1. Introduction to the Judge Hat
Introduces the judge hat as the converging phase of creativity, following the explorer and artist hats, and previews techniques for selecting and narrowing down ideas.
please all rise I say all rise ok you may all sit I am judge Vincent so today we're gonna talk about what does it mean to wear the judge hat okay so in the previous videos we looked atwearing the Explorer hat and wearing the artist hat so when we do that we are into a diverging mode so it means that we're gonna start with few ideas and we're gonna develop a lot a lot of ideasbut we cannot continue like that forever at one point we're gonna have to make some selections we're gonna have to make some choices on some of the ideas that we want to use so we're gonna start to convergethis is where the judge had step see so we're gonna see that to start the converging process we're gonna have to select some of the ideas that we believe have the most are the most promising or the most
novel and what I'm going to explain to you today is how what are the different ways and technique to make this selection to sort out our idea and to narrow down the number of ideas so again at the
2. Idea Matrix and Ladder of Ideas
Explains a matrix classifying ideas as now, wow, and how based on originality and feasibility, plus the ladder analogy of floor, mountain, and sky ideas.
end of the artist heart we came up with a lot of a lot of ideas maybe 50 maybe 100 different ideas but what do we do with all of these ideas so there is a framework or matrix whichis quite simple but which helps to illustrate what can be done about this so as you can see you have two axis on the horizontal axis you have normal ideas and then you have original ideas and on thevertical axis you have ideas that are easy to implement and ideas that are impossible to implement so let's look first out of at the bottom left corner which are what we call now idea because them now because theseideas that are easy to implement they have low risk of trying them they have a like very high likelihood that they would be accepted easily so they are what we call some low-hanging fruits very easy to pick up
so this is a group of ideas that could fit into this now category the second category are original ideas which are easy to implement so on this quadrant we get what we call some Wow idea so these aresome idea which are innovative which are more breakthrough type of ideas compared to the now ideas and but the idea that can still be implemented we do after the know-how the expertise the technology that will allow us toconvert these ideas into a new product a new service and you process a new business model or whatever and the third type of ideas so which are original ideas but that might not be possible to implement at thisstage so that's what we call the how idea how because we don't know yet how we're gonna make it happen but they have also there may be more futuristic or more breakthrough ideas but that are worth also capturing
anokhin ideas so these are more ideas for the future but it's nice to always look also into the future and not look at what can be done as of today so when you have a lot of ideas youcan categorize them into these three different categories and then later on decide with which categories you want to go for oh we're gonna see later on how maybe to organize a portfolio of ideas with different ideas for differentcategory of of level of complexity a level of novelty this can be represented also just to give you another analogy but what we call the ladder of ideas at the bottom this rzf ideal so the idea which areeasy to implement low-risk that have a high level of acceptability and that are also may have been done before but maybe in a different context in a different country in a different company or whatever then we move to
the mountain ideas so these are the ideas that can be implemented which are much more oh well but which somehow are a little bit more disruptive than the previous type of ideas disruptive compared to the existing ideas andthen the last level is a sky idea so this one can actually be implemented as a for now there are more audacious and a more a dream about what could be the future light so that's exactly the samerepresentation as before at the bottom you have the what now now idea and then for the mountain level this has a Wow idea and for the sky lovers isaw see how I D how we going to be ableto make this happen okay so you classify your idea on this three level and let's say that for instance we want to focus on the mountain ideas okay so you take all your post-it or all your ideas that
3. Clustering Ideas and Selection Criteria
Describes how to cluster similar ideas under overarching themes and lists common criteria questions used to evaluate which ideas to move forward with.
fit into this category and then what do we do next so next we're going to cluster this idea so we should cluster this idea by ideas that are similar or answer the same aspect of your challenge let's sayfor instance would we like to id8 about the car of the future okay so you can come up with a lot of idea and then you might say okay this group of idea of focus more on the energyon the energy type that this car will use in the future or this group of idea focus more on the design of the car of the future all this group of idea focus more on on the IT capabilityis attached with this car what it can do and and and so on so you will cluster your large amount of ideas in small groups and these small clusters you will label them with an overall arching theme you
will define based on you on your challenge now once you have this cluster what do you do next so you still have to define which one you want to implement okay so there are some common criteria out questionsthat can be used to identify which idea I have my big wolf moving forward or my big wolf investing the first idea was the first question could be for instance does it fit with people needs is there reallya demand for such kind of product or idea of feature right does it meet the requirement of our problem statement or if you using a design thinking approach does it meet the requirement of our point of view isit different enough from what exists and does it really add some new value what's a new value proposition attached to it do we have the budget required to be able to implement this this idea is a technology available
to make it happen we will be able to roll it out with the available resources that we have in-house not just financial but also production resources or human resources or whatever can we get the approval of decision makeror can we get easily the approval of decision makers which can be also something you might want to consider and finally is it aligned with our organization core values which is also a very important aspect to take inconsideration okay so these are just some example of question you might want to ask of criteria and then for each of the idea that you come up with you will rank them just to give you another example thisis for from a recent survey of the 2017 Business Innovation report and where companies listed what kind of criterias are used to select idea so 71% of the companies that were interviewed use the alignment to the business strategy
than 56% the feasibility 51% the estimated values and the estimated cost then and and so on and so on so you can see that these are very similar to the one I presented to you early on but againyou can create your own criteria based on your particular industry or field or interest now what do you do next so it's not the answer should not be a yes or no to this question you should use a
4. Scoring Ideas and Innovation Portfolio
Covers ranking ideas on a 1-to-6 scale against criteria to compute totals, and introduces a three-dimensional portfolio balancing certainty, timing, and risk.
scale I recommend you to use a scale from 1 to 6 so it's an even scale one being for instance that it does not meet at all so requirement and 6 it meets a lot this requirement I tooka scale from 1 to 6 so there is no middle value so it's a slightly positive or slightly negative but at least you need to take position so for each question and for each idea you will say welldoes it fit people's need is there a demand for it so it's a 4 idea number one yes a lot so let's say we put five out of six for idea number two yes there is a demand yeah4 out of 6 and so on and for each idea and for each question you will rank you will give a value then once you have answered all the question for each of the idea you just compute the
total number and the ideas that have obtained the highest value are the ones that you probably might want to move forward okay so that's one technique again very simple that helps to the identify your criteria put a weightto each of these criteria and then help you identify the idea that much most of this criteria as I mentioned a little bit early on you might want also to consider a portfolio of ideas or portfolio of innovationproject so on this visual you can see a matrix which has three dimensions so the level of certainty low moderate or high on how certain or how confident we are that this idea is going to succeed or noton the horizontal axis you have the timing so this idea that can be completed on short term midterm or long term and on the third axis on the right you have the level of risk what are the risk
involved with implementing this idea low risk moderate risk or high risk okay so you can have in your portfolio different type of ideas a different type of innovation projects that fit different criteria usually organization put a heavyweight inIndia portfolio on ideas that are on the top left corner which are high level of certainty short term and low risk okay so it makes sense so here it shows that in average 70% of the ideas of theinnovation project fit into this category only 20% fit into mid moderate level of certainty a model rate level of risk and finally only 10% in average focus on long term high risk and low certainty okay so having aportfolio like this of ideas is like having a pot for you a financial portfolio you don't put all your eggs in the same basket here you don't put all your ideas again in the same basket some of them
might have the potential to do very well but are risky so you might want to explore some of them but you want also to make sure that you have some of them that will succeed succeed on a veryshort term now last thing I would like to talk to you about is its I mean we can always estimator some estimation or forecasting about what my work what is likely to work or not work what is the
5. Prototyping and Closing Remarks
Explains prototyping as an iterative way to test ideas with customers before full implementation, followed by the judge's farewell and preview of the next video.
level of risk or whatever but nowadays instead of thinking that we know what's gonna happen one of the approach which is well used and it which is used for instant also in design thinking is prototyping so before youtry and you move your idea of fullscreen to the I mean to the end product or to the end service then you test your idea and you build a physical prototype of your idea and you show this prototypeto your customer to your client and you get their feedback you learn from them and you refine your prototype and you go for a lot of psycho like this iterative cycles where you slowly improve your idea you testyour idea all along the way you learn all along the way so while at the end when you have a prototype which is close to what you plan to market or to produce you know that the market is
ready and that also your potential customer I have tried it after stood and I've approved I'll give you a positive feedback on these so it can be part and you should be part of the testing part testing youridea physically with prototype and prototype also laterwell thank you so much for watching but it's time for me to go so I have a couple of murderers to judge now so I'm sorry I will have to leave now but again stay tuned and I willsee you soon with wearing the wire your heart please all rise