1. The Experiment Concept and Four Aesthetics
The creator introduces his illegal Hinge catfishing experiment: launching multiple dating profiles with different aesthetics (red flag villain, soft boy, gamer, finance bro) to see which attracts the most women and what types of women each attracts.
I've never seen this much motion on Hinge before.The fact that there are literally multiple versions of me on Hinge right now.This profile got 52 likes in 11 hours.I am running an illegal catfishing operation on the world's biggest dating app and it is way harder than you might think.Oh my god, it happened.Your account has been removed prohibiting impersonation or misrepresentation.But to explain how I got here, I have to take you guys back to the question that I asked myself two weeks ago.Is there just one aesthetic of a man that attracts the most women?Like if the same guy made four different dating profiles with four different aesthetics and launched them all at the exact same time, which one do women actually pick?But more importantly, can you tell anything about the girls that the guys might attract?Let's find out.
First, we need to pick the four aesthetics.I decided to make the first aesthetic a boy.So, we have a red flag villain.He's been to every rooftop bar in the city and hasn't texted back since Tuesday because he's busy texting his ex.He's Justin Lam.And honestly, he's probably been in your friend's DMs.Now, Justin has one role in this experiment.To answer the question, can you girls really resist the playboy douchebag who they know isn't good for them?But since we have a boy who is screaming red flag, we also need its counterpart.There needs to be a green flag.He makes matcha at home and goes to therapy to learn how to be more emotionally intelligent.His name is Elliot Chell.He calls his mom every weekend to tell her that he loves her, but he has one problem with the ladies.
He's just too sweet.Now, if you think he's too sweet, wait until you meet Brian.He'll fix your Wi-Fi, your resume, and your entire code base before he even learns your name.And trust me, you don't have to worry about Brian cheating on you with a girl at a club on the weekend because he's too busy at home or at a PC cafe playing League of Legends while simultaneously bycoding his app to cure cancer.Enter Andrew.He wakes up at 5:00 a.m.to read about the markets and he always wears his Rolex.Now, Andrew's got aura.I have a feeling he will do pretty well because he's confident, he clearly can afford the city, and he can definitely take care of the girl and provide for her.But now that we have our four aesthetics, we need to find the photos that represent him well by scouring Pinterest.
And the most important part of dating apps are good photos.So it is absolutely imperative that I find a highly skilled photographer who knows how to take the right angles with the right lighting and understands the female gaze.Oh wait, that's just any woman.So second, we hire any of my female friends to take photos of me.And after we get all the photos, we'll get on Hinge, launch all the profiles at the exact same time, and watch as all the data comes in.And don't worry, I'm going to do something with that data.I'm going to create a big sexy presentation at the end of this video to show you guys who got the most likes and answer any questions and assumptions that we might have about the modern dating world.
Hey, whatever happens in just be yourself.Just kind of like tapping into that.Tap into that juicy side of your
But this is not going to be easy.There are constantly bots trying to join these dating apps, and with the rise of AI image generation, security has been tighter than ever.Hinge has even made face verification mandatory whenever you want to join the app.Like who the hell would even bother creating fake profiles to catfish people anyways on Hinge?Anyways, this is going to be really hard to pull off.So I just spent the last 4 hours basically planning outfits and pictures for all four profiles.Now I have to make sure that these photos look like they're being taken on different days in different locations.Otherwise, it screams fake profile.
2. Photo Shoots and Profile Setup Logistics
He and his friend Yvon shoot photos across the city for each persona, juggling multiple phones and eSIMs, and standardize profile details like age (27), height (6 ft), and relationship goals for a fair comparison.
Okay, so first stop, we're going to this bookstore over here, Rizzoli.
We're going to be taking two photos here, one for Brian and one for Elliot.And I had to shamelessly change in the middle of the bookstore, but you got to do what you got to do, you know?Now here's where I ran into my first problem.To have multiple Hinge accounts, you have to have multiple phone numbers, emails, and phones.Now one of my friends, Efon, who's actually helping me take these photos right now, just happened to have four phones lying around because she does a lot of brand deals with Samsung.But the problem is none of them have data or their own phone numbers.So, we're going to have to figure out how to get that some other way.Which means I need to buy e-sims for all of these phones.Like, bro.But, luckily for the sponsor of this video, we got them.
Yeah, that that would have been a perfect place to like insert like a e-sim sponsor, you know?But, yeah, I am 100% in the red for this video.But, anyways, after we finished our photo shoot at the bookstore, I decided to head over to the pizza shop.I just got some pepperoni pizza.
We need to get Elliot a pizza picture.
3 2 1 Don't actually bite it.3 2 1
Now, that's when I realized that I was supposed to get two more photos for Brian.So, I begged Yvon to give me a little bit more time.Currently at gaming cafe.
It's actually funny cuz I used to be a huge gamer in high school.Like, I used to be hella addicted to League of Legends.I think I've genuinely spent 3,000 hours on that game.
Last photo that Yvon is going to help me with.She's so tired.Um, I'm going to be playing Switch on the subway.Oh my god, we only took like six.Yvon is the goat.Um, she really
So, although we're creating different profiles to make sure that one profile doesn't get an unfair advantage, we need to make three things the same.Number one, they all need to be looking for a long-term relationship, but they're open to a short.This is probably the most serious dating app.So, in order to maximize the number of likes that we can get, we also need to be looking for something more serious.If we only say long-term relationship, then it might scare away any short-term casual daters.So, long-term relationship open to short is probably the most optimal for getting the most number of likes.Now, second thing we need to keep the same is our age.
Question is, how old should Elliot, Andrew, Brian, and Justin be?I feel like a lot of girls my age, I'm 24 by the way, like they don't want to go like at 30 because that's a little too old.So, I decided to go with lucky number 27 because I feel like that's within the range of younger age demographic, but at the same time, the older ladies around like 30 or 31, it'll also be within range forthem to to say yes to.I also think that personally the way that I look, I feel like I don't know if I could pass off as somebody who's 30.I swear if y'all are cooking me in the comments right now telling me that I look 30, I I'm going to be so mad for real.Now, in terms of height, I'm exactly like 181 or 182 cm.
6 ft is 183 cm.So, I'm right under 6 ft and I know I I I hate it.I hate it.I used to put 5'11" on Hinge, but a lot of girls actually pay for Hinge Premium just so that they could filter out anybody who's below 6 ft.If we're under 6 ft, we're actually limiting a lot of our options.So, I decided to put every guy at 6 ft.
It sounds a lot like the truth.I'm like, for real, closer.I'm pretty much 6 ft, guys.I'm pretty much 6 ft.
3. Day Two Shoots and Bypassing Verification
With a new helper, he finishes the remaining photo shoots, nervously attempts Hinge's face verification fearing a repeat of his past ban, and successfully verifies the test profile, getting the first like.
All right, this is day two of taking all my photos and today I have a magical helper.
You might know her as the fan Sukuna.
EXCEPT I'M WEARING A SHIRT.
OH, is that actually like the
Oh, Wait, so your comments are like
Sukuna doesn't wear a shirt.Sukuna doesn't wear a shirt.
Bro, that's so bad.Oh my god.
it come true.Don't put out there.
What?So, the first thing me and Charlie did was go to a matcha cafe to finish taking photos for Elliott and Brandon.Excuse me, this is going to be a really weird question.Can I quickly borrow your glasses for a quick picture?I'm trying to like make like a Hinge profile.Thank you so much.Thank you so much, man.I appreciate it.I'll be right back.
Thank you so much, man.I appreciate it.
I honestly I think finance bros will win, too.Not in like some weird but I feel like the girls are on dating apps.Not like four finance bros, but I feel like that's the ideal type you're on Hinge and swiping.
That's true.We just finished doing the finance bro shoot.These were some of the photos that we had.Okay, now we're getting to the good stuff.I Amazon ordered all of these for the ABB shoot.Fake tattoos.
That's like hardcore ABB.
Now, while we were putting on these tattoos, I was still thinking about my biggest obstacle, the selfie verification.Oh, Oh, Now, I'm going to let you guys in on a little bit of a secret.Um your boy's been banned on Hinge before.Ashamed of it, but man enough to say it.I have been banned before and I've tried to get back on it.
Oh my god, I'm so scared.
It was over a year ago and I used a completely different phone number.If you've never used Hinge before, by the way, you tend to get shown to more people if you are a verified person.Because I wanted to get more likes, I decided to get verified on my re-ban while using one of my friend's numbers.I did the verification and then a few hours later I got banned.But this is a completely new phone with a different phone number and different Wi-Fi.Hopefully they don't store my biometric data and instantly ban me.Cuz if so, this experiment is so I know it was over a year ago, but I'm still terrified.As soon as I scan that first phone, boom, it's over.
Wait, it doesn't instantly ban you though, right?
We'll we'll wait like 5 minutes and then hop back on to see whether or not this works.
What the is the up right now?Can you guess which photos we're doing right now?
What is this the gamer nerd, right?
Finance bro after 12:00 p.m.12:00 a.m.I mean.
What did I do to deserve this?Is this sick or what?
Oh, Wait, the neck one is actually kind of insane.Okay, not going to lie.I thought it was going to be way riskier than what you were going to come in with.
interrupted my nap for this Are you kidding me?
Update.Um we are verified.And we got our first like.Oh my god.
I I need I need to pause this profile actually cuz we need to start all of it at the same time for experimental purposes.Let's go.We got the first one.Ready.I hope this doesn't get banned.
4. Launch Day, Bans, and Early Results
After scrapping the gamer profile due to a locked phone, he launches the remaining profiles simultaneously. The finance bro account is quickly banned, leaving soft boy Elliot and villain Justin, with one profile pulling in 52 likes in 11 hours.
Which means that the only thing left is to finish taking our ABB photos and we can get these profiles launched.
We have the leather jacket on.We're going to do it off camera, but just keep in mind for this picture, I am not actually smoking the cigarette, okay?
Oh I got a good one.Good.You got a good one, too.
Okay, stop walking and like turn to your left a little bit.Yes.
Oh yeah, that's good.Yo, why are we giving ABB like such good photos?
Right?Because it's so doable.It's because it's so performative.
of me was still shaking in my boots.Even though the verification went through, I can still be found by Hinge in the next few hours or in the morning.Just like I did that very first time I got banned.I'm just going to check whether or not this Hinge account has been banned yet.Before we closed it last night, there's a We actually got two likes instead of one.The first one already says, "Hello, are you sure you're Elliot?"Oh my god.Now that we got the test profile verified, we just needed to set up the three other accounts.But that's when I ran into my next obstacle.Man, there are so many steps to this process, bro.We have one phone with a SIM card here, one phone here that has a SIM card, but the freaking Wi-Fi doesn't work.So, I have to bring it back to T-Mobile.
This one has Hinge set up.It also has a SIM card that works.Great.But there's one problem.This last phone over here has a password to it.And unfortunately, my friend Yvonne who gave me all these Samsungs forgot her password for it.So, we can't get it.As you can see over here, too many attempts.We have to wait 50 minutes for it, and I can't even hard reset it because you need the password to hard reset it.At this point, I need to get all the hinge set up.What we're going to do is we're actually just going to scrap the gamer guy.We had to scrap Brian, and we're only going to have finance, AVB, and soft boy.But, it's okay.It's okay.If there's anybody to scrap, it would be Brian because, honestly, like I think this guy would have gotten smoked by the three other profiles.
It's very unfortunate, but this isn't going to stop us, and let's still set the profile up.Little did I know that was not the last obstacle I had to face.We're going to use Claude right now.I'm putting basically like the archetype, and we're going to have Claude basically answer all the hinge prompts for us so that we don't have to do it.Thirsty photo.Oh my god, I look like such a boy in this, dude.All right.We got the photos.Yo, this is so boy, bruh.I'm looking for someone who can keep up.I go crazy for
you.I cried watching Toy Story 5.Oh, that is good.And after a whole combined 60 minutes of setting up all these profiles, we finally had all the profiles set up.And now, the moment we've all been waiting for is time to go live.I launched all the profiles at the exact same time, and now we just sit and wait and let everything roll in.We officially went live about 20 minutes ago.I have spent so much effort and so much work in the last few days literally just prepping for this, and I swear to god if it gets banned literally tomorrow, I will be so upset.Cross our fingers and really hope to god that it doesn't get banned, but it is currently 12:00 p.m.on the next day, and I open one of the phones, Andrew, the finance bro, and this is what I saw.
Your account has been removed for We're our terms of service.Oh my god, it didn't get verified and it was like uh for some reason it wasn't working and then now Oh my god, it like immediately dropped.That means I only have two accounts left.Oh my god, bro, after all this work.But that's okay because the show must go on.Let's check what the other two have right now.I can't believe this went from like five profiles originally to down to two just because of how strict Hinge is.Honestly, it kind of worked out because if there were two profiles that I wanted to be left in the competition, it had to be the soft boy and the boy.I grew up watching Ryan Higa who made this song
Does the nice guy really finish last?Yes, I had my League of Legends phase, I had my Boston College finance bro phase, but I feel like I'm a philosophical romantic at heart that really fits that soft boy persona.But I also feel like I like to go out and party a lot.So when I checked the next day and found out that there was one profile that was overwhelmingly pulling in way more likes than the other.This profile got 52 likes in 11 hours.Yeah, I was shocked.But you know what?Let's just show you guys.
5. Live Presentation of Experiment Results
In front of a live audience, he reveals which photos and prompts won, analyzes the traits of women attracted to each persona, and shows that Elliot the nice guy beat Justin the villain, even hitting Hinge's 'standouts' before both accounts were banned.
Hey guys, so much for coming.I know this was a Thank you guys.Thank you guys.For the past month I have been working on a very big project, a Hinge experiment.So I decided to run the question that I've been wondering for literally since high school, do nice guys really finish last?Today we're going to find out.Let's start.Let me introduce you guys to Justin.
You mildly bully me then ask me This is a the red flag.This is the boy.This guy has probably DM'd all your friends before.
And Shut the up, bro.So with the villain you need to have a counterpart.Um so meet Elliot.This is the good boy.This is the soft boy, the the good gentleman guy who probably gets friend zoned for being a little too sweet.Let's Let's ask some questions.I have some jellies today for any rewards.Out of Out of a show of hands here, um I'm curious like you guys could just blurt out which photo do you guys think was liked the most?
Wait, right side this this one?This this one?
This one this one?All right all right.Make some noise.Make some noise when I hover over the photo if you think that THIS ONE WON.
OKAY, WHAT ABOUT THIS ONE?OKAY, OKAY.SO, it's mainly between this one and this one, huh?
No, actually Shirley those two those two Shirley and Ethan right over here the most amazing photographers that helped me with most of these.Shout out to them.Thank you guys so much for helping me.And shout out to Ethan for for your extra phones as well to conduct this experiment.Um but yeah, let's start with the least popular photo.The elevator photo.
Photos 5 and 6 photos they they got a tie at 10%.Um these two.Out of curiosity let's run this one more time.Which one got the most likes?I want a show of hands.This is another opportunity to win a jelly.Raise your hand if you think this is the the photo with the most likes.
Wow.Wow, okay.Raise your hand if you think this photo has the most likes.Okay, clearly nobody thought it was this photo, right?So, in third place we got the female gaze as as you guys as you guys believe.
Well, apparently I thought this was like the most mid photo ever.It's like if you're holding my hand or something, it kind of looks like I'm your boyfriend.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.With 20% of the likes, in second place we got the thirst trap.AND IN FIRST PLACE, WE GOT the winner.So, raise your hand one more time if you guys voted the winner.
Wait, yo, who gave you that leather jacket?
Uh thank you, Daniel.I appreciate it.But, I don't think you voted
you call a bottom of funnel like conversion event.Yeah, you want to swipe on the the face one.
Uh let's run through this one more time.Um the lowest number of likes was the dog photo.It was the one Yo, Yifan Yifan was hella shocked, bro.She took that one.
Hey, look at the dog.It looks like a disease, though.What's wrong with that?
It's like a fish that's like flopping on the
I'm sorry, bad comment.I'll All right, I'll delete the comment.
All right.We got we got another tie, the performative photos here.Um and then, these are our top three photos.So, one more time, let's get a little guess.Let's get a little guess.
All right, raise your hand for the flowers.Raise your Raise your hand for the feeding one.
Okay, raise your hand for the pizza.
So obvious.Okay, okay, okay.All right.Well,
No, it's not the ice cream.
Yeah, it's the ice cream.It's the ice cream one.All right, so what did we learn, guys?What did we learn?What did we learn from this?What do you guys think?
Hinge is unfair for Prosper to you.
Guys, we learned to keep our shirt on.We got to keep the shirt on, okay?That's what we learned.That's what we learned.Um we're going to jump into what type of girls that these uh guys attract.So, starting off with Justin's prompts, I feel like I intentionally made one very red flag.I made one mildly red flag.Text all night, flirt all day, and tell everybody we're just friends.And this last one is kind of neutral.You mildly bullied me then act innocent about it all night.This one got the most likes.And this is what a lot of the women said.
Yeah, 38 women wrote something.
Of course not.It was It was purely FOR EXPERIMENT.
UM SO I LOOKED AT ALL THESE UH all of these prompts and then I analyzed three major characteristics that that these women all have in common.Um they're women that want to play games.
Yes.So, first of all first off, we have bold.These girls are like probably the most forward women that I've ever seen on a dating app before.They try to start the first move.Second, we have playful.So, playful and bold kind of go hand in hand.What that means is like a
Yo, I don't have enough playful examples, bro.Chill.Holy Uh high maintenance.So, this is the last one.Uh Girls who kind of feel like they you know, they deserve it a little bit.And now for Elliot.
I'm kind of curious, like out of the guys here, which one do you guys think is the most uh liked prompt here?The song one?
I like two.I like number two.
You you like What What one is two?Which one is two?
Okay, raise your hand.Raise your hand for uh the two truths and a lie.Okay, we got uh six seven Okay, eight eight votes.Oh, nine votes.Oh, wow.Yo, Jeffrey, you changed your vote.Yo, vote.All right.Who Who voted Who voted for the song?Nobody.
Wow.Uh bookstore?Only Charles.Wow.All right.I'm curious, what do the women think?What What do the ladies think?
I would respond to the two truths and a lie.
And I would be like, I bet you can't beat me.
In Mario Kart?Yeah.Okay.What would you say?
Like, oh, I love Like, let's go.
so nobody No woman would respond to the uh the sauna 2:00 a.m.Okay.Well, that is correct.THAT is correct.Most number of likes was the Mario Kart one, and then right afterwards, it was the bookstore date.It's It's a very tough battle.Now, there were a lot of mays out there, I will say.There were a few mays out there.You're actually terrible at Mario Kart.Um I'm insanely good at Mario Kart.You won't beat me.
So, yeah, the the three traits these women all have in common I would say are uh competitive, intentional, and romantic.I had to make three up, guys.Starting with competitive, we got the Mario Kart.
Okay.In second, we have intentional.Now, this one honestly, forget about the prompts.I just looked at the willingness to say long-term relationship.Justin had 68%.Elliot had close to 90%.It was very, very different.In third, we got romantic.A lot of these girls like can picture the date.They can imagine it.And that was like their main response to to some of these.
None of these are romantic.
Yo!House fence is kind of romantic, though.Yo, it's kind of romantic.
Justin versus Elliot.Which one got more likes on Hinge?All right.Let's do a
Wait, are Are these matches or likes?
So, they approach you first?
Yes.Yes.Yes.Yes.Oh.Oh, if you guys don't know how Hinge works, if they see you on the profile, they can send you a like.You don't have to say yes, but if you say yes, you guys do a little match.Yeah.Yeah.Yeah.So, let's raise our Let's
Who thinks that the winner is Justin?
Oh, we got we got 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Oh.Oh, 10.Oh, this is very split.Okay.All right.All right, who thinks who thinks it's Elliot?1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Not 9.Okay.Wow, it's 9 to 10.That's a very even split.Well, let me tell you guys the winner the winner of this is as soon as he joined he hit standouts.
Do you guys know Do you guys know what standouts is?Yes, yes.For for my hinge newbies for my hinge newbies, standout is a feed where hinge will throw literally the most beautiful profiles the ones that get the most attention and the most likes onto this little bar over here.You can only send a rose to get their attention which actually costs money.
So, it's literally pay to win.Wait, and how DO YOU
SO, WITHIN 42 HOURS this profile actually got banned.Both got recognized as Prosper and reported for impersonation or misrepresentation.So, what I'm going to do I'm going to do one final show of hands.Who guessed Justin again?OH.
OKAY.KEEP YOUR HANDS UP.Keep your hands up.Patrick, is that a hand?That's not a hand.Shirley, hands up high.Hands up high.Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.Keep your hands up because you guys are NOT GETTING THE
PATRICK.CARLOS.THERE WE GO.AMANDA.
UH WAIT UH DAN.WHO ELSE SAID Who else said Elliot won?
Within the first 42 hours.
Yo, they did not get Justin's account.
No, I did not know about it.Wait, what did she swipe on Justin?MACE LIKE WHAT?
OH MY GOD, CALM DOWN MACE.IT'S PROSPER.
6. Conclusions and Audience Q&A
He concludes that 'you attract what you are'—green flag profiles attract serious, intentional women—then answers audience questions about the scrapped profile, recognition, and whether he'll go on dates as his personas.
But yeah, the verdict, the final conclusion of this presentation is that nice guys don't finish last.
the the conclusion is that you attract what you are.If you have a more serious and green flag profile, you will attract more green flag serious intentional women versus Justin who has a bit of a fuckboy profile, he'll just attract girls that want to
Yo, you hear that guys?We just got to be nicer.
Questions, questions.Any questions?
Uh We we couldn't figure out the password for one of the phones.
Yeah, she uh I I like ended up getting locked out for like 8 hours.So that I was just like, okay, we're we're going to scrap this one.
Uh did you think that you did you account at all that uh some of these girls would be interested because they would know you from your social media account and not because they you whatever?
So there there were a few comments that were like, oh, are you Prosper Chu or like you look like Prosper Chu's twin.
But um for the most part, I don't think any of them actually recognize me or it's too hard to say just from one like.
To be fair, I didn't know immediately.And I saw the profile.
Did you like the pictures?
No, no, she was the one who put I'm really competitive, MARCUS.NO.
WELL, I'm aware like whatever order you set is what they see, right?So
they automatically like the first thing that they see.
That that is true.That's a good point.Um so for Justin, that was his first photo.But this one is actually not Elliot's first photo.The first photo was this one.Yeah.This was the first photo.
Where did you get the flowers from and what did you do with them after?
So, uh yeah, I like I I kind of set up my friend on a date for this one and then I decided to like get him flowers, but then the date didn't take it home, so I decided tojust use it for the picture.
you gave me?Wait, I left OH, YEAH, I LEFT
OH, GEE, I DIDN'T KNOW THAT.OH.
HEY, they wanted the good news, bro.They wanted the good news.
All right, well, that's my presentation, guys.Thank you guys so much for coming.I really appreciate the spontaneity and the time you guys have given me today.Oh, shout out shout out Charles for letting me use his phone number for um I think Justin's account, actually.So, thank you very much.Thank you, Charles.
Now you're Now you're locked in.Like you're banned forever.
You can't go on Hinge again, ever.
Wait, what Whatever happened to just being yourself?Just kind of like
Like whatever happened to being being happy?And also, did you go on a date with any of these girls like Cuz if they didn't really convert, like really what are we doing here?
You're right, you're right.On if you guys want to see me go on a date as Elliot or Justin, then subscribe and comment down below if you guys want to see that.Yeah, thank you guys so much for watching.I I really I really had a lot of fun with this experiment.I feel like I did a little science fair project and I haven't done one in like years, so this was very very fun to present and thank you guys all for so much for coming.I know this was super last minute, but you guys are the goats.