1. Three Goals of an Argument
Introduces the three goals of rhetoric—changing mood, mind, and willingness to act—using the Rock the Vote campaign as an example of why getting people to act is hardest.
okay welcome everyone to the crash course on rhetoric before you listen to this presentation it's really important that you have read the three chapters from Jay Heinrichs book thank you for arguing is chapters two three and four theyhave been scanned and uploaded for you and the week five part two content where it says argument so make sure you've read those before you begin this presentation okay so the goals of an argument there are three goalsto change the audience's mood mind or willingness to act now of the three it should make sense to you that the hardest one is willingness to act you can get someone in a better mood you might even beable to change their mind but to really get their butt out of the seat and do something that is hard for example in the early 90s MTV when it still just played music videos launched a whole campaign called
Rock the Vote they were trying to get that young demographic that 18 to 24 year olds out to vote in the election and so the first thing they needed to do was to get the audience their audience wasthat young age group and so they needed to first change the mood around voting so up to that point voting for that young group of people might have felt like something their mom and dad did politics was somethingthat older people did and so to change they're kind of just get them thinking about it they had to first change their mood about it right and so they started to that's why the rock the vote campaign andyou know there was music behind it there were stars that said Rock the Vote all of that was to combine change mood and mind hey voting is cool we want you to feel differently we want to warm you
up to the idea that you should be voting and then we want to change your mind that it's not something just your parents do but it's something that you should be doing so that's mood in mind but whatthat Rock the Vote campaign didn't do well with was actually improving their audiences will is to act when the poll numbers came in after the election they didn't see the impacts they were hoping for and all of thatis because it's really easy to change someone's mood in mind but to actually get them to get up and act and do something different is hard so willingness to act is the hardest but before and what you shouldknow too is that normally you're trying to change a combination of all three so you might know that like if you were trying to get your mother or father to let you do something that's why you know you
hear flattery people say Oh mom did you get a haircut that's that cliche scenario right well that's the mood part get her in a better mood by flattery first and then try to change her mind about what youwant to do and so that her willingness to act which is allowing you to do whatever you want is different so again you're probably trying to do all three most of the time but it does depend on the
2. Forensic, Demonstrative, and Deliberative Rhetoric
Explains the three chief topics of rhetoric (blame, values, and future choices) through the story of the speaker's son Sam and his socks, highlighting why deliberative rhetoric best changes behavior.
situation but willingness to act that one's the hardest okay so there are three chief topics in rhetoric there's forensic rhetoric demonstrative rhetoric and deliberative rhetoric now I'll go over all three but I need to give you a scenariofirst my son Sam leaves his socks all over the house they are everywhere they were on the kitchen table the other day I came home and there they were but they're in couch cushions they're on the couch theyare on the counter they're on the floor they're on the bed they're everywhere but on his feet and you know that's annoying enough as it is but our problem right now is that we have this beautiful young puppywell she's not so much a puppy anymore but when she was a puppy it was a bigger problem we have this beautiful Samoyed named bianca and she's a wonderful dog but boy excuse me does she like socks so
the problem is is I need to change Sam's willingness to act right and so I need to think about how I'm going to do that now when we think of rhetoric I could use forensic reg rhetoric this isthe rhetoric of blame this is the rhetoric of guilt and innocence and it's all done in the past tense this is the rhetoric of court and so I will tell you that forensic rhetoric in general my son isnow let's see he's almost 14 blame does not work if I want to change his willingness to act I want him to pick up the socks using Fred forensic rhetoric is not going to work think about the lasttime you were in a pretty big argument with someone how did you feel when they started blaming you for everything you've done recently like if I went up to Sam and I said Sam I'm so sick of your
socks being everywhere I saw them on the table today yesterday I found them in the couch the day before I found them on the counter and they're all over the floor in your bedroom if I start doing thatthink about what my 14 year old Sam is doing he has probably stopped listening so I might have changed his mood certainly but not in the way that I want to so forensic rhetoric is not going to workI am NOT going to win his heart in his mind by blaming him for everything he's done in the past all right the next kind of rhetoric is demonstrative rhetoric and this is the rhetoric of church it hasa lot to do with praise a lot to do with values we call it tribal rhetoric because it's one of those things where you're either with me or with the other side like we believe this we do not
believe that and so if you are the kind of person that believes what we believe then you're in our tribe does that make sense so it's kind of like this it's called tribal rhetoric and it's usually argued inthe present tense so I will tell you in general that Sam since he is 14 this is not the best rhetoric to use with him either because the last thing he wants to do is join my tri I'mhis mother and I am just generally seen as being largely annoying and uncool so therefore he does not want to be in the mom tribe he wants to be in the Sam tribe with the coal 14 year oldSam tribe so therefore trying to get him to say hey Sam you know everyone in this family we all pick up our socks and we don't do that he's probably going to say yeah well you know what how
I feel about that it is not going to work so knowing my audience I can tell you right away forensic rhetoric is not gonna work demonstrative rhetoric is not going to work but may be deliberative rhetoric will workso deliberative rhetoric is the rhetoric of politics or I will tell you it's the rhetoric of the way politics is supposed to be because it's all done in the future tense it's all about what can we do inthe future so that this doesn't happen again so let's bring me back to the scenario where I saw Sam socks on the kitchen table if I call him I go Sam I'd really like to talk to you andif I don't blame him and I don't get tribal rhetoric on him instead I say you know what Sam these socks on the table are really you know is there anything that we can do so that like your
socks aren't here the next time like what can we do so that I don't see this and so when I do that that's all future tense it's not blaming him and it's not putting him in a certain categoryinstead I'm just saying what can we do in the future so this doesn't happen again this is the rhetoric of politics I will tell you I've read some articles recently about the main thing that's wrong with our politicalsystem in the u.s.right now is that the deliberative rhetoric has actually broken down we're very much tribal right now and so our rhetoric has changed to demonstrative rhetoric you're either Republican or you're Democrat you're either conservative or you're liberal you're eitherpro-abortion or prolife you're either this or that like people are very much entrenched in their tribes and so our rhetoric has gotten very Demong which is why we're not in a future tenth what can we do next time
so that things can get better kind of place but deliberative rhetoric future tense rhetoric is the rhetoric of politics and it is the best way to change someone's willingness to act you can work on their mood you can
3. Types of Claims and Ethos
Covers claims of fact, value, and policy and how they map to the three rhetorics, then details the four components of ethos: decorum, virtue, practical wisdom, and disinterest.
hopefully change their mind and you can actually get them to do something different the best in deliberative rhetoric okay now there's three types of claims and they actually follow the three types of rhetoric so claims of fact aremost often seen in forensic rhetoric because they can be verified and proven from past tense information here's things that already happened I'm gonna cite this factual evidence and this is my claim of fact so it is a claimof fact that Sam leaves his socks around the house every day I can prove that okay so that's a claim of fact that is forensic rhetoric now claims of value are about morality and opinion and that fits withdemonstrative rhetoric so if I say in this family we value cleaning up after ourselves and so that is me putting an opinion and a sense of what's right and wrong on the idea of cleaning up our socks and
so that is a claim of value that is demonstrative rhetoric and then claims of policy our future tense rhetoric this is what we want to have happen in the future so claims of policy again could be what canwe do in the future so that our socks are always cleaned up so normally they have a qualifier a persuasive qualifier like should what should we do in the future we should do this right like and so thatis again our deliberative rhetoric its future tense rhetoric okay now we're gonna get into the three tools of persuasion and you might have some background with these there's three tools the first one is ethos ethos is argument bycharacter now when you think of argument by character there's a couple different things that make up that kind of argument so first there's decorum people need to fit with what you value as a leader they need to look
and behave the way you expect them to behave so if you think about I know this isn't a face-to-face class but I normally in a face-to-face class when I talk about decorum I talk about how the first coupledays of class I really pay attention to what I'm wearing because I need to look the way you expect me to look so I need to look professional and I need that helps me build up my ethos sothat you trust me that I know what I'm talking about that's decorum so when if you want to think about the last election both candidates had a decorum issue both of them were not necessarily holding up to whatwe valued as what a leader should look like so when Hillary Clinton wore pant suits a lot of people thought that that was her breaking decorum she's a woman she should be wearing a skirt or a dress and
she's trying to look like a man and that means she broke decorum right and so people were challenging that so decorum is actually a big deal you need to look the way that people expect you to look youneed to speak the way people expect you to speak you need to fit with what they think a leader should be like that's decorum now virtue is that you need to live up to your audience's values that doesn'tmean that you need to like live up to all sorts of values it just means that if you are speaking in front of a group that let's say you're speaking in front of a Catholic group of people youneed to hold up the values you need to know what the values of that Catholic audience are so that you live up to them because if you say something that's outside that virtue or what they value that you
will automatically be discredited in their eyes actually Jay Heinrichs had a wonderful example I've actually taught his book and a couple of my reading courses and he will Skype our class for free and what's fantastic about that ishe gave a wonderful example of skyping a Christian Academy and he was talking to like a senior AP English class and they were asking him I think a question about ethos and he said something about drinking and itwas just a joke but see he said that was a huge virtue breakdown because drinking and getting drunk is obviously not a virtue that that conservative Christian Academy would support and so therefore that hurt his ethos and theyhung up the call so virtue is also an issue you now what's interesting about virtue is Jay Heinrichs did stress this he said you don't necessarily have to believe the things that you're saying but you do have to
make sure your audience thinks that you do because if you hold up to what they've hold as virtuous they will trust you all right next is practical wisdom you need to appear like you know what you're talking aboutthe minute you flounder or the minute that you appear to not exactly know the answer to something that hurts your ethos you need to always appear that you know what to do in every occasion finally you need tolook impartial so part of having our building good ethos is did what's called disinterest which is lack of bias okay so those are the four main things that actually help you argue by character now in essays what you'llsee or hear and author do most of the time is kind of acknowledge years of experience or you'll see in some of the essays we have we're going to read a lot of essays by lawyers and you're going
to hear them build their practical wisdom their impartiality so their disinterest and they're going to help you trust them by showing you how knowledgeable they are and so that's one way you might hear that done in an essay
4. Pathos and Logos in Persuasion
Discusses argument by emotion, including storytelling, humor, and fear appeals, then explains argument by logic through syllogisms, enthymemes, deductive versus inductive order, and concessions.
okay the next part is pathos so pathos I want you to look at the word pathos and know that one word you might know that's related to this is the word pathetic now and that word connotates very negativelyin our culture but no that pathetic means just having a motion and so according to rhetoric having something that hat is pathetic is actually good because that means that you're arguing by emotion and you should know of thethree pathos is the most important if you can get your audience to laugh if you can make them cry if you can make them react emotionally or get emotionally and invested in what you're saying then you are muchfurther on the road of mood mind willingness to act I mean ethos matters and that's why it's first because they have to trust you first and believe in you but once they do if you start telling stories by
the way actually storytelling can enhance your ethos because if people laugh at a joke that you make they like you and so that is an ethos building thing but pathos is all about emotional appeal so argument by emotionstorytelling anytime you tell a good story people like stories actually our brains cognitively are wired for stories we like stories therefore when you tell them that is going to be way more persuasive than listing a whole bunch offacts storytelling works humor works any kind of appeal to emotion whether you want to scare them or make them upset in some way emotional appeals do a lot to persuade people and finally one of the most powerful emotionsis desire that want for something I will tell you that when I was arguing with my son about picking up his socks I certainly was trying to use humor because 14 year olds like humor but I also was
trying to appeal to his emotion so in my deliberative rhetoric argument I certainly could appeal to his emotions and I might appeal to fear because like I said I've got a problem it's not just that the socks areeverywhere but it's that my puppy likes to eat socks and I don't know if you know this but when an animal eats a sock especially more than one they can become impacted in their digestive tract and actually requiresurgery it can be quite a mess so if I talk about that with Sam that could be an appeal to fear you don't want the socks that you leave around the house to be the things that make Biancasick and so that would be an emotional appeal okay so pathos is appeals to emotion and again the most persuasive all right and finally the last one is logos logos is argument by logic I will tell you that
this one is a tough sell people in general the minute you start quoting facts and quoting statistics they kind of tune out to that so it's important to have it it's a good balance to have it in therebut you have to be careful in any kind of argument how that's done all right there's two kinds of argument by logic there's deductive order and inductive order so when we look at argument logical the logical argument ofdeduction we're talking about syllogisms so syllogisms the most classic syllogism would be okay all men are mortal Socrates is a man therefore Socrates is mortal that is your classic logical syllogism you're looking at if all men are mortaland Socrates is a man therefore Socrates is mortal okay so that is your most common logical syllogism example so deductive logic is applying a general principle to a particular matter so in that case your general principle was all
men are mortal right and then we applied it to Socrates and that's how we know that Socrates is also immortal because he's a man now there's a logic sandwich called an enthymeme which actually cuts out that middle linethat all men are mortal line because no I'm sorry not all men are mortal it's Socrates is a man that's the line because that middle line is actually sometimes seen is to call it the duh line like ofcourse Socrates is man he's right there right and so that line gets cut out and so they call it a logic sandwich because you squish the premise and the conclusion together and to have a what's called an enthymemeall right now the thing to remember with deductive logic is that the thesis is usually in the beginning and then it's supported through the rest of the argument the opposite is induction and if you think about your personal
narrative which is what we're writing right now most of the time in the mentor text you're seeing that the thesis or what we're calling this so what for a personal narrative is at the end and that is moreinductive order because it's called argument by example we start with something really specific and then we move to a really general conclusion and you should kind of see that in your personal narrative you're starting with your story whichis specific and then you're boiling it down to a more general statement that's argument by induction the thesis or the main point or in the personal narratives case this so what is at the end all right concessions we'regoing to get into this more when we look at counter arguments but a concession is where you might actually concede that someone has a point and again that is going to be in what's called a refutation or a
counter argument where you bring up the opposition's what the opposition would say so let's say if you're arguing a pro-life stand point then you might acknowledge what the pro-choice people think and that would be making some kind of
5. Kairos: Seizing the Right Moment
Concludes with the concept of kairos—the right message, time, and medium—illustrated by the story of the dog eating Sam's socks, plus a note on how different mediums suit different rhetorical appeals.
concession okay so that's argument by logic now the next thing we're going to talk about actually this is the last thing I'm going to talk about is Kairos Kairos is the art of seizing the moment it's the rightmessage at the right time with the right medium so I'm going to wrap up this presentation by telling you a story about Kairos I have been telling you all along about my son Sam and his socks right soI will tell you that I did try really hard to make sure to prevent what happened I did my son loves soccer so I took him out into the yard one afternoon and I said hey Sam let's takeBianca outside and let's pass the ball you should see my dog loves to play soccer she's so good at it so we have a lot of fun doing that so if you look at this as a kind of
manipulation you can see that I was setting the scene I'm gonna change Sam's mood first I'm gonna get him in a good mood because it's awesome to watch my dog play soccer she's so good at it and thatmakes everyone laugh and if I can make my son laugh then he's in a good mood right and so if he's in a good mood then I can start working on his mind right but I'm not going touse forensic rhetoric and I'm not gonna use demonstrative rhetoric because I don't want to blame him and I don't want to use tribal rhetoric with values right so I'm gonna be deliberative and I'm gonna say something like heyand I did this by the way I said hey Sam because remember I got his mood right and so I'm going to then try to change his mind by just going wow look at your dog man she is
so awesome you know and try this I said things like that and I was trying to get him to understand and value the dog right because if I can get him loving his dog at that moment then Imight be able to use the future tense rhetoric to say you know it's him it's really hard to keep her safe and one of the ways that we need to keep her safe is by making sure there's nothingaround that she can chew on so in the future do you think there's something we can do to make sure your socks aren't where she could get them get at them and get hurt right and so we're inthe backyard see I've done mood I've tried to do mind right and so then I'm trying now willingness to act deliberative rhetoric what can we do in the future right so I did all of this and I will
tell you that Sam and I had a plan and you know he was just like mom I just need to pick him up I know better right and he does and so but see by him saying that Ididn't blame him and so he was more willing at least saying he's willing to now I will tell you that as you know it's very hard to change behavior right so you should know that the socks were leftaround and you should know that Bianca got ahold of the socks and ripped them up and ate them and so I will tell you that the boy I was actually at work and I got a phone call fromboth my kids kind of freaking out they're like mom Bianca's laying on the kitchen floor and she's throwing up everywhere and there's little bits of material in the vomit and I was like oh no because you know that
if she has some kind of intestinal blockage that's actually a really big deal and one of the symptoms is they vomit right and so I actually left a meeting went home my dog is laying on the kitchen flooras she's vomited everywhere and there's little bits of material everywhere so we wrap her up in a blanket and I say Sam I put her on Sam's lap in the car we're racing to the vet I've called thevet we're racing to the vet we get there and of course they're running the dog back for x-rays well I will tell you by using Kairos that is the right argument at the right time with the right mediumif you've ever seen a child look more scared and more responsible at any moment in their lives that was it he knew that because he left his socks laying around he actually did it he put his beloved dog
in major in a major health crisis so there's your right moment it's the right time because the dog is really sick and the right medium is his dog that he loves that is Kairos that is seizing Kairos tosay Sam what are we gonna do so this never happens again and do you think that he was scared enough to pick up his socks I would like to tell you the answer to that is yes I wouldlike to tell you that but I will tell you that it's much better which I think is why now I find them on the kitchen table because at least they're up high enough now that the dog can't getthem so some things were solved but maybe not everything but now you understand Kairo the right message the right time with the right medium now medium is interesting medium means your delivery model and you should know too that
in rhetoric some delivery models are better at some things than others so if you think of the rhetoric of an email that is very much logos right it's for facts it's for reporting things it's not emotion if youthink of text text is also very much logos right it's just facts and information and so that's why emoticons were made so that people can add that pathos in right and so that's why breaking up with somebody overtext or over email is a horrible idea that might be the right argument it might even be the right time but if it's not the right medium oh then you're in trouble and so it's really good to knowwhat mediums work for what occasion alright so that brings us to the end of our crash course and rhetoric I hope everything makes sense please let me know if you have any questions because next week we're gonna start
practicing and breaking down essays have a great day thanks