Transcript

Use with ChatGPT / Claude Auto-scroll A

1. Documentary Doesn't Mean Truth

The hosts introduce the Theranos documentary as a meta-documentary about what we ingest from true crime media, discussing how every documentary involves editing, manipulation, and point of view, from The Staircase to the earliest films.

0:02 - 0:06
What do you think that Tyler really means?You can see everything.
0:06 - 0:10
It's interesting, right?Because does it mean that you do see everything?
0:10 - 0:11
Yeah, or that
0:11 - 0:12
possible to see everything?
0:12 - 0:22
You can see everything, just like Theranos machines can run hundreds of tests when we get the software in that way it works.
0:25 - 1:21
Well, all right.This documentary I think has maybe the best MacGuffin of all time, which is Theranos.Cuz this is not a documentary about Theranos.I mean, if you want a documentary about that, there are plenty that really go through every bit of the lore of this person, Elizabeth Holmes, this company.I think that this movie brings you in with the idea of we're going to tell you something that you haven't seen, but quickly pulls the rug out from under you and puts you into a much bigger question, whichis what are we ingesting even in those documentaries?What are we actually seeing?Who are we actually connecting with?We're in a world of murder podcasts and Netflix documentaries.We are constantly making choices.That person's good.That person's evil.We must free this person.I mean, Britney Spears is truly a perfect encapsulation of a documentary that riled up a nation.
We got her emancipated.It doesn't seem to have worked out well.
1:26 - 1:28
It might not have been the full story.
1:28 - 1:28
Right.
1:28 - 1:36
Right, because that's the thing.How are you going to get an entire human life and all the complications of it in 2 hours or it, even 3 hours?
1:36 - 1:44
I mean, even this poster is showing us something that depends on how you look at it, what you see.I mean, how many people do you see?
1:44 - 1:49
everything.You can see half of a person, then you can see half of a person behind or out of focus.
1:49 - 1:50
The third person?
1:50 - 1:51
Who's the third person?
1:51 - 2:01
Right there in the eyeball, Lance Oppenheim, right there.He is the person holding the camera.Get close.Take a look.You can see him right there.That's the There he is right there.
2:01 - 2:06
Okay, maybe I can see that.I can't see that.I can't see that.I can't see him in there.I don't know what you're talking about.
2:06 - 2:27
I do think that this is probably one of the most important pieces of work in a time where we need to kind of understand the documentary doesn't mean truth.I mean, this is a meta documentary because everybody believes they're doing their part of telling a story, but it is a story.And I remember when I watched The Staircase.Do you ever see that documentary The Staircase?
2:27 - 2:27
it isn't.
2:27 - 2:56
So The Staircase is this six to 10-part documentary about a woman who fell down the stairs in her house.Her husband said that she slipped.Other people say that he pushed her down the stairs.And there's a lot of debate about it.And you watch it and you go, oh my gosh, you know, I have an opinion about this guy.And you realize that all of a sudden I have tried this case, but I didn't know anything about the case because then other documentaries came out that showed the evidence that they omitted.
2:56 - 3:11
Well, yeah, Michel Gondry, the filmmaker Michel Gondry, he made a documentary about this idea.It was called Is the Man Who Is Tall Happy?And it was an interview with Noam Chomsky, but he made the decision to animate the entire documentary so that we're always aware of the artifice of what a documentary is.
3:11 - 3:12
Yeah.
3:12 - 3:20
lays out so right away, if I as a filmmaker record an interview with a person and even cut out one second, you're not seeing the whole story.You're not seeing the entire truth.
3:20 - 3:27
the world is a very puzzling place.If you're not willing to be puzzled, you just become a replica of someone else's mind.
3:27 - 3:49
That's essentially what Donald Trump threatened to do to CBS with 60 Minutes.Like he was playing a a game here of saying like when you edit anything, you're making decisions.But that's not untrue for anything that you possibly see.What's the first story that you see on the news?That's a decision as well.It's always kind of affecting this choice.
3:49 - 4:06
Yeah, every documentary is a decision in some way.Even the very first one, you know, train rushing into the station, 1800s.He put the train up.He knew who was walking in front of the camera.The people walking in front of the camera knew that a film was happening.Even in that little way, it's not a true documentary because people are aware that they're on camera.
4:06 - 4:11
Right.Once you put a camera in front of somebody, you are manipulating reality.
4:11 - 4:13
You are inviting a person to become an actor.
4:13 - 4:26
And when you're an actor, you're a liar.And I do think this movie's larger premise is we all lie, but how do we justify the lies that we tell to each other?Because
4:26 - 4:28
Are you saying you're a liar?
4:28 - 4:50
I think that everyone is a liar.And I don't mean that in a bad way.It's like like the way that Amanda Seyfried talked about her performance.She's like, well, it's fiction.Well, but is it fiction?I don't think that many people would tell you that The Dropout is a fictionalized account.I think it was a movie based on these events, right?And she's like, well, that's just fiction.It's like, well, but to most people, they would take that as fact.And then, you know
4:50 - 4:53
then that's an audience literacy problem.And then my whole
4:53 - 5:08
no, no.But I think when you're doing an autobiography of somebody, again, it's through a lens.You are making these choices.Everything that is made for entertainment on any level, even news, is filtered through a point of view.That's what makes good entertainment.
5:08 - 5:13
Okay.So you can see everything is announcing this?Cuz it's like
5:13 - 5:14
never see everything.
5:14 - 5:14
But that's the thing.

2. The Meaning of 'Can' and Manipulation

The group unpacks the title's thesis around the word 'can,' Elizabeth Holmes's language games, and how Nathan Fielder, Holmes, and her partner Billy are all manipulating each other and the footage itself.

That title is drawing attention to the fact that that can is a really iffy, wobbly word.
5:19 - 5:35
That can is the whole thesis of the film, right?That's really where Nathan and Lance are kind of interrogating the Theranos stuff.I think Theranos again, not important.But it comes down to can this machine do it or does it have the ability to do it?
5:35 - 5:43
Well, right.Like the analogy that I used in my head to understand that whole Theranos thing was if I said, I can bench press you.
5:43 - 5:43
Right.
5:43 - 5:48
When I work up to the ability to bench press you by starting to lift weights now.
5:48 - 5:50
100% So and
5:50 - 5:50
what can means.
5:50 - 6:31
And there is this kind of constant battle of how language can be justified by your perspective.Now, I don't think that Elizabeth Holmes went to jail because of can and could.I think that that is like the most basis level of it.I mean, Nathan Fielder even said before he went to even do this, he told her, I think you're guilty, right?So he is not going there to be slayed.I think he's going there to kind of understand what she's going through.And I think that she's manipulating him.I think that he's manipulating her.I think that then the footage is being manipulated.And then you have somebody else, which is Elizabeth Holmes's partner, who's also trying to manipulate the story that they're telling.
6:31 - 6:38
Right, but you can see everything of him.Why do you think this documentary has a fully nude shot of Billy, her partner?
6:38 - 6:46
I don't want to say anything untoward, but that guy did a lot of sniffing, and I think there's a couple decisions there.Whether it was the Celsius is talking
6:46 - 6:47
Yeah.
6:47 - 6:51
or maybe it's just the testosterone coming out.Like I think that he was challenging them.
6:51 - 7:05
Well, yeah.I think he's saying you can see everything.You want to put this on camera?And I think Nathan Fielder was saying, All right, I'll put this on camera to show that you did tell me I can see everything.It feels like that shot is them letting the audience know they're serious.
7:05 - 7:07
Come jump in with me, hm?
7:07 - 7:09
You asking me to go?
7:09 - 7:10
Yeah.
7:11 - 7:29
Nathan Fielder and Lance decided we will only release this if we can find something interesting about the story because the Fielder story has been told.And what they realized after a couple of days of shooting was we don't even know what we're getting.Everyone is coming back from the shoot day being like, what just happened?
7:29 - 7:30
Right.
7:30 - 7:31
And that's the movie.
7:31 - 7:33
her when she said this?Yes, no.And nobody could agree.
7:33 - 7:38
Well, what about you?Do you believe that she doesn't understand who's on first?

3. The Fielder Method and Three Elizabeths

They debate whether Holmes truly understands 'Who's on First,' explore Fielder's method of mimicry, the three versions of Elizabeth in the film, and how the movie plays like a Western and film noir, echoing Vertigo.

7:38 - 7:39
No.
7:39 - 7:40
I don't either.
7:40 - 7:45
No.How can you not?Because here's why I don't believe it.He explains the joke to her.
7:45 - 7:46
Mhm.
7:46 - 7:54
And she doesn't go, oh, I get it now.She just looks at him like he's still speaking Martian.Like a normal person would be like, I get it, right?
7:54 - 8:06
well, here's the thing.When you go back, and this is where the movie is trying to be as honest as it can be, she was looking for Oh.Really wish we had maybe nailed them to the wall, yeah.
8:06 - 8:08
Well, I wish we had a management
8:08 - 8:09
that gave a damn.
8:09 - 8:12
You know, they don't want to mess up their walls with nails.
8:12 - 8:16
Nails?I'll nail them.I'll nail them.Do we have nails?I'll nail them.
8:16 - 8:30
don't nail them.It's going to keep on dropping.Now, the only reason why this documentary exists is because the subjects of the documentary wanted a documentary about them.So that's already a skewed perspective.They know they're on camera and they want to tell their story.
8:30 - 8:44
And I believe they have full faith that Elizabeth can snake charm whoever the interviewer is, right?And can I say, I think that's why they chose Nathan Fielder, not knowing that much about him.I think they thought And this is this is me getting inside their brain.This is me guessing.
8:44 - 8:45
Yeah.
8:45 - 8:49
I think they thought that dork, he's going to fall in love with her.
8:49 - 8:58
It's interesting because I think that Nathan often plays a guy who falls for women in his pieces.And I do think that that is an act.
8:58 - 9:00
I love you.
9:02 - 9:34
Again, right?A lot of people have gone around like, oh, Nathan fell in love with her and he was duped.I don't think so.I think he was intrigued.I think that when you look at Nathan watching her Again, we got to get better tape.He is fascinated with her like a magician is fascinated with another magician.He's like, wait a second.I'm really curious about what you're doing cuz it doesn't look to me like he's falling in love.I think he's impressed by her commitment to the bit.And his commitment to the bit is solid.I mean, all goes back to the Fielder method.
9:34 - 9:39
With this show, if your performance isn't accurate, you could ruin someone's life.
9:39 - 9:40
Are you familiar with the Fielder method?
9:40 - 9:44
Yes, but I want you to describe it to me.Actor, actor, tell me about the Fielder method.
9:44 - 10:30
All right.So I'm fascinated by the Fielder method because his idea was the only way to really understand a subject is by following them, mimicking their physical actions.And then by mimicking their physical actions, you can get into their mental state.And then when you're in their mental state, you can actually see what it's like to be this person.And we see that as the documentary continues, he creates these reenactments.And the only person to really be able to reenact Elizabeth Holmes is a person who's already paid to do it.Amanda Seyfried, who did a great job in The Dropout, which was a, I guess now a scripted or fictionalized account as she says, TV, which I thought was one of the funniest justifications about acting.I said, well, that's it's not a movie, it's TV.So of course we could lie.There's three Elizabeths in this movie.
There's Elizabeth Holmes, right?Then you have the version of Elizabeth Holmes created by Amanda.But then you also have the version of Elizabeth Holmes created by Nathan for Amanda to play.So that's three different versions, three different writers, if you will.I mean, there's no writer for the original Elizabeth Holmes.
10:48 - 11:09
I mean, I think that's really true.And one of the things that I put a little mental asterisk on is that one of the great big Elizabeth monologues at the end of this movie is delivered by Amanda reenacting what Nathan says that Elizabeth said inprison with no recording.We're kind of taking his word that that's what she said.And it's a long monologue.
11:09 - 11:42
a long monologue and it's also a monologue that he's not even sure that he got right because as they talk about this, Amanda's challenging him, his memory.And I think this is all incredibly deliberate.I think that anyone who believes that this film was released kind of in happenstance.No, he's making very clear choices.I think that he's creating a narrative of falling for her because it's an easier story to tell.Like when he's in New York and saying, oh, I just got out of a breakup and I'm here.He's baiting her.When he stands so close to her, it looks like they're going to kiss.
11:42 - 11:51
Right.That's the camera man as well making you feel attention between them.Because I would say that this is not even it doesn't play like a documentary to me.
11:51 - 11:52
it's a meta documentary.
11:52 - 12:12
plays like other genres.I would say the first half of the film plays like a western, like a showdown between two people who are like the greatest BSers of all time.The way that the camera is cutting back and forth between like her eyes, his eyes, her eyes, his eyes.It's like that part in The Good, the Bad and the Ugly when you're cutting between eyeballs and who's going to shoot first.
12:12 - 12:12
This is
12:12 - 12:26
a movie that is basically faces.I mean, he's using these zoom lenses from across the room and is just living in these very, very tight close-ups.So it's a very intimate setting between two people, but it makes it even more intimate in the theater.
12:26 - 12:36
Exactly.And then when she goes into prison, it shifts into film noir, right?It becomes closer to something like Vertigo.You're hearing the score shift into music
12:36 - 12:38
Oh, I mean the score is very similar.Yeah.
12:38 - 12:58
And what's Vertigo about?Vertigo is about like a man obsessed with a woman, but is it the real woman?And who is the real woman?And is it that woman or that woman?And who is acting to him?And who's the truth?And who's he obsessed with?It becomes Vertigo.You hear it.It looks like it.The shots of him driving through Texas.It's Vertigo.So it's a documentary, but it's really a Western plus noir.
12:58 - 13:12
I find that really interesting.And this is why I'm furious that Amanda can't win best actress because she's not in a documentary.She is in a documentary, but I mean, I guess it's a little bit half and half, all right?I mean, that's that's an acting performance.

4. Media Literacy and the Lies We Believe

The discussion turns to our cultural hunger for villains and heroes, the New York Times reporting dispute, murder podcasts, and the ocean scene reveal that teaches audiences they cannot trust their own eyes.

13:12 - 13:21
Well, it is.And you know what I keep thinking when I was watching it too is she is sort of doing her version of The Dropout, but it's also Amanda doing The Housemaid.
13:21 - 13:21
Yes.
13:21 - 13:30
Did you see The Housemaid?It's where she's like a It's basically like a noir, a modern noir about like a woman who's married to a man who might be manipulating her and we as the audience don't even know what the truth is.
13:30 - 14:07
Well, I think that we also are in a culture right now where we love judgment.We want a villain.We want a hero.We want a bad guy.And I feel like Amanda did something that's really interesting, which is she articulates the audience's POV in this movie about Billy at least, right?And I love the way that she talks about, oh, I can be so smooth and charming.People love me.And then immediately once she's in that room with him, she goes at him so hard because she is biased.We all are biased.And I guess maybe to go back to my original theory, it's not that we all lie, but I do think we all lie.It's that we all are you never lie.
14:07 - 14:10
I've never told a single lie.I do think that that but that idea
14:10 - 14:15
a do that more convincingly even to you.I've never told a single lie.Why would I lie to you?
14:15 - 14:15
I
14:15 - 14:31
mean, and that to me, to hold the line on that.And when you look at, truly, when you look at any facts about Theranos, and this is what the movie does so brilliantly, is it takes away all those facts.There's so many times that she lied.It's aggressive.It's so over the top.So
14:31 - 14:42
Yeah, the way that in this movie even she's like, I don't care about money.I never care about money.The book about her, Bad Blood, is just like, I want money.I want money.I want money.I want money in print already.
14:42 - 14:51
Well, speaking about in print, another big theory about this movie is what was said to the New York Times, right?You have a reporter who's standing by one journalistic thought process that
14:51 - 14:52
Chozick.
14:52 - 15:56
Okay, Amy Chozick, who stands behind her reporting and said that Elizabeth Holmes said to her that she created this character.And then Elizabeth Holmes says she'd never said that.But yet no one has the audio tape and they both stand by what they said.And I think that what this movie does is something that I'm really passionate about is it's teaching us media literacy in the most entertaining way.Why are you believing this?When everyone believed that Adnan, you know, didn't kill his girlfriend.Remember this like Serial, the first season Serial?And remember Sarah fell in love with him.Like you you felt that they had this connection, right?And everyone was like, oh my gosh.And and that is this.You know, we are constantly in this battle of trying to be saviors, trying to be heroes.I I'm always blown away by this want to hear more murder podcasts because these modern day horror stories and we're diluting everything and we're profiting off of the death of people because it's entertaining.
Oh, what happened?What what's going on here?And we're
15:59 - 16:02
You're telling me that if you got murdered you wouldn't want a podcast about it?
16:02 - 16:03
No way.
16:03 - 16:05
You wouldn't want a murder podcast, the death of Paul Shearer?
16:05 - 16:09
No, because I don't know what version they're telling of me.There's a great podcast.
16:09 - 16:10
What if I wrote it?
16:10 - 16:38
I would let you do it.I can't remember the name of the podcast and what a great way for me to kind of kick this off.But there is a a story about this woman who went missing.And they start investigating it.And everyone, oh, I saw her leave her house that day.Oh, I saw this.I saw that.Now, what it comes out at the end is her boyfriend murdered her, put her in the back of his truck, drove out to the desert, and that was it.But when you talk to all the witnesses, they had completely different stories.
16:38 - 17:16
Well, that's the thing.I think one thing that you can see everything gets out really well is that we as the audience think we're seeing something that we're not seeing, right?Because you have this shot in the movie, Elizabeth in the water playing with a guy, frolicking in the ocean.And you you think it's Billy.You're convinced it's Billy, right?Because of where it's put in the movie, because we've also seen her in the ocean already with her family, you just assume that it's Billy.And so Nathan Fielder's reveal later on that it's actually him and that he lied to us on camera when he edited it and said, I won't get in the water.It's too cold.He withheld that until the right moment.He's telling us we cannot trust our eyes in this own movie.
17:16 - 17:25
Right.I think that's what's so genius about it is like we're hearing all these things from so many different people.What is the reason?Why are they telling me this?What is the true story?

5. Privilege, Guilt, and Documentary's Future

The hosts consider Holmes's privilege, the noir dynamic between her and Billy, why their cooperation with the film suggests performance, and conclude that documentaries are forever changed by this film.

I will say that there's been a lot of discussion about why people would believe Elizabeth Holmes, but I do keep on saying it's bigger.I think that yes, she has a privilege.You know, I I don't think this Elizabeth Holmes story happens with any woman of color.And I think that she's blonde and she is white just like you.And you can get away with anything.
17:48 - 17:50
We've never told lies.
17:50 - 17:56
But no, but there is a thing of wanting to like protect the purity of this.Well, she couldn't have been this malicious.
17:56 - 18:12
Well, I mean, a long time ago on the first season of our podcast, we did Double Indemnity.We did a bunch of noirs.And I think they follow a lot of this movie same template.Blonde girl says she needs help.Guy who's like, I'll be a little crooked for you, baby.You know, and she's setting up a patsy.I'm saying that that's her and Billy.
18:12 - 18:13
Oh, yes.I mean, I
18:13 - 18:15
I kind of feel like she's setting up Billy to take the fall.
18:15 - 18:19
But I also believe that Billy believes that he's setting her up.Like it's
18:19 - 18:22
Fred McMurray thought too.Yeah.They're soulmates in a
18:22 - 18:24
So it's a little bit of
18:24 - 18:25
they're a good couple.
18:25 - 19:14
So in a in a weird way, it's High Noon meets Double Indemnity in a doc format.I mean, right?Cuz you have the standoff and that's when the movie gets interesting is when they realize we can't reconcile this.So where do we go from here?Like the first half an hour is like, okay, this is going to be an interesting documentary.It's weird.But when it goes further, you start to realize that everything that you've ever known about this case is bias.You can have your opinions about it, but you're getting it from all these different sources.And we should look at everything because now new stories and stories like hers have become entertainment.They are the things that we are tuning into.Have you heard that podcast?Have you watched that doc?And we want to talk about it and we want to talk about these people like they don't exist.
And that's why I don't like the murder podcast.I'm fascinated by that that producer who might have killed his wife.It's like a news producer and the door was locked from the inside.And there's a documentary is like making it very clear that he did it.And I'm like, what would happen to that guy?Like when your friends start to see it, it's like you're constantly living in this world where if you weren't found guilty by a jury of your peers, you will be found guilty by a documentary crew that will thatwill affect more than your peers, a giant audience.
19:44 - 20:05
Well, you're going to love your murder podcast.I mean, you won't be around to hear it.You're going to really love it.You're going to think it's the greatest.I mean, I will say I think the biggest strike for me as a viewer about thinking Elizabeth Holmes is guilty is just that this documentary exists.Because if you only have a couple weeks left with your partner, and more specifically, your young kids, do you want Nathan Fielder in your house?
20:05 - 20:06
No.
20:06 - 20:07
Exactly.
20:07 - 20:10
And and they invite him in.And they have journals open.
20:10 - 20:16
leave.They they're like he's like, I should give you guys some conjugal time.Oh, you don't have to.
20:16 - 20:16
No.
20:16 - 20:19
That's not real human reactions, right?
20:19 - 21:12
to manipulate a master manipulator.And I think that what I love about this at the end of the day is it's saying everything is Everything is It's insane.And I mean we would get into the idea of like them even being paid for it, but I don't even think that that's necessarily the most interesting part.I mean I think it begs the question of are people being paid for their participation?We have seen like the Harry and Megan documentaries.We've seen, you know, the documentary of Eddie Murphy.I think Eddie Murphy was a producer on we start to see these like docs produced by the subjects.That's weird.But to any documentarian out there, the gauntlet's been thrown.You can't just make another documentary now.I think documentaries are forever changed.I do because how can you not put it through a lens of going how do I convince my audience that this is just not my point of view versus what the truth is?
Because we've started to take documentary as the truth.
21:16 - 21:18
Well then let me ask you this.When your murder podcast
21:18 - 21:18
Mhm.
21:18 - 21:20
becomes a murder show,
21:20 - 21:20
Mhm.
21:20 - 21:21
who do you want to play you?
21:21 - 21:40
Oh, that's easy.Corey Stoll if I want to do, you know, something that has a little bit more gravitas or you know, I would even be open to David Cross.You know, honestly there's a lot of a lot of great bald men out there, but chances are if it's a Hollywood movie, they're going to get a haired man and they're just going to put a bald cap onhim.Nicholas Hoult, I see you.Damn it.
Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Nathan's Subliminal Message Changes Everything