# The Potato Dish Everyone Will Fight Over This Thanksgiving | J. Kenji López-Alt | NYT Cooking

**Channel:** NYT Cooking
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZKWmo9wH3s
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/nZKWmo9wH3s

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Introducing the Potato Gratin Idea
- 1:15 — Choosing and Slicing the Potatoes
- 2:25 — Mixing Cream and Preparing the Dish
- 4:37 — Assembling and Seasoning the Gratin
- 6:21 — Baking, Finishing, and Serving

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** I like that that looks like one mouthful the way it is right now.

**[0:08]:** Everyone, I'm Kenji Lopez Alt. I am a New York Times contributor and the author of The Food Lab. And in this book I had a recipe for this dish. The idea for this recipe started with the concept of a potato gratin. I wanted to have a potato gratin recipe in here and then I was thinking about this other dish called Hasselback potatoes. It was a dish that was created in the 1950s in Sweden. The idea is that you take a whole potato, you slice it not quite all the way through but you cut it into a lot of thin slices that are all connected on the bottom. You put butter on it and you roast it. And so you end up with this kind of half baked potato half potato chip hybrid thing. So the idea was how do I combine that dish with a potato gratin?

**[0:45]:** And so what we do is we slice our potatoes and put them on their side and so you end up with a dish that's creamy and buttery and cheesy and really satisfying in the way that potato gratin is but with this kind of array of potato chip like crispiness on the top. It's really good. It's great for holidays. It's It's a great anytime year. It's not great in the middle of the summer but it's really good for the holidays or or whenever it's cold outside or whenever you feel like doing a little bit of work and putting some time into your potatoes.

**[1:15]:** All right. So first thing we're going to do we're going to start with russet potatoes. I like to use russet potatoes for this because they have a higher starch content and a lower water content than most other types of potatoes. When they're starchier like this they end up a little bit crispier. So you get a much nicer contrast between the crisp top layer and the creamier bottom layer. Um in in the same way that you know a russet potato makes a really good french fry because it gets crispy on the outside but stays nice and sort of fluffy and creamy in the center. All right. So we're going to do about 4 to 4 and 1/2 lb of these. You want basically enough that they're going to fill up a casserole dish entirely. Once you've got your potatoes done now we're going to slice them.

**[1:55]:** So we want to go about an eighth of an inch thick.

**[2:03]:** That looks about right. These mandolins are sharp and they come with a little plastic guard uh which always gets lost uh but you can also get like Kevlar gloves or um or you can get someone else to do this bit like you know a little small child. Joke. It was a joke.

**[2:25]:** Once you get your potatoes sliced we put together this cream mixture. So it's going to be heavy cream as well as a mixture of Parmesan and Gruyère. So we're going to we're going to actually keep some of this grated Gruyère and Parmesan off to the side about a third of it off to the side cuz we're going to add that to the top in the end but the rest we're going to put right in here. Got some fresh thyme minced garlic and then some freshly ground pepper and salt. Whenever you're making a potato dish you know potatoes really love salt so you want to make sure you season it pretty heavily. A little more than you think you should. We're going to mix it all up and this this is a thing where it is best to get in there with your hands. All right.

**[3:06]:** So we're getting all our potatoes in this bowl. This is a step by the way you can't really do any of this ahead because potatoes they oxidize if you slice them or peel them so they'll start to kind of turn red and if you let them sit long enough they'll even start to kind of turn black. It's not going to kill you or anything but it makes the dish look not as good. The one thing you got to be careful about is that the potato slices because of their big surface area tend to stick together so you want to make sure that you're kind of separating the potatoes and getting that cream mixture really nicely coating each slice. I wouldn't do the potatoes ahead and soak them in water. When you do that you you're you pull starch out of there and so it actually ends up a little bit less creamy uh when you do that.

**[3:44]:** This is This is one of those dishes where you kind of once once you start making it you want to get it into the oven. There's going to be three sort of basic oven steps in here and you could potentially do the first two ahead of time and then finish it off on the last day if you really want to make this ahead but you know potatoes their starch retrogrades once you've cooked it and and let them cool which is why you know french fries or mashed potatoes are never quite as good when you reheat them. All right. I'm not going to bother washing my hands cuz I'm going to take some butter and rub it into this casserole dish. You want to get it to go kind of all the way up the edges because as this gratin cooks the cream starts to kind of bubble up and it'll leave a layer of kind of caramelized cream and cheese

**[4:27]:** all around the edges which is really nice to kind of pick off and and eat before you serve it to your guests. Since I got this extra butter I'm just going to just going to plop it in here.

**[4:37]:** Now at this stage we're going to start assembling our casserole. And what you want to do is take little stacks of potatoes like that. You actually don't want the edges to line up perfectly so it's perfectly fine that some are big and some are small um cuz we want some of the edges to kind of jut out and others to kind of sink down. We're just going to kind of work our way around the perimeter first. If you've got kids this is a good task for them to do. You know often times I will you know do a ton of experimenting to come up with a recipe. This is one of those dishes where I I literally woke up in the middle of the night and I was like oh that's a great idea and I started peeling potatoes at like 2:00 a.m. and stayed up until 4:00 until the first one came out of the oven but the idea for the dish itself was was one of those rare moments where it just kind of just kind of came in a dream.

**[5:25]:** I came up with this idea and I was like come on like somebody's got to have done this before. And and I'm sure somebody has but at least not in the sort of published literature um cuz we went around looking in books and looking all over the internet to see if there was a you know a sideways potato gratin and at the time that I wrote this recipe there there wasn't. All right. So once you work your way all the way around the edges you're going to start filling up the center like this. You might find that 4 or 4 and 1/2 lb is not quite enough to fit into a dish. This turned out pretty pretty perfectly. So if you do find that you don't have quite enough potatoes left over you can always just slice an extra one get it mixed in here and mix it in.

**[6:00]:** If you have too much potatoes you can also get like a little ramekin or something and make a little side casserole for yourself. I should have done this at the beginning but I'm I'm going to just taste my cream mixture for season. Yeah so it should be nice and salty at this point cuz you need to put enough salt into the cream that it seasons all the potatoes and the cream mixture.

**[6:21]:** All right. We're going to cover it with foil and then we're going to put it straight into a 400° oven for about 30 minutes. So all we're going to do now is take that foil off pop it back in and it's going to go for another 30 minutes uncovered like that. All right. Ooh. It's looking like the the inside of an angry volcano here. We're going to add some cheese. You know there's some there's some chefs or cookbook authors I've read who insist that a potato gratin does not need cheese. I think they're correct but you know it doesn't need cheese in the way that a that a bath doesn't need bubbles you know. It'll It'll It'll function but better with it. And because this looks like it might it might overflow the edges a little bit and I don't want to completely mess up my oven or the New York Times oven I'm going to stick a tray on the bottom.

**[7:09]:** It's going to go for one final half hour where it's going to crisp up. I think they're looking good in here. The cream has broken meaning that it has evaporated enough that the butter fat of it is starting to separate from the liquid elements which means that the potatoes have absorbed some of that milk away. They've absorbed some of the butter fat so they're going to be nice and creamy in the bottom. Let me give it a little poke to make sure that we're tender all the way through. Oh yeah. This is going to be insanely hot at this point so I'm going to let it rest for about 10-15 minutes or so. And in that time what's going to happen is some of that butter that we see bubbling at the surface will all kind of sink back down and absorb into the potatoes.

**[7:52]:** All right. So this is the finished dish. You can see the bottoms of these potatoes are really nice and creamy.

**[8:03]:** And the tops you get these almost little like kind of potato chip like crunchy bits. So when you eat it all together just this like wild mix of textures and flavors that all come from really simple ingredients. A hint of garlic hint of thyme. So good it doesn't even need gravy. You can find this recipe all of my other recipes and all of the other great recipes from other contributors on New York Times cooking.nytimes.com.
