# 為什麼絕大多數鴨蛋都被做成了皮蛋和咸蛋？原來鴨蛋和雞蛋竟然差別這麼大！

**Channel:** 老肉雜談
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBgntp_zX6U
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/cBgntp_zX6U

## Chapters

- 0:00 — The Duck Army: Pest Control Heroes
- 3:33 — Why Chickens Dominate and Duck Origins
- 9:33 — Duck Diet and the Duck Egg Problem
- 14:14 — Duck Meat and Traditional Chinese Dishes

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** Hello everyone , I'm Lao . We just talked about geese , so today let's talk about ducks . Back then , we said the most famous label for geese is their ferocity . They attack any stranger or animal they encounter with high aggression and a short temper , but in contrast , ducks have a completely different image . They leave people with a deep impression of being funny and comical , naturally possessing a sense of humor and being easier to approach . This likely has to do with their appearance , their quacking , and even the way they waddle when they walk . In short , they just look particularly funny . For instance , the British Science Association once conducted a study on jokes and concluded that the funniest animal in the world is the duck , meaning the mere mention of a duck is most likely to make people laugh

**[0:38]:** ; this is a common impression of them . So , what else is it that makes ducks stand out ? It’s the " duck army . " You might have seen videos online about rice paddies and ducks where farmers release thousands of ducks into the fields every year after the rice harvest . What for ? To have them clean up the battlefield . The most common targets are golden apple snails and their eggs , which are very abundant in the fields . We’ve talked about these before ; they are highly damaging to rice paddies , and it just so happens that ducks love to eat them . They also eat various pests , eggs , weeds , and fallen grain — it’s like they’ve entered an all-you-can-eat buffet . You know , if you’re full , you have to relieve yourself , right ? So , duck droppings act as fertilizer , increasing the fertility of the paddies .

**[1:21]:** Plus , their big feet stomp around , flattening the rice stubble , which makes future plowing much easier . All in all , it’s full of benefits . Beyond the harvest season , ducks are actually useful during the rice growth period too . They won't eat the rice seedlings in the paddy ; instead , they hunt for golden apple snails and various pests , fertilizing the field as they go . Additionally , their feet stir up the water , which loosens the soil and increases aeration — it’s just perfect . This model of " rice-duck farming " has actually been around for over a thousand years . For example , the " Qimin Yaoshu " from the Northern Wei Dynasty records that rice paddies can require less pesticide and save on fertilizer . Raising ducks also saves a lot of feed , and the ducks eat more nutritiously .

**[2:00]:** In the end , both the duck eggs and the duck meat have better quality and color , making it a win-win . This is a big reason why the " duck army " is so popular . And by the way , when else does the duck army become quite a hit ? During locust plagues , for instance the one in Xinjiang in 2000 , a flock of ducks became famous when Zhejiang sent 100,000 of them to help eat the locusts . The results were excellent , and it was even cited as a model case by a UN organization . Later , during the 2020 locust plague in Pakistan , there was a proposal to send 100,000 ducks from China . However , because Pakistan was so dry and lacked water , the ducks wouldn't have survived , so they didn't go . That said , some viewers might wonder : don't chickens also love to eat locusts ?

**[2:42]:** Why use ducks instead of chickens to exterminate locusts ? Well , there are two main reasons for this . First , it’s quite simple : ducks have a larger appetite . A single duck can eat about 200 locusts a day , while a chicken can only eat 70 , making the efficiency two to three times higher — this is the ducks ' first advantage . There is a Chinese idiom , " to flock like ducks , " referring to how they always move together in a unified group , which makes them very easy to herd . In contrast , chickens are different ; a large flock easily scatters , with each bird foraging on its own . If you released 100,000 chickens on a grassland , you might only get 50,000 back , as the rest would run off to become wild birds . They aren't as easy to manage as ducks ; this is the ducks ' second advantage .

**[3:30]:** That is why ducks are used instead of chickens .

**[3:33]:** However , while ducks are better at eating locusts , chickens dominate the market share , and large-scale commercial farming primarily focuses on chickens . You'll notice in any supermarket that the consumption of duck meat and eggs is on an entirely different level compared to chicken meat and eggs . The average person is just more accustomed to buying chicken meat and eggs . In Western countries in particular , some supermarkets don't even sell duck meat or eggs ; the market is basically monopolized by chickens . Regarding this topic , I’ve mentioned before why commercial farming prefers chickens over geese . But ducks are different from geese because a major issue with geese is their high aggression , making them unsuitable for dense farming , which hinders scaling . Ducks , as mentioned , are very easy to manage and not aggressive at all . Plus , they have a natural habit of huddling together ; in a rice paddy , for instance , a few dozen ducks crowded together is no problem at all , which seems quite suitable for large-scale farming , right

**[4:29]:** ? And here’s another thing that many people probably don't know , what is it ? It’s that when it comes to laying eggs , ducks are actually even more productive than chickens . For example , as early as 1898 , a British breeder named Adele Campbell developed a duck breed called the Khaki Campbell . This type of duck can lay eggs almost all year round without a break ; tests at the time showed they laid 345 eggs in a year , basically one per day . So , for comparison , what was the annual egg production of a hen 100 years ago ? Only about 120 , which is just one-third of the Khaki Campbell . Even with over a hundred years of modern improvement , chickens only reach about 280 to 320 eggs , still trailing behind the ducks of 100 years ago .

**[5:13]:** And keep in mind , duck eggs are also a size larger than chicken eggs , right ? The protein content in duck eggs is actually higher as well , making them more nutritious ; in other words , at least in terms of laying eggs , the duck's advantage is quite clear . So , since ducks can be raised in dense groups and are exceptionally good at laying eggs , why haven't laying ducks outperformed laying hens ? Especially when you go to the supermarket , what is the phenomenon you see ? While supermarkets do sell duck eggs , most are salted duck eggs or century eggs ; fresh , raw duck eggs are quite rare . And when most people want to scramble , fry , or boil an egg , they almost always buy chicken eggs . Very few people will buy duck eggs to take home , so what exactly is wrong with them ?

**[5:52]:** Why are most duck eggs processed into salted eggs or century eggs ? Why are chicken eggs rarely used to make salted eggs or century eggs ? Well , to answer these questions , we first need to get a better understanding of the duck as an animal . Broadly speaking , most species in the family Anatidae are ducks ; aside from various geese , mandarin ducks , and swans , everything else is classified as some kind of duck . There are so many types of ducks , found everywhere except Antarctica ; so who is the ancestor of the domestic duck we usually talk about ? It’s the mallard from the genus Anas ; currently , the vast majority of domestic ducks are descended from the mallard and are considered a subspecies of it . The only exception is the Muscovy duck , also called the red-faced duck , because it has a large patch of red , fleshy caruncles on its face .

**[6:36]:** The most common example is ginger duck in Southern Fujian cuisine , for which Muscovy ducks are typically preferred . Now , Muscovy ducks are not descendants of mallards ; they were domesticated by indigenous Americans . Their ancestor is the wild Muscovy duck from Central and South America . They only left the Americas for Asia after Columbus . They are a unique case . As for the earliest domestication of ducks , genetic analysis suggests about 4,000 years ago . In a previous episode , we mentioned that geese domestication dates back 7,000 years , and chickens about 3,500 years ago . So , the order of domestication for these three types of poultry might be different from what you think . It was actually geese first , then ducks . And chickens came last . Although chickens are most common now , they were actually domesticated the latest .

**[7:16]:** The reason ducks were domesticated earlier than chickens may relate to their location ; chickens were domesticated in Southeast Asia , while ducks and geese were domesticated in southern China . That region is the wintering ground for wild geese and mallards . You see , agricultural civilization emerged earlier in southern China , right ? Naturally , the domestication of livestock would be earlier too . Also , the dominance of rice cultivation there was very suitable for raising waterfowl , which is why ducks and geese were domesticated relatively early . After mallards were domesticated , many breeds were developed over the following thousands of years ; for instance , the most typical meat breed is the Peking duck . Though named " Peking , " it was actually domesticated from mallards in the canals of Nanjing , reportedly related to grain often spilling from transport boats .

**[7:57]:** After being introduced to Beijing , it became the standard for Peking roast duck . Other common breeds include the Shaoxing duck and the Gaoyou duck ; both are highly prolific egg-layers , especially the Gaoyou , which is famous for laying double-yolk eggs . Because their feathers are mottled with spots and black , they are also called " spotted ducks . " These two , along with the Peking duck , are collectively known as China's three most famous duck breeds , all with very long histories . Later on , as these breeds spread , many new varieties were improved and cultivated in other regions . For example , after the Shaoxing duck reached Southeast Asia , the Indonesians bred a particularly slender duck with an upright posture . These ducks don't waddle or look clumsy when they walk ; on the contrary , they are quite good at running , which is why they are called " runner ducks .

**[8:41]:** " However , the British later made a mistake and called them " Indian Runners , " but they are actually native to Indonesia . Runner ducks inherited the Shaoxing duck's traits and are also known for being prolific egg-layers . As for Europe , there are also several representative breeds , such as the Rouen duck , a meat duck bred in northern France . It was also bred by crossing Asian meat ducks with local mallards after they were introduced . So , its plumage is still that of a mallard , but it is much larger and highly productive . Then there is also the egg-laying champion mentioned earlier , the Khaki Campbell . The Khaki Campbell is even more complex ; it’s a breed created by crossing Indian Runner ducks , Rouen ducks , and wild mallards . So , although these ducks look very different in form and features , tracing them back to their roots , they all stem from the same domestication event in Southern China , which is the origin of the vast majority

**[9:32]:** of domestic ducks .

**[9:33]:** While ducks and geese are relatives in the same family , their diets are quite different . As mentioned in the previous episode , geese are primarily herbivores , grazing on grass or eating aquatic plants . By contrast , ducks eat a much wider variety of things because they are omnivores . As seen with the " duck army " at the beginning , besides eating grass , seeds , and fruits , they also eat fish , snails , worms , various insects , larvae , and even frogs . Wildlife photographers have even captured footage of mallards eating small birds that had fallen into the water , which is quite fierce . In other words , the diet of a duck might be more aggressive than you think ; after all , they are tough characters with " teeth " in their bills . Now that we understand the habits of ducks , we can explain why commercial capital doesn't like raising them .

**[10:19]:** First of all , a duck's need for water and swimming is an absolute requirement . For instance , there was a study from Cambridge University in 2007 . Everyone knows that ducks often dip their heads into the water and shake them around . While it looks like they're just playing , it serves a purpose . Researchers found they need water to clean their nostrils and eyes ; otherwise , they are prone to infections . So , if you want to raise ducks indoors like chickens , you have to provide them with enough water troughs for them to splash around in . But in doing so , they will inevitably spill the water , making the duck house very damp , and high humidity breeds bacteria that cause diseases . Therefore , ultimately , raising ducks requires open spaces and access to open water . This means it is better to free-range them rather than keeping them purely in pens .

**[11:03]:** It is certainly not feasible to keep them in industrial sheds like chickens , which makes their farming efficiency lower than that of chickens . Another issue is the duck eggs themselves . Why are fresh duck eggs so rare , and why are most processed into salted eggs or century eggs ? First of all , this has something to do with the composition of duck eggs . It is said that egg whites contain a protein called ovomucin . It is related to how egg whites coagulate when heated . Duck eggs have a much higher ovomucin content , so if you boil them a little too long , the texture becomes tough and rubbery , unlike the tender texture of chicken eggs . Plus , if ducks eat too many snails or worms , their eggs often have a strong , fishy odor . That is why raw chicken eggs are generally better for cooking .

**[11:45]:** Another thing is that duck eggshells are quite different from chicken eggshells . If you have ever bought raw duck eggs , you might have noticed that many sold on the market are dirty , sometimes stuck with feathers or straw , and possibly even feces . Why are they so dirty ? Well , it’s because they absolutely cannot be washed . The pores on their shells are quite large — nearly twice the diameter of those on chicken eggs — and their surface lacks the protective cuticle layer found on chicken eggs . If you wash them like chicken eggs , these large pores become exposed , allowing bacteria to easily enter and cause them to spoil within days . This is a problem . So , how do we resolve these many shortcomings of duck eggs ? The ancients discovered a way to turn decay into magic : making century eggs ( pidan ) .

**[12:28]:** Century eggs are also known as pine-pattern eggs or preserved eggs , and are believed to have been invented during the Ming Dynasty . They wrap the duck eggs in a mixture of quicklime , wood ash , and salt , then seal them to mature for a period , turning them into century eggs . This highly alkaline environment transforms the egg white into a translucent , tea-colored gel , so it doesn't get as hard as when boiled . The yolk turns dark green and develops an ammonia-like scent . Of course , many people find this smell disgusting and aren't used to eating century eggs , but others find them delicious . At the very least , this flavor masks the fishy odor of the duck eggs , effectively turning the " fishiness " into a unique profile . This is the benefit of the century egg .

**[13:07]:** Besides making century eggs , another method is to salt-cure the duck eggs , using high salinity to suppress the fishy odor while also preventing the eggs from spoiling . In particular , since there is a lot of fat in the yolk , the salt causes this fat to coagulate into a fluid rich in fatty acids , similar to shacha sauce — this is what we often call " oily yolks . " Everyone knows how delicious this is , right ? I imagine no one can resist that . Having said all this , the question arises : why are century eggs and salted eggs generally made from duck eggs ? Why are they so rarely made with chicken eggs ? Actually , as mentioned , it's because duck egg pores are larger . With larger pores , strong alkaline agents and salt penetrate more easily , allowing for a more thorough internal reaction .

**[13:47]:** If you use chicken eggs , because their pores are too small , it's very difficult to cure them thoroughly and evenly , so you can't achieve that effect . Another point is that the fat content in duck egg yolks is the highest among poultry eggs , reaching 35 % , compared to only 26 % in chicken eggs . Therefore , it's hard for chicken eggs to ooze oil when cured ; they might end up firm and dry even after being salted , which is far inferior to duck egg yolks . This is why century eggs and salted eggs prefer using duck eggs .

**[14:14]:** Alright , having finished with duck eggs , let's talk about duck meat . The issue of meat was mentioned earlier as well . The reason chicken has such high market demand is that it is basically all white meat with no strong flavor . It is easily processed into various foods and dishes that are widely accepted by the public . However , goose and duck meat , although also poultry and generally considered white meat , have ancestors that were migratory and needed to travel long distances , so their muscle tissue has a very high myoglobin content , leaning more toward red meat . You can tell by the color of duck and goose meat , but this type of meat has a somewhat distinct flavor , so it isn't as widely used as chicken . Of course , compared to goose meat , duck meat consumption is much higher .

**[14:54]:** Duck meat accounts for about 5 % of the global meat market , and like goose meat , most of it is consumed by Chinese people . Why is that ? Because of that special flavor of duck meat , you need genuine traditional skills to make it taste good . Since China has all sorts of traditional ways of eating it , it's naturally consumed in greater quantities . Western countries don't know how to cook it or lack the dietary habit , so they naturally stick to eating chicken . That's how it is . As for what those traditional ways are , everyone is probably quite familiar with them . The first thing that comes to mind is definitely Peking duck , right ? The whole duck is roasted until it's glossy , crispy on the outside , and tender on the inside . Especially that layer of fat under the skin — it can be called the soul of Peking duck .

**[15:34]:** It might be a bit greasy to eat on its own , but after dipping it in sweet bean sauce and sugar , it's just right , then wrapped in a small pancake with shredded green onions and cucumber . So , duck meat really requires these traditional techniques and specific methods to bring out its best flavor . Besides Beijing , there's also Nanjing ; this is another place where ducks are truly cherished . For example , the famous Nanjing Salted Duck is a very delicious cold dish . The duck meat in salted duck has a particularly fresh and tender texture . Its seasoning is very simple , mainly salt and Sichuan peppercorns , which actually brings out the natural flavor of the duck , making it very unique . Besides salted duck , Nanjing also has pressed duck . Pressed duck is marinated , flattened , and then air-dried until it looks like a board , which is why it's called " board duck " — it's primarily for easy storage .

**[16:18]:** When it's time to eat , it's prepared like cured meat , usually steamed or boiled , resulting in a savory and rich flavor . Then , there is also the ginger duck mentioned earlier . This is a famous winter tonic dish from the Southern Fujian and Taiwan regions . As I mentioned just now , it is usually made with Muscovy duck . Why is that ? Because Muscovy duck meat is firmer and holds up better to boiling . It needs to be stir-fried with mature ginger and sesame oil , then simmered over low heat with rice wine and other medicinal herbs . The duck meat eventually absorbs the spicy aroma of the herbs and ginger . Eating it in cold weather has a warming tonic effect , making it perfect for winter . I bet some viewers are already eating it , right ? Of course , there are many other ways to eat duck , so I won't list them all here .

**[16:58]:** If you can think of any other famous ways to prepare it , feel free to leave a comment below and share them . Alright , that's enough about duck for now . If you like this channel , don't forget to like and subscribe so you don't lose track of us next time . Also , you are welcome to join my membership . Exclusive member programs are constantly being updated and cover many very interesting topics .

**[17:26]:** Now , for just the price of a cup of coffee , you can learn even more knowledge .
