# Why You Shouldn’t Become Eastern Orthodox | Part 1: The Filioque

**Channel:** Jesus and Whatnot
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zm3zHXF1Oqs
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/zm3zHXF1Oqs

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Introduction and Trinity Explained Through Analogy
- 5:31 — Defining the Filioque and Per Filium
- 11:45 — The Distinction Problem Argument
- 21:17 — Principium Quo and the Divinity Problem
- 26:31 — Church Fathers Affirming the Filioque
- 30:09 — Answering Orthodox Objections and Eternal Manifestation
- 37:34 — More Patristic Evidence and Conclusion

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** The filioque is a centuries-old debate between the Catholic Christians and the Eastern Orthodox Christians. And in my opinion, it is the clearest theological victory that the Catholic church has ever taken because the filioque is so obviously true. Now, if you're somebody who isn't very familiar with this debate, fear not because not only in this video am I going to explain why Catholics are right, I'm also giving a brief introduction to what the filioque actually is and what we mean by eternal procession or hypostasis or all of these fancy words that you might hear tossed around. So, we're going to start off by explaining the Trinity and then after this I'm going to get into the arguments for the filioque. You can check the description for the timestamps. If you already have a good understanding of the debate, you can skip this part and go straight into the arguments.

**[0:50]:** But if you're someone who actually wants to fully understand and you're coming at this from sort of a a novice standpoint, you might want to stick around and just hear the explanations for the Trinity that I'm about to give. So, when we speak of the Trinity, specifically of eternal processions, we are speaking not in a temporal sense. We are not saying that the Son is created or that the Holy Spirit is created, but rather we are talking about relations of origin, where one receives its being from. Now, again, this can sound like it's temporal and that's because human language is inherently temporal, but it's not talking about one beginning. It's talking about origin. A great way to understand this, a great way to understand what we're talking about is through analogy. Now, no analogy is perfect, but the one that I'm going to give you is from St.

**[1:41]:** Thomas and it will help you understand the Trinity in a very important way. So, the first thing to understand is that when we say Christ is the image of the Father or Christ is the Word of God, we aren't talking in the way that most people think. Most people think that the Word of God just that like Jesus is a a a sort of revelation or Jesus is some sort of you know thing that we read in the Bible as like maybe the Baptist would argue. But that's not really what we mean. We mean something much deeper. we say word, we're not talking about an external word, but an internal word of God, a mental image of some sort. So let let me help you guys understand this. If I look at this lighter, when I look at this lighter, there is an image of that lighter made in my head.

**[2:30]:** That lighter is reproduced in a sense. We would call that a word of the lighter. It is an image of the lighter. And so there's this reproduction an image in my mind. Now ask this what if? What if I were instead of looking at the lighter, looking at my own essence, pondering my own nature? Well then in my mind there would be a sort of reproduction of myself, a mental image of myself, an internal word. Now a final what if? Imagine if God, the perfect and eternal being, were to ponder his own divine essence. Well God differs from us in the sense where our ponderings, our internal images are limited and they begin in time. But God's images, the image of God that would be reproduced in this this loose sense would be eternal and would have no beginning because it is eternal. Not only that, but it would be a perfect representation of the divine essence that is actually identical with the divine essence.

**[3:35]:** And now remember I'm using loose language to help you guys understand. This isn't going to be the most precise way to explain this. Now that you have that understanding, you can start to understand the language that is used to describe the sun. The sun proceeds from the father. He is he is begotten of the father. However, he is identical with the divine nature. He's the image of the divine nature. And so that's how the persons of the Trinity are truly distinct from one another. The father is truly distinct from the son. However, they are both identical with the divine essence. Now the same thing can be said about the spirit. The spirit is God's willing of his own being. God willing himself, the will of God, the love of God, the shared love between the father and the son. And this is where the spiration of the spirit comes from.

**[4:27]:** So just in the way that the son is begotten, the spirit is spirated. Catholics would say that the spirit is spirated from God the father and from God the son. Whereas the Orthodox would say that the Holy Spirit is spirated only from the father. So now you kind of understand the the imagery that we're working with. You have some mental image of this in your mind. You can somewhat understand what we're talking about, what we mean when we say procession. So it's an eternal procession. There's no beginning. Now there are many different technical terms that are used to describe what we're talking about. You might hear me toss around relative opposition, relations of origin, hypostasis, personhood, nature of being, principle, principium quo, all of these ridiculous terms. Don't get scared by them. I will explain all of them, but you just need to listen closely and I would recommend that you take notes on this entire next section of the video where I actually give an explanation and an argument for the

**[5:29]:** Catholic position on this topic.

**[5:31]:** Okay, now we can kind of get into the actual arguments for the filioque. And in this slideshow, in this video, you're going to see a lot of church father quotes that you've probably never seen before. I collected them with the help of a lot of theologians, with the help of a lot of clergy, and it's pretty special. It took a really long time. So hopefully you guys enjoyed that. But not only that, we also have a lot of really high-level metaphysical arguments from Cardinal Cajetan, Father Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange, from Saint Thomas Aquinas. So really really good arguments in here. It's going to be quite the cumulative case for the filioque. And then part one is going to focus on those main arguments. Um, so the first thing we need to focus on is is what the filioque actually is, what the word means, and and so on.

**[6:15]:** So filioque means and the son in Latin. And this is pretty clear. It's because Catholics believe the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, whereas Eastern Orthodox uh they they believe that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father alone. And you can kind of see this on the image to the right. The Father under the Eastern Orthodox Church um is kind of it like the peak of a triangle, and there's no relation between the Son and the Spirit. So the Father begets the Son, and the Father spirates the Spirit. On the other side, we have the Latin Church, which is the Roman Catholic view, where the Father begets the Son and spirates the Spirit, and the Son also spirates the Spirit. And we'll get into the technicalities of that um what the word also means there. Um, but it's just important to note right now cuz we'll get into this later, that there is a relation between the Son and the Spirit under the Latin view that the Eastern Church does not have.

**[7:08]:** And I'm not going to make an argument on that right now, but it's just something to have in the back of your head cuz it's it's very important and it'll come up later. So there there are two valid formulations under the Roman Catholic view of how you can describe the filioque and how you can describe what's going on. The most common formulation of the Son causing the Spirit um and keep in mind when I use the word cause um it's not talking about the Son having a beginning in time, but it's talking about that origin that we mentioned in the beginning of the video. So the most common formulation of the Son causing the Spirit is known as the filioque formulation. This states the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, filioque. However, it's also completely in line with Catholic teaching to state that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father through the Son.

**[7:53]:** This is called the per filium approach, through the Son. Both of these descriptions are valid and they can be found all throughout the the Church Fathers, which I will show you later in this video. Um, and this this can be found pretty clearly in the Council of Florence as well. It says we that when the holy doctors and fathers say that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father through the Son, per filium, this bears the sense that thereby also the Son, also the Son, filioque, should be signified according to the Greeks indeed as cause. And according to the Latins as principle of the subsistence of the Holy Spirit just like the Father. And since the Father gave to his only begotten Son begetting him everything, this father has except to be the Spirit. So the Son eternally from the Father by whom he was eternally begotten.

**[8:39]:** This also namely that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son. So pretty clearly in the Council of Florence we we have both the per filium and the filioque approach. Um and this is this is just something to show that you know it's not something we're making up here. It's found pretty clearly within the Council. Okay. Here's a helpful analogy that can show you what we mean when we say through and also and. Okay. So imagine that there is a spring, a stream, and a pond. The spring is the ultimate cause of the water deposited in the pond and sends the water through the stream. Okay. We can also say though that the stream is the cause of the water in the pond, meaning that the pond is caused by the spring and the stream. So this shows how we can have through but also and at the same time.

**[9:28]:** This is per filium and filioque. Okay. So the stream and the spring are both causes of the pond, but the spring causes through the stream. Now in a similar way, the Father is the ultimate cause of the Holy Spirit and sends the Spirit through the Son, per filium. However, we can also say that the Son is a cause of the Holy Spirit, meaning that the Holy Spirit is caused by the Father and the Son. And again remember cause is not meaning temporally. I just want to throw that out there so that people are not confused. We're not saying that the Son has a cause in time, but rather he has his origin in the Father. Same with the Spirit. So, the Father sends through the Son. However, he also is, you know, sending alongside the Son. So, they are both going to be causes in this sense.

**[10:23]:** Now, Saint Hilary, he actually explicates this. And keep in mind Saint Hilary is a a saint East and West. He explicates this exact understanding in both ways. He says and So so here's the first quote. This is from On the Holy Trinity, Book II. He says, concerning the Holy Spirit, I ought not to be silent. And yet I have no need to speak. Still, for the sake of those who are in ignorance, I cannot refrain. There is no need to speak because we are bound to confess. He's saying this is something that Christians are bound to confess that the Holy Spirit proceeds, as he does, from the Father and the Son.

**[11:07]:** Okay, so he's saying very clearly the He he's formulating the But then notice that Saint Hilary also says that the Holy Spirit proceeds through the Son in the next quote. This is On the Trinity, Book XII. Let me ensure adore you, our Father and your and your Son together with you. Let me win the favor of your Holy Spirit who is from you through your only begotten. So this is this is exactly what the Council of Florence says, that there is the approach and the approach. And this is something that's taught explicitly by Saint Hilary.

**[11:45]:** Now, in order to prove this, we're going to take some metaphysical approaches. There's two theological arguments that we're going to we're going to set forth in this video. The first line of argumentation I'm going to refer to as the distinction problem. And the second line of argumentation I'm going to refer to as the divinity problem. So um just just kind of laying this out here so that you guys can can best understand. Um the first argument is the distinction problem. In the Trinity, we can only distinguish the persons by what's called relations of origin, okay? So, for example, the father is not distinct from the son because he has some sort of like different essence from the son. That would be, you know, partialism or tritheism, one of the two. But rather, the father is distinct from the son because he begets the son. That is why there is this distinction.

**[12:35]:** Remember what we talked about in the beginning of the video, okay? The distinction comes from the relation of origin. Okay. So, we cannot try to distinguish the three persons by anything absolute. For example, to say that the father has more power than the son, that's going to be Arianism because it means the son is less God than the father. The only way that we can distinguish the persons is through their hypostatic relation to one another, relative opposition, okay? So, what what relative opposition is is A is related to B in one direction while B is related to A in some opposite direction. For example, a master is related to a servant in one direction and the servant is related to the master in the opposite direction. Okay? You can see that on the right. A mother is related to her daughter in one direction and the daughter is related to her mother in the opposite direction.

**[13:31]:** This is the only way that the divine persons can be distinguished. Anything else falls into some heresy, Arianism, tritheism, partialism. It's going to be something along those lines if you try to distinguish the persons in any other way. Okay. So, with relative opposition, we can see this clearly in the Trinity. The father has relative opposition to the son because the father begets the son. The son has relative opposition to the father because he's begotten by the the father. The father has relative opposition to the spirit because the father spirates the spirit and the spirit has relative opposition to the father because he receives spiration from the father. Now, this is very clearly laid out by Saint Basil, who is also a saint in East and West. He says, as light in light, there is no opposition between them. So he's saying as them being God, they don't have opposition, but as begotten and unbegotten, one considers them under the aspect of their opposition.

**[14:28]:** So he's saying very clearly, this is how they are distinguished. We consider them by their aspect of opposition. The properties idiomata effectively have character of showing alterity within the identity of substance, ousia. The properties are distinguished from one another by opposing themselves. So very very clearly, he's talking about this distinction that clearly exists. K. More specifically, the relations of opposition within the Trinity are due to origin. This means that one comes from another. Okay? So the father is distinct from the son because he begets the son. The son is distinct from the father because he's begotten of the father. The father is distinct from the spirit because he sends the spirit and the spirit is distinct from the father because it proceeds from the father. So very very clear. This should be something that we can all agree on. Saint Gregory of Nyssa says this pretty clearly.

**[15:18]:** Again, a Saint East and West, we do not deny the difference in respect of cause and that which is caused, by which alone we apprehend that one person is distinguished from another. By our belief that is that one is the cause and another is of the cause. And again, we recognize and again that in that which is of the cause, we recognize yet another distinction for one is directly from the first cause and another by that which is directly from the first cause. Now he's actually teaching the filioque here. He's saying that there is a cause that is from the cause. So he would be referring to the son being a cause of the spirit. But that's that's something for another time. Right now he's just talking about relations of origin. Now, this is the problem with the Eastern Orthodox position. The Eastern Orthodox deny that there is any relation between the Holy Spirit and the son, or at least any relation of origin.

**[16:11]:** But remember, the only way to distinguish the persons is through relations of origin. This means that the Eastern Orthodox have a framework of the Trinity where there is no way to distinguish the Holy Spirit from the Son. The best way to show this is with a full model of the Trinity from both sides. So this is the Catholic view, okay? With the filioque, we can see that there is perfect distinction between all three persons. Each person has relative opposition by way of origin and there's no mixing between each person. So remember, the only way to distinguish these persons is through relations of origin. So you see, we have relations of origin between every single person of the Trinity here. And notice specifically the Son and the Spirit are distinct because under the Catholic view, the Son spirates the Spirit and the Spirit proceeds from the Son.

**[16:57]:** However, under the Orthodox view, if you reject the filioque, then there is no longer a distinction between the Son and the Spirit. In the words of Cardinal Cajetan, they have made a Son-Spirit. Without the filioque, the Son and the Spirit collapse into one person because there's no distinction. They aren't distinct anymore. This is heresy. This is not the Trinity. Now this doesn't mean that the Orthodox are like inherently anti-Trinitarian. That's not what we're saying. But but their theology leads to anti-Trinitarian conclusions. So they they literally don't have a full understanding of the Trinity because of this. Now the typical Orthodox response is that they say that we can distinguish the Son and the Spirit because they have distinct relations to the Father. So they will falsely claim that since the Son is begotten, he must be distinct from the Spirit who proceeds. However, this is a bad argument.

**[17:54]:** This is a really bad argument. So they'll say, uh you can kind of look at, you know, the the image on the right, we'll say, okay, well the Son is begotten of the Father and the Spirit proceeds from the Father, therefore the Son is different than the Spirit. We can we can show that this is a really bad argument though with the following analogy. We're just going to replace the three persons with a woman, a daughter, and a student. We can imagine that there is a woman who has a person who is her daughter and also a person who is her student, okay? These are two different relations, but there is no way to distinguish the daughter from the student without more information. The woman's daughter could potentially be her student. This actually occurs all the time in public schools. So, imagine, right, that there's there's this woman.

**[18:39]:** She has a daughter, and then there is also a child who is her student. Unless we have more information, we cannot use that alone to distinguish them because somebody can be your student and your daughter at the same time. So, just because there's different relations does not mean that you automatically have different persons, okay? So, just because their relationship to the woman is is is different does not mean that they are different persons, okay? We would need something else to tell us that they are distinct. Maybe the daughter has blonde hair and the student has brown hair. That would be an an accidental difference. But remember, in the Trinity, there's no accidental difference. There there's no accidents at all. Now, maybe the daughter is a human and the student is a frog. That would be some sort of absolute difference, some sort of natural difference.

**[19:29]:** But again, that's not found in God because God is consubstantial. There's one essence. There's one nature. And so this means the only way in God to distinguish the persons is still going to go back to relative opposition. So, there's a huge problem with the Orthodox framework. Just because the Son is begotten and the Spirit proceeds, we cannot say that they are distinct unless we have some information that tells us otherwise. Since they would not be distinguished by anything according to their nature, there must be some relation of origin between them. This is the Without the the Son and the Spirit are simply collapsed into one person. Now, this is actually taught pretty clearly at the Council of Ephesus, which is accepted by the Eastern Orthodox when they accept the letter of Cyril. Look at what Cyril says. This is his letter to Nestorius. Even though the Spirit exists in his own person and is conceived of by himself in as much as he is the spirit and not the son, yet is he not therefore alien to him.

**[20:33]:** For he is called the spirit of truth and Christ is the truth and he proceedeth from him just as from God the Father. So he's saying that the son proceeds from the Father and just in that same way the spirit proceeds from the son. It's pretty clear that remember this is accepted at the Council of Ephesus, accepted clearly at the Council of Ephesus. Now there's a second argument that you can make from you know the metaphysical framework and it says that if you deny that the son also spirates the spirit, you deny that the son receives the fullness of divinity from God the Father.

**[21:17]:** This results in a semi-Arianism which is obviously heresy, but in order to explain this argument we're going to have to define a few terms, okay? So the the the things that we're going to describe, there's some Latin involved. I know that people don't like Latin, but it it's somewhat necessary in this just so that we we don't get confused with just this one word by. So there's principium quo and there is principium quod. Principium quo is the principle by which and the principium quod is the principle which. Okay. So the principium quo are the principle by which is the faculty or power that communicates nature in a natural operation. The principium quod or the principle which is the principle which performs the operation. This distinction can be seen through an example. So I know that this is confusing, but hold on. It it makes more sense once you explain it a little bit further.

**[22:14]:** If you touch a burning hot steel rod, there are two principles that are going to be at play. When the steel burns you, heat is the principle which, the principium quo you are burnt. We know this because the heat is communicated to you. Heat is communicated. You receive heat. You receive hotness, okay? And so that is the principium quo. Now on the other hand, if you are burnt by steel, the steel itself is the principle which burns you. This is because the steel is actually performing the action of burning you, okay? This distinction is between the principle which and the principle by which is going to help us understand the Trinity. So if you don't understand that, maybe watch back that explanation. Make sure you understand it because it's really important for what we're about to talk about. In the beginning of the Son, when the Son is begotten of the Father, the Father is the principle which in the divine essence is the principle by which.

**[23:13]:** We know this because the divine nature is what is communicated to the Son, hence him having divinity, okay? So the Father is not communicated to the Son. The Son doesn't receive fathership. He receives the divine nature. So just like with the steel rod where heat is communicated, it means that divinity is the principium quo. Okay? He's the principle by which that the divinity. So the same description now applies to the sending of the Spirit. The Father is the principle which and the divine essence is the principle by which, just as with the Son. We know this because the divine nature is what is communicated to the Spirit. The Spirit receives divinity. He doesn't receive fathership, okay? So this is really just repeating what we just said. However, it's about the Spirit now. The reason this is important is because the ordering of the Trinity. Remember that the Son is the second person of the Trinity because he proceeds naturally before the Spirit.

**[24:16]:** He comes naturally before the Spirit. Okay? When the Son receives divinity from the Father, the Spirit has not yet been sent. And again, we're using temporal language, but we're describing something in a logical sense. So we're not saying that there was ever a time when the Spirit was not, but rather that the Son logically comes before the Spirit. So, that's why we call the Father the first person, the Son the second person, and the Spirit the third person. K. Now, this is a huge problem for the Orthodox. Seriously, it is. The principle by which spiration occurs is the divine essence, as we just said. Spiration and begetting only terminate in the Spirit and Son respectively, okay? When the Son receives the divine essence, spiration has not yet terminated in the Spirit. This means that the Son receives the active power to spirate, and therefore the Father and the Son send the Spirit.

**[25:10]:** That's the doctrine of the filioque, okay? The Orthodox position ends in semi-Arianism. Since the principle by which the Spirit is sent is the divine essence, the Son must also send the Spirit or he does not have the fullness of divinity. If the Son doesn't receive spiration, he's not receiving the fullness of divinity. But remember, the divinity is what's communicated to him, and he is fully God. By denying the filioque, you deny that the Son is truly divine. St. Augustine actually teaches this to us pretty clearly. He says the Father is a beginning in relation to the Son because he begets him. It must be admitted that the Father and the Son are a beginning of the Holy Spirit, not two beginnings. But as the Father and the Son are one God and one Creator and the Lord relative to the creature, so are they one beginning relatively to the Holy Spirit.

**[26:08]:** So, very clearly, St. Augustine, who is a saint East and West, teaches us this clear distinction, okay? Now, there are more church fathers that we can talk about. But before we get into that, I just I just want you guys to really think about what was just said about that argument, okay? If you deny that the Son spirates the Spirit, you are denying that he has the fullness of the divinity, Okay?

**[26:31]:** So, this is St. Hilary. St. Hilary is very very clear. Accordingly, the spirit receives from the sun, who is both sent by him and proceeds from the father. Now, I ask whether to receive from the sun is the same thing as to proceed from the father. But if one believes that there is a difference between receiving from the sun and proceeding from the father, surely to receive from the sun and to receive from the father will be regarded as one in the same thing. Very clearly St. Hilary is teaching the filioque. Now look at St. Leo the Great. And so under the first head is shown what the unholy views they hold about the divine trinity. They affirm that the person of the father, the son and the Holy Ghost is one and the same. So, this is he's he's dealing with, you know, some some sort of heresy here.

**[27:19]:** Very clear heresy. As if the same god were now named the father and the son and the Holy Ghost. So he's refuting modalism. He says, he who begot were not one and he who is begotten not another and he who proceedeth from both yet another. Who is he referring to? Who is he referring to when he says he who proceedeth from both? It's the Holy Spirit. Which means that he believes the Holy Spirit proceeds from both father and son. Look at what St. Ambrose says, St. East and West. He says, the Holy Spirit received from the sun, he received them however through the unity of substance as the sun received from the father. He says that not only is it just a an economic procession, he explicitly says it's a substantial procession. The Holy Spirit proceeds from the father and the sun substantially, unity of substance.

**[28:10]:** Okay? Look at this. St. Basil, St. East and West. So in the case of the divine and uncompounded nature of the union consists in the communion of the godhead. One moreover is the Holy Spirit and we speak of him singly conjoined as he is to the one father through the sun and through himself completing the adorable and blessed trinity. So that's the perfilium approach. But look at what he says here. He also states the natural goodness and the inherent holiness and the royal dignity extend from the Father through the only begotten to the Spirit. Thus, there is both acknowledgement of the hypostasis and the true dogma of the monarchy is not lost. So notice that he's talking about the goodness of God. The goodness of God is God himself. That's directly from the Apostle James. And the inherent holiness. God is holy substantially by his essence.

**[29:01]:** And he's saying that that royal dignity is extended from the Father through the Son to the Spirit, speaking of a substantial procession. St. Epiphanius, St. East and West. Therefore, he always existed with the Father and the Spirit always breathed forth from the Father and the Son.

**[29:23]:** Very very clear. St. Isidore, who is a saint East and West. He says between the Son who is born and the Holy Spirit who proceeds is this distinction. That the Son is born from one. The Holy Spirit proceeds from both. Therefore, the Apostle says, now if any man have not the Spirit of Christ, he is none of his. So very clearly, the Holy Spirit proceeds from both. Okay. So there's a little bit of of a conclusion here. Um we just need to to clarify, okay? That that I could continue to go on and we actually will. There there's there's more um metaphysical claims that we can make.

**[30:08]:** Okay.

**[30:09]:** So now we're going to get into part two where we deal with some of the objections and a little bit more information on this, okay? So the first thing that you hear from a lot of Eastern Orthodox Christians is that in certain church fathers such as Gregory the Theologian, Gregory of Nyssa, and John John of Damascus, there's sometimes a phrase that the Father alone is cause or the Father gives all to the Son except causality, okay? Because of this, it's really important to understand which is being used for cause, okay? The word can mean simply cause, but it can also mean primordial cause or first cause, okay? Now, I know that that's confusing. I'll explain those words. We can understand the usage of through our previous analogy of the string, the the the stream and the pond, okay? So the spring is the primordial cause of the spirit.

**[30:59]:** We actually touched on this but without using the technical terms, okay? The stream is still a cause, just not a primordial one, okay? So the stream and the spring are both causes of the pond, but the the spring is the cause in a unique sense, okay? So the certain Greek fathers that we'll talk about here in a second would say that the spring is the only of the pond because it is the only primordial cause. And we actually see this in St. Maximus, okay, who is a saint East and West. He takes the exact same stance, okay? Um look at this. He says as the mind is the of the word and so also of the spirit through the word is intermediary. Very very clearly. Okay? So St. Maximus attributes or cause to the father alone, but still believes that the son causes the spirit as intermediary, okay?

**[31:49]:** So that's pretty clear. The does not mean cause in the general sense, but primordial cause just as with this analogy, okay? Now, St. Gregory the Theologian actually makes this way clearer for us, okay? Look at how he uses the word here. The former is called God and subsists in three greatest, namely the cause, the creator and the perfector, I mean the father, the son and the Holy Spirit. So St. Gregory here, he uses to refer to the father as the creator of the world. However, we obviously know that all three persons created the world. He uses to show that the father is the only primordial cause of creation, but not the only cause of creation in general, okay? So in the same way, the father is the primordial cause of the spirit, but not the only cause. He's the only primordial cause, the only in the sense that certain Greek fathers use it, but not the only principle.

**[32:44]:** Okay. Now, we believe in one father, the beginning and cause of all, and the father is himself the beginning and cause of the existence of all things in a definitive and natural manner. So again, we obviously know that the father, son, and Holy Spirit are all cause, but here is being used as a primordial cause. So once again, just kind of reaffirming what we read in the other Greek fathers. Now, this is something that we spoke on earlier with relative constitutive traits, okay? Where there is a relative constitutive trait um that that's really really important. So so so Saint Gregory the theologian on relative constitutive traits, um he says here um that the persons are distinguished by relation, okay? Um and he further goes on to explain that these relations distinguish in so far as they related towards their terminus. So the conceptually distinguishes the son in so far as filiation is related to the father.

**[33:42]:** So that's something really important. This is what he says, but it is the name of relation in which the father stands to the son and the son to the father, for as with these names make known a genuine and intimate relation that is the only begotten son him that begets. Okay. So very very clear um just these relative constitutive traits. Saint Augustine says something very similar, okay? He explains it. You can kind of read this on your own. Um but but overall he's just explaining these relative constitutive traits. Um and Aristotle says a similar thing on relative distinction, relations of opposition that we talked about before. Um and the reason this is important is because this is a really really good defense against what we talked about with the one Eastern Orthodox objection where they say, well the son is begotten and the spirit proceeds.

**[34:30]:** Well here is a little bit of like a logical proof or a logical explanation as to why that's not true, okay? So imagine trait one and trait two. These are the things that are distinguishing X, and Z. Okay? So, replace X, Y, and Z with Father, Son, Holy Spirit, or whichever way you want to do it. So, imagine that there's one trait, trait one, and that's equal to the relation between X and Y and the relation of Y towards X. Okay? And then there's trait two, which is the relation of X towards Z and of Z towards X. So, this is going to be similar to, you know, begetting, which is the Father's relation towards the Son and the Son's relation towards the Father. And then there's going to be spiration, which is in the Eastern Orthodox view, it minimalistically the Father's relation towards the Spirit and the Spirit's relation towards the Father.

**[35:16]:** These are the relative constitutive traits that we were talking about. Okay. This means that T1 is not equal to T2 because they are equal to different relative constitutive traits. Further, okay, T1 is not greater than X towards Y and is not greater than Y towards X because we just said that it was equal to it. Same thing with trait two. It's not greater than X towards Z and it's not greater than Z towards X. Just because T2 and T1 are distinct does not mean that you can use the relation of X towards Z to distinguish X and Y. So, this is more so just a logical proof of what we talked about before. Now, there's also the topic of eternal manifestation. The reason I wanted to touch on this is because it's very very silly. Um, they'll often use eternal manifestation as kind of a way to dodge the objections that are given from the Catholics.

**[36:11]:** Um, but look at what St. Gregory the Theologian says about manifestation here. He says, but the difference of manifestation, if I may so express myself, or rather of their mutual relations to one to another, has caused the difference of their names. Pretty clear. It's caused the difference of their names. The these manifestations that the the, you know, the Eastern Orthodox will appeal to, they'll say, oh, well, you know, the Father um, you know, hypostatically sends the Spirit, but he's he's eternally manifested through the Son. Well, look at what it says about eternal manifestation. He says that manifestation causes the differences in their names. Pretty pretty clear. Proceeding has given the name of Father to the first, of the Son to the second, and of the third to him whom we are speaking of the Holy Ghost. So pretty clearly he's talking about this eternal manifestation.

**[37:06]:** He says it gives the names to the persons of the Trinity. So you'll hear, you know, people like J. Dyer, people like David Erhan, maybe like your Alex Sorin or Nobi Petris out there, they will appeal to eternal manifestation. They'll say, well, this the Father eternally manifests the Spirit through the Son. However, eternal manifestation, according to Saint Gregory the Theologian, is what distinguishes the persons. It's what gives them the difference of their names. Here's some more Church Fathers.

**[37:34]:** Um we already covered this one from Saint Hilary, apologies. Here's one from Saint Athanasius, who is a Saint East and West. He says, therefore the Spirit has the same relation of nature and order with respect to the Son that the Son has with respect to the Father. Nature and order. This is one of the most clearest examples we can give. The Spirit has the same relation of nature and order with respect to the Son that the Son has with respect to the Father. You can't get more clear than that. That is like textbook definition of the filioque. Here's another one from Saint Augustine. But whatsoever he shall hear that that shall he speak, he shall hear of him from whom he proceeds, the Son, okay? But of him from whom he proceeds and of whom he proceeds, he has essence. So he's speaking here of the Spirit and says that the Spirit has the has his essence from the Son.

**[38:24]:** This is an essential procession. This is a substantial procession. Saint Augustine is very clear. He's a Saint East and West. Saint Gregory the Nyssa. This is very clear. Saint Gregory of Nyssa, this is this is such a killer quote. Look at this. The Trinity is as if a man were to see a separate flame burning on three torches, okay? He says, and we will suppose that the third flame, the Spirit, is caused by that of the first, the Father, and transmitted to the middle, the Son, and then kindling the end torch, the Spirit. So he's saying that the divinity, the flame, is transmitted first to the Son and then kindles the end torch. Here's what Saint Ambrose says. The Holy Spirit also, when he proceeds from the Father and the Son, is not separated from the Father nor separated from the Son. For how could he be separated from the Father who is the Spirit of his mouth, which is certainly both a proof of his eternity and expresses the unity of this Godhead?

**[39:25]:** Very clearly, the Holy Spirit says he proceeds from the Father and the Son and then says clearly that this is about the unity of the Godhead. It's not just economic, it's about the unity of the Godhead, about the eternal. Okay. Saint Cyril of Alexandria, three quotes from Saint Cyril here. It says, it is necessary to confess the Spirit to be from the essence of the Son. How much clearer can you get for existing from him according to nature? That's from his Thesaurus. He literally says the Spirit is from the essence of the Son and existing from him according to nature. That is the The Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son. Clear. This settles the debate. Clearly he is of the divine substance proceeding in it and from it. The Holy Spirit is the spirit of God and the and the Father as well as of the Son and comes forth substantially from both.

**[40:26]:** That is from the Father through the Son. So unbelievably clear. Here's Saint Basil the Great. The natural goodness Oh wait, we already read this. Apologies. Here's another one though. The Spirit is called good as the Father is good and he who is begotten, the Son, is of the good and to the Spirit is his goodness, is essence. So clearly what he's saying is the goodness he's speaking of is essential, it is substantial. So, when he say, so when he says that the royal dignity extends from the father through the only begotten, he's saying essentially the only begotten gives the goodness, the essential goodness to the spirit. Um, here's another one from St. Epiphanius. Christ is believed to be from the father God God from God, and the spirit is to be from Christ or indeed from both. Very very clear. Now, we can go over this council real quick, which is also pretty damning for the Eastern Orthodox position.

**[41:23]:** This is the council of of St. Lucia. You ready for this? And we confess the living Holy Spirit, the living Paraclete, who is from the father and the son in one Trinity, in one essence, in one will, in harmony with the faith of the 318 bishops. So, you might be asking, okay, 318 bishops, what is this talking about? This is talking about the council of Nicaea. The council of St. Lucia is from bishops who went to spread the faith that was preached at Nicaea. And they are already confessing that the Holy Spirit, the living Paraclete, is from the father and the son. Now, this is one final thing to kind of conclude the principium quo and the principium quod conversation. This is St. Augustine, he explicates this difference, okay? We won't read through the whole thing, but basically he points out that in creation um, there is a principle by which the world is created, one God, one principle.

**[42:18]:** However, he also notes that in creation we have three principles which create the world. That that exact distinction applies to the spiration of the spirit. So, pretty clearly you can read that passage that I have up on the screen there, but it it's it's a lot, so I don't need to go through all of that. Um, and then he clarifies it further um, in De Trinitate, okay? And this is why St. Augustine is so clear on the Trinity, okay? Um, he actually clarifies more. Oh my God, I didn't realize how many quotes I have. Um, we also see this in Aristotle. This is De Anima, book one, chapter four. Um, and he lays out the distinction um, between the principle by which and the the principle by which uh, principle which and then the principle by which something acts. Um he says it is better to avoid saying that the soul pities or learns and rather to say that it is the man who does this with his soul.

**[43:02]:** So if somebody questions you and they say, oh the principium quote the principium quote is not found anywhere within Aristotle. It's not found anywhere within Augustine or or any of the early church fathers. There's some quotes for you. Um but yeah guys, what a what a long video. This is kind of one of my more in-depth ones. I know it probably won't do as well as some of the other videos that I put out there, but I figured that this would be some helpful knowledge to kind of share with you guys. Um and again, please remember I'm not a priest. I'm not a theologian. I'm just some 20-year-old sitting in my room. Um but I I still think that I can definitely add to the discussion, especially when it comes to you know those logical descriptions those that logical notation that I showed. I think it will help kind of settle that debate, you know just the objection of oh well the son is begotten and the spirit proceeds.

**[43:43]:** It's not a very good argument. So hopefully I added to the discussion a little bit. Hopefully this is kind of a good collection of those um different quotes that I showed as well. So God bless you guys. Thank you so much for watching. Um if if you want to know more about what I do, please go check out my Substack, like and subscribe to the video or don't. I don't really care. It helps me, but if you don't want to, I get it. Um I never really do it when people ask anyway. So yeah, thank you so much. God bless every single one of you. Please pray for me and know that I'm praying for you.
