is the better of the two and the more correct and the more rightly guided.Now pause here.The Shia accused us of being on the side of Muawiya and this is simply wrong.
This is simply wrong.And I said this when I talked about Karbala, we are the real Shiatu Ali.I said this and I meant it.And it is something that we Sunnis theologically believe.This is a false accusation against us that the Sunnis are from on the side of Muawiyah.No, we are the real Shia to Ali.We are the real supporters of Ali.And this is Ibn Taymiyyah whom the Shia think is like the worst hater of Ali radiallahu anist.And it's not true.Look what he's writing.This is straight from his book Minhaj Sunnah.Ibn Damiyah has a 10 volume book.It is the most comprehensive book ever written in the history of Islam pre modern, about the differences between Sunnism and Shi' ism and the critique of Shi' ism from Sunnism.This is the most comprehensive book, 10 thick volumes.And in this book he writes that by unanimous consensus of all Sunni Ulama, Ali was a Haqqoo bin Khilafah wal Imam.
Ali was the one who was better suited and in charge of being in charge of the Ummah.And that there is no doubt that, you know, Muawiya made an Ijtihad and that ijtihad no doubt was the less correct of the two.So Ibn Taymiyyah is now technical here because he is saying our Prophet said if a leader or a ruler makes ijtihad, he tries to form something and he's correct.He'll get a double reward if he's incorrect.He will get a single reward.
So Ibn Taymiyyah says, even if Muawiya was Mukhti, and Mukhti means he was wrong, even if Muawiyah was Mukhti, Allah Azzawajal will still give him a single reward.And this is the Sunni point that we do not accuse Muawiya of Astaghfirullah, Kufr or Nifaq.But we say Ali was better than him, without a doubt.And the Sahaba who refused to fight were the best in terms of this issue.They weren't better than Ali.Overall.Ali is better than any Sahabi alive right now.But in this issue, those who refused to fight, both sides were the ones who had the safest and the best position.And he also pointed out, and this is something very important for us, this battle that took place was a battle of politics and not Aqeedah.It was a fight that deals with Siyasa and not deen.
Neither of the two sides accused the other of heresy, of Kufr, of Nifaq, of deviation.They are praying janaza over the dead of each other.And there are even reports.And Allah knows how true they are, but it is not surprising at all.It is not surprising at all.But Allah knows how true they are that at times when salah was taking place, they would pray in one jama', ah, even if they have to go and fight on the other side.Now, it's not at all bizarre if you understand the mentality of what's going on.The Ikhtilaf was not over dinner, so why would they mind praying behind other people?The notion of the other side being deviant did not come to their minds.The notion is you're wrong, yes, politically wrong, not theologically wrong.
So this is a khilaf Siasi, not a Aqadi.And he says, and this is something very awkward, but it is probably true that on both sides, words were uttered that were very harsh.And we're not going to mention those words.As I said many times, you know, if your mother and father have a fight, you don't regurgitate each and every phrase.You let it be.Life goes on.And we respect Muawiya and we respect Ali more than Muawiya.And words were exchanged.Some of the books record these words.We turn away from them.We don't find any benefit, any benefit in regurgitating.He said this.He said that.This was said about him.This was.
It's a war.People are dying.Yes.Tempers are going to rise.Perhaps even Ali and Muawiyah said things about not each other's deen, but that, you know, this is whatever, they might have said things, let's leave it at that, but it's understandable.
And so Ibn Taymiyyah points out that, you know, it's harsh words that we just, we don't have to think too deeply about them.It's a war going on, there's anger going on.And the main point is that Muawiyah never proclaimed himself as Khalifa, nor even did he challenge Ali's right to be Khalifa.But it is true that when Ali died, yes, that was when Muawiyah took the oath of allegiance of Khilafah.That was when.
And he did not accept Hassan's oath, which is Ali's son in Kufa.He did not accept Hasan's oath.And eventually, of course, Hasan Radiallahu Anhu would basically acquiesce and give up.Now, as for Muawiyah himself, ask Muawi himself.His Persona is one of the most controversial within Sunni Islam.
It's not controversial for the Shia.They hate him, they despise him, they don't view him as a Muslim, by and large.But even within Sunni Islam, unfortunately, we've always found some tension out of all of the Sahaba.No Sunni ever says anything disparaging about the elite or else they wouldn't be Sunni.Unfortunately, we do have some of our ulema, especially modern Mufakkirin, I should say modern thinkers, right?
They kind of went beyond what is permissible and they said things about the akhlaq and character of Muawiyah that they should not have said.And the fact of the matter is that he was a Sahabi, that he was of the last batch of converts, and therefore he just got the honour of being a Sahaba.But that because he's of the last batch, he cannot be compared with the first batches.Also, he was the brother in law of the Prophet.How can we ignore that?
Because his sister is who?Umm Habiba Binti Abi Sufyan.Right.And so Muawiya is a brother in law of the Prophet and that cannot be ignored as well.Muawiya was chosen for a brief period of time to be of the people who wrote the Quran when it was revealed, the Kuttab Al Wahi, he was of those who were chosen because his background was educated and there were very few educated people in Mecca.We know this Abu Sufyan was a politician and he was educated, his sons were educated.And so Muawiya was chosen by The Prophet to be of the Qutb Al Wahi.This is well known.Ibn Sa'd, everybody of the classical book says this.The fact that he wrote the Quran for a period of time.
9. Umayyad Dynasty Legacy and Controversies
Defends the establishment of the Umayyad dynasty under Muawiyah, highlights its global expansion achievements, counters modern critiques, and situates dynastic rule within Islamic history.
If you're gonna doubt him, you're doubting the Quran.If you're gonna doubt his character, you're doubting the Prophet's choice and asking him to write the Quran.And we don't go.We don't cross that line as well.There are some hadith that seem to indicate indirectly or directly the blessings of Muawiyah.Of them is hadith in Musallima Muhammad that the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam prayed for Muawiyah that Allah mujalu hadiyan mahdiya.This is a famous hadith Allah majaluhu hadiyan Mahdiya.He saw Muawiya and he made a dua for him that O Allah, make Muawiyah somebody who is guided and who guides other people.So there's dua in Muslim Muhammad.And it is also reported in Sahih Muslim that the Prophet praised the first group of Muslims who would ride the waves in Ghazwa in Jihad, the first naval expedition.
And Umm Salama was there.And she asked the process to make dua that she is of them.And she is.She was of them.And that is why she was of the group of Sahaba who.
Who invaded which land?Cyprus.Right.And that's why her grave is still over there to this day.Literally.
The masjid is next to the beach.It's on the beach.The masjid attached to her is on the beach because that's where she died.Who was in that group as well is Muawiya.Muawiya was one of the leaders of that group.
And our Prophet said that that group shall be a forgiven or a blessed group.There are different versions of the hadith that that group is a forgiven group and Muawi is a part of that group.So Muawiya has the blessing of being of that group that the Prophet praised.And there is no question that Muawiya radiallahu Anhu effectively managed to rule over Syria during his lifespan.And then when he became the Khalifa, he became the most effective king the Ummah has ever seen.
Because he became a king, as we know, he put his son in charge.He became the most effective dynastic ruler the Ummah has ever seen.And the only ruler who is a Sahabi, the only dynasty ruler who's a Sahabi.Right, because who after him was A Sahabi and a dynastic ruler, meaning a king ruler.And Imam Al Awza', I, one of the famous scholars of Syria, who died in the year of the Tabi', Un, Imam Alza' I said that many of the Sahaba were alive in the time of Muawiyah.
None of them challenged Muawiya's rule, none of them.After Ali's death, none of the Sahaba rebelled against Muawiyah Radiallahu an, including Abdullah bin Zubayr, who rebelled in Mecca and Hijaz.When did he rebel?For those who know history, after Muawiya's death, Yazid, after Muawiyah's death is when he really rebelled against the Khilafah.Before that time it was tension, I would say, but the actual proclamation, if you like, this is afterwards, that took place.
And in Sunan al Tirmidhi there is a beautiful narration that says that Muawiya Radiallahu an wrote to Aisha, Aisha is alive.When Muawi becomes the Khalifa.He wrote to Aisha, give me some advice and be short.Give me some quick advice, short advice.And so Aisha wrote to him this hadith in Tirmidhi, Aisha wrote to him, assalamu alaikum.
I heard the Prophet, sallallahu alaihi wasallam say, whoever seeks the pleasure of Allah, even if it means displeasing the people, Allah will take care of the people for him.And whoever seeks the pleasure of the people by disobeying Allah, Allah will leave him to the mercy of the people.This is the hadith.Simple, sweet, short, to the point.But what does it show us?
Good relations and that Muawiyah wants spiritual advice.The fact that he's writing to Aisha and says, give me some advice, I want to hear something that will benefit me.What does that show us about the character of Muawiya?So all of this cannot be ignored.And we, and especially myself, I'll be very, very clear here.
I do not at all agree with a group of thinkers of our times.Some of these are founders of Islamic parties and movements.I don't want to go beyond this.Many of you look up to these individuals.These are modern thinkers in the 40s, 50s, 60s, 70s, who are founders of these political movements.
They felt that the problems of Islam began with Muawiyah.These are Sunni thinkers that Muawiyah changed the Khilafar Rashida into a kingdom and dynasty.And it's too deep and too profound or too much to detail.Go into this, but honestly, it is naive simplicity to assume that if Muawiyah hadn't done anything, we would still have had a khilafah Rashida.All you need to do is to look at Ali Radiallahu Anhu's reign and how much fitna happened in his time.
Even though he is way better than Muawiya, but he could not quell the rising tide of whatever instability what not.And the fact of the matter is, I believe, and we Sunnis should believe this, that Allah used Muawiya when he needed to be used as the Khalifa.And he was the most effective Khalifa for his generation.And honestly, if you look at it from a neutral standpoint, he was an amazing leader.He managed to transform the religion of Islam into a global civilization.
He was the single handed person who changed the dynamics of Islam from being something that literally has not been exposed to the world.It's still coming out of the culture of Arabia.And he makes it the beginnings of a global civilization.And that's the Umayyad dynasty overall and especially Muawiyah Ibn Abi Sufyan.And he is the only king of our history who was also a Sahabi.
No king after was a Sahabi.And there's no question that having a dynasty is not the default and the ideal.But we also have to be clear here, being a dynasty doesn't disqualify you from being a Khalifa.And if you believe this, then essentially you are saying we have never had a khilafah for the last 1400 years.And that's ludicrous.
What are the Umayyads, the Abbasids, the Mamluks, the Zenjavids, the Ayyubids, the Ghaznavids.I mean, every single Sultanate, every single Khilafat has been dynastic for the bulk of our history because frankly, it's easier for a civilization to understand, okay, this is the family that's gonna rule us.And the world works in a more better way in this regard.And even if it has problems, there is no ideal when it comes to this.The khilafah Rashida has gone away.Bottom line.I'm going on and on and we need to finish up here.The bottom line, Muawiyah is somebody whose character and whose iman and taqwa is beyond dispute.That's beyond the red line.We may disagree with his Ijtihad in how he handled the situation, but we don't ever impugn his Niyya.
We don't talk about his character as Being bad, we may disagree.And it does appear that his rebellion against Ali was not the better of the two Ijtihads.But in the end of the day, what happened, happened.And Allah subhanahu wa ta' ala will deal with them based on their niyya.And we also believe that if you look at what he did afterwards by establishing the Umayyad dynasty, and by I mean the Umayyad dynasty as well, another dynasty, that a lot of dhulm is done against it.
The fact of the matter is, once again, we have never had a dynasty as effective as the Umayyads, despite its flaws, despite its negativities, and there are negatives.The Umayyad dynasty, overall, for 90 years, it was the only dynasty that was completely uniting the Ummah.After the fall of the Umayyads, what happened?The Ummah split up.You had Andalus, you had the Abbasids as well.
Eventually you had the Safavids, the Mughals, the Hamanids.You had all of these fractures.In the time of the Umayyads, it was one from Sin all the way to Maghrib, from Morocco all the way to China, you had the Umayyads ruling one khilafah.We've never had that since that time.The Umayyads as well, were the only dynasty where the conquests were still taking place at the same level as that of the time of the Sahaba.
When the Sahaba's expansion, the Umayyads continued all the way to China and to not even Morocco.Where did they go?Spain.They entered Europe.Right.
This is the time of the Umayyads.The Abbasids did nothing compared to that, and the Ottomans did nothing compared to that.And the Mamluks did nothing compared to that.And the Ayyubids and the Hamanandids did nothing compared to that.So the Umayyads, indeed, some tragedies happened, like Karbal and whatnot.Major tragedies, no question.But.But in the grand scale of things, we have never had a dynasty as powerful and as effective and, yes, as humble even.How so?And again, I go into my tangents here, but the way that the Umayyads lived was not like the way the Abbasids and the Ottomans lived.The Umayyad Khalifa intermingled with the people.He lived amongst the people.He gave the Khutbah and led the Salah and Jummah, whereas later on, the Khalifa is not even qualified.And these days, we don't even want our leaders to Recite Fatiha.
They're gonna embarrass themselves as we see YouTube videos all the time.
The world has changed.The Umayyads were people, generally speaking of Iman and Taqwa.They had some knowledge.They.They were in charge of the Ummah.They had so much khair in them.Yes, they had major problems, but compared to what happened afterwards, they were light years ahead of the rest of the later generations in any case.So the bottom line is the battle of Sifin is a great tragedy.And we simply ask Allah subhanahu wa ta' ala to forgive both sides and we move on.And we don't dwell too deeply about that timeframe.Inshaallah.
10. Conclusion and Community Announcements
Final reflections asking forgiveness for both sides of the conflict, preview of the next lecture on the Khawarij, followed by community youth-director appointment announcements.
Next week we'll talk about the Khawarij and the assassination of Ali and then move on to the other Sahaba.We have a very important announcement Inshallah before our salah and that is Alhamdulillah.As you know, MIC has been looking for youth director Alhamdulillah.We now have brother Safi.
You can stand up.Safi is alright.Alhamdulillah.Everybody knows Safi.Mashallah.
Safi Khan has been appointed our youth director Alhamdulillah.We felt that he is the most qualified person because he is a member of our own community rather than he get somebody from outside.We know brother Safi, Inshallah will be very effective in this role.And inshaallah, any youth related activities and all complaints now can be directed to him.Insha'.Allah.So I have now cleansed my hands of youth affairs and it all goes on.Inshallah.But inshaallah, he'll do fine.Inshaallah.
Okay, Was praying and after Islam he seen it.One side, his wife, sister of Magia and another sister.
He says that time that if anybody will face a power against Mavia and his kids, not gonna last long.That's true.No, there's no hadith like this.No, there's no hadith like this.Nothing like this.
Yeah.When it comes to these types of blessings about these, it's most literature that we read.It's not found in the classical sources.Inshallah.Yes.
Not every single Khatal Maktul.Not every single.This is the general rule that when they fight for an illegitimate cause, then indeed Al qaatulah Maktul finnaar.But this is as we mentioned a few weeks ago in the class.Sorry, in the hadith class that we're doing Riyadh al Saliheen.
What is the Sunni rule when it comes to waid, when it comes to punishments, what is the rule that Sunnis have when it comes to punishments and threats?In the Quran and Sunnah, when Allah threatens punishment, what is the rule?Do you remember the rule we mentioned it?The rule is that the threat of punishment is generic and we do not apply it to specific people.Because the default of a Muslim is forgiveness.
So the threat is general.So when Allah says, or the Hadith says that whoever drinks Khamr, this is gonna happen.Or when the Quran says whoever eats the orphan's money is eating Jahannam, Right?But now you see the Muslim and he's drinking, are we gonna say you are going to Jahannam?No, because Allah will weigh that one evil with all of the other good.
And Allah will judge based on the good and the evil combined.And the default when it comes to a Muslim is forgiveness.So when it comes to the sahabah, the default is even higher than this.And therefore radiallahu anhum waradu anhu.Okay?Inshallah.With that we pause and continue next week.Inshaallah.