1. Introduction and Pride Month Greeting
The host introduces his recurring response series to Ali Stucky's content, explains why he critiques her theology, and greets viewers for Pride Month.
Friends, what's up?Welcome back to the channel.Let's be real, okay?Would this be a Tim Whitaker Speaks channel if there wasn't a weekly episode of me responding to an Ali Stucky clip at this point?And look, the reason I do this is because she, like many others, puts out a fire hose of content that is so hateful, but it's masked as love and as, you know, beauty and goodness.and we have to expose it because the theology that Ali Stucky espouses is killing our neighbors.So, welcome into the channel.Please make sure to like this video, subscribe to the channel so you get notified for future pieces of content.I'm trying to hit 80,000 subs by the end of this month.And to all of my queer friends out there, happy Pride Month to you.Unless you're Ali Stucky.If you're Ali Stucky, then no Siri Bob.
No, no Happy Pride because well, you're going to find out in a minute here.So, buckle up.We'll go through this piece clip by clip.I'll respond as I always do.Let's get into it.Here we go.
2. Deconstructing Stucky's Pride Month Framing
The host critiques Stucky's claim that LGBTQ people 'choose' their identity and exposes the hypocrisy of her pride rhetoric given her support of Trump and MAGA.
Now, today marks the beginning of what some may refer to as Pride Month.And this is a month where those who call themselves LGBTQ celebrate their sexuality.
Pause.Pause.We have to stop right away because even the framing of this is disingenuous.Okay.Some celebrate this what some might identify as.I mean, the way the way that that that she frames this, listen again, it's very important.
Who call themselves LGBTQ
who call themselves LGBTQ.See, Ally refuses to acknowledge the existence of gay people.They don't exist.They are choosing people.If you're out there and you're queer, Ally believes that you are choosing to live in a lifestyle of sin.She doesn't think that that that that this is how you were wired, that you like who you like.She thinks that you are choosing this.That's very important.By the way, small side note here.I guess I'm watching too much Ali Stucky.She changed her set.The set is now her broadcasting from a kitchen, which I do think has a lot of overtones for what she's trying to communicate to her mainly white female audience,
right?Their sexuality.And that sexuality is conflated with identity.And so today, we will look at where the movement is for America.for worse in some ways but also for better in other ways so that we Christians can know how to pray, how to minister, how to speak, how to shine light in the darkness.Now for Christians, we celebrate today like we do every day.This is the day that the Lord has made.Let us rejoice and be glad in it.And when we think of pride, we don't think of pride month.We don't think pride and sexual so-called identity.We think of the vice that comes before failure.So, there's a couple of things you need to see here.I'm I'm sure you're picking up on it.Immediately, like I said earlier, Ally sees uh sexual identity as as either made up or a choice or at odds with the biblical notion of human sexuality.
I'm sure she's going to talk about the Bible, so we'll debunk all that in a few minutes here.The other point important thing to realize is her whole statement on pride is quite hilarious when you consider that this is a woman who is in the tank for one of the most prideful, arrogant men to exist.Does anyone know of a of a queer famous person who has posted themselves being depicted as Jesus Christ on on their social media platforms and then lies about it and says, "Oh, I thought I was being depicted asa doctor."Cuz Alli Stucky believed that when when Trump stated that he thought he was being depicted as a doctor in that photo, Ali Stucky said, "See guys, he thought he was a doctor, not Jesus Christ."This is what is so maddening about people like Ally in this whole right-wing world that will try and tell you that Pride Month is about this sin of pride when it's not.
We all know that Pride Month is about taking being proud of who you are.Being proud of who God made you to be.It's not about arrogance.It's not about the kind of pride that Donald Trump and the MAGA right embodies every single day.How they refuse to answer questions.How they refuse to be accountable.No, no, no.But Alli's gonna project all of that onto the term Pride Month because her audience will fall for it.Ally wants her audience to think that everything about Pride Month is inherently against how God created things to be.And the MAGA movement that she's a part of and that she profits a lot of money off of is what God has called good and what faithful Christians should be endorsing.
We look to the rainbow.We think of God's promise to Noah and to the whole world that never will he flood the earth again and that he's faithful to keep his promises.
Well, we should also point out here that the story of Noah's arc is that God kills every human on the face of the planet, including children.And again, like this is the problem why a lot of us ended up deconstructing because when you start reading these Bible stories and you're told that God is pro-life, then you read the story of Noah's arc where Godkills children.God kills every person on earth besides one family.And of course, you're taught to take that literally.This isn't a metaphor.This isn't about a meta narrative.This is about a literal historical event that, by the way, didn't happen.Um, and then Ally is telling her audience that that the rainbow is really about God's promise to never kill all of humanity again.As if that's somehow a beautiful and loving thing.The God over all things.The God who spoke the world into existence promised to never kill their creation ever again in mass.
Like the whole world.Wow.Thank you.Thank you, benevolent God.
When we think of love, we don't follow it up with some kind of circular meaningless mantra is love.We think of that which is never prideful and never boast, never rejoice in wrong, and is always patient, and it's always kind.Does any of that line up with the policies or the person of Donald Trump or the MAGA movement?I'm going to beat this drum until the day I die because the fact that Ally with a straight face can say this and not think about the the movement that she fully endorses and and and and is famousoff of.To think that the MAGA movement isn't prideful, that it's always kind, that it's not proud or rude or self-seeking is crazy talk.It is a level of delusion.You have to wonder how brainwashed someone like Ali Saki actually is.To what extent?Well, to the extent where she can say this with a straight face and not think, hm, I wonder if the person that I say is saving America actually embodies all these prideful things that I'm accusing other people of
being.Because Pride Month is not about arrogance.It's about rejoicing with beauty and goodness and the truth that gay people, queer people exist and that they are beautifully and wonderfully made and that they have a right to live proudly for who they are.I'm proud that I'm Tim.Hopefully, you're proud that you're you.That's not prideful, but I do take pride in who I am, the work I put in, etc.Same thing with you.That's not what Ally is doing here.It's an intentional misfring of this topic.
3. Presuppositions Behind 'God Defines Love'
The host unpacks the layers of assumptions beneath Stucky's appeal to biblical authority, then debunks her use of Genesis and Matthew 19 on marriage, noting polygamy and contradiction in scripture.
Think of God who tells us that he is love.1 John 4:8.And therefore, he alone has the authority to define it.And when we see this acronym LGBTQ, we don't see sexual identities to celebrate.We see image bearsers of God.
That makes no sense.You You obviously don't see image bearsers of God, Ally.You see people that are worth condemning and hating on and and voting for politicians who want to restrict their rights.You think that that that they're disgusting, that they're more intent, that that that they're more inherently perverted and and sexually promiscuous.You think all these things.Just guys, just just go on Alli's Twitter.She routinely picks up stories of queer folks who do heinous things as a way to then scapegoat the the entire group.She'll never do this when it comes to the pastors in her tribe.Of course, she'll never do it when it comes to Trump being a convicted felon or a man who was found liable for sexual assault.And that will never get pasted onto the whole MAGA movement, but Ally will do this when it comes to queer people.
See, the thing that makes Ally so sneaky is that she sounds so nice and sweet and kind.Even the set, right?She's in her kitchen or a kitchen, probably a set.She's all done up.Her makeup is done.She looks like the like the typical American wife, but she's a famous podcaster.She's a businesswoman and she has a product to sell her audience and that aud that that product is patriarchy and homophobia and xenophobia that maintains a very white nationalist culture in America in the name of God.That's what's going on.
Pursuing what is right in their own eyes to the detriment of their bodies and souls.True.We see people who are lost as we were all once lost.deceived as we were all once deceived and who need the kind of love that points toward Jesus and his truth.
Oh God, we're going to go through this point by point, aren't we?Because wow, notice how Ally goes from God defines love to now really she defines love and her interpretation of the Bible defines love.We should pause here for a minute.I have to break this down for you.There is a a lot of presuppositions underneath what Ally is saying.Ally believes that that God first exists.Okay?Ally believes that.Okay, fine.Alli believes that the only God that actually exists in, you know, in real in real life, in reality, is the God of the Bible.Okay, but that's kind of complicated because the God of the Bible is is not univocal.It's kind of all over the place, right?There's a there's Yahweh in the Old Testament or Hebrew Bible who commands genocide.There's Jesus who Christians believe is God in the flesh.
It says, "Love your enemies, etc."So then Ally then says, "Well, the Bible was is the inspired, inherent, infallible word of God.God gave us the Bible."Now, not just any Bible, not the Catholic Bible, not the e, not the Eastern Orthodox Bible, but the English Protestant Bible.This is what she believes God has spoken through or God has in some way written.Now she'll acknowledge that that people have written it but under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit that has produced a flawless flawless collection of texts and not just these texts on their own but of course how she interpretsthese texts which texts she highlights as authoritative which text she says are actually prescriptive versus descriptive.all these different assumptions underneath all of this that get Ally to this point where what she really believes is that she believes that God is the author of love and that she knows what God has told her about
love via the Bible.So, there's a lot of layers, a lot of hoops that she's jumping through to get to this conclusion.and she disregards any other view or understanding or or worldview, philosophical outlook that would contradict her very narrow fundamentalist understanding of the Bible.And the result is a fruit that votes in line with MAGA policies that ends up killing our queer neighbors.We know statistically that people who are gay, who go to unaffirming churches and hear that kind of theology, are more likely to self harm because of that theology.Bad theology literally kills people.But Ally is so stuck in her dogma, she doesn't care about that.she has gas lit herself to believe that what she's telling uh gay people is truth and that and that that they follow what she's telling them that apparently God wants they'll live a more fuller life when we have
example after example of people in these spaces who were closeted who tried all of this who got to the point where they almost took their own life doesn't it doesn't add up but for Ally she doesn't care bythe way this rhetoric for Ally is incredible incredibly profitable.She makes a lot of money doing this stuff.I don't, by the way.So, if you want to like and subscribe to this video and help me out, that'd be great.Or you can be a supporter of the channel.Link is in the bio.All right, let's keep going.Only a minute in.
We think of Jesus's words in Matthew 19:4-5, which say that God made us male and female in the beginning, so that a man will leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and the twowill become one flesh.This has nothing to do with homosexuality or gay marriage.The context, I know I was a big fan of context, has to do with divorce.Jesus is asked by the religious elite about divorce.A Jewish audience.And Jesus being a Jew goes back to their scriptures, cites Genesis 2.The language is a man takes his woman and cleaves to her.It's not husband or wife.There is no word in the Hebrew or Greek for husband or wife.It's always man or woman.Then it's translated from there.Just so we all know.And the language, by the way, the ancient world, if you think that lovebased, romantic, long-term relationships were the norm.
You have another thing coming.The ancient world was not largely concerned about that kind of marriage.It was about property.A man took a woman or took women, plural, as his property to then create more offspring.This notion that Ally is like we're just being consistent today with the biblical notion of marriage is so ignorant, so ahistorical.And this is like a a a sophomore level New Testament or intro to Bible class will tell you this.Genesis 2 is saying nothing about the uh objective uh narrow understanding of marriage.Because if it was, then Enoch in Genesis 4 would be sinful.But the Bible never says that.Oh, sorry.Lamech.Lamech, not Enoch.I always say Enoch.Or how about Jacob, the father of Israel, taking two wives who are both his cousins who were both sisters, Leah and Rachel.No condemnation of that.David had multiple wives.
No condemnation.In fact, God says that he would have given David more wives.So again, I just encourage you if you want read the scriptures.There is not a univocal portrait of marriage portrayed like how Ally wants you to believe.It's just it's absolute hogwash.
You remember that we're not nicer than God.So if God says something is good, he says it out of love.If he says something is sin, he says so out of love.If he is love, we can't out love him.We can't out mercy him.We can't out wisdom him.We can't out compassion him.In fact, the most loving thing we can always do is agree with God.
This is a huge point of indoctrination.Because who is talking on behalf of God right now in this conversation?Ally or the pastors that Ally will tell you to listen to.God's voice is always mediated through other human beings.That's a reality.If you grew up in church, your pastor tells you what God says.A human is still telling you.Now, some people believe that that God will appear to them in dreams, whatever.But for most of us, and then by the way, that's fine.my my whatever comment isn't meant to be flippant.It's just saying putting that aside.I'm not going to get into that in that side of it.When you learn about God, you're taught about it through men.Even the Bible, which Alli will acknowledge was written by men.They're mediating what they think is happening about their experience with God.
So for Alli to make it seem like I like there's no middleman here, like she like she has direct access to a God, the God of all creation, of all things, of all time, of all people, and allof those different religions.that God that she has the corner on that is just it's insanely prideful.Speaking of pride, it's incredibly arrogant and also it's intellect it's anti-intellectual.Just look around.We don't we don't even have to look at at at at the global religious landscape.We can look inside of Christianity to see how they agree on almost nothing.They don't agree on the trinity.There's the oneness movement.They don't agree on on how one is saved.Even inside of evangelicalism, even inside of the basement of evangelicalism, there's massively competing ideas for how one is saved.Ali Stucky and people like her are reformed Calvinists.
They believe that God has predetermined who will be saved.They believe that God has predetermined every single action that comes to pass in human history.There's not one rogue molecule.Other people who are more charismatic believe that you choose to be saved.You you invite Jesus into your heart.Those are massively different sotiologies.So for Alli to pretend that this is all just settled data, it's all clear.There's no room for disagreement.There's no different ways to see these texts is just so it's just I don't know.It's it's ignorant.And that ignorance translates to her audience and it creates more ignorant people who have a lot of vote who who have a lot of voting power that vote for policies and laws that harm people who want nothing todo with this religious identity.Most gay people don't agree with Ally on any of this.
They don't they don't have to they they don't they shouldn't be forced to be under the thumb of Alli's religious zealatry.We have a first amendment for a reason.And God calls homosexuality and the denial of our God-given sex sin and deception.
And he calls the creation of male and female in his image very good.
That is and he exclusively designates as holy marriage between one man and one woman.
4. Marriage, Fruit of the Spirit, and Weaponized Scripture
The host challenges the 'five R's' marriage argument, counters with the fruit of the spirit and 1 Corinthians 13, and argues Stucky weaponizes the Bible against queer people for profit.
Now, if you've been listening since
just read the Bible, guys, four chapters in, multiple wives are on the scene.Heck, Alli believes that Genesis 1 and 2, which by the way are different contradictory creation stories.That should tell you something right away that that maybe it's not about about taking it literally because you have to go in all kinds of you have to jump through all kinds of hoops to to smooth out whatare very big contradictions, including what days uh things were created on.Whatever.If Ally really thinks what you just said, that God created marriage to be between one man and one woman for life and then God sets up a situation where Adam and Eve are the first two humans on theentire planet and they are responsible for populating the entire earth.You don't think that God is setting those people up for disaster to sin right away?
At a minimum, incest is happening.At a minimum, let alone what would more most naturally happen where people are taking multiple multiple partners all in the family.Doesn't make any sense.Like it doesn't it doesn't add up.Like just use your rational abilities here, your cognitive abilities.It doesn't add up for this to be the truth of what the Bible is trying to get at.Look up the book The Lost World of Genesis for more on this.Uh John Walton, pretty conservative scholar from my understanding, does great work on what's happening in Genesis 1 and 2.It's much more about chaos and order.There's much it's much more beautiful than the flattening out and weaponizing of Genesis 1 and 2 that Alli's doing here.
All the way back in 2000, I believe it was 18 or 19 that we first talked about this acronym.This will be familiar, but it bears repeating.Marriage between one man and one woman is rooted in creation.That's Genesis 1:27.It's reiterated throughout scripture.Honor your father and mother.That's one example repeated by Jesus.Matthew 19:4-5.Representative of Christ and the church.That's incredible.Ephesians 5.And is therefore reflective of the gospel.So rooted, reiterated, repeated, representative, and reflective.So
that sounds cute, but it just falls apart under further scrutiny for all kinds of reasons.I've already explained many of them.I'm not going to go through all these pieces, but it's just it that is one portrait maybe of marriage that you could talk about.It's not the only one in the Bible by a long shot.And again, none of this is based in mutual romantic affection for life.A man takes a woman is the language and then marks her by having sex with her.That that that's the imagery we see over and over in the Bible.Even if it was just one man, one woman, the whole motivation for why you get married back then, nothing like what it is today.So the the whole the whole foundation is already off.It's already off.It's already off.It's just when people say that the Bible doesn't really mean homosexuality.
It's not really talking about that.Jesus doesn't really talk about that.There are all kinds of ways that we can try to finagle ourselves into justifying sin by making an argument from absence.First, it's not true.The Bible does talk about these things in the negative sense, but we also read the Bible asking, but what does God define positively?Not just what does God call sin, but what does he call good?
So, this is the this is the mental gymnastic here that that that they do, right?First, they go to the Bible and God are clear on this issue.Then when people rightfully bring up that Jesus, who Christians believe is God, never talked about homosexuality for a lot of reasons, including the fact that modern notions of human sexuality didn't exist back then, but just in general nevermentions it.Then they go, "Well, that's not a good argument.That's an argument from absence."Okay.Then they go to what does God affirm?Great question.What is the fruit of the spirit, Ally?Love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control.Do you know how many people I know who are who were closeted in church who were in agony and pain and suffering and depression trying to pray it away trying to ask God to to give this burden or
to take this burden off of their shoulders.Some of them got to the point where they almost started selfharming.
Sure.God.Let's go with just the most basic Aana level Bible verses.I was taught the fruit of the spirit.Love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control.Yeah, my queer neighbors embody those things all the time.My gay Christian neighbors embody those things who are in relationship with someone else.Yeah.Love is patient.Love is kind.Does not envy.It's not proud.It's not rude.It's not self-seeking.Keeps record of wrong.Doesn't rejoice in evil.Rejoices in the truth.Yeah, great.So, we can make that argument easily.Easily.Ally is just weaponizing the Bible for hate.Don't let her soft demeanor deceive you into thinking that somehow she's a compassionate individual.This person wrote the book Toxic Empathy.In fact, I'm actually reading uh Christine Duay's new book uh Live, Laugh, Love that talks about the history of evangelicalism in women.And there's a whole kind of there's a whole under there's like a whole culture underneath of this that's designed to capture mostly white women to put them into these frameworks where it upholds patriarchy um you know u um
heterosexual normativity all those kinds of things.This is all very intentional for Ally and she laughs all the way to the bank.
And if we love God, we're not just trying to get away with things.We want to glorify him.Then we are trying to align ourselves and our lives as closely to what he calls holy as we possibly can.The Bible starts with a marriage between Adam and Eve, ends with a marriage between the bridegroom and the bride.These are gender specific designations that have eternal significance that's reflected here on earth only between a man and a woman.That's
Jesus says that there's no marriage in heaven.What are you talking about, Ally?What are you talking about?Also, the bride of Christ is the church plural.Aren't we all part of the church?You and I are.Am I the bride of Christ?That's not gender specific.That I'm I'm I'm a male.Christ is a male.Obviously, it's not talking about this, Ally.Like, again, just guys, use just use the obvious.The church is billions of people.We're all married to Christ.Wow.That is one hell of a situation if I ever heard one.Just saying.It's
so incredibly sacred.And that is why we don't celebrate Pride Month because we cannot we can't by definition love others by affirming sin.
5. Hypocrisy on Children and Persecution Claims
The host rebuts Stucky's claims of loving children and family by citing MAGA policies and scandals, then dismantles her persecution narrative and compares it to segregation-era rhetoric used to control gay people.
Okay, doesn't believe this.Allowi does not believe this because she loves Trump and affirms his sin all the time.
Again, this and I want to just pause for a second.When I was growing up in this world and I was a conver a committed conservative Christian, I realized early that we were picking on one sin, homosexuality, over others.The Bible talks so much more about greed and how we treat the poor and the oppressed and rulers and principalities and how rich people steal from their workers than it does about homosexuality or same-sex sex like by likea thousand%.It's it's kind of wild.There are thousands of verses talking about this.Ally is part of a movement that has convinced people that they're only good Christians if they vote for a man in his regime who is who are continuously oppressing the poor who are continuously making this country more andmore difficult to live in for the majority of us while their billionaire friends make a lot of money off of us and our backs.
James 5 scathing critique of the billionaire class, not a peep from Ally.Ally will tell you that we have an obligation to vote for biblical values, which in her mind are MAGA values.This is why I say do not, if you're a Christian and you're debating this stuff, maybe you're on the fence, do not listen to these people.They are wolves.Listen to any scholar worth their salt.Read the Bible for yourself.Just go through and read the four gospel accounts and take a look at how many times God mentions pride flags, transgender people, homosexuality, and look at how many times he mentions rich and poor.Look how many times he mentions um you know taking care of the outcast, welcoming the stranger, feeding the hungry, liberating the oppressed, loving one's neighbor as oneself.Again, I just use their own framework.This is not complicated stuff.
This is very straightforward stuff.I'm we're not getting into deep exit Jesus.We're not looking into the original.This just read the English Protestant Bible in particular the red letters because we are Christ followers, aren't we?After all, and just see how much of this adds up with Ally and her worldview.
Against the darkness of the movement, not because of hate, but because we love God.
And because it's bad for people.It's bad for children.
We love people.We love the family.We love children.And we want what God calls good.
Yeah.Ally loves children so much.She defends a man who is best friends with a pedophile.Yeah.Yeah.Good job, Ally.You really nailed this one.You really nailed it.You Yeah.Trump brags about assaulting women, but you love children, Ally.You vote You vote for politicians who take away Affordable Care Act subsidies for families.You don't think that families should have access to paid family leave.You don't think that mandatory livable wages should be a thing in the world's richest country.You don't think that universal healthcare should be a thing.You're not pro- family.You hate kids.You don't think that.You don't think that school lunches should be expanded so kids can get affordable lunches or free lunches.You don't love children at all.Kids understanding how the world is and that people exist who might not be like them is very normal.
Ally, I'm so sick of these people having the corner on protected children when their movement has so many freaking groomers.Ken Paxton, who's running against James Telico for Senate, a person James Telerico that Ally says is like Satan disguising himself as an angel of light.Ken Paxton let a pedophile off the hook.His his attorney general's office let a pedophile off the hook.Adam Hoffman, look it up.He received 30 days of jail time.He he he didn't have to plead uh uh uh anything anything about the victim's age, so he doesn't have to register as a sex offender.Yeah.You care about the children.Ally, come on.Give me a freaking break.This is a joke.
What he calls good, right, and true, not only for ourselves, but for our neighbors.Now, remember this because saying all of this, living all of this will bring with it its fair share of criticism.I know that very very well as anyone in the public space who has been talking about this knows and I just remember this Luke 6:26 Jesus says woe to you when all people speak well of you for sotheir fathers did to the false prophets.Okay, so it's not just hey it's an option if you're a Christian that everyone's going to like you or maybe like some people aren't going to like you and that's just you know that's just life.No, Jesus actually says no it's bad.Woe to you when everyone has something nice to say about you.
Okay, that's a gross misrepresent repres representation.Obviously, the prophets critique power.It's not just about being a nice person.Alli's in bed with power.Okay.And by the way, Ally says hateful things, makes a lot of money.Ally then cries when she gets push back in America.I can make the same case about Ally.People like her, maggot people like her are in my comments all the time saying mean nasty things.So I guess I'm also suffering for Jesus at the same time.Come on.This it's just a weaponization of this is the next step.It's the persecution kink that evangelicals have.They love to be persecuted or pretend that they are.They live in the world's wealthiest country.They are in charge of the government.Their guy got their Supreme Court picks.They overturned Roie Wade.They're accomplishing their culture war agenda.We had a 9-hour long worship service on the national lawn paid for by tax dollars.
And Ally wants you to think that she and people like her are the ones under attack here.Come on.Come on.This isn't the truth.There's only one side of this conversation that has a billion dollar plus war chest introducing legislation in all 50 states all the time that reduces the rights of one group of people.And shocker alert, it's not groups like GLAD that are trying to reduce the rights of heterosexual marriages.It's people like Ali who are going after their gay neighbors in love.Of course, though, guys, this is how they love their gay neighbors by stripping their rights away.Whitewash tombs is the word I have for people like Ally.
For so they did to the false prophets.People love when you lie to them.People love when you say things just to make them feel good.People love affirmation of sin.We've probably all been there at one time or another.We don't want to be around the friends, the pastors, the mentors who will tell us what's true because we want to do what we want to do and we don't like conviction.And
if that was true, then why does Ali have such a big platform, Ally?Or sorry, I'm a little all over the place here.If that was true, Ally, why do you have such a big platform?Do people like what you have to say?Are are they approving of of who you are as a person?Are you not convicting them enough because they still tune in?Like again, like this it doesn't make any sense.It just sounds nice.It tickles ears and it reinforces their reasons to be homophobic.This only applies to gay people.It doesn't apply to the billionaires.Doesn't apply to any other group of people that scripture would obviously clearly condemn who are oppressing, who are punching down.Ally will never use this this way ever.
You might speak badly of them or think badly of them.Well, Jesus says, "Woe to you when all people speak well of you."And that's why I just remind myself and remind you too not to grade yourself or grade your obedience or grade the word of God by people's reaction to you.Now, we should do everything we can to strive to be gentle and peaceable and kind and loving.But listen, if you speak what is biblically true, there will always be people who accuse you of being hateful.All
because I can pull my hair out, guys, watching this.This is taking years off my life.It's only weaponized towards minority groups.By the way, this is the same rhetoric that was used to justify segregation, that was used to justify blatant racism, systemic racism, uh lynchings, slavery.It's the same stuff.The Bible's clear.You probably maybe you don't know this, but Bob Jones University, a massive fundamentalist evangelical school, sued the government in the 70s, I want to say, because the IRS said, "We're going to take away your tax exempt status ifyou don't allow interracial dating."And they said, "You're going after our religious freedoms.You're persecuting us.We're going to sue you because the Bible is clear that the races are to stay separate."Now, Bob Jones lost that court case.They got their tax exempt status taken away.They overturned their interracial dating ban in 2000.
2000, 28 years ago.This is the same framework.All of these all of this these words biblical and truth and loving.It's used in service to beat gay people over the head.Gay people want to be left alone.Ally doesn't have to turn on the TV.Ally doesn't have to go to a pride parade.Ally doesn't have to personally affirm someone's marriage.But that's not enough for Ally.She also needs those gay people not to be able to go to the pride parade, not to be able to get married under the state, not able to have the same rights that she has.It's not just enough for these people to exist and ally ignore them.Ally has to control them because her worldview is ultimately about power and control.And all of these all these all this rhetoric is used in service to further that narrative of why Christians like her who are speaking on behalf of God.
This is Christian nationalism 101 are supposed to be in control while everyone else submits to their authority.That's how this works.
Being bigoted and being holier than thou and being self-righteous.It really doesn't matter how sweetly you say it.It's not about how you say it for a lot of people.It's really about what you are saying.And if they crucified Jesus who was full of grace and truth and they stoned Steven who was full of grace and power, then why do you believe that you have the winsomeness and you have the niceness and charisma
6. Calvinism Contradictions and Closing Remarks
The host points out the contradiction between Stucky's Calvinist determinism and her culture war activism, critiques her selective use of 1 Corinthians 5, and closes with a call to support the channel.
to somehow escape the hatred of the world.
Jesus was was killed by the empire for being a threat to the empire and the religious establishment.That's why they killed him.They thought that they thought that he was a threat to their institutions.Steven was stoned because he was also a threat to their institutions.They weren't stoned for punching down at minority groups.They weren't crucified because Jesus was like, "Look, Rome, you keep doing these pride parades and I just let you got to let you know I stand against it and I want it outlawed and then then they killed them."No, it's not what happened.It's it's a gross misinterpretation.Obviously, it's a it's a gross it's a gross mislication of what's happening here.
It's just not going to happen.All who desire to live a godly life in Christ Jesus will be persecuted.Will be persecuted.God loves us.He loves his image bearsers.So, he created marriage.He created holy sexuality.He created our bodies.He created gender.And he knows better.That's what it comes down to.God knows better.
As told by Ally.As told by Ally.as told by Ally.
Now that we have our base for all of this, let's dive into the culture war because we're not called as Christians just to put our head in the sand.God has placed us in this physical world in this temporal space for a reason.We know that his eternal plan of redemption is going off without a hitch.He's going to gather his church.The gates of hell will not prevail against his church.And yet we have a purpose here.To do the next right thing in faith, with excellence, and for the glory of God to make this small plot of the earth, this tiny spot of eternity more like the kingdom of heaven better, a better place forour neighbors for the glory of God.
Which neighbors lot of ways to do that.Obviously, we share the gospel, but we also for the sake of our neighbors, for the sake of the truth, push back against the darkness.
Yeah.Which neighbors, Ally?Not your gay neighbors.Also, Ally, like I said earlier, is a Calvinist.She believes that God has pre-ordained everything and that, like she said, God's eternal plan of redemption is going off without a hitch.Yet, she feels the need to be in this conversation 24/7, 365, fighting against the powers of darkness in according to her own worldview.My question to Ally is, what's the freaking point?The game set match.Whatever happens is to happen, Ally.Whether you sit on a couch for the rest of your life and do nothing or you yap 24/7 365, it doesn't change the plan that God has put into place according to your own worldview.They don't really believe this stuff, guys.That that that's my point.They don't believe their own rhetoric.It falls apart.And as a former I was a former Calvinist.The acronym is tulip.
Okay?T U Li P.total depravity, unconditional election, limited atonement, irresistible grace, perseverance of the saints.There you go.Okay, there's my credentials.I know what the hell I'm talking about here.They don't actually believe that.They don't had to hop on.I wanted to share this clip.I just had to respond to it.I've been covering a lot of pride uh and and stuff because the church is going crazy.They do this every year.They do this every freaking year.They go after, you know, they make up they they say things that Sodom and Gomorrah is about homosexuality.It's not.That was my last video.They are obsessed with Pride Month.That was my video before that.And now here's a response of one of the more prominent people in this Christian nationalist space saying things that just first off aren't even accurate according to the Bible, are full of contradictions, and ultimately is hateful.
Ultimately is hateful.These folks have a massive gun that they use against everyone else but their own tribe.Which is so weird because 1 Corinthians 5 is specifically about the need to hold those inside the church accountable and not to worry about about what the world does.That's that's what the Apostle Paul says.If I told you not to associate with the sexually immor immoral, you would have no place to go is essentially what what Paul says.And by that I don't mean the world.I mean that in the church.What business?What business is it of mine to judge those outside the church?God will do that.Judge those inside the church.That's what first 1 Corinthians 5 says.Ally doesn't care.Out the window.Cuz gay people are terrible.They're the worst thing on the planet.And they essentially must be erased.That's what Ally believes.
And as a Christian, I'm telling you that is horrible theology.It is uncristlike.And this Christian is going to stand against it every single step of the way.Friends, thanks for being here.Please make sure to support this channel.It's how I do this work full-time.I really appreciate you so much.Thank you for all the love and support.I love doing this stuff.Let me know what you think about it in the comments.Talk to you'all later on.